News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @08:46PM (#12536064)
The actual facts aside, this makes her appear far less electable, as her campaign camp looks like it's being run by a bunch of clowns.

Just from a PR perspective, this could not have come at a worse time.

The collapse at the 9/11 memorial, the "basket of deplorables", and the mention of the Pepe meme on her official website. Right after a couple of muslim terror attacks, some evidence surfaces purporting that she tried to cover up email indiscretions?

Most people do believe that where there's smoke, there's fire. And this cluster of events can't be good.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mcphage on Monday September 19, 2016 @08:59PM (#12536124)
> Most people do believe that where there's smoke, there's fire.

Which is why continuously pushing smoke, even when you know there's no fire, is such an effective strategy. How many Benghazi hearings were there, that all came to the same conclusion? But people hear "oh, there's another Benghazi hearing, it must mean something that there's so many!" even though everyone involved knows that it means nothing.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by 001sky on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:32PM (#12536826)
Couple of points -- (1) Colin powell's leaked e-mails apparently called the meetings a circus and a sideshow but also placed blame at the feet of HRC for outcome of that episode. that last bit isn't always quoted in the media.

(2) The leak to the NYT about the server that broke this story appeared has been originated by the Obama administration. They were seeking to clip her wings as whispers about her policy differences with the Obama administration were circulating on Iran. Once HRC became such a sure thing she was inevitable as POTUS it would rended BSO an early lame duck, and on policy in the middle east where the two differ, would create issues for obama establishing a legacy. Obama now has the ability to pardon her (or in the actual turn of events, the Justice granted 'stonetear' limited immunity and killed a looming FBI indictment).

So both of these narratives play into a deeper and more complex game existing in DC than any sound bite or talking point proffered from a PR agency will attest.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jljljl on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:03AM (#12537186)
Do you have a source for #2? It defies belief, why would Obama clip the wings of his likely democratic successor, knowing that a Republican presidential would endanger Obamacare and several other major achievements of his administration?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by 001sky on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:23AM (#12537263)
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/03/us/politics/hillary-clinto...

Cites obama admin source

byline By MICHAEL S. SCHMIDTMARCH 2, 2015

24 hours before

Netanyahu’s Full Speech Before Congress, Mar. 3, 2015

http://www.nytimes.com/video/world/middleeast/10000000354782...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Monday September 19, 2016 @08:58PM (#12536119)
> as her campaign camp looks like it's being run by a bunch of ~~clowns~~

as her campaign camp looks like it's being run by a bunch of criminals who delete incriminating evidence.

FTFY

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:05PM (#12536157)
> being run by a bunch of criminals who delete incriminating evidence.

I have no problems accepting the fact that politicians might hire crooks to do some things that are extra legal. The fact that they're incompetent criminals who get caught and who don't understand the internet, that worries me.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:14PM (#12536219)
> do some things that are extra legal.

Illegal.

I have more problems with politicians hiring crooks to do illegal things for them, than with criminals being incompetent.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by sillysaurus3 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:08PM (#12536179)
Can you help me understand your point of view?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:13PM (#12536209)
It might be kind of silly, but I think that the US government has to do a lot of shady things to ensure that we have a high standard of living and more of our share of natural resources.

Look up the origin of the term "banana republic" if you don't believe me. Or just look through how many things we did in South/Central America due to the doctrine of manifest destiny.

So if we have to do something bad to ensure a steady supply of oil at a reasonable price, sure. I can accept that.

But we should be discerning enough to figure out who to hire, and how to GET AWAY WITH IT to avoid repercussions. If you're the president, there's a lot more at stake here than your campaign - we're talking about full blown war.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by PKop on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:28PM (#12536292)
That's shadiness for the country's benefit you're describing, not shadiness for personal benefit to avoid criminal prosecution so you can get elected president... Shadiness to cover the tracks of previous shadiness to hide your own emails from FOIA requests.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:46PM (#12536381)
The question here is competence, and lack thereof.

I think that skill in shadiness is transferrable across motives. If you can't plan a robbery of a convenience store for your own wallet, why should I let you plan the robbery of a bank to give it all away to charity?

The ends (sorta) matter in a moralistic sort of way. But the means matter much more. You're playing for higher stakes here, not just criminal prosecution, but a low level brush war in the middle east if you mess things up.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by maxerickson on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:26PM (#12536284)
The banality of evil and all that.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by ookdatnog on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:54AM (#12537880)
> So if we have to do something bad to ensure a steady supply of oil at a reasonable price, sure. I can accept that.

aka robbing from the poor and giving to the rich

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by albinofrenchy on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:13PM (#12536212)
Its the Lil Wayne metric -- be good or be good at it. Every politician is presumably some level of corrupt; you might as well prefer the ones smart enough not to leave evidence everywhere.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by 794CD01 on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:34PM (#12536585)
Evil can be harnessed to good with appropriate incentives. You can't incent a stupid person to be smart.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by rezashirazian on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:26PM (#12536281)
On top of all of these what I found fascinating is the amount of blind luck bestowed upon Trump. The guy has swallowed a horseshoe.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:59AM (#12537173)
I don't think it's blind luck.

Trump really knows how to seize advantage of a weakness.

And remember, he's already primed the pump.

He's labeled Clinton as "crooked" and "lacking stamina" far before all this happened. He must have seen something, cause everything she's done since then has confirmed it.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imjustsaying on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:15PM (#12536513)
I think this demonstrates the frailty of a two-party system. If one candidate in the general unexpectedly gets knocked out, the election is all but over.

Granted, the primaries remedy this to an extent, except when you have the unabashed stacking that was employed to counter recent 2012 and 2016 primary campaigns.

