News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by TillE on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:46AM (#12424280)
It's really incredible that three months after the vote, we still haven't the slightest idea what post-Brexit UK will look like. Will they go for the EEA (the least destructive option), or will they - as Theresa May threatens - sacrifice everything just to limit immigration?

Three months after the biggest decision in decades, and the subject is barely even being talked about seriously in the UK. I don't understand it.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tim333 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:08AM (#12424403)
There was a very good article on the practical difficulties of leaving the EU successfully - "Everything you need to know about Theresa May’s Brexit nightmare in five minutes." Basically either you restrict immigration, lose free trade and screw the economy by mucking up decades of prior investments such as that by the Japanese or you go the Norway model where you still have EU immigration and budget payments but less say in what happens so a worse position than we now have.

May promised "We're going to make a success of Brexit" but basically does not have the means to do that. What she can do is delay, do studies and so on hence the lack of progress.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by okket on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:18AM (#12424449)
Here is a link to the article you mentioned:

http://www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2016/07/14/everything-you-ne...

I also find the following article very informative:

"Brexit means Brexit – and that means there will be no debate on freedom of movement"

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/brexit-means-brexit-and-...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tim333 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:24PM (#12425174)
That's a little scary if that is what happens. (The article suggests May will enact article 50 in Jan without significant trade concessions from the EU). Maybe time to sell up and short the FTSE.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Scarblac on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:05AM (#12424384)
Maybe the best option is to have a big party and declare Brexit a huge success, without actually doing anything.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tim333 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:16AM (#12424442)
I suspect we may end up with something close to that. Maybe a Norway option and a party.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by varjag on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:17PM (#12425123)
Norway option includes taking its fair share of refugees along with the EU, and overall following the EU regulations. I thought the point of Brexit was against all that?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by martinko on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:48AM (#12424291)
I think everyone in any position of power understands that they must remain in the single market - now the only question is how to position / sell this to the electorate.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:58AM (#12424342)
I don't think May and the Cabinet do. All the noises seem to suggest the real priority is xenophobia - i.e. immigration.

...Which is a purely political strategy to capture the continued support of leave voters - exactly the people whose lives will be destroyed when trade dries up.

The problem is that the typical leave voter understands immigration because they have direct personal experience of immigrants.

But leave voters don't understand the intricacies of trade deals, or the incredible damage poor trading conditions can do to an economy.

May does, which is why she has been warning of "tough times ahead."

If she was interested in continuing trade on realistic terms she wouldn't be saying that.

My suspicion at this point is that the Tory party is willing to sacrifice the economic future of the UK in order to remain in power.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by davidf18 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:22PM (#12425160)
The issue with immigration is not xenophobia but economic as Economist Branko Milanovic (and perhaps others) have been pointing out since 2012. Milanovic's now famous "Elephant Curve" shows that the working or middle class in developed countries have seen no wage growth in 20 years. Part of that effect is from exporting jobs to China, Mexico (for US), Eastern Europe (for Europe) and part of that is from importing unskilled/low skilled labor.

20 years ago Britain had 900,000 immigrants. Today they have 3.3 million. The British government promised to limit EU immigration to 100,000 last year but broke their promise: it exceeded 300,000.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-27/get-ready-...

These low-skilled immigrants compete for jobs in the UK and lower wage growth. Not those of professionals but of the working class/middle class.

In the US, in 1970 we had 9.6 million immigrants (less than 5% of the population) and 2013 41.3 million (about 14% of the population). That does not include the 11 million immigrants in the US illegally.

http://www.pewhispanic.org/2015/09/28/chapter-5-u-s-foreign-...

As in the case of Britain, the working class in the US is suffering from the mostly low-educated immigrants that compete for jobs and drive down wage rates. The 11 million immigrants in the country illegally take jobs with illegal working conditions and illegally low wages since they can't complain.

So, the issue is economic and not xenophobic.

