News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:35AM (#12537094)
> Willfully ignoring that these people are attempting to get organized, and co-opting whatever gets them traction, is unhelpful at best and dangerous.

You've got it backwards. Allowing their words to control your actions gives them power over you.

Are 'dank memes' now racist also just like Pepe?

Imagine instead of 'It's going to involve pepe' he said 'It's going to involve breathing air and drinking water', or some other common and popular thing.

Do you give such idiots the power to control your actions over some common and totally innocuous thing that you might otherwise enjoy or find amusing?

That is called being played for a fool and that is what gets them traction.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:41AM (#12537115)
What are you talking about? I'm pointing out that they are intentionally using pepe memes to make their ideas seem innocuous. And they get retweeted widely. It's a fact, choose to do what you want with it.

If you want to blow that up into a giant hyperbole that's on you. Making people aware of what is going on doesn't limit anyone's speech or actions.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:00AM (#12537174)
> I'm pointing out that they are intentionally using pepe memes to make their ideas seem innocuous. And they get retweeted widely. It's a fact, choose to do what you want with it.

The same would be true if they posted Mickey Mouse memes or anything else. To claim Pepe memes by default have any sort of racist undertones (as the Clinton campaign is doing) is false.

> Making people aware of what is going on doesn't limit anyone's speech or actions

Except with that article on Hillary's site, it's not being done to 'make people aware' it's done to brand Pepe as being racist so that when you see regular Trump supporters posting completely innocent Pepe memes (which they do with regularity) it creates the illusion that a large number of Trump supporters are racist (some are I'm sure but the same goes for any group that contains tens of millions of people).

Taking a white-supremacist at his word that Pepe is part of their movement also give them power and notoriety that they wouldn't otherwise have. By 'making people aware' you are giving voice to people who otherwise wouldn't be heard.

Don't believe me? Look at Google Trends for something like 'David Duke'

https://www.google.com/trends/explore?q=david%20duke

Who do you think is responsible for creating that upsurge in interest?

Who are the people quoting Duke in articles and writing pages and pages of content about him?

Hint it isn't Trump, it's the people trying to tar Trump with a racist brush.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:01AM (#12537180)
I can't reply to you, but I suggest you try replying directly to my points instead of injecting your own political agenda.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:13AM (#12537221)
You can reply, you just need to wait a few minutes - it’s an HN feature to prevent people replying in haste.

I have no political agenda. I’m not from the US, I’m not in the US, I can’t vote in this election. I have no horse in this race. I’m an outsider looking in on the stupidity (on both sides).

I am addressing your points - or at least thought I was. Your point as it appears to me (feel free to correct me if I've misinterpreted you) was ‘we need to make people aware of how these white supremacists are promoting their ideals’.

My point is ‘this has the opposite intent of what you expect and like the Streisand effect, it inadvertently helps promote such ideals and gives these people cultural ground that they otherwise wouldn’t be able to occupy. Giving any sort of import to their ravings, makes them more important than they deserve to be, and gives them a degree of control over your actions.'

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:37AM (#12537326)
> this has the opposite intent of what you expect and like the Streisand effect

They are promoting it themselves, loudly, and trying to inject their ideas into mainstream political discourse. I see no problem in calling for people to reject it, and helping them identify them. You can look into american history and see that we have been through cycles like this before (example the 'Know Nothings' against the catholics).

I have myself clearly seen more speech in favor of segregation ("we just weren't meant to mix together") on many sites (reddit, facebook comments on congressman pages, etc). I can give you links to explicitly racist sites where they talk about organizing on popular websites to change discourse. You argue I'm giving them the Streisand effect, but we are already too late. They are here, people need to be aware today. These people intentionally prey on those who are susceptible and angry.

I have two (former) friends who have tried talking to me about how "cultural marxism is destroying western values" and that every muslim has evil in their hearts. They weren't always like this.

They don't deserve to be important, instead of ignoring them people need to be willing to say that this is unacceptable and their ideas are not welcome.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:16AM (#12537492)
> They don't deserve to be important, instead of ignoring them people need to be willing to say that this is unacceptable and their ideas are not welcome.

