Commenters on HN post both to persuade other commenters and to expose their own opinions to scrutiny by the community. I attempt to persuade and be persuaded by other HN commenters. It is useful to add disclaimers so other commenters can see if I have an agenda. Often I do, and it's useful to disclose that so suspicion is suspended and discourse can continue.
Sadly, I'd say the fact that every other commenter seems to go out of their way to point out that they're not a Trump supporter, and the fact that I feel the need to do so myself, is evidence enough that HN is not polite and thoughtful enough when it comes to this issue.
And honestly I wouldn't expect that from HN, even though I do feel this is still a place where there is relatively more politeness and thoughtfulness.
The debate in the comments was lively and both sides were represented over the Sam Altman post defending his decision to keep Peter Thiel at YCombinator.