News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:32AM (#12751998)
As the GM of a amateur youth team (one of the parents has to do this role here), I've watched the coaches trying in despair to make players unlearn things that the boys picked up from playing the FIFA series games.

Mostly it's about tricks that are much more prominent in the video game than they ever can be in real life, because the gameplay is not entirely realistic. The gameplay on screen rewards visual stunts that are much less effective in real play. The movement of ball and players doesn't actually have to be like it is in reality, because it is a video game. It's adjusted for visual appeal.

Where this is most often seen is passing the ball up in the air; this enables the video game to show amazing slow-motion captures of skill, but on a real football field such gameplay is not effective; in fact it is stupid.

In video gameplay, the characters make the ball traverse in a slo-mo arch, all the other moving objects maybe slow down, and the player receiving this pass then picks it up with amazing skill.

In real gameplay, it is better to keep the ball on the ground and pass quickly. A ball flying in an arch in the air travels more slowly, so the opponent has time to come close end press the ball; a flying ball is more difficult to control so it is slower to receive and pass on; making an accurate pass with a ball up in the air is much more difficult than controlling a ball rolling on the ground.

Thus, playing like FIFA just means you lose the ball to the opponents and you lose the game.

Also, things like a bicycle kick tend to succeed in a video game, but in real life they are exceedingly difficult to score with.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by kohanz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:15AM (#12752320)
There have always been kids who wanted to play sports the fancy way, with flair, long before video games. Especially at the youth level, you'll just get a lot of kids who value creativity and self expression over what the most winning strategy is.

I play FIFA (and soccer IRL) quite a bit and the highest level players (yes, there are professional FIFA players) actually play the game much closer to what you're referring to as the optimal style of play: short ground passes, keeping possession, playing backwards to keep possession, very little trying to beat your man one-on-one, creating chances by making runs, defending by jockeying your man without gambling, and good shots from good positions. At a high level, it's well understood by players that most scoring opportunities are created by causing the opposing team to lose their defensive shape through probing passes and runs, and then capitalizing on that space. Of course FIFA is not a simulation and can't be fully realistic - you're generally fitting a 90 minute soccer match into about 12 minutes of real life gameplay.

What you're describing sounds like typical youth behavior, but you're blaming it on video games. Before video games, kids would try to do things they saw their pro idols do on television as well. It didn't ruin the game.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Bartweiss on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:41PM (#12753886)
Right around the time kids gain enough coordination to reliably move a ball, they start wanting to emulate the most creative techniques the sport offers. I don't think that can be laid on FIFA.

I remember learning the Cruyff turn before I could cleanly dribble down an open field. It was fancy and an obvious display of skill, so everyone wanted to do it - even though it's a useless technique if your control and acceleration aren't perfect.

If anything can be chalked up to video games, I would expect it to be aerial passing and a reluctance to play back. The rest - fancy moves and beating defenders - has been an ego issue since long before FIFA.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by cgag on Thursday October 20, 2016 @04:47PM (#12756017)
I think it's pretty hard to get into a "playing to win" mindset at any age. At least it is/was for me, it's hard to let go of the joy of winning through clever or flashy moves and focus on the joy of winning a high level competition, where everyone is playing to win.

Sirlin's (fighting game player / game designer) has a good book/series of articles about this that's made the front page a few times: http://www.sirlin.net/ptw-book/introducingthe-scrub

"I once played a scrub who was actually quite good. That is, he knew the rules of the game well, he knew the character matchups well, and he knew what to do in most situations. But his web of mental rules kept him from truly playing to win. He cried cheap as I beat him with “no skill moves” while he performed many difficult dragon punches. He cried cheap when I threw him five times in a row asking, “Is that all you know how to do? Throw?” I gave him the best advice he could ever hear. I told him, “Play to win, not to do ‘difficult moves.’”"