Democracy is at its most interactive in the early stages of the election, but the vast majority of people will never leverage that opportunity. People don't act until a media apparatus cues them to cast a vote for its packaged candidate de jour.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by adamrezich on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:15AM (#12537742)
Good thing here in America we don't have a two-party system!
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by devopsproject on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:16PM (#12540667)
> blind luck

He has been successful in business and is now at the helm of one of the most powerful political parties in the known universe. No one has that kind of "luck". There is something more there.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by brown9-2 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:20PM (#12536242)
> and the mention of the Pepe meme on her official website

mentioning a meme on her website is disqualifying?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:25PM (#12536269)
> huh?

It's horrifying https://www.hillaryclinton.com/post/donald-trump-pepe-the-fr...

Edit: In response to your edit, she's attacking a cartoon frog. In seriousness.

Not only that, but she's trying to attribute characteristics to that frog that simply aren't any core part of why people post Pepe memes.

All of that questions the sensibilities of her campaign. Basically her campaign is going all out trying to paint Trump as racist, because that's really all they have left at this point, and even that isn't working too well.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by cloakandswagger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:34PM (#12536320)
I especially love the pop-up modal asking me "Is Trump unfit to be President?" on that site.

There's only a single button (I Agree), and clicking the X in the corner to close the modal causes the button to be pushed at the same time.

For someone as "experienced" as Clinton, her campaign is astoundingly incompetent.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by PostOnce on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:59PM (#12536684)
Literally the first thing you see visiting her site is an attack that you are forced to join in on, rather than talk of what she's going to do for the country.

"Guy B is bad, elect me." is not as strong an argument as "I can and will do X to improve Y, guy B can't." And you still get to attack in B!

How can I in good conscience vote either party? I would be infinitely amused if everyone without talking about it voted for a third party out of spite and it was a total shock the day after. "Green party, bafflingly, wins election", or whatever.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by colejohnson66 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:39AM (#12537108)
The problem with third parties is that it is, somehow, a vote for Trump[0] and Hillary[1]. Then there's the "lesser of two evils" fallacy[2] some Hillary supporters use. It's actually sad how people think there's no escape from the two party system.

[0]: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/201... [1]: http://www.breitbart.com/california/2016/08/11/nevertrump-yo... [2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lesser_of_two_evils_principl...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by PostOnce on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:45AM (#12537842)
It's not, though. If you dislike both of them equally, and it doesn't matter to you who wins, and you vote a third party, the difference to you is the same... you just have less on your conscience now because you didn't contribute to a particular side -- and there's the slight, lotto-winning-odds chance that everyone else quietly did the same thing...

What the hell, I'll give it a shot.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by adamrezich on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:11AM (#12537728)
We don't have a two-party system. The DNC and GOP just want us to believe that we do.

The more we keep believing that we do, the more this same crap will keep happening every four to eight years.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by SerLava on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:11PM (#12540633)
Yeah and when a lot of people vote third party, it pulls a lot of politicians toward the views held by the unelected third party.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by eli on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:09PM (#12536494)
Trump just blasted out a fundraiser text message with a broken link. Hard to find good tech people I guess.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by conanbatt on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:52PM (#12536413)
I clicked the link, saw that popup and had to share that abomination. What the hell.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by tomjakubowski on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:27PM (#12541265)
> There's only a single button (I Agree), and clicking the X in the corner to close the modal causes the button to be pushed at the same time.

Huh? No it doesn't. It just closes the modal. Pressing the button does a different thing.

Try it out in a fresh Incognito window, or equivalent.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jungletek on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:56PM (#12536437)
You say incompetent, I say intentional. It's an inverse Hanlon's Razor situation.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by cloakandswagger on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:04PM (#12536468)
The whole point of click-bait ads with fake vote buttons is to entice people with the perception of choice.

Only giving me one option offends my sensibilities, even if I belong to that person's camp. I can't think of a person on earth who enjoys having their autonomy removed.

So at best you've pissed off the people who support you, and at worst you've reinforced the other camp's argument that you're an authoritarian control-freak.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:30PM (#12536818)
You haven't been paying attention. Yes, pepe was fine, and yes many people who post it do so with no ill intent.

But you are ignoring that people who are proudly racist are openly admitting to using pepe specifically to broaden and popularize explicitly racist ideas. That deserves to have light shown on it.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:18AM (#12537021)
> But you are ignoring that people who are proudly racist are openly admitting to using pepe specifically to broaden and popularize explicitly racist ideas

You mean like the prominent white supremacists quoted in the article linked to by that expose?

Who later turned out to be a couple of trolls making up stuff for shits and giggles to see what sort of ridiculous things they could make journalists write? (http://dailycaller.com/2016/09/14/heres-how-two-twitter-pran...)

Giving credibility to that just makes you look foolish.

> using pepe specifically to broaden and popularize explicitly racist ideas

I await Hillary Clinton's expose on Mickey Mouse

https://www.google.com/search?q=mickey+mouse+nazi&tbm=isch

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:27AM (#12537059)
No, I mean people like Richard Spencer, an unashamed white supremacist who believes in segregating by race.

"We live in a society of a great deal of degeneracy, we live in a society in which the fundamental norms are liberal, and we are attempting to fight our way out of that. And sometimes that's going to involve using the means that are at hand. That's going to involve being a part of this fragmented group. That's going to involve dank memes. It's going to involve pepe. It's going to involve unleashing a little chaos". - Richard Spencer at the recent conference of the Alt Right

Willfully ignoring that these people are attempting to get organized, and co-opting whatever gets them traction, is unhelpful at best and dangerous.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:35AM (#12537094)
> Willfully ignoring that these people are attempting to get organized, and co-opting whatever gets them traction, is unhelpful at best and dangerous.

You've got it backwards. Allowing their words to control your actions gives them power over you.

Are 'dank memes' now racist also just like Pepe?

Imagine instead of 'It's going to involve pepe' he said 'It's going to involve breathing air and drinking water', or some other common and popular thing.

Do you give such idiots the power to control your actions over some common and totally innocuous thing that you might otherwise enjoy or find amusing?

