I agree. However, I also think that a lot of the world, especially Europe, has a strange and unrealistic vision of what a multi-polar world would look like. A multi-polar world looks like 18th and 19th century Europe writ large, with nation states jockeying for power, and war being considered as a logical extension of economic and political policy. It isn't nations coming together and negotiating peacefully at the EU or UN or wherever.
It feels a bit like the U.S. thinks the rest of the world isn't capable of looking after itself.
Arguably because the rest of the world isn't. If you look at the "free world", who actually spends even 1% of their GDP on defense? Heck, half of Germany's air force can't even fly because they've pared their maintenance budgets back too far to buy spare parts for their planes. When France and Italy bombed Libya, they had to rely on the US to provide necessary logistical support, like tankers and reconnaissance, and even the smartbombs themselves. Taiwan explicitly relies on US carriers to guarantee its territorial sovereignty against Chinese aggression. Japan likewise.
A world in which the US is in full retreat is not a more liberal, peaceful world. It's a world in which even more autocratic powers, like China and Russia advance.
EDIT: By the way, I totally agree that the US is overstretched. But unilateral retreat, leaving our allies in the lurch to face hostile powers on their own is not the correct way of addressing that problem.
China was the number one country in the world at the beginning of 1600, per population and economy, as usual. They also had an oceanic fleet travelling to India and possibly to Africa. Then they decided to concentrate on internal matters because they were the only ones important to preserve the government. They even burned the fleet.
That move played out very bad for them in a couple of centuries. The world is much faster now. My bet is that turning inwards, if it really happens, will play bad for the USA in two decades or less. They are laughing in Moscow and Beijing now. Any immediate commercial trouble will be repaid with interests by a more prominent international status. Even wars will pay off in the long run, especially if not fought at home. Check WW1 and WW2 for the USA, or any regional conflict after then.
Here are the numbers. All but five of the countries do.
You're point still stands, though.
http://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/pdf_2016_0...
Same thing on the other side of the planet: both Japan and South Korea have very little military might; they depend on the deterrence the U.S. provides. They are looking at China and wondering what happens next.
If the U.S. reduces or removes these relationships, it will dramatically change these nations. Japan and China hate each other. If the U.S. draws back, Japan will complete its transition away from pacifism and will have nuclear weapons of its own in less than a decade. Same with South Korea.
Even if you think that the U.S. is not a leading light of democracy, these are real relationships and altering them has real consequences: more weapons and more tension among more nations in the world.
And who will stop China from intervening if US is out of the picture?
So you think the current token US force in SK can stop China if it decides to intervene? That force just acts as a nuclear tripwire; it doesn't need to be larger to act in that fashion.
And it seems likely to me that as Trump continues to receive intelligence briefings, economic and military advice, we will see a whole lot not change. That's my prediction. Probably.
1) A big strong guy, stronger than anyone else, fucks with anyone who tries to change anything
2) lots of strong people stop anyone who gets too destructive
I don't think 1 is remotely sustainable. 2 might be doable.
> In October 2013, the incarceration rate of the United States of America was the highest in the world, at 716 per 100,000 of the national population. While the United States represents about 4.4 percent of the world's population, it houses around 22 percent of the world's prisoners.[1]
> How can you take yourselves seriously?
Totally agreed.
If the US had low crime rates, great quality of life, and was seen as universally fair and just - well then 1 might work. But when it's so unjust, unfair, and unbalanced at home, while we spend billions abroad... it stops making sense.
That's a very idealistic view. You can't have lots of more or less equally strong parties -- only a very few. From those few all secretly want to switch to 1).
Unless each of those has learned that 1) always ends poorly and has decided they're better off with strong allies comitted to the ideals of justice.
Yeah, we quibble over the details. But there is a direction we all want to go - safety and personal freedom are universal ideals.
Even dictatorships fake elections.
I believe the economic analysis would be: it's not a Nash equilibrium, and therefore it cannot exist for any length of time, because the cost of it rises exponentially over time.
So can I just say: Good luck with that, and I, personally, would like to opt out if possible.
In some ways the world is quite different now, with nuclear deterrent...but it's still worth considering history.
Well, this was the sentiment of most Americans after World War 1. It took the attack on Perl Harbor for Roosevelt to have enough support from congress to join WWII.
I think that after WWII the US government made part of its foreign policy to use economic integration and military might to prevent any country from ever dragging them into WWIII.
I am personally not worried about China, Russia, the middle east or even North Korea. But I would be seriously worried to see Japan rebuild their military because we pulled our bases out of there.
Those things aren't really related, except as far as american attitudes go.
For example, a massive amount of money is spent on health care.
A massive amount of money in the U.S. is spent on administering healthcare.
Not much actually goes towards actual health care.
Healthcare could be relatively inexpensive to provide, if we chose to eliminate the profit motive.
It's absurd to me that anyone should profit from my being unwell. That's the sort of thing mosquitoes, leeches, ticks, pathogenic viruses and bacteria, thrive on.
I don't have a fully-formed whole-system replacement for for-profit-healthcare, but it definitely seems like something we ought to work on.
How does it make sense that people's unwellness should be paying for my neighbours Toyota Prado (that's never been taken off the road).
I do think US attitudes lead to both things (world police/broken health care system).
Rather, I think what you've done here is mimic the common HN pattern of saying "X is orthogonal to Y, so I don't get what you're saying", which, as I've try to point out above, lacks imagination.
I even went to some length to try to explain why I feel like that.
A large daily dose of craven "speaks comfortable untruths for power" mainstream media, who have been owned by the military-industrial complex for decades. The morons at CIA didn't see it coming, that Americans would question the lies of network news, or else they would have attempted to strangle this internet thing in its cradle. They've adapted somewhat, e.g. the "good work" done at Facebook this cycle or the constant fear-mongering about Russia, China, North Korea, ISIS, etc. They just couldn't get their bloodthirsty old gal over the line, though.
The conspiracy theorist in me would like to be a fly on the wall in Pence's personal security briefings. If they hear what they like from him, he'll be our President in short order. Wasn't he a big incarceration fan?
It feels a bit like the U.S. thinks the rest of the world isn't capable of looking after itself. And perhaps it isn't, and some boarders will be redrawn, but I get the feeling a lot of people are ready to give it a shot.
Especially considering the U.S. as de facto self-appointed global police, is doing a terrible job of looking after it's own citizens with regard to education, healthcare, the war on drugs, shooting black men, mass shootings, etc etc etc.
Personally, the way I feel about the U.S. as the purported bastion of "The Free World™", the leading light of Democracy is this:
It has to stop. No one believes the charade any more. And with the presidential election being a choice between terrible and wacko, the U.S. would be the laughing stock of the world if the situation wasn't so frightening.
I'll give one strong example:
In October 2013, the incarceration rate of the United States of America was the highest in the world, at 716 per 100,000 of the national population. While the United States represents about 4.4 percent of the world's population, it houses around 22 percent of the world's prisoners.[1]
How can you take yourselves seriously?
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_ra...
Edit: fixed randomly incorrect reference