News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by minikites on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:37PM (#12536343)
You don't think his rhetoric against undocumented immigrants is racist?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:42PM (#12536362)
It's not "undocumented immigrants", it's "illegal immigrants".

If you enforce the law, they should be deported. Now they probably have very good reasons for immigrating, but the fact remains that they broke the law and our borders, and the job of the executive branch is to enforce the laws.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by minikites on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:48PM (#12536389)
Deporting Syrian refugees (the most recent target of Trump's rhetoric) would be breaking a major international law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_Relating_to_the_Sta...
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by tanderson92 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:56PM (#12536436)
Syrian refugees are not illegal immigrants, which was the topic of conversation of the GP poster.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Zpalmtree on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:53PM (#12536418)
Last time I checked "undocumented" immigrants aren't a race, and they also broke the law. It's not racist to attack people breaking the law.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by zimzam on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:12AM (#12536997)
This claim cain only be made by somebody ignorant of the history of racism: racism almost always lives with a non-racist pretext. Here are a couple of examples, though many more exist:

Lynchings were instigated by an accusation of a crime - the perpetrators could claim they weren't racist, they were just keeping their communities safe! [1]

Japanese internment too had a non-racist pretext: people of Japanese descent were claimed to be disloyal citizens with greater allegiance to Japan (even after being born in the USA or becoming naturalized) than the USA. [2]

We know that the debate about undocumented immigrants isn't about to Europeans who overstay their tourist visas or Canadians sneaking across the border: it is about a single ethnic group (hispanic) who have come across the Mexican border. This means that 'undocumented' can easily be a euphemism for 'hispanic', allowing people to shift racist statements into ostensibly non-racist ones. While not all discussions of undocumented immigrants are racist, some certainly are a form of dog whistle [3]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynching_in_the_United_States#...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog-whistle_politics#United_St...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:10AM (#12537466)
You're talking ignorantly right now.

First, the two examples of racism you point out are decades old. Try to pay attention to current events.

We share a long, fairly badly secured land border with a country with significantly worse living and earning conditions than we enjoy. The fact that all those people trying to come to a better life share an ethnicity is not relevant at all.

If you want to see racism, see how British people treat Polish immigrants, even though the Poles have every right in the world to be there.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:33AM (#12537089)
Are there a ton of EU overstays causing noticeable impact? Do you think if millions of Russians were illegally in the US working low-end jobs (for the most part) and being rather highly visible (flying Russian flags at protests) it'd be waved off?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:04PM (#12536466)
>“When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.”

It's pretty racist to attack a whole contingent of people and make broad negative generalizations about them and qualify with a half-hearted caveat that 'some' are good people. He's quite clearly drawing a line between "you" (the white audience he was speaking to) and the Other (i.e. the Mexicans) personified as rapists and drug dealers.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:33PM (#12536582)
Sounded like it was clearly "you" as legal Mexicans and other immigrants. The rest of the sentence is about illegals -- he's not, afaik, made any claims about Mexicans in general. If he was actually making a racist statement, then immigration status wouldn't matter.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:11AM (#12536991)
"You" clearly haven't even read or seen the speech and are talking completely out of your ass. It was one of his opening talking points in his presidential announcement in New York City to his cronies - https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/06...

It's pretty straightforward xenophobic, hyper jingoist nationalist rhetoric. You = us good Americans. They = the Other. He uses the car industry for Japan, a conservative talking point since the 80s. For Mexico he harps on immigration and calls them rapists. It's aggregate and subjectivity-denying. It's racist and dumb.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:30AM (#12537074)
I saw it, way back when he spoke. "They're not sending you" never occurred to me as "you, Americans". That'd uh, make no sense: Mexico is not a significant source of Americans immigrating to America.

At any rate, it's still besides the point. He's accurate in saying that people coming in illegally aren't "the best". If you're a top professional you're not going to risk illegal immigration anywhere, generally speaking. This lines up with my and others' personal experience (I lived in Central America for nearly 2 decades).

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by yolesaber on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @10:11AM (#12539599)
> "They're not sending you" never occurred to me as "you, Americans". That'd uh, make no sense: Mexico is not a significant source of Americans immigrating to America.

He's talking to a roomful of Americans mentioning how America (referred to as us, you) is being beaten by other countries (they). It's pretty obvious. Just because it doesn't make any sense doesn't negate what Trump was implying - it's not like he's known for sound logical reasoning or even being able to approximate a grain of truth. If you seriously think he was referring to "legal Mexicans" in that speech (again, to a roomful of his white cronies in Midtown NYC) then I got a brooklyn bridge to sell you.

>At any rate, it's still besides the point. He's accurate in saying that people coming in illegally aren't "the best".

Is he accurate in saying that Mexicans only care about "beating" us at the border and that they are mostly rapists with only some, he "assumes", are good people? Come on.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by maxerickson on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:12PM (#12536500)
Depends a little bit on the law at hand.

Illegal immigration is easy to attack without being racist. Mixed marriage not so much.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by thatswrong0 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:45PM (#12536374)
I don't think he's said anything about having a problem with legal immigrants.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:58PM (#12536445)
Incorrect. He wants to end the H1B visa program (despite the fact that he uses for seasonal work at his club in Florida) and he does not want to accept political refugees attempting to come to the US legally.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Inconel on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:21PM (#12536775)
Correct me if I'm wrong, and I may well be, but I'm under the impression that a significant number of posters on HN have problems with the H1B visa program. I'm not particularly knowledgable on the subject but from the comments I've read most of the concern centers around driving down wages, and thus costs for employers, and shackling H1B visa holders to specific jobs.