Which is a better way to show someone that they are not important:

  * Ignoring them
  * Giving their views countless press in order to discredit them
I agree that calling out racism is important, but when it's just people spouting nonsense in their own little corner of the Internet why give that any attention.

> They are promoting it themselves, loudly, and trying to inject their ideas into mainstream political discourse

Something they have been trying to do since basically forever. However they can only successfully inject themselves when other people allow it.

Have a look at this basic timeline:

Internet: Pepe the frog is fun

Racists: Pepe the frog now belongs to us

Internet: Nah, Pepe's not racist.

Clinton: Pepe the frog belongs to racists

Internet: Nah, Pepe's not racist.

Question: In this scenario, who gave racists control of Pepe the frog and who allowed racists to inject themselves in to this part of mainstream culture? (Hint: it was not the racists and it was not the Internet).

> I can give you links to explicitly racist sites

This is exactly what I was talking about. In your fervor to show how horrible these people are, you are willing to promote these sites yourself...

I don't care for those sites any more than I care for sites promoting flat-earth science and/or UFOs. I know they exist, but I ignore them completely, which is exactly the attention they deserve.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:45AM (#12537622)
You are wrongly characterizing what I am saying. Maybe try reading my original post again? People can only "allow" them to inject themselves into discourse when they have full consent, ie what their agenda is. Ignoring them doesn't silence them, nor makes it clear that their ideas are not acceptable.

Did I give you any links? I indicated that they are there and it is explicit and obvious.

If you cannot handle that a meme is ALSO (which means NOT ENTIRELY ie they dont own it) by people with a racist agenda then I frankly don't know what to say. The above people asked for proof, I gave it to them. Deal with the facts.

I'm not going to stop pointing out the tactics of white supremacists to inject themselves in mainstream culture.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by imron on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:23AM (#12537764)
> Maybe try reading my original post again?

Ok, sure

> But you are ignoring that people who are proudly racist are openly admitting to using pepe specifically to broaden and popularize explicitly racist ideas

Yes. I am ignoring such people, because such tactics don't merit anything more. I would also ignore them if they claimed to be using Mickey Mouse or any other broadly popular icon to promote their ideas.

Because it deserves nothing more than a rolling of my eyes.

What I will call out is people (like the Clinton campaign) accepting or validating the idea that Pepe is somehow a racist, nazi frog.

> If you cannot handle that a meme is ALSO (which means NOT ENTIRELY ie they dont own it) by people with a racist agenda then I frankly don't know what to say

I can handle it fine. It's the Clinton campaign (and surrogates) that are trying to actively associate Pepe as a symbol of racism and that's what I object to.

I think this conversation has reached the point where it is only going to go round in circles, so I'm bowing out now. Please enjoy the rest of your day.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Inconel on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:21AM (#12538361)
This is exactly my problem with the Clinton campaign article about Pepe being a white nationalist symbol. I found that article troubling because first, it reads like satire and I am legitimately frightened that this is what a major presidential candidate views as political discourse in this country, and second because it so unequivocally casts Pepe as racist symbolism, which is completely false. There is no nuance whatsoever in that article, which increasingly seems like standard procedure in politics on both sides of the aisle. Nuance and deep understanding seem to have completely disappeared from politics, everything is black or white, good or evil.

I'm writing this on my computer and I have an entire folder on my desktop filled with rare Pepes that I've collected over the years. I'm not a white nationalist and up until last week I had a Pepe sticker on my backpack that I carry with me everywhere. When I saw this article gaining mainstream attention I immediately took the sticker off. I have enough things to deal with in life to not want to worry about being called a racist because of my Pepe sticker. Now, I understand there are much greater injustices in the country to deal with than this, but this is yet another example of politicians using these kind of binary arguments that end up making serious discourse impossible.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @08:09AM (#12538848)
1. Not a member of the clinton campaign

2. > I can handle it fine. It's the Clinton campaign (and surrogates) that are trying to actively associate Pepe as a symbol of racism and that's what I object to.

People promoting racism are doing this, you want to stay willfully ignorant about it.

[dead]
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:43PM (#12543222)
Care to explain?
[dead]
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by saboot on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:28PM (#12543934)
In the opinion of an anonymous Donald Trump troll account. Not really lending much credibility there. Not surprised you can't defend for your own agenda though.