News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:42AM (#12752065)
>Thus, playing like FIFA just means you lose the ball to the opponents and you lose the game.

You're coming from a place where winning seems to be the goal. For a kids' team shouldn't having fun come first?

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by jerf on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:55AM (#12752178)
It depends on the age. My children have done some soccer at 4-5, and at that age, yeah it's just a fancy way of running around.

But as the kids get older, if winning and losing isn't on the table at all... what's the point? Why can't we use our hands? It's not like it affects the nonexistant outcome. Why are we chasing the balls instead of just running around on the playground? It's not like it affects the nonexistant out come. Why are we... non-existant outcome... etc. The whole activity has no foundation whatsoever if there's no victory state, and kids do eventually notice.

Yeah, some people get way too excited about it. This is not the dominant problem that I see; I see more people entirely destroying all reason to play the game at all by trying to remove the pain of loss, at the cost of the thrill of victory, any reason to work on improving oneself, and any reason to even be playing at all.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by vacri on Thursday October 20, 2016 @08:26PM (#12757337)
I'd rather play a good game and lose, than play a lopsided game and win.

I even remember once in my 20s in a local basketball league, we only had four players show up one night, including one fat guy who didn't run and couldn't shoot. We defeated our opponents who had a full bench and a couple of subs, who on a normal night were only slightly below our team's ability at normal strength. Rather than feeling elated that we defeated a full team when we were almost at half-strength, we felt bad for our fellow team, that they had such a bad night that they were defeated in such a way.

Winning is fun and a rush, absolutely, but I've had plenty of boring wins and plenty of awesome losses - there's more interest in a good challenge than a win, per se. If you distill the success of the game (in a local league, at least), just down to win/loss, you're doing it wrong, IMO.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by esrauch on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:00AM (#12752205)
What do you think of Hackeysack? It seems to have all of the characteristics of the "no point anymore without a winner" but people still don't use their hands, they still socialize and have fun and have a (reasonable) thrill of doing well and the pain of messing up.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by jerf on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:25AM (#12753123)
I think that it doesn't have nationwide programs for every grade, with local tournaments running up to international tournaments, taught in school, and such a large part of our culture that we all know what a "soccer mom" is even as soccer still hasn't really taken over as our dominant national sport.

Not everything has to be competitive. I mean, duh, right? But taking an activity that was designed to be competitive and then trying to strip out the competitive part isn't a good idea. Far better to start over again and design something not competitive from the get-go.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ensignavenger on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:46PM (#12753929)
I've only played Hackeysack a few times, but it seems like 'losing' was equated to 'messing up' and 'winning' was equated to 'not messing up'. The victory conditions are different, and you and your team are playing against yourselves, but the concept of victory is still there.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by sosborn on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:14PM (#12754739)
> It seems to have all of the characteristics of the "no point anymore without a winner"

It's like you have never even played California Games.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by stcredzero on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:42PM (#12754408)
What do you think of Hackeysack? It seems to have all of the characteristics of the "no point anymore without a winner"

Looking clumsy or looking skillful is a consequence in and of itself.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by malz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:14PM (#12756973)
Why is your kid playing a sport? To have fun. What's more fun, winning or losing? Winning. That's all there is to it.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by hyperpape on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:51AM (#12752139)
You should have fun, but you should also teach real skills. You seem to have confused the statements "winning isn't the only goal" and "winning isn't a goal".
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by kohanz on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:00AM (#12752871)
Not sure why you're getting down-voted. I think people are confusing "fun comes first" with winning not mattering at all.

For young kids, the focus should be on fun (otherwise they won't play) and skills development (fundamentals). Of course you try to win the game, but the idea is that you don't try to win at all cost, especially at the expense of those other two things.

The strategy you would employ with a team of kids to win as many games as possible is very different from the one you would use to develop them the most as good future players.

Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by bachmeier on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:48AM (#12752114)
Repeatedly losing the ball is not only not fun, it is painful for teammates to watch someone waste opportunity after opportunity in an attempt to create highlights, and it is boring for the parents to watch.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:19PM (#12754785)
I think for a child's team being coached by parents the main goal should be the kids having fun and getting exercise, not entertaining the parents.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by Fredi_ on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:17AM (#12753053)
For a kids team the goal should be improving their skills as well as having fun. Winning should not take a front seat to development.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by duaneb on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:39AM (#12753262)
This is true. But I also remember being sick of that rule by age ten. Competition is very necessary to enjoy the game.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:51AM (#12752742)
It really depends on the age. Even if the play is just for fun, losing games repeatedly is very demotivating for older kids. My youngest is now 20.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:24PM (#12754839)
20 year olds don't play in leagues coached by parents. It's fine for leagues to be competitive. However, for the most part, it's the parents who care about winning and losing in the leagues for young kids, not the kids themselves.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by scient on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:11AM (#12752293)
Don't bring that "everyone is a winner" talk here, it a breeding ground for people with no competitive drive.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by ptaipale on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:12AM (#12752998)
I think you bring it on in a bit too negative way, but indeed, many people have competitive drive and when we speak about 16 to 19 year olds playing in a competitive team, most have quite a bit of that drive, so a foolish team-mate who loses games is frustrating.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by lazyant on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:54AM (#12753416)
For kids under 12 or so the first objective is to keep them in the game; too many players give up under the pressure of yelling coaches and parents that care more about results than anything. We don't need a "everyone is a winner"; children are naturally competitive and enjoy winning, what we don't need is a "win at all costs" mentality in youth sports, you can both develop a player and a person. In youth soccer you can "cheat" players of their development by focusing on strategies that will win you games.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:20PM (#12754792)
Yeah, my bad. If a child's team being coached by one of the parents isn't being taught to go for the throat, there probably isn't any point.
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by bmm6o on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:55AM (#12753420)
Is having the ball stolen during your pass attempt fun?
Re:Video Games Are Changing the Way Soccer Is Played by paulcole on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:21PM (#12754807)
For a young kid's team, I would think that just getting out, running around, and enjoying themselves would be the primary goal.

Teaching ball control and possession are probably better suited for more organized, competitive leagues for older children.