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by projektir on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:09PM (#12757702)
Part of the issue with this is that a lot of games get very boring when you treat them seriously and people do not originally get into them for those boring parts.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by jimmydddd on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:28PM (#12757966)
This. A friend of mine plays paintball (skirmish). He said the way to win is to hide during the whole game and slowly crawl towards your objective. But, it's way more fun to go in guns ablazing like Rambo.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by viewer5 on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:54AM (#12752796)
Kinda random, but is there a guide for FIFA for someone who doesn't know how to actually play soccer? I very much enjoy playing with my brother, but neither of us understand 80% of the vocab, so the usual video game trick of "go look at the controls, find out what's available to you" isn't even useful. We'd both love to get better but we don't really have the time to invest in learning a whole sport and all the vocab that goes with it. I've searched youtube and google, but haven't found anything to help.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Fredi_ on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:15AM (#12753037)
I would suggest going to /r/bootroom on Reddit and asking for some help there. It's a subreddit catered to getting better at soccer. I'm sure they'd be glad to help with any vocabulary questions, even if you never plan on playing the game in real life.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by kohanz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:56AM (#12752812)
I would recommend searching the r/FIFA subreddit. There is a ton of stuff on there that is childish (it is a game played mostly by kids after all), but every so often one of the better players will post a thorough guide on how to emulate their playstyle. Be forewarned about how much FIFA players like to complain about the game.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by gadders on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:36AM (#12753237)
>>There have always been kids who wanted to play sports the fancy way, with flair, long before video games.

I had a friend who was a boxing coach in the sixties and seventies and he told me about all the young lads that tried to box like Muhammad Ali, but with painful consequences.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by gosukiwi on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:23PM (#12754828)
> Before video games, kids would try to do things they saw their pro idols do on television as well.

I agree with this. Beeing from Argentina back when we played in the neighborhood there was always a kid pretending to be Maradona who wanted to solo score from mid-field or make a luxury goal :p

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by eropple on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:27PM (#12754866)
> the highest level players (yes, there are professional FIFA players) actually play the game much closer to what you're referring to as the optimal style of play: short ground passes, keeping possession, playing backwards to keep possession, very little trying to beat your man one-on-one, creating chances by making runs, defending by jockeying your man without gambling, and good shots from good positions

I played the NHL series of games at a high level for a while and saw a lot of what you describe there, too. Tons of people just trying to run it up the ice and hammer away at the goal, but if you played it akin to how an actual hockey game is played you'd see a lot of opportunities open up.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by dangravell on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:36AM (#12753233)
It's not flair though if you are doing a rabona because you saw your favourite player do it the other day.

Genuine flair is the ability to do the unexpected. At best, these games open our eyes to these possibilities. At worst, they teach style over substance, and our game is poorer as a result.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by nbclark on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:38PM (#12754381)
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by triplesec on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:24PM (#12753737)
al creativity starts with learning the moves, the tropes, and getting inspired. There's a reason Brahms' 1st symphony sounds like Beethoven that it's often called Beethoven's 10th, but his 5th much less so...
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by kohanz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:03PM (#12753499)
I would argue that it is flair, because it's a move you don't see on the pitch very often (and with good reason). It's almost always unnecessary and a way of saying "Hey, look at me!". Maybe you're saying it's not original? I would agree with that.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by arjie on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:29PM (#12754301)
How interesting. Usually your teammates will kill you for flair that doesn't help. And if you do it repeatedly, you won't get called the next time the gang goes out to play.

Here's a story: Growing up in India, we'd play football on this muddy ground next to an open sewer. There's only one field and maybe six or seven teams so we'd play golden goal or ten minutes. You had ten minutes to score to stay, but if your opponent scored you have to join the back of the queue. If you boot the ball too hard, it falls in the sewer and it's on you to go retrieve it among the shit and piss and everyone has to remember not to head it until it's washed off. It's also about 37 to 40 degrees outside and there's no shade, so losing is no fun since you may have to wait half an hour for your next game.

Amusingly, this ends up defaulting to the possession game with short passes. Unfortunately, I wasn't very good at the game, and so I played RB and had to retrieve the ball from the sewer many times before I learned to be a little better with my ground passes. I never did get very good, but at least I stopped having to go get the ball.

Maybe a few tropical diseases will fix your kids right up.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by stcredzero on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:40PM (#12754389)
I think the helicopter parenting debate could be reduced to just knowledge of consequences and systemic thinking. The situation you described was an excellent opportunity for you and your playmates to understand the consequences of play style and play environment as a messy real-world system.

This is something you don't get nearly as much of playing video games or going to the mall. So many of our experiences are curated, artificial, and fall far short of the real-world level of complexity.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by tnecniv on Thursday October 20, 2016 @08:38PM (#12757392)
> How interesting. Usually your teammates will kill you for flair that doesn't help. And if you do it repeatedly, you won't get called the next time the gang goes out to play.

Depends on the group. Where I grew up, style was the name of the game. It wasn't good enough to do a layup. You had to do a trick layup with a needless underhand, etc.