That is called being played for a fool and that is what gets them traction.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:41AM (#12537115)
What are you talking about? I'm pointing out that they are intentionally using pepe memes to make their ideas seem innocuous. And they get retweeted widely. It's a fact, choose to do what you want with it.

If you want to blow that up into a giant hyperbole that's on you. Making people aware of what is going on doesn't limit anyone's speech or actions.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:00AM (#12537174)
> I'm pointing out that they are intentionally using pepe memes to make their ideas seem innocuous. And they get retweeted widely. It's a fact, choose to do what you want with it.

The same would be true if they posted Mickey Mouse memes or anything else. To claim Pepe memes by default have any sort of racist undertones (as the Clinton campaign is doing) is false.

> Making people aware of what is going on doesn't limit anyone's speech or actions

Except with that article on Hillary's site, it's not being done to 'make people aware' it's done to brand Pepe as being racist so that when you see regular Trump supporters posting completely innocent Pepe memes (which they do with regularity) it creates the illusion that a large number of Trump supporters are racist (some are I'm sure but the same goes for any group that contains tens of millions of people).

Taking a white-supremacist at his word that Pepe is part of their movement also give them power and notoriety that they wouldn't otherwise have. By 'making people aware' you are giving voice to people who otherwise wouldn't be heard.

Don't believe me? Look at Google Trends for something like 'David Duke'

https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=david%20duke

Who do you think is responsible for creating that upsurge in interest?

Who are the people quoting Duke in articles and writing pages and pages of content about him?

Hint it isn't Trump, it's the people trying to tar Trump with a racist brush.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:01AM (#12537180)
I can't reply to you, but I suggest you try replying directly to my points instead of injecting your own political agenda.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:13AM (#12537221)
You can reply, you just need to wait a few minutes - it’s an HN feature to prevent people replying in haste.

I have no political agenda. I’m not from the US, I’m not in the US, I can’t vote in this election. I have no horse in this race. I’m an outsider looking in on the stupidity (on both sides).

I am addressing your points - or at least thought I was. Your point as it appears to me (feel free to correct me if I've misinterpreted you) was ‘we need to make people aware of how these white supremacists are promoting their ideals’.

My point is ‘this has the opposite intent of what you expect and like the Streisand effect, it inadvertently helps promote such ideals and gives these people cultural ground that they otherwise wouldn’t be able to occupy. Giving any sort of import to their ravings, makes them more important than they deserve to be, and gives them a degree of control over your actions.'

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:37AM (#12537326)
> this has the opposite intent of what you expect and like the Streisand effect

They are promoting it themselves, loudly, and trying to inject their ideas into mainstream political discourse. I see no problem in calling for people to reject it, and helping them identify them. You can look into american history and see that we have been through cycles like this before (example the 'Know Nothings' against the catholics).

I have myself clearly seen more speech in favor of segregation ("we just weren't meant to mix together") on many sites (reddit, facebook comments on congressman pages, etc). I can give you links to explicitly racist sites where they talk about organizing on popular websites to change discourse. You argue I'm giving them the Streisand effect, but we are already too late. They are here, people need to be aware today. These people intentionally prey on those who are susceptible and angry.

I have two (former) friends who have tried talking to me about how "cultural marxism is destroying western values" and that every muslim has evil in their hearts. They weren't always like this.

They don't deserve to be important, instead of ignoring them people need to be willing to say that this is unacceptable and their ideas are not welcome.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:16AM (#12537492)
> They don't deserve to be important, instead of ignoring them people need to be willing to say that this is unacceptable and their ideas are not welcome.

Which is a better way to show someone that they are not important:

  * Ignoring them
  * Giving their views countless press in order to discredit them
I agree that calling out racism is important, but when it's just people spouting nonsense in their own little corner of the Internet why give that any attention.

> They are promoting it themselves, loudly, and trying to inject their ideas into mainstream political discourse

Something they have been trying to do since basically forever. However they can only successfully inject themselves when other people allow it.

Have a look at this basic timeline:

Internet: Pepe the frog is fun

Racists: Pepe the frog now belongs to us

Internet: Nah, Pepe's not racist.

Clinton: Pepe the frog belongs to racists

Internet: Nah, Pepe's not racist.

Question: In this scenario, who gave racists control of Pepe the frog and who allowed racists to inject themselves in to this part of mainstream culture? (Hint: it was not the racists and it was not the Internet).

> I can give you links to explicitly racist sites

This is exactly what I was talking about. In your fervor to show how horrible these people are, you are willing to promote these sites yourself...

I don't care for those sites any more than I care for sites promoting flat-earth science and/or UFOs. I know they exist, but I ignore them completely, which is exactly the attention they deserve.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:45AM (#12537622)
You are wrongly characterizing what I am saying. Maybe try reading my original post again? People can only "allow" them to inject themselves into discourse when they have full consent, ie what their agenda is. Ignoring them doesn't silence them, nor makes it clear that their ideas are not acceptable.

Did I give you any links? I indicated that they are there and it is explicit and obvious.

If you cannot handle that a meme is ALSO (which means NOT ENTIRELY ie they dont own it) by people with a racist agenda then I frankly don't know what to say. The above people asked for proof, I gave it to them. Deal with the facts.

I'm not going to stop pointing out the tactics of white supremacists to inject themselves in mainstream culture.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:23AM (#12537764)
> Maybe try reading my original post again?

Ok, sure

> But you are ignoring that people who are proudly racist are openly admitting to using pepe specifically to broaden and popularize explicitly racist ideas

Yes. I am ignoring such people, because such tactics don't merit anything more. I would also ignore them if they claimed to be using Mickey Mouse or any other broadly popular icon to promote their ideas.

Because it deserves nothing more than a rolling of my eyes.

What I will call out is people (like the Clinton campaign) accepting or validating the idea that Pepe is somehow a racist, nazi frog.

