This is not a pro-Jewish statement. It's a textbook anti-semite stereotype.
Secular (non-religious or atheist or whatever) and Reform (not sure about Conservative, but I think they don't wear yarmulkes to work) Jews wouldn't be included.
I know both Jews who would laugh and those who would be offended by it.
If you really cannot understand how stereotyping an entire ethnicity as short money-counters is offensive, you are far beyond help. I should have figured that from the start.
It depresses me that such retrograde, Nazi-level antisemitism is tolerated on Hacker News.
As a Jew, I am offended. And I'm the group who that statement is supposed to "flatter." Think of the Black accountants who Trump apparently thinks are incompetent purely due to the color of their skin. This shit belongs in the 1940s, not 2016.
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/8-of-the-sleaziest...
Also Trump was the President of the Trump organization when the DOJ fined the company for illegal housing discrimination, doing things like marking the lease applications of African Americans with a 'C' for 'Colored' so that they would know not to rent to them.