The problem is that there was always one or two players that were naturally gifted and played all day so they could do any trick they wanted. Then, everyone tries to do it to show they have chops, too.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by hluska on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:38PM (#12757806)
I really enjoyed this comment and you're one heck of a good writer. Thanks for telling your story!!
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by supercanuck on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:54AM (#12753415)
I don't know if FIFA Is the true source of the "stupidity" ... I mean, who doesn't want to try using the things you've been goofing around with in your own backyard. I remember visualizing myself as Ken Griffey Jr when playing baseball, who isn't pretending they are Lionel Messi in soccer.

This reminds me of the kids trying to hit homeruns on an 0 - 2 count in baseball. They'll learn.

Its kids learning the game, and kids being kids rather than simply being chess pieces for a 40 year old dad.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:09PM (#12754686)
Trying it a few times in training is not stupidity, it's just curiosity.

Doing it over and over in a game, even when your coach and teammates tell you not to, is stupidity...

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by hluska on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:42PM (#12757818)
I take deep issue with anyone who refers to anything that kids do as 'stupidity'. They're kids playing a game. We have no idea what their home lives are like and we have no idea what the game represents to them. They're kids, not professionals and frankly, they deserve the benefit of the doubt.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:07AM (#12758470)
Now, it depends on who are the "kids" here. You are possibly thinking of this in terms of American school activity soccer, and small children in general . I completely agree with you about 10-year-olds.

I was writing in the context of 17-19 year old kids who have trained football for a dozen years and perhaps played advanced computer games for almost as long. It falls into category of the Einstein's quote about doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by hluska on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:18PM (#12764930)
Okay, good point. I read your comment wrong - thanks for clarifying!
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by 127001brewer on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:58AM (#12753450)
This past season, the Baltimore Orioles were hitting for runs instead of bases: http://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/orioles-near-mlb-home-run-...

...and they almost made it past the Wildcard Playoff game.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by supercanuck on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:30PM (#12753795)
You are missing my point

http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/split.cgi?t=b&lg=M...

Even the Orioles had a low OPS in 0 - 2 counts.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/split.cgi?t=b&team=B...

basically, your approach should change in an 0 - 2 count:

http://www.ahittersedge.com/AboutUs/ArticlesBlog/tabid/4804/...

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by rlander on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:15AM (#12752318)
> The gameplay on screen rewards visual stunts that are much less effective in real play. The movement of ball and players doesn't actually have to be like it is in reality, because it is a video game.

Ronaldinho would like to have a word with you.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IBERQ9abkk

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0ksVaLlaIw

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6mk0auHpis

* Edit: For the donwvoters: I used to play college-level football in the US and Brazil, and these kinds of plays are commonplace in Brazil. Kids learn to dribble before they even learn how to run. This is part of Brazilian culture: a player who can dribble is much more valued than one who can shoot or pass accurately.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by noxToken on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:47AM (#12752695)
For every clip or montage of beautifully executed flair, there are tens or hundreds of hours of unrecorded or unpublished mistakes. I have a few hundred hours of recorded gameplay footage. I could make plenty of highlight reels out of the footage, but the mistakes eclipse the fancy by a wide margin.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by rlander on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:46AM (#12753345)
I used to play college level football in the US and Brazil, and I can tell you for sure: these kind of plays are totally usual in Brazil.

But I do understand your feelings, since US football (or soccer as they call it) is more about about physical conditioning than skill.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by sangnoir on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:07PM (#12754096)
> For every clip or montage of beautifully executed flair, there are tens or hundreds of hours of unrecorded or unpublished mistakes.

This is true, but for athlete who takes the sport seriously, most of those mistakes are made during practice and not on match day.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by petepete on Thursday October 20, 2016 @05:15PM (#12756237)
Most professionals don't play at the top level, you don't see many moments of beautifully executed flair in the second or third divisions.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by thom on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:29PM (#12753786)
If you're advocating that kids play more in the streets, practising these motor skills coupled with actual competitive decision making, then I absolutely agree. But these sorts of skills coupled with bad decision making gives you incredibly frustrating players like Ross Barkley.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by betolink on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:17PM (#12753661)
Well I wish we had more Ronaldinhos.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by stcredzero on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:32PM (#12754324)
Of course games are going to change the way people see the world. Any powerful form of media is going to be able to do this. This can work out for good or for ill.