> If you cannot handle that a meme is ALSO (which means NOT ENTIRELY ie they dont own it) by people with a racist agenda then I frankly don't know what to say

I can handle it fine. It's the Clinton campaign (and surrogates) that are trying to actively associate Pepe as a symbol of racism and that's what I object to.

I think this conversation has reached the point where it is only going to go round in circles, so I'm bowing out now. Please enjoy the rest of your day.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Inconel on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:21AM (#12538361)
This is exactly my problem with the Clinton campaign article about Pepe being a white nationalist symbol. I found that article troubling because first, it reads like satire and I am legitimately frightened that this is what a major presidential candidate views as political discourse in this country, and second because it so unequivocally casts Pepe as racist symbolism, which is completely false. There is no nuance whatsoever in that article, which increasingly seems like standard procedure in politics on both sides of the aisle. Nuance and deep understanding seem to have completely disappeared from politics, everything is black or white, good or evil.

I'm writing this on my computer and I have an entire folder on my desktop filled with rare Pepes that I've collected over the years. I'm not a white nationalist and up until last week I had a Pepe sticker on my backpack that I carry with me everywhere. When I saw this article gaining mainstream attention I immediately took the sticker off. I have enough things to deal with in life to not want to worry about being called a racist because of my Pepe sticker. Now, I understand there are much greater injustices in the country to deal with than this, but this is yet another example of politicians using these kind of binary arguments that end up making serious discourse impossible.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @08:09AM (#12538848)
1. Not a member of the clinton campaign

2. > I can handle it fine. It's the Clinton campaign (and surrogates) that are trying to actively associate Pepe as a symbol of racism and that's what I object to.

People promoting racism are doing this, you want to stay willfully ignorant about it.

[dead]
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:43PM (#12543222)
Care to explain?
[dead]
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:28PM (#12543934)
In the opinion of an anonymous Donald Trump troll account. Not really lending much credibility there. Not surprised you can't defend for your own agenda though.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by adamrezich on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:00AM (#12536958)
Does it? What does it prove? Why does shining the spotlight on self-proclaimed Internet racists actually accomplish? Especially seeing as how much of the racism seems to mostly be in service of attention-seeking?

What do you get out of proving that self-proclaimed racists [do x], as a small subset of people who [do x]?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by snowwrestler on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:35AM (#12537317)
It helps motivate others to help keep their standard-bearer out of the most powerful office in the world.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:12AM (#12536998)
Not self proclaimed internet racists, we're talking about white nationalists and race segregationists like Richard Spencer and Jared Taylor discussing Pepe as a way to "speak truth to power".
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Klathmon on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:37PM (#12536338)
Wow, not a single line on that page about what she believes, what she stands for.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by akhilcacharya on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:50PM (#12536404)
That's because you can find that here:

https://www.hillaryclinton.com/issues/

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Klathmon on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:59PM (#12536450)
I just find the whole "attack others without any mention of myself" thing to be so... Off putting.

It's sad that it's so common, and scary effective. I just wish that it wasn't this way and that things like attack ads would at least include some info on how the candidate is different/better than the one they are attacking.

The sad truth is that I believe many of the same things as one of the major candidates, and when looking at the issues I do agree with some from the other, but the way they almost entirely ignore the issues and spend most of their time attacking others doesn't fill me with confidence that either one wont just bring that toxicity into an already toxic and gridlocked political system.

Yelling half-truths and over exaggerating the "enemy" isn't going to help the country at all. And IMO that stuff has no place on the offical website of a candidate.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by adamrezich on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:11AM (#12536993)
The actual reason for all of this is because both major American political parties have discovered, as many corporations have over the past few years, that the only thing that matters when it comes to persuasion is appeals to one's identity and emotions directly. As it turns out, people don't give a crap about logic, reason, facts, deduction... our day-to-day lives are complex enough as it is, only a few of us can actually afford the time to research all of the media's claims, and thus, reactionary, controversial, attention-grabbing headlines (not full articles, who reads those anyways?) dictate what people believe is the truth.

So yeah, you and I look at that modal popup and think, "ew gross, why are you trying THIS hard to shove this negative image of your opponent down my throat, before I can even see a single fact about you and your campaign?", but I can totally see why they would do such a thing. People are very susceptible to being persuaded by these strong emotional accusations—it seems to me that the dialog is saying, "hey, you're not one of those filthy TRUMP supporters, ARE YOU? If not, prove it by clicking this button below." I believe that such a persuasive device is far more effective than either of us can imagine.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by akhilcacharya on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:51PM (#12536408)
> because that's really all they have left at this point

It's really not, the reason why they keep hammering it home is because his vocal support among the fringes is unprecedented in the modern era.

They've got plenty of things to attack him on - which they do.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:45AM (#12537625)
A more cynical view is that they keep hammering it home because Trump's outreach to black voters is working enough that it has become electorally significant [0].

Polls show he currently has historically high support among black voters - and not just for himself, but out of any Republican candidate over the last few decades [1], and it's high enough that it could tip the election.

0: http://graphics.latimes.com/usc-presidential-poll-dashboard/ (scroll to 'by race/ethnicity').

1: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2015/06/11/ho...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by akhilcacharya on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:52PM (#12545258)
That's unlikely. The LATimes tracking poll is known to be unorthodox in its methodology, it's meant to track fluctuations in support more than actual support. Trump has not broken ~6% in any other swing state polls or national polls that I've seen, sometimes he's in 4th place behind Johnson and Stein.

As it turns out, delegitimizing and spreading conspiracy theories about a wildly popular president in a community does not make people in a community fans of you.

Most analysts don't think the outreach was targeted at black voters at all, but rather white moderates, who are more persuadable and numerous in number.

0: http://www.vox.com/2016/8/24/12587672/donald-trump-s-black-o...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jessaustin on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @09:12AM (#12539231)
...the fringes...