The real issue of BrExit and the rise of Trump is because the political and media elites in both countries (and this includes the Democrats as well as Republicans) have ignored the economic concerns of the working class.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:38PM (#12425256)
In the US the reason the middle class has had no wage growth is NOT because immigrants have hindered wage growth. The reason is simply because immigrants lower the averages simply by being included in statistics.

In the US, most people with American parents have higher income than their parents did (in their 30's). This is true for all quintiles except maybe the top 20%.

http://www.pewtrusts.org/~/media/legacy/uploadedfiles/wwwpew... Figure 1

http://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/alfresco/publicatio... Figure 5

Yet when we look at cross sectional statistics (rather than longitudinal ones), income (though not compensation) has remained flat.

The way to square these two facts together is that George Jr. has a higher income at 30 than George Sr. did, but the average of George Jr. and Jose Jr. has lower income at 30 than George Sr. did.

Jose Sr. is excluded from the cross-sectional statistics since he lived in Mexico in his 30's.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by davidf18 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:50PM (#12425331)
> In the US the reason the middle class has had no wage growth is NOT because immigrants have hindered wage growth. The reason is simply because immigrants lower the averages simply by existing.

It is probably for both reasons, but certainly immigrants that have low education compete with Americans who have low education for jobs and they do drive down wage growth. This is not my opinion. It is economics.

The issue is that proportion of both US and UK populations that are immigrants. Since 1970 in the US we have gone from 1 in 20 to 1 in 6 or 7 who are immigrants, most who are low-skilled.

It would have been wiser and more fair to the American working class to have kept the proportion of 1 in 20.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:05PM (#12425413)
But the wages of Americans with American parents has risen, not fallen. Wages for Americans with American parents in the lowest quintile of income have risen the most - that seems like exactly the opposite of what your theory predicts!

Since immigrants are consumers as well as producers, it's unclear that they drive down wages. Similarly it's unclear that Americans having children drives wages down.

I'm not sure what "fair" means in your comment, or why you only consider "fair to the American working class" rather than "fair to humans". Could you clarify?

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by davidf18 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:13PM (#12425456)
> But the wages of Americans with American parents has risen, not fallen. Wages for Americans with American parents in the lowest quintile of income have risen the most - that seems like exactly the opposite of what your theory predicts!

Are you certain that this applies to Americans that don't have a college education? That didn't graduate from high school? Those who would suffer most economically from uneducated immigrants?

And one must average in those who are unemployed (eg, 0 wages).

Don't look at averages, look at distributions.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:22PM (#12425508)
Are you certain that this applies to Americans that don't have a college education?

No, I am not certain that Americans with American parents in the bottom 20% didn't get an education. Some of them probably did (about half the population has at least some college) and had their place at the bottom of the ladder filled by an immigrant.

Don't look at averages, look at distributions.

It helps if you actually follow the link provided and look at the exact figure being cited. Then you'd see it's a histogram of a distribution!

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by davidf18 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:12PM (#12425819)
One of the documents is 38 pages and the other is 20 pages. Were there are emotions such as immigration and especially illegal immigration, it is important to provide the data and answer the exact question which I could not see the proper distribution.

“The facts support the application of Ricardo’s theory to immigration. Skilled immigrants lower the wages of skilled natives, and unskilled immigrants lower the wages of unskilled natives. … In contrast, in the United States, which takes in a far higher percentage of low-skilled immigrants than the U.K. does, it is unskilled wages that have stayed low: the income of unskilled workers has barely kept pace with inflation for the last forty years.” -- Tim Harford: The Undercover Economist (2nd ed) p. 30 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0199926514/

Financial Times columnist Harford has a BS & MS Economics Oxford

The question is: For people whose parents were born in the US without a high school education and also without a college education, and including those who have no income because they can't get a job is there wage growth or a decrease?

It is economists that state that immigrants who are uneducated displace those citizens who are working class.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:30PM (#12425917)
You may be right that the particular slice of people you single out has also had a decrease in wage growth. Do you have any evidence of this? Or are you simply assuming that all unknown facts support your position?

