News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by DoofusOfDeath on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:35PM (#12934605)
I suspect we actually know very little about Trump's intentions. I believe that, like Clinton, he was willing to say just about anything to get into office, regardless of what he truly intends.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by jrockway on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:43PM (#12934712)
What were Clinton's outrageous promises?

If anything, I think what killed her is that she is a very unexciting stay-the-course President. No major changes, just incremental improvements. Very likely what is actually happen in any Presidency. What's sad is that the American people punished her for actually being realistic about what a President can actually do.

There's not going to be a new border wall and there's not going to be any more jobs for the middle class. Clinton knows that, Trump doesn't.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:54PM (#12934820)
> I think what killed her is that she is a very unexciting stay-the-course President. No major changes,

Also lies and corruption, that's what killed her. But you're right that it would have still been "no major changes" from what she was before.

She had major investors behind her, all that money from speeches, all the media, Obama, the DOJ, people at CNN passing her debate questions before hand. And she still lost. To a TV show star.

I don't buy the idea that was "experienced", "the most qualified", "a good manager". She lost to Trump. That is a fact now. The argument of her competence, integrity, intelligence is very hard to make at this point.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by jrockway on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:41PM (#12935165)
We certainly had the opportunity to examine the inner workings of Hillary Clinton and the DNC.

We had no data whatsoever on Trump or the RNC. Beyond his barrage of lies, low-level offenses (paying fines with his nonprofit, bribing elected officials, all that), and alleged sexual assaults, that is. I think he did so many little bad things that the American People couldn't keep track of them, and voted for the interesting television personality.

It is unfair to assume that "no news is good news", but assume we did. The Clinton campaign lost the information war badly. (And apparently against state-sponsored adversaries!)

And what did we conclude from Hillary's emails? That she got paid by investment banks and accepted donations to her Foundation from foreign dignitaries that she interacted with while Secretary of State? While I don't think that influenced her decision-making, the appearance of impropriety is just as bad as actual impropriety, and so I can see why people were upset. But like I said, I trust her decision-making and voted for her anyway, because her positives vastly outweigh her negatives.

(The DNC is another issue altogether, but it's very simple why they didn't support Bernie. They're the DNC, not the "independent who suddenly claims to be a democrat" NC. The system of political parties sucks. But it's the system we set up and keep voting for. I don't think Bernie would have beaten Trump. College students can make some pretty good subreddits and Facebook posts, but they just aren't enough of the electorate. Clinton and Trump both have Very Powerful Friends, and you need them to be elected.)

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by saalweachter on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:39PM (#12935489)
Re: the DNC I think the focus on the DNC also over-emphasizes the power of the DNC (eg, the primaries are run by the State committees, not the DNC) while confusing the direction the influence flows in the DNC -- members of the DNC are influential members of the Democratic Party because being an influential member of the Democratic Party is how you become a member of the DNC.

If the DNC's role in the primaries was replaced with a laptop to add up the popular vote of all of the primaries, all delegates and superdelegates eliminated, the members of the Democratic party who would otherwise be "superdelegates" -- elected Democrats in Congress, top members of the state Committees, past and current Democratic Presidents, Democratic governors, etc -- would still have an outsized influence in backing one candidate or another, because they are influential people with personal experience with the candidates whose opinions are trusted by many people.

Pretending it could be any other way is silly; when I need an opinion on someone, as either a political candidate, a plumber, or a potential new engineering hire, I talk to people who have personal knowledge, whose opinions I trust. Demanding that these people not share their opinions is absurd.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by tootie on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:22PM (#12935022)
If voters cared about lies, they would have strongly rejected Trump. They just wanted lies that appealed to them.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:28PM (#12935074)
Agree. Well in this case we know which ones they picked.

So what do think she should have done better? Did she not lie convincingly enough, and Trump was a better liar?

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by sprafa on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:36PM (#12935472)
Some of Trump's statements made more sense, others were more exciting, many of them were just lies, as I suspect we are about to find out.

But yes charisma is often the ability to persuade, and persuasion passes through exaggeration, bravado, and if you are completely lost, lying. Everything indicates Trump is a pathological liar (same with Hillary). But because voters got caught up in his narcissism, he "won" (again electoral college only etc.)

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by mercer on Saturday November 12, 2016 @10:53AM (#12938436)
I think that doesn't do justice to the many people who voted Trump because they didn't want to vote for Hillary.