Who is this? How can I tell who of my neighbors is in this group? Having made that determination, how should I treat those neighbors?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by sanderjd on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @10:00AM (#12539527)
This seems akin to feigned disbelief - you know the answers to these questions but are pretending not to. I'll bite anyway!

> Who is this? How can I tell who of my neighbors is in this group?

People who espouse beliefs far away from the median belief in the society. You can tell by taking to them about their beliefs, or often in my experience by having them talk at you about them or by looking at bumper stickers and flags they display, and then comparing the beliefs they espouse to your intuition of what the median belief is. Of course everyone's intuition of that is based on the people they themselves know, so "the fringe" ends up defined differently for different people. This can be controlled a bit by reading or being exposed to summaries of reports of society-wide studies, like polls and surveys. This is what the news should help with, but unfortunately people tend to choose news from inside the same bubble as all the people they know, so that doesn't work that well either.

> Having made that determination, how should I treat those neighbors?

With the same kindness you treat everyone else, but without having to agree (or pretend to agree) with our have any respect for their views. You "hate the sin, not the sinner".

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jessaustin on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:16AM (#12540146)
Thanks for making the effort, but this definition is problematic in several respects. First of all, Trump is only a bit behind Clinton in the polls now, so either OP is wrong about Trump's supporters being those, as you put it, "far away from the median" (we typically call this "long tail") or the variance is much higher than any rational observer could believe. 538 gives Trump an 88.5% chance of winning the state where I live. The median voter here is a Trumpet.

Second, the proposed method of making this identification is entirely subjective. I'm planning to vote either Green or Libertarian this election, because I oppose war, prohibition, and other travesties of the status quo. On the topics of most concern to me, I literally can't tell the difference between Clinton supporters and Trump supporters. How can I determine whose "sins" I should "hate"? Perhaps I should hate my own sins, even though they couldn't possibly be of support to Trump? This is quite disturbing to me, and the principle of charity had previously ruled out this reading of OP.

With the same kindness you treat everyone else, but without having to agree (or pretend to agree) with our have any respect for their views. You "hate the sin, not the sinner".

Incidentally, if any particular campaign takes this particular idiotic rhetorical stance, and then loses, and then wonders why? They'll be able to blame this particular idiotic rhetorical stance. In order to convince people of anything, one must speak with fluency in the people's terms. Your use of "sin" here would not be considered idiomatic by any Trump supporter I know.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by sanderjd on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @07:07PM (#12544118)
I shouldn't have included it at all for this exact reason, but the quote about "sin" and "sinners" is an aphorism that is meant to be interpreted metaphorically, not literally. It just means that you can respect people without needing to respect all of their opinions.

Like I pointed out in my comment, "fringe" is definitely subjective, but there are also some objective measures, but they are also fraught for various reasons (which I went into a bit in my comment).

The claim (which, I'm not making, but others are) is that the Trump campaign has attracted more of "the fringe", not that all his supporters are of "the fringe". It's very possible to have both "mainstream" and "fringe" support.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by phil248 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:32PM (#12536310)
How many more decades of witch hunts and investigations before we find some damn fire?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Mao_Zedang on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:33PM (#12536312)
It will happen pretty fast after a regime change, you cant expect dems to indite their own.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by throwanem on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:41PM (#12536355)
Except to the White House.

("Indict" means to charge with a crime. "Indite" is an archaic synonym for "invite". The joke I make about this confusion of terms originates with Shakespeare, so I think "indite" must be pretty archaic indeed!)

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by umanwizard on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:54PM (#12536428)
What do you mean? We found it. This is fire.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by heurist on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:57PM (#12541002)
It's an old unverified post on reddit being reviewed by republicans in the House of Representatives. Has everyone gone mad? We are literally paying our representatives to waste time reading Reddit based on a tenuous connection and some miniscule hope that it some how someday leads to FINALLY exposing the CORRUPT Hillary, or even better, hurting her chances of winning the presidency. Even if this were illegal, everything could be done with the best intentions and primarily legal concordance just like the email scandal, and STILL House Republicans would investigate it as if it were a war crime. Taxpayer money is being wasted on this bullshit, and yet these dipwads keep being reelected. THAT is the fire.

In this period of great economic uncertainty, a billionaire real estate tycoon and media mogul with no political experience, inflammatory rhetoric, and awful, authoritarian policy proposals is a serious contender for the most powerful office in the world, I'd say we have bigger problems to worry about tHan anything Hillary may have done. Our economy, livelihood, and potentially our freedom is at stake under this threat. Trump is a true menace to society and we are treating any little flaw shown by Hillary as villainy in the highest order. It's baffling, and terrifying.

In short, I'd take Crooked Hillary over Tyrant Trump any day.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by discodave on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:14PM (#12536216)
> The actual facts aside

I happen to believe that facts are important in a Presidential race.

Essentially your response is repeating talking points of the Trump campaign... which is OK, 1st amendment and all that but to pretend like you're making a constructive addition to the discussion / debate is folly.

Right now America has a choice between Trump, a racist, mysoginist demagogue who has never held a public office and Hillary Clinton. Hillary may have issues but she is also possibly the most experienced presidential candidate of the last couple of decades.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by TillE on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:25PM (#12536275)
> the most experienced presidential candidate of the last couple of decades

George H. W. Bush was a two term vice president, director of the CIA, etc.