In any case, the specific stats Harford cites are cross sectional. This means the averages include immigrants and fall victim to the exact same Simpson's Paradox issue that I discuss above. To show that immigrants have reduced anyone's wages, you need longitudinal data.

And your question is also malformed, because you don't specify whether you are discussing the children (who may be educated) of uneducated American parents, or the uneducated children of American parents (who may or may not have been uneducated).

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by davidf18 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:51PM (#12426047)
My intent to is to ask about the children of people born in America. The parents lacked a high school or college education and the children lacked a high school or college education. Average wages don't work unless it also takes into account people in this category who are want jobs but are unable to get them.

In order to successfully complete college, one needs an IQ of 110 which is of course above average of 100. Others are being left out not because they don't work hard, but because of biology/opportunity.

If one reads Harford's book, which I found out from the Freakonomics people, they'll get a better idea that the intent is that low educated immigrants compete with low educated American citizens for jobs and drive down wages and that highly educated immigrants (think H1-B visas) compete with highly educated American citizens.

The problem is not immigration, but the percentage of the population should have remained at 5% of the population and not at nearly 14% (which does not include 11 million immigrants here illegally).

By comparison, in 1990 about 1 million of 60 million Brits (1.5%) and now it is 3.3 million or about 5%. The legal immigrant levels in the US today are 3 times that of the level the Brits voted for BrExit.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by NetStrikeForce on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:14AM (#12428864)
That's a very long comment to fail to justify it's not xenophobia. It is.

Leave got better results in places with less immigration, i.e. in places where they don't have foreign neighbours but fear having them.

Moreso, restricting immigration will actually make economy worse and take unskilled jobs out of the country (to China, India, etc), thus screwing even more over the working class.

If it was the economy, people would favour immigration (young people paying taxes, keeping jobs around, not using the NHS, etc) and complain about other stuff (company tax loopholes anyone?), but they complained about immigration and that's what they fear.

It is xenophobia, but of course no one fears Swiss, Japanese or Swede immigrants because they're rich. I don't see many problems in UK for Saudi princes or Russian magnates that exploit and slave people, again because they're rich. Racism is basically now fear of the poor (hence all the negativity about asylum seekers and other refugees).

People, including me of course, are assholes.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by davidf18 on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:12PM (#12432261)
This Guardian article states its economics and not Xenophobia.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/mar/07/donald...

Believe what you want to believe.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by rwmj on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:28PM (#12425199)
If it wasn't freedom of movement, it would be technological change (how many people will self-driving lorries put out of work?). The real problem is no one has thought about the long term where a lot of people either won't be able to work or won't need to work. In the UK we still have politicians who genuinely think a less than minimum wage job packing training shoes in a warehouse is morally better than someone being unemployed.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by clappski on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:22AM (#12424464)
As far as I was aware it was the areas that the least amount of immigrants that wanted to vote for leave, but at this point it's moot. And I wouldn't say that fears over immigration are xenophobic, I think that the referendum came at a terrible time when Europe as a whole is facing a big refugee (economic or not) problem that they still can't decide how to solve.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mpweiher on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:26AM (#12424803)
>areas that [have] the least amount of immigrants that wanted to vote for leave

Ironic, isn't it? But absolutely typical. In Germany as well, the areas with highest anti-immigrant sentiments (and voting etc.) are the ones with the least amount of actual immigrants.

Which kind of makes sense when you think about it...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by sbmassey on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:56AM (#12424972)
I don't see why it is ironic, really: areas of low immigration can see what happens to areas of high immigration, so will vote against it, whereas for areas with high immigration it is too late
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by genofon on Monday September 05, 2016 @09:40AM (#12430214)
except that immigrants were not allow to vote for Brexit.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Scarblac on Sunday September 04, 2016 @04:54PM (#12426667)
The people complaining are the people in areas with high unemployment.