I once had an interesting experience when referring to a bit of anthropology in a comment. I brought up the well known idea that the requirement for cooperation in traditional Japanese rice agriculture -- namely for the maintenance of irrigation -- had a strong influence on the egalitarian peasant side of Japanese culture. To this, an avid 4X game player replied in outrage, "AGRICULTURE!?" He then elaborated that he had been conditioned to think of it as the starting point on the tech tree, therefore base, basic, and completely insignificant. This is completely at odds with reality, however. There is a lot of skill and knowledge involved with agriculture, especially so when done with stone age technology.

Does this make games worse than other forms of media? No. You can find examples of screwed up ideas people pick up about things in all forms of media, going right back to ballads about princesses and war heroes in pre-literate cultures. However, I would say that the potential for both good and harm is especially strong with video, cinema, and games, because they can work on such a visceral level. (Also, is our culture as savvy with such effects from games, as it is about such effects from songs, novels, movies, and TV commercials? I think it's currently catching up.)

EDIT: Please don't automatically assume that I agree with the loudest voices when it comes to the analysis of media. I don't! Reality is complex and nuanced.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by gspetr on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:38AM (#12752039)
You got to admit though that the bicycle kick is spectacular to watch when it does succeed, like this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1odrzGKMzE
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by supercanuck on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:46AM (#12753344)
and ridiculously hilarious when they do not, even for professionals.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KA-AEEPol_8

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Bartweiss on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:46PM (#12753925)
I enjoy any technique that looks that absurd when it goes slightly wrong. Flying headers are particularly beautiful - you just get a player sailing across the field into nothing in particular.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by caseysoftware on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:47AM (#12752692)
Thanks for the clip. That was great. You can see everyone briefly relax when the keeper deflects the initial shot. They thought the pressure was gone.. and then BOOM.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by sschueller on Thursday October 20, 2016 @03:49PM (#12755489)
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:48AM (#12752712)
Of course, yes, but about nine times out of ten a better attempt would have been made with a simple header or by passing the ball downwards. Football is a team sport. It's great to be able to score from a difficult position. But it's much better to keep your eyes open, know where your teammates are, and pass to someone who is in a better position.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by thom on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:31PM (#12753799)
Which, nine times out of then, means not crossing the ball in the first place. Although now I look upthread, that's pretty much what you're advocating.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ktRolster on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:46PM (#12754437)
If you have kids that are passing the ball accurately to each other through the air, then you have a really good team.

Also, if you have kids who can accurately do bicycle kicks, then you have a really good team.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by pbhjpbhj on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:21PM (#12754809)
Well, you have really good players. Good players can carry a team, but they're not the same thing.

I found in the past when playing that players who are convinced of their own greatness could ruin the game; maybe still get a win, but that was never really what I cared for.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ktRolster on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:45PM (#12755013)
maybe still get a win, but that was never really what I cared for.

Winning is the only thing lol.

In any case, if you have good players on your team, it's better to build on that foundation.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by m1sta_ on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:52PM (#12757641)
Winning is not the only thing.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:23AM (#12758139)
A good nutmeg is worth almost as much as a goal.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by brudgers on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:23PM (#12754250)
Der Ball ist rund und das Spiel dauert 90 Minuten. [1]

Everything else is just theory. One of those is o jogo bonito. Paid coaches are usually not so great a fan as a child among friends left themselves. In the end, objectively good players are in part objectively good because they've learned to receive aerial balls aerially and that enables them to play more quickly.

It's a case where kids are making themselves better despite the intentions of the adults taking charge. They're not just playing FIFA, their researching the moves on YouTube.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sepp_Herberger

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by parthdesai on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:58AM (#12753444)
Completely agree about "visual stunts" parts. You will find that there are world's best freestylers ( people who can do insane tricks with ball at their feet) who don't even make it to a 2nd division league.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:17PM (#12753658)
And that's completely reasonable, because freestyling with ball is just a different sport. It can also be amazing to watch, some guys are incredibly skillful.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XH42LEhcV3Y (beware, the sound track is irritating)

Great football players often could make some reasonable freestyling that impresses laymen, but they don't get even close to a dedicated spacialist. And the dedicated specialist will loose the ball in an actual game quickly, because in freestyling, you don't learn to shield from a tackle and you're probably not good at all in running 90 minutes.