I've been following this election pretty closely for more than a year, and I seriously couldn't tell you what Clinton's positive message is besides "I'm experienced". Nobody cares. Americans don't elect technocratic planks of wood. This is the worst, most inept presidental campaign I've ever seen. She's very nearly losing to a joke candidate.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by adamrezich on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:03AM (#12537698)
It's really interesting to hear you say that, actually, because from my perspective, she had two positive messages:

- "I'm experienced"

- "I'm a woman, and it's high time a woman became President"

It's interesting that her campaign has finally stopped beating us over the head with the latter, at least; it was insultingly sexist.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by peu4000 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:33AM (#12540288)
It's insultingly sexist to suggest that 51% of the population should finally have representation in the highest office in America?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by devopsproject on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:19PM (#12540693)
If a man said that he deserved a job over a woman on the basis of gender, it would be sexist (and wrong). The reverse is also true.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by pdabbadabba on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:31PM (#12536306)
He was elected a "couple of decades" ago. Feel old now? :)
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by elgenie on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:35PM (#12536327)
HW won in 1988 and lost in 1992. 1996 was two decades ago.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Dagwoodie on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:35PM (#12536326)
Since when is a long tenancy in a public office a good thing? What happened to strong morality and doing the right thing when nobody is looking? Hillary broke the law [0], plain and simple, and she isn't being punished because well, she is a powerful life-long politician with many friends in high places. At least Nixon had the moral decency to resign when it was clear he wasn't right to lead by example. The simple truth is she is a leftist, a globalist, and for those reason alone she'll get a lot of votes but unfortunately being those things in America today means nothing that else matters. Basic morality? flawed candidate. Broke the law? She had a good reason? Poor health? Doesn't matter, she has a capable leftist/globalist to take her place, we just need to get another D in the white house.

[0] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/d-c-rutledge/fbi-clinton-was-e...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:50PM (#12536405)
>At least Nixon had the moral decency to resign when it was clear he wasn't right to lead by example.

Yes, it was because Nixon had moral fiber. Not because he negotiated a deal with Ford to pardon him immediately and preemptively, thus saving him the humiliation of impeachment and legal repercussions.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Dagwoodie on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:57PM (#12536439)
I'm sure you're absolutely right. If he hadn't been such a snake he would have just fought the system, used his ample government connections to ensure he won't get prosecuted. The people would understand, he was just acting in those good intentions of advancing the desires of the party, after all.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:06PM (#12536480)
Nixon was 100 percent going to be impeached if he did not resign. He had very little sway in the Republican Party by the time the tapes came out. He ran an incredibly secretive and paranoid White House that was mostly disconnected from the Senate and made many enemies even in his own party.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by minikites on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:36PM (#12536334)
Globalist? I'm not sure what that means, much less why it earns votes.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by leurfete on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:27PM (#12536290)
"a racist, mysoginist[sic] demagogue"

"Hillary may have issues but she is also possibly the most experienced presidential candidate of the last couple of decades."

s/Trump/Clinton/ and your statement: "Essentially your response is repeating talking points of the Trump campaign."

serves as a valid critique of your own response.

-

Qualified for not, Clinton's corruption has been confirmed beyond any reasonable doubt over the course of many leaks and scandals. Democrats who continue to support her are just as blindly partisan as Republicans.

The whole system is broken. I won't be voting for anyone.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by WalterSear on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:40PM (#12536351)
At least vote. Write in your dog, if you have to. Otherwise future politicians won't aware that you will be at the poll, ready to vote for them, and they'll pander to someone else.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:35PM (#12536325)
Curious, do you have a handful of racist Trump quotes? Not stuff about illegals, but actual racist stuff (like not wanting to rent to blacks or something)?

Trump aside, electing someone that's openly corrupt (DNC Wikileaks show they went against Bernie, against rules) seems to be far more dangerous to the future of the US and worldwide democracy. Up until now, corruption was sort of assumed, but if a publicly corrupt candidate wins, it just shows "crime pays".

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:55PM (#12536431)
'"Black guys counting my money! I hate it. The only kind of people I want counting my money are little short guys that wear yarmulkes every day." (Trump called the things written about him in the book "probably true.")'

http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/8-of-the-sleaziest...

Also Trump was the President of the Trump organization when the DOJ fined the company for illegal housing discrimination, doing things like marking the lease applications of African Americans with a 'C' for 'Colored' so that they would know not to rent to them.

[dead]
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by morgante on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:33AM (#12537090)
> The only kind of people I want counting my money are little short guys that wear yarmulkes every day.

This is not a pro-Jewish statement. It's a textbook anti-semite stereotype.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by patrickg_zill on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:41AM (#12537337)
Technically it is a reference only to Orthodox Jews, who wear their yarmulkes to work.

Secular (non-religious or atheist or whatever) and Reform (not sure about Conservative, but I think they don't wear yarmulkes to work) Jews wouldn't be included.

I know both Jews who would laugh and those who would be offended by it.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:58AM (#12537167)
How is it anti? It's a positive stereotype.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by morgante on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:03AM (#12537185)
I'm done here.

If you really cannot understand how stereotyping an entire ethnicity as short money-counters is offensive, you are far beyond help. I should have figured that from the start.

It depresses me that such retrograde, Nazi-level antisemitism is tolerated on Hacker News.

As a Jew, I am offended. And I'm the group who that statement is supposed to "flatter." Think of the Black accountants who Trump apparently thinks are incompetent purely due to the color of their skin. This shit belongs in the 1940s, not 2016.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:28AM (#12537545)
Most people can see exactly who these people are, so leaving their comments up provides everyone with a persistent proof of their character.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:47AM (#12540417)
The person that said the quote about which financial people he wants has Jewish grandkids. I hardly think that is "Nazi level" and I don't mind having my comment up.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:07PM (#12536710)
You might want to look into whether or not your understanding of the concept of racism comports with its actual definition.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by minikites on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:37PM (#12536343)
You don't think his rhetoric against undocumented immigrants is racist?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:42PM (#12536362)
It's not "undocumented immigrants", it's "illegal immigrants".

