I don't agree with Trump but to think he really doesn't want to do the things he's been saying over the decades seems wrong.
I feel like I need to keep adding a disclaimer that I'm not a Trump supporter because my comments make it seem like I agree with him. I'm simply stating his views because I keep seeing people project their own feelings onto him even though he has been clear about many parts of his platform. Sure, he's had to walk back many statements or clarify that he was "being sarcastic" but there are many parts of his platform where he is crystal clear, yet people don't think he'd actually pursue those policies.
...I feel like I need to keep adding a disclaimer that I'm not a Trump supporter...
Please don't, it does not add anything to the discourse. It does not matter whether you support him or not when pointing out facts (or fallacies, for that matter). Having to add disclaimers all the time is a damper on any discussion and as such should be avoided. Those who lack the wisdom to separate their personal opinion on people who support a certain policy or person from the merits of what those people say need to take a gander at the following rant:President Trump: How & Why... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLG9g7BcjKs
I see this come up frequently on HN, usually not as well-worded as your response. Typically it's just "ad hominem" with the link to the logical fallacy on wikipedia.
But the source of a fact or argument is valuable information. Since humans have finite time and attention, it's useful to know why someone is making an argument.
Wouldn't you want to know if a drug study was sponsored by its manufacturer before believing it?
Wouldn't you want to know if a drug study was sponsored by its manufacturer before believing it?
That is not the same thing. I assume someone is not sponsored by a manufacturer unless such a sponsorship is explicitly stated. I also expect someone who is in fact sponsored by a manufacturer to state this explicitly as that would be relevant in the interpretation of that person's claims which, in the context of drug studies, can be judged objectively. In the context of a political or societal discussion it is much harder to be objective as those fields are largely subjective - there generally is no absolute truth. Seen in that light it is hardly relevant whether a person supports this or that party, policy or politician when discussing claims about their merits as other participants in the discussion can make up their own minds on the subject regardless of what the claimant thinks about them. I'd go on step further and claim that the discussion would actually improve when such disclaimers are left out as it would reduce the influence of group think and open up the possibility to discuss matters which fall outside of the comfort zone without needing to excuse oneself for even mentioning the subject. This would only work in a place where the discourse is generally polite and thoughtful, HN being an example of such.Commenters on HN post both to persuade other commenters and to expose their own opinions to scrutiny by the community. I attempt to persuade and be persuaded by other HN commenters. It is useful to add disclaimers so other commenters can see if I have an agenda. Often I do, and it's useful to disclose that so suspicion is suspended and discourse can continue.
Sadly, I'd say the fact that every other commenter seems to go out of their way to point out that they're not a Trump supporter, and the fact that I feel the need to do so myself, is evidence enough that HN is not polite and thoughtful enough when it comes to this issue.
And honestly I wouldn't expect that from HN, even though I do feel this is still a place where there is relatively more politeness and thoughtfulness.
The debate in the comments was lively and both sides were represented over the Sam Altman post defending his decision to keep Peter Thiel at YCombinator.
It's going to be an awful four years where any of the good things Trump said (the stuff that resonated with Bernie supporters, renegotiating trade deals, infrastructure improvements, term limits and curtailing lobbyist influence ) are going to be flat out denied by this awful congress headed by one of the slimiest most cynical men in our history. Mitch McConnell's congress is a massive roadblock to progress.
So, yeah, we're looking at four years of obstructing their own candidate on anything good or reasonable that an "outsider" might want to do. While pushing aggressively forward (or backward, as the case may be) on all the same stuff they've been outraged at Obama for over the past eight years.
While it may work to get some populist laws through, this dynamic also makes us extremely vulnerable to an autocratic power grab.
Unfortunately I can't help but fear for the bad things he might push for, whether prompted by those close to him or populist sentiment.
I guess that means let's hope Peter Thiel wins the power behind the thrown? :/
I'm not a Trump supporter but I'd be behind purging the Old Guard and bringing in new ideas.
When push comes to shove and if Trump tries to suborn the Senate, McConnell, like Roberts on the Court, might be the great white hope.
We will all find out in time, but as I watched him sit with Obama yesterday and also with Paul Ryan, both of whom looked like seasoned politicians who knew what was expected of them, I saw in Trump a man who looked lost and uncertain.
I suspect that he liked the idea of being president more than he will enjoy doing the job.