Is this an incorrect reading of the sentiment here? And more importantly, should I assume that anyone against the H1B program feels so because of racial animus?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:09AM (#12536987)
I should have been more clear when I referenced H1B. My personal opinion about the program is that it is deeply flawed, mostly because it is a sort of legalized indentured servitude.

I doubt Trump has those same feelings however, as he hires H1B works at his own club in Palm Beach instead of Americans. If he was morally opposed to the program, I doubt he would do that.

I brought it up because he talks about it in a way to scapegoat foreigners, appealing to the darker angels of people who have racist tendencies and are looking for someone to blame. I find such a tactic reprehensible, and I personally do not draw a distinction between someone who acts on racist feelings and someone who makes racist appeals to those who act on racist feelings.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Inconel on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @05:50AM (#12538260)
Thanks for the response. I agree with you that at best Trump seems hypocritical to denounce the H1B visa program after having employed those holding H1B visas, and at worst much more nefarious for using those immigrants as scapegoats. At the same time, my main concern with your original comment was that you used his stance on the H1B program as an example of his racism. Now, in Trump's case that very well may be true, but by using his stand against H1B's as your reasoning you basically imply that anyone against the H1B program is also racist. I understand that wasn't what you meant to imply but it highlights to me one of the dangers of the current political climate. Namely, a person might have a specific stance on an issue based on very legitimate reasoning, in this case the H1B program being indentured servitude, and if someone else comes along who happens to hold those same views for perhaps less legitimate reasons, lets say racism, we tend to automatically discount the stance as being racist or otherwise illegitimate.

Being labelled a racist is a pretty serious charge for most people who don't have wealth or power and actually have to live and work with a diverse group of people. I would hate to be called a racist due to being against the current way the H1B program is administered just because Trump is against it as well.

Again, I'm sure that's not actually what you meant, but it points to the importance of using very clear language when leveling these kind of accusations.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by garrettgrimsley on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:53PM (#12536659)
There's a difference between immigration law and immigrants. Your comment doesn't address what the parent commentor said.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by douche on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:59PM (#12536686)
Fixing a broken, oft-abused system is contemptible now?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:17PM (#12536756)
I think the H1B program is terribly flawed and certainly abused. But Trump is not talking about reforming it, he only talks about in the context of "foreigners stealing our jobs" (paraphrase), which I find quite contemptible. And without a meaningful plan to replace it would close an avenue for people to legally immigrate to the US, which makes it seem like he might have a problem with legal immigrants.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by MichaelGG on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:35PM (#12536836)
Why is "foreigners stealing our jobs" contemptible? Assuming H1B is abused (I understand this can be in dispute), why should a candidate for a country not want to help its own citizens?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by throwaway2016b on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:21PM (#12536774)
I think this is a big part of why the SV powerhouses are mobilizing against Trump. They rally the troops with hyperbole and accusations of racism and sexism, but in private they're afraid of losing their H1B wage slaves and tax havens.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by JoeAltmaier on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:24PM (#12536786)
Some of that I suppose. But also, he's an evil man. Doesn't take a conspiracy theory to want to see him defeated.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by throwaway2016b on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:34PM (#12536834)
Hillary is far, far more deserving of that label than Trump. To campaign and donate millions of dollars on her behalf requires ignorance, a seriously twisted moral compass, or some financial and political incentives that you don't want to talk about.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @08:38AM (#12538998)
She's spent her life struggling to help children and single parents. Donations fund her charity that has helped millions worldwide. To twist that into something bad is just more of the political smokescreen that plagues any woman in public office.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:36PM (#12545211)
You're saying this is a sexist thing?

She was linked to Whitewater, was that because she was a woman?

She constantly defended Bill Clinton's sexual indiscretions. http://www.nationalreview.com/article/435941/hillary-clinton....

She moved to New York just so she could run for senator.

She and Bill also spent 3 million dollars on her daughter's wedding. Where did she come up with that money, considering that a President's salary is in the mid six figures?

Oh that's right, she (and Bill) get quarter million dollar speaking fees at Goldman Sachs.

What part of all that would not be reprehensible if she were a man, and if she were a man, wouldn't this all be dug up and thrown into his/her face if you were running for president?

How is pointing out moral turpitude a "political smokescreen that plagues every woman in public office"?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @08:46AM (#12547658)
Great list: Like any number of men get away with and no comment. None of that is reprehensible; that is all business as usual. A good fraction of our Senators are 'carpet baggers', not been brought up before. Loyalty to a spouse is lauded if its a man being loyal. #2 speaking fees is George Bush but nobody brought him up. And 'linked to' is another smokescreen catchphrase, slings mud without having to show any real problem.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jimmywanger on Friday September 23, 2016 @02:30AM (#12562713)
Yes, and none of those men are currently running for president.

If a man did all these things, and were running for POTUS, they'd get raked over the coals, just like Clinton is. What's your point?

Also, Clinton has made it a point to argue for "the right to be believed" for sexual assault victims. And she went to bat for her husband before that statement to cast doubt on his accusers? http://nypost.com/2016/08/15/hillarys-site-edits-sexual-assa...

What a two-faced person who should not be president.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by douche on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:54PM (#12536426)
I suspect he might end up sleeping on the couch if he did
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by AznHisoka on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:47PM (#12536384)
Quotes?