If you enforce the law, they should be deported. Now they probably have very good reasons for immigrating, but the fact remains that they broke the law and our borders, and the job of the executive branch is to enforce the laws.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by minikites on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:48PM (#12536389)
Deporting Syrian refugees (the most recent target of Trump's rhetoric) would be breaking a major international law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_Relating_to_the_Sta...
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by tanderson92 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:56PM (#12536436)
Syrian refugees are not illegal immigrants, which was the topic of conversation of the GP poster.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Zpalmtree on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:53PM (#12536418)
Last time I checked "undocumented" immigrants aren't a race, and they also broke the law. It's not racist to attack people breaking the law.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by zimzam on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:12AM (#12536997)
This claim cain only be made by somebody ignorant of the history of racism: racism almost always lives with a non-racist pretext. Here are a couple of examples, though many more exist:

Lynchings were instigated by an accusation of a crime - the perpetrators could claim they weren't racist, they were just keeping their communities safe! [1]

Japanese internment too had a non-racist pretext: people of Japanese descent were claimed to be disloyal citizens with greater allegiance to Japan (even after being born in the USA or becoming naturalized) than the USA. [2]

We know that the debate about undocumented immigrants isn't about to Europeans who overstay their tourist visas or Canadians sneaking across the border: it is about a single ethnic group (hispanic) who have come across the Mexican border. This means that 'undocumented' can easily be a euphemism for 'hispanic', allowing people to shift racist statements into ostensibly non-racist ones. While not all discussions of undocumented immigrants are racist, some certainly are a form of dog whistle [3]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynching_in_the_United_States#...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog-whistle_politics#United_St...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:10AM (#12537466)
You're talking ignorantly right now.

First, the two examples of racism you point out are decades old. Try to pay attention to current events.

We share a long, fairly badly secured land border with a country with significantly worse living and earning conditions than we enjoy. The fact that all those people trying to come to a better life share an ethnicity is not relevant at all.

If you want to see racism, see how British people treat Polish immigrants, even though the Poles have every right in the world to be there.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:33AM (#12537089)
Are there a ton of EU overstays causing noticeable impact? Do you think if millions of Russians were illegally in the US working low-end jobs (for the most part) and being rather highly visible (flying Russian flags at protests) it'd be waved off?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:04PM (#12536466)
>“When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.”

It's pretty racist to attack a whole contingent of people and make broad negative generalizations about them and qualify with a half-hearted caveat that 'some' are good people. He's quite clearly drawing a line between "you" (the white audience he was speaking to) and the Other (i.e. the Mexicans) personified as rapists and drug dealers.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:33PM (#12536582)
Sounded like it was clearly "you" as legal Mexicans and other immigrants. The rest of the sentence is about illegals -- he's not, afaik, made any claims about Mexicans in general. If he was actually making a racist statement, then immigration status wouldn't matter.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:11AM (#12536991)
"You" clearly haven't even read or seen the speech and are talking completely out of your ass. It was one of his opening talking points in his presidential announcement in New York City to his cronies - https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/06...

It's pretty straightforward xenophobic, hyper jingoist nationalist rhetoric. You = us good Americans. They = the Other. He uses the car industry for Japan, a conservative talking point since the 80s. For Mexico he harps on immigration and calls them rapists. It's aggregate and subjectivity-denying. It's racist and dumb.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:30AM (#12537074)
I saw it, way back when he spoke. "They're not sending you" never occurred to me as "you, Americans". That'd uh, make no sense: Mexico is not a significant source of Americans immigrating to America.

At any rate, it's still besides the point. He's accurate in saying that people coming in illegally aren't "the best". If you're a top professional you're not going to risk illegal immigration anywhere, generally speaking. This lines up with my and others' personal experience (I lived in Central America for nearly 2 decades).

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @10:11AM (#12539599)
> "They're not sending you" never occurred to me as "you, Americans". That'd uh, make no sense: Mexico is not a significant source of Americans immigrating to America.

He's talking to a roomful of Americans mentioning how America (referred to as us, you) is being beaten by other countries (they). It's pretty obvious. Just because it doesn't make any sense doesn't negate what Trump was implying - it's not like he's known for sound logical reasoning or even being able to approximate a grain of truth. If you seriously think he was referring to "legal Mexicans" in that speech (again, to a roomful of his white cronies in Midtown NYC) then I got a brooklyn bridge to sell you.

>At any rate, it's still besides the point. He's accurate in saying that people coming in illegally aren't "the best".

Is he accurate in saying that Mexicans only care about "beating" us at the border and that they are mostly rapists with only some, he "assumes", are good people? Come on.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by maxerickson on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:12PM (#12536500)
Depends a little bit on the law at hand.

Illegal immigration is easy to attack without being racist. Mixed marriage not so much.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by thatswrong0 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:45PM (#12536374)
I don't think he's said anything about having a problem with legal immigrants.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:58PM (#12536445)
Incorrect. He wants to end the H1B visa program (despite the fact that he uses for seasonal work at his club in Florida) and he does not want to accept political refugees attempting to come to the US legally.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Inconel on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:21PM (#12536775)
Correct me if I'm wrong, and I may well be, but I'm under the impression that a significant number of posters on HN have problems with the H1B visa program. I'm not particularly knowledgable on the subject but from the comments I've read most of the concern centers around driving down wages, and thus costs for employers, and shackling H1B visa holders to specific jobs.

Is this an incorrect reading of the sentiment here? And more importantly, should I assume that anyone against the H1B program feels so because of racial animus?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:09AM (#12536987)
I should have been more clear when I referenced H1B. My personal opinion about the program is that it is deeply flawed, mostly because it is a sort of legalized indentured servitude.

I doubt Trump has those same feelings however, as he hires H1B works at his own club in Palm Beach instead of Americans. If he was morally opposed to the program, I doubt he would do that.