Whether justified or not, many of the Trump voters/fans I've spoken to did not get caught up in Trump's 'narcissism'; they just feel so sick of 'the establishment' that they'd do anything to not get another Clinton in office.

To be clear, I myself would probably have voted for Hillary instead of Trump, because I'm a cautious person and I prefer the 'evil' I know over the unpredictable nature of Trump. But if I squint, so to speak, I could see myself voting for Trump just because I dislike Hillary so much. That in itself scares me a bit (I'm big on LGBT rights and whatnot, on a very personal level).

The reason why I'm pointing this out is that 1) we are now stuck with Trump, so let's try and make the best of it, 2) part of why we got here was the incredibly shallow name-calling and condemnation and stereotyping from both sides, encouraged by the media.

Our best way forward is to try and understand the situation and most important the people involved, and why they voted the way they did, and go from there. And perhaps being honest and factually correct is a good idea too.

Could be further analysis proves you right, btw. But right now I have no reason to believe that most people voted Trump primarily because they got 'caught up in his narcissism'.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by tootie on Saturday November 12, 2016 @10:16AM (#12938197)
No idea. More pandering, more lying. Nominate someone with no record of anything.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by serge2k on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:31PM (#12935093)
> I don't buy the idea that was "experienced", "the most qualified", "a good manager".

She was a lawyer, first lady for 8 years, a senator, and secretary of state. She's incredibly experienced and qualified.

Trump is nothing but lies and corruption. It's hypocritical to whine about Hillary and ignore trump.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:59PM (#12935278)
> It's hypocritical to whine about Hillary

I didn't know I was "whining" sorry about that. Will try to keep my tone in check.

> and ignore trump.

Have you read the rest of the posts? Are you responding to the same comment section in HN? There is a lot of stuff being ignored but Trump is not one of those things.

> She's incredibly experienced and qualified.

Let's accept that. How do we reconcile the fact that she completely blew this election? With a star team of strategists, Obama behind her, all the financial support, media helping her every single step of the way, even down to passing her debate questions in advance, all that experience. Out of all people she lost to Trump? What happened there?

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by dpark on Friday November 11, 2016 @07:59PM (#12935905)
> How do we reconcile the fact that she completely blew this election?

We don't reconcile them, because while not unrelated, they also aren't tightly correlated. "Experienced and qualified" don't guarantee success in an election (or anything else for that matter). Trump is clearly not experienced politically and a large number of people agree that he's not qualified, yet he still won.

Experienced and qualified people fail at stuff pretty regularly.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @10:00PM (#12936354)
> Experienced and qualified people fail at stuff pretty regularly.

Everyone fails. But this was not a simple tactical fail, this is a strategic type long sequence of failures.

> "Experienced and qualified" don't guarantee success in an election (or anything else for that matter).

What good are those things for then? I would imagine such a long experience at being a politician should translate into the ability to manage an election, understanding and communicating the issues to the constituents, seeing what the voters want, and so on.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by dpark on Friday November 11, 2016 @10:16PM (#12936408)
> But this was not a simple tactical fail, this is a strategic type long sequence of failures.

Really? Because from what I saw, the biggest failure from Hillary was the email scandal, and of course the failure to actually get elected. I didn't see sequence of failures. If anything, Trump had a much bigger sequence of failures, from the tax leaks, to the Trump University fraud, to belittling a former Miss Universe, to the pussy grabbing comments and more. He got elected nonetheless because he managed to sell a message people wanted to hear.

> What good are those things for then? I would imagine such a long experience at being a politician should translate into the ability to manage an election, understanding and communicating the issues to the constituents, seeing what the voters want, and so on.

Those things are helpful, in the same way that being smart is helpful if you're starting a company. But smart people start failing companies all the time and experienced politicians lose elections all the time, too.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @11:12PM (#12936543)
> Really? Because from what I saw, the biggest failure from Hillary was the email scandal,

I would say the sequence of failures is not understanding what voters were looking for. That didn't happen as a singular event. That happened at first, then later, it happen probably up until she canceled the fireworks show for celebration party. As a politician, knowing what the voters she (hopefully!) planned to represent wanted, should have been one of the top qualification requirements, would you say?

Losing the Rust belt was a major strategic failure. I can understand if it was down to a few electoral votes, could then argue it was random, but it was 60 votes.

> he managed to sell a message people wanted to hear.

But she's been in politics with all that experience. Out of all the people shouldn't she be the one who can sell people what they want to hear? Maybe the idea is that she has a higher integrity than Trump and wouldn't want to do that?