Moreover, football is a game where you have 22 players on the pitch, and at most one player has total control of the ball at any one time. Most of the game play is moving without a ball - but still it's very important; particularly, defending is all about where you are and how you move, but also in attacking play, the ball-less players make the opportunities.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Bartweiss on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:44PM (#12753910)
Honestly, it feels like the difference between synchronized and 'regular' swimming, or ice dancing and speed skating. The only difference is that freestyling hasn't been equally established as a distinct activity.

In every case, the regular sport requires some of the technique and control of the performance sport, but comes with a rigid demand for efficiency.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by parthdesai on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:03PM (#12754633)
Yes definitely. It's just that to a normal person who doesn't know the sport, it might seem that being good at freestyle translated to being good at regular soccer/football.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by swasheck on Thursday October 20, 2016 @03:47PM (#12755481)
i've found that, so far, the hardest things to teach u10-u12 teams are:

a) spacing b) timing runs c) speed dribble

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:30AM (#12758547)
These seem to be the challenges with u17 or u19 teams as well...

Perhaps the speed dribble is done by that time - whatever can be done - and the emphasis is on spacing when defending: "Get closer!" (or whatever the coach shouts in English, ours goes NÄRMARE!)

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by SandersAK on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:52PM (#12754515)
The lack of flair and ingenuity in youth soccer in America is why our teams are so bad. We drill kids in what we think are core fundamentals because we treat soccer like US Football instead of the fluid dynamic game that it is.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by serge2k on Thursday October 20, 2016 @06:12PM (#12756637)
> we treat soccer like US Football

Well that's the problem. Quit leaving half the team on the bench and only practicing in 10 second bursts.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:42AM (#12752065)
>Thus, playing like FIFA just means you lose the ball to the opponents and you lose the game.

You're coming from a place where winning seems to be the goal. For a kids' team shouldn't having fun come first?

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by jerf on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:55AM (#12752178)
It depends on the age. My children have done some soccer at 4-5, and at that age, yeah it's just a fancy way of running around.

But as the kids get older, if winning and losing isn't on the table at all... what's the point? Why can't we use our hands? It's not like it affects the nonexistant outcome. Why are we chasing the balls instead of just running around on the playground? It's not like it affects the nonexistant out come. Why are we... non-existant outcome... etc. The whole activity has no foundation whatsoever if there's no victory state, and kids do eventually notice.

Yeah, some people get way too excited about it. This is not the dominant problem that I see; I see more people entirely destroying all reason to play the game at all by trying to remove the pain of loss, at the cost of the thrill of victory, any reason to work on improving oneself, and any reason to even be playing at all.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by vacri on Thursday October 20, 2016 @08:26PM (#12757337)
I'd rather play a good game and lose, than play a lopsided game and win.

I even remember once in my 20s in a local basketball league, we only had four players show up one night, including one fat guy who didn't run and couldn't shoot. We defeated our opponents who had a full bench and a couple of subs, who on a normal night were only slightly below our team's ability at normal strength. Rather than feeling elated that we defeated a full team when we were almost at half-strength, we felt bad for our fellow team, that they had such a bad night that they were defeated in such a way.

Winning is fun and a rush, absolutely, but I've had plenty of boring wins and plenty of awesome losses - there's more interest in a good challenge than a win, per se. If you distill the success of the game (in a local league, at least), just down to win/loss, you're doing it wrong, IMO.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by esrauch on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:00AM (#12752205)
What do you think of Hackeysack? It seems to have all of the characteristics of the "no point anymore without a winner" but people still don't use their hands, they still socialize and have fun and have a (reasonable) thrill of doing well and the pain of messing up.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by jerf on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:25AM (#12753123)
I think that it doesn't have nationwide programs for every grade, with local tournaments running up to international tournaments, taught in school, and such a large part of our culture that we all know what a "soccer mom" is even as soccer still hasn't really taken over as our dominant national sport.