I brought it up because he talks about it in a way to scapegoat foreigners, appealing to the darker angels of people who have racist tendencies and are looking for someone to blame. I find such a tactic reprehensible, and I personally do not draw a distinction between someone who acts on racist feelings and someone who makes racist appeals to those who act on racist feelings.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Inconel on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @05:50AM (#12538260)
Thanks for the response. I agree with you that at best Trump seems hypocritical to denounce the H1B visa program after having employed those holding H1B visas, and at worst much more nefarious for using those immigrants as scapegoats. At the same time, my main concern with your original comment was that you used his stance on the H1B program as an example of his racism. Now, in Trump's case that very well may be true, but by using his stand against H1B's as your reasoning you basically imply that anyone against the H1B program is also racist. I understand that wasn't what you meant to imply but it highlights to me one of the dangers of the current political climate. Namely, a person might have a specific stance on an issue based on very legitimate reasoning, in this case the H1B program being indentured servitude, and if someone else comes along who happens to hold those same views for perhaps less legitimate reasons, lets say racism, we tend to automatically discount the stance as being racist or otherwise illegitimate.

Being labelled a racist is a pretty serious charge for most people who don't have wealth or power and actually have to live and work with a diverse group of people. I would hate to be called a racist due to being against the current way the H1B program is administered just because Trump is against it as well.

Again, I'm sure that's not actually what you meant, but it points to the importance of using very clear language when leveling these kind of accusations.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by garrettgrimsley on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:53PM (#12536659)
There's a difference between immigration law and immigrants. Your comment doesn't address what the parent commentor said.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by douche on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:59PM (#12536686)
Fixing a broken, oft-abused system is contemptible now?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:17PM (#12536756)
I think the H1B program is terribly flawed and certainly abused. But Trump is not talking about reforming it, he only talks about in the context of "foreigners stealing our jobs" (paraphrase), which I find quite contemptible. And without a meaningful plan to replace it would close an avenue for people to legally immigrate to the US, which makes it seem like he might have a problem with legal immigrants.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:35PM (#12536836)
Why is "foreigners stealing our jobs" contemptible? Assuming H1B is abused (I understand this can be in dispute), why should a candidate for a country not want to help its own citizens?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by throwaway2016b on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:21PM (#12536774)
I think this is a big part of why the SV powerhouses are mobilizing against Trump. They rally the troops with hyperbole and accusations of racism and sexism, but in private they're afraid of losing their H1B wage slaves and tax havens.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by JoeAltmaier on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:24PM (#12536786)
Some of that I suppose. But also, he's an evil man. Doesn't take a conspiracy theory to want to see him defeated.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by throwaway2016b on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:34PM (#12536834)
Hillary is far, far more deserving of that label than Trump. To campaign and donate millions of dollars on her behalf requires ignorance, a seriously twisted moral compass, or some financial and political incentives that you don't want to talk about.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @08:38AM (#12538998)
She's spent her life struggling to help children and single parents. Donations fund her charity that has helped millions worldwide. To twist that into something bad is just more of the political smokescreen that plagues any woman in public office.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:36PM (#12545211)
You're saying this is a sexist thing?

She was linked to Whitewater, was that because she was a woman?

She constantly defended Bill Clinton's sexual indiscretions. http://www.nationalreview.com/article/435941/hillary-clinton....

She moved to New York just so she could run for senator.

She and Bill also spent 3 million dollars on her daughter's wedding. Where did she come up with that money, considering that a President's salary is in the mid six figures?

Oh that's right, she (and Bill) get quarter million dollar speaking fees at Goldman Sachs.

What part of all that would not be reprehensible if she were a man, and if she were a man, wouldn't this all be dug up and thrown into his/her face if you were running for president?

How is pointing out moral turpitude a "political smokescreen that plagues every woman in public office"?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @08:46AM (#12547658)
Great list: Like any number of men get away with and no comment. None of that is reprehensible; that is all business as usual. A good fraction of our Senators are 'carpet baggers', not been brought up before. Loyalty to a spouse is lauded if its a man being loyal. #2 speaking fees is George Bush but nobody brought him up. And 'linked to' is another smokescreen catchphrase, slings mud without having to show any real problem.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:30AM (#12562713)
Yes, and none of those men are currently running for president.

If a man did all these things, and were running for POTUS, they'd get raked over the coals, just like Clinton is. What's your point?

Also, Clinton has made it a point to argue for "the right to be believed" for sexual assault victims. And she went to bat for her husband before that statement to cast doubt on his accusers? http://nypost.com/2016/08/15/hillarys-site-edits-sexual-assa...

What a two-faced person who should not be president.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by douche on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:54PM (#12536426)
I suspect he might end up sleeping on the couch if he did
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by AznHisoka on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:47PM (#12536384)
Quotes?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by slantedview on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:41PM (#12536356)
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:31PM (#12536575)
I don't see quotes on that page, just a few opening paragraphs and "Loading..." where I'd expect content to be. The opening paragraph is has a misquote/misstatement of its own so I'm a bit suspicious. The linked articles from the opening are also all-headline, little substance.

I don't mean this as a defence of Trump, but people seem to read into statements to determine his racism/bigotry/whatever. AFAIK he has not technically made a racist statement in any of his campaigning, for instance.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bpodgursky on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:19PM (#12536235)
Unfortunately, it's very easy to be both experienced and terrible at your job.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:39PM (#12536349)
I see that you're having a bit of trouble parsing my statements. Allow me to help.

>but to pretend like you're making a constructive addition to the discussion / debate is folly.

That's silly. I'm just saying that all these things happened. Facts, if you will. These things definitely happened and were reported ad nauseum. The terror attacks, Clinton passing out, her basket of deplorables comment, those actually happened. And now this email thing.

These were Trump talking points long before the events happened.

Now, I think that her campaign staff could somehow spin this so that she comes out relatively unscathed, IF all these things didn't happen within about a week of each other. If this was spaced out over a month or so, we'd forget.

The way the timing is, no spin doctor in the world can buff this out.

I'm not advocating for either candidate, like you are, but I'm pointing out the fact that Clinton has pretty much made herself unelectable.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Pxtl on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:36PM (#12536595)
The fact that those items have more negative impact on her electability than her mentorship under Henry Kissinger is terribly depressing.
[dead]
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:30PM (#12536817)
Probably even more mildly amusing when the ideological cleansing begins as well.