> biggest failure from Hillary was the email scandal,

Email scandal was not one thing. The contents of the emails show sequence of failures.

> If anything, Trump had a much bigger sequence of failures

Exactly, it was terrible, and she still couldn't win. That is just baffling to me.

> Those things are helpful, in the same way that being smart is helpful if you're starting a company. But smart people start failing companies all the time and experienced politicians lose elections all the time, too

That's a fair point I agree with that in general.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by dpark on Friday November 11, 2016 @11:40PM (#12936635)
I'm not clear where you're going with all this. Clearly Clinton lost. Clearly she made mistakes. That's indisputable. But based on the fact that the populace elected Trump, I'm not sure there's anything Clinton actually could have done to win. What Trump had was a message that apparently appealed to a very large section of the population (plus a xenophobe outreach campaign that built him a base to get through the primaries), and even if Clinton wanted to sell that message, I don't believe she could have, because she actually has a track record that the message clearly doesn't align with.

You seem to be convinced that experience and qualifications necessarily lead to winning elections, and therefore Clinton's loss proves that she has neither. But this is fundamentally untrue. Many times voters have chosen someone with less experience and weaker qualifications. I'd argue that Clinton was more qualified and more experienced than Obama when he beat her in the primaries. McCain was arguably more qualified and certainly more experienced when Obama beat him in the general election, too. He won because at the time voters preferred his message and his vision.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Saturday November 12, 2016 @01:42AM (#12936922)
> at built him a base to get through the primaries), and even if Clinton wanted to sell that message, I don't believe she could have

That makes sense.

Also good point on experience regarding Obama/Clinton/McCain

> I'm not clear where you're going with all this.

Nowhere really. I am just baffled about this and wanted to discuss stuff and see what other people think about it. As much as we don't do political stuff here, this still a more sane forum than reddit for example.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by dpark on Saturday November 12, 2016 @10:50AM (#12938413)
Fair enough. Your comments made it look like you were arguing that Clinton didn't have experience, etc. I can understand wanting to discuss and understand this, because it seemed like an almost impossible result.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by sprafa on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:38PM (#12935482)
Trump got debate questions as well. See Megan Kelly.

Yes Hillary blew the election. In the end Colin Powell was right - whatever she did right she ruined with hubris

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by Natsu on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:10AM (#12955989)
Can you give a cite for that? I missed that story.

The ones I read in Podesta's emails were quite clearly leaked, and then Donna lied about the message being changed by Russia. That was false, because it's DKIM validate and those headers cover the body as well as the headers.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by serge2k on Friday November 11, 2016 @07:53PM (#12935877)
She's dull and kinda unlikeable. She had some good ideas but nothing really exciting.

Trump has, in his way, an Obama like gift for getting people excited to vote for him. It makes him look god awful to his opponents, but it gets people to vote.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by foota on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:33PM (#12935457)
Also remember all the free press Trump has gotten?
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by foota on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:32PM (#12935453)
The money she's made from speeches is relatively trivial.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @10:05PM (#12936370)
Alright, let's take that off the table. How do you explain other stuff. How did she manage to lose this election?
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by foota on Saturday November 12, 2016 @03:18AM (#12937094)
I don't really think I'm qualified to say, but that's never stopped anyone ;) I don't think she could pivot too far to the right, and so had difficulty attracting any conservative vote. I'm not sure why she couldn't get out the democratic vote more. Maybe she just wasn't charismatic enough.

There's also sexism.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by pstuart on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:48PM (#12934766)
I think she should have pandered more on jobs. I'd take her exaggerations over Trump's made up stuff.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by rdtsc on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:30PM (#12935087)
Her losing the Rust Belt to Trump will probably be seen as one of the biggest election campaign blunders.

I don't see making the case for her "experience" and "qualification" anymore. With all the resources, media, donations, etc she should have had this election in the pocket.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by sprafa on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:39PM (#12935487)
True. Whatever happened there was a major fuck up. And Bill Clinton was right all along - the campaign had no message whatsoever.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by pstuart on Sunday November 13, 2016 @10:22AM (#12943722)
> the campaign had no message whatsoever.

The irony of this failure is that heeding to the message "It's the economy, stupid!" was what put Bill in the White House to begin with.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by nilkn on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:32PM (#12935102)
I wouldn't be surprised if there will in fact be a new border wall. If there's anything I've learned from this election cycle, it's that many of us have repeatedly and consistently grossly underestimated what's possible in politics.