Not everything has to be competitive. I mean, duh, right? But taking an activity that was designed to be competitive and then trying to strip out the competitive part isn't a good idea. Far better to start over again and design something not competitive from the get-go.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ensignavenger on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:46PM (#12753929)
I've only played Hackeysack a few times, but it seems like 'losing' was equated to 'messing up' and 'winning' was equated to 'not messing up'. The victory conditions are different, and you and your team are playing against yourselves, but the concept of victory is still there.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by sosborn on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:14PM (#12754739)
> It seems to have all of the characteristics of the "no point anymore without a winner"

It's like you have never even played California Games.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by stcredzero on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:42PM (#12754408)
What do you think of Hackeysack? It seems to have all of the characteristics of the "no point anymore without a winner"

Looking clumsy or looking skillful is a consequence in and of itself.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by malz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:14PM (#12756973)
Why is your kid playing a sport? To have fun. What's more fun, winning or losing? Winning. That's all there is to it.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by hyperpape on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:51AM (#12752139)
You should have fun, but you should also teach real skills. You seem to have confused the statements "winning isn't the only goal" and "winning isn't a goal".
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by kohanz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:00AM (#12752871)
Not sure why you're getting down-voted. I think people are confusing "fun comes first" with winning not mattering at all.

For young kids, the focus should be on fun (otherwise they won't play) and skills development (fundamentals). Of course you try to win the game, but the idea is that you don't try to win at all cost, especially at the expense of those other two things.

The strategy you would employ with a team of kids to win as many games as possible is very different from the one you would use to develop them the most as good future players.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by bachmeier on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:48AM (#12752114)
Repeatedly losing the ball is not only not fun, it is painful for teammates to watch someone waste opportunity after opportunity in an attempt to create highlights, and it is boring for the parents to watch.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:19PM (#12754785)
I think for a child's team being coached by parents the main goal should be the kids having fun and getting exercise, not entertaining the parents.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Fredi_ on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:17AM (#12753053)
For a kids team the goal should be improving their skills as well as having fun. Winning should not take a front seat to development.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by duaneb on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:39AM (#12753262)
This is true. But I also remember being sick of that rule by age ten. Competition is very necessary to enjoy the game.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:51AM (#12752742)
It really depends on the age. Even if the play is just for fun, losing games repeatedly is very demotivating for older kids. My youngest is now 20.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:24PM (#12754839)
20 year olds don't play in leagues coached by parents. It's fine for leagues to be competitive. However, for the most part, it's the parents who care about winning and losing in the leagues for young kids, not the kids themselves.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by scient on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:11AM (#12752293)
Don't bring that "everyone is a winner" talk here, it a breeding ground for people with no competitive drive.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:12AM (#12752998)
I think you bring it on in a bit too negative way, but indeed, many people have competitive drive and when we speak about 16 to 19 year olds playing in a competitive team, most have quite a bit of that drive, so a foolish team-mate who loses games is frustrating.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by lazyant on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:54AM (#12753416)
For kids under 12 or so the first objective is to keep them in the game; too many players give up under the pressure of yelling coaches and parents that care more about results than anything. We don't need a "everyone is a winner"; children are naturally competitive and enjoy winning, what we don't need is a "win at all costs" mentality in youth sports, you can both develop a player and a person. In youth soccer you can "cheat" players of their development by focusing on strategies that will win you games.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:20PM (#12754792)
Yeah, my bad. If a child's team being coached by one of the parents isn't being taught to go for the throat, there probably isn't any point.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by bmm6o on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:55AM (#12753420)
Is having the ball stolen during your pass attempt fun?
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:21PM (#12754807)
For a young kid's team, I would think that just getting out, running around, and enjoying themselves would be the primary goal.

Teaching ball control and possession are probably better suited for more organized, competitive leagues for older children.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Noctem on Saturday October 22, 2016 @02:18PM (#12769861)
I'm surprised that you mention lob passes to support your case. While the gameplay footage in trailers may feature them prominently since they're fun to watch, I wouldn't say that the actual game usually rewards playing that way. I rely far more on ground passes in the game than the teams I follow (Manchester United and Real Salt Lake) do in real life since it's so much easier to retain possession that way.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by pvg on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:44AM (#12753318)
Kids will still emulate semi-impossible things done by pro players even if it wasn't for FIFA so I'm not sure (nor do I think the article makes a particularly convincing case) the video game is to blame here. These long passes and traps are not from a video game:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VoviAc15Amk

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by CriminallyInane on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:48AM (#12752113)
but... the kids are playing the game... they are playing fifa like they play in real life and vice versa. Just sounds to me like they are learning the game and making mistakes in both.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:07AM (#12752259)
Sure, and it's pretty all right when they are young kids playing for fun.

When it's boys nearing adulthood supposedly playing more seriously, a few of them dreaming about pro careers, it looks silly and is frustrating to observe.

One essential thing to learn when you study football is that you have to respect and listen to your coach and also the teammates: don't lose the ball stupidly.