Presidents generally do try to fulfill their campaign promises, and building the wall is the biggest, most concrete, and earliest campaign promise he made. Realistically, it's also one of the most straightforward of all his promises to achieve, and at $25-30B it's not very expensive in the grand scheme of a presidency. Its overall effect will be minimal, meaning that it won't wreak havoc, it won't do much good either (in fact it might ironically backfire by keeping people in instead of out), but it will satisfy his supporters.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by DanBC on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:35PM (#12935131)
As job creation schemes go I'd much rather people build stupid walls than build bombs and weapons.

I'd be interested to know the CO2 estimates for a 5,000 mile wall.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by CamperBob2 on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:54PM (#12935255)
Interesting question. Some say the carbon footprint of concrete production is pretty horrific, but I don't know much about the specifics.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by robotresearcher on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:00PM (#12934866)
I honestly don't believe he has many intentions and is not motivated by a vision for the country or the world. He's a super-aggressive competitor and I think that's his sole motivation.

President Obama ridiculed him to his face at the Correspondent's Dinner a few years back. The campaign is a Fuck You to Obama and the rest of the establishment that laughed at him as a lightweight.

He worked very hard and won and now he'll be improvising. He'll have to pay back some people that supported his campaign, many of whom have specific political goals. He'll allow them to work towards those. But apart from a big tax cut for the very rich (strangely) I'm almost certain see that he doesn't care much at all about the rest of his platform. Certainly not the Christian-right stuff.

Maybe he has a real conviction about trade deals. It'll be interesting to see if he moves the needle on any meaningful trade metrics.

That's just my personal impression from listening to him talk.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by jrockway on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:43PM (#12935183)
Indeed. We rail on Facebook for making a pro-Trump echo chamber, but the powerful elite and well-educated also live in an echo chamber. In our echo chamber, everyone is equal, and we want to work together, and we incorrectly assumed that that's what voters think. Nope. That KKK endorsement probably helped more than it hurt. It was a wake up call from believing that humanity is mostly decent. It's not.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by linkregister on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:22PM (#12935394)
Over the past few days I've been hearing much about the liberal elite, but I think most are disregarding that at least half of the wealthiest Americans are conservative. Many of these conservatives don't believe in what you stated.

That said, Trump's candidacy was not enthusiastically received by most of the wealthy conservatives. Carl Icahn and Peter Thiel are the only billionaires that I can think of that supported Trump. Charles & David Koch didn't endorse or fund his campaign or use their political entities to support him.

So your point remains and is good. I wanted to remind the HN audience that the elite is comprised of conservatives too, and they disagree with the liberal elite about much.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by jrockway on Friday November 11, 2016 @07:08PM (#12935663)
Yes, we've really corrupted the terminology in order to fit a multitude of positions into two political parties.

I'm guessing that most of the wealth in the Republican party comes from people that are Republicans because they want a lower corporate tax, rather than people that want bans on who can use which bathroom. But somehow they ended up in the same political party.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by linkregister on Saturday November 12, 2016 @01:16PM (#12939228)
Absolutely it's a mixed bag. Mike Pence is a proponent of both of the examples you gave, having especially harsh attitudes about the LGBT community. It appears that Icahn and the Koch family are against governments regulating who is or isn't permitted to enter a bathroom; rather, they believe that limited regulation and low taxes are key to economic growth.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by freddyc on Friday November 11, 2016 @07:09PM (#12935667)
> Charles & David Koch didn't endorse or fund his campaign or use their political entities to support him.

Maybe not directly, but Pence has pretty strong ties to the Kochs and his nomination as VP was widely seen as a nod to them.

Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by AznHisoka on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:28PM (#12935069)
given the effort and energy needed go run a multi year campaign, i highly doubt it. look at his videos of him talking about the possibility of running decades ago. he has always had the passion hidden for many years.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by mrfusion on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:44PM (#12934723)
He's also a negotiator and he likes to seek out extreme positions as a starting point.
Re:Obama Administration Gives Up on Pacific Trade Deal by esturk on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:26PM (#12935059)
Did Clinton really incite racial divide? Throwing Muslims and Latinos under the bus?

While I give credit that Trump may indeed be well intentioned but the main difference between him and Clinton is that Trump does not understand his words have consequences. Clinton knew to attack Trump the persona and not attack an ethnic group.