Migrants don't go there, they come to where the jobs are.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by dogma1138 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:02AM (#12424371)
The typical leave voter lives in the areas with least immigration.

The areas with any substantial immigration either from the EU or elsewhere voted remain.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:26AM (#12424479)
Aside from London, which is a special case, that's not particularly true. Remain won in the very big cities with urban cosmopolitan populations and in a few university towns, but lost almost everywhere else.

There are two main groups of leavers, with some overlap - the working classes with limited education and low prospects, and the petit bourgeois, who are relatively poorly educated and uncurious but can be reasonably well off.

The first group has direct experience of poor working conditions, and often lives in an area with immigration. They'll have seen wages being kept down first hand. This vote was enough to swing it for Leave in many working class areas.

The second group may not have direct experience, but is easily persuaded by xenophobia and jingoism. They're often older and are nostalgic for an England that never really existed. They tend conservative - and Conservative.

They like simple explanations to complicated problems, and they're easy marks for the British press - the real source of many of the UK's problems - which has been stoking their prejudices for decades with a constant stream of anti-EU scare stories.

This pattern isn't unique to the UK, but so far the UK is the only country to stress test it.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by ZenoArrow on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:25AM (#12424798)
> "There are two main groups of leavers, with some overlap - the working classes with limited education and low prospects, and the petit bourgeois, who are relatively poorly educated and uncurious but can be reasonably well off."

I fit into neither group, and nor do the other people I know who voted to leave.

> "the British press - the real source of many of the UK's problems - which has been stoking their prejudices for decades"

I couldn't agree with you more on this point. However, I suspect this had a role in your earlier summation of the two groups of Leave voters. You really should take what you read/view/hear in British mainstream news outlets with a huge pinch of salt, even when it lines up with your own opinions.

To give you one example of a group you overlooked, I'd suggest taking a look at the Left Leave website:

http://www.leftleave.org/

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by barrkel on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:19AM (#12424450)
The places with the least immigration are usually the poorest places most fearful of immigrants taking their jobs (specifically, lowering their wages - and they're probably right) and least optimistic about the future. They are usually remnants of the industrial revolution getting marginalized by globalization (mostly China).
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by biofox on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:24AM (#12424471)
The sight of a few immigrants in an otherwise white British community is probably more shocking for the locals than it would be in a metropolitan area with a large immigrant population.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by timthorn on Sunday September 04, 2016 @06:50PM (#12427105)
The majority of immigrants from the EU are also white.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by vixen99 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:04AM (#12424692)
Not all serious economists (who we can assume voted Leave) agree that Brexit is going to be economically harmful to the UK. Not all serious economic analyses suggest that Brexit will leave the UK permanently and materially poorer.

The argument can be taken up with the following who we can assume voted (if they are or would be UK citizens) to leave the EU, and some of whom might well have some understanding of the intricacies of trade deals.

Roger Bootle, Managing Director of Capital Economics, and Gerard Lyons, Economic advisor to the Mayor of London and former Chief Economist of Standard Chartered Bank. Ruth Lea, Warwick Lightfoot, Neil MacKinnon, Ryan Bourne, Head of Public Policy, Institute of Economic Affairs, Keith Boyfield, Executive Director, Keith Boyfield Associates, Professor Tim Congdon, Founder, International Monetary Research Ltd, Sean Corrigan, Hinde Capital, Mike Denham, Research Fellow, The TaxPayers’ Alliance, Bryan Gould, Former Labour Shadow Cabinet member & former vice-Chancellor, University of Waikato, Dr David Green, Chief Executive, CIVITAS, Dr Graham Gudgin, University of Cambridge, Dr. Oliver Hartwich, Executive Director, The New Zealand Initiative,Damon de Laszlo, Chairman, Economic Research Council, Graeme Leach, Former Chief Economist, Institute of Directors, Andrew Lilico, Chairman, Economists for Britain, Neil MacKinnon, Global Macro Strategist, VTB Capital,Dr Eileen Marshall, IEA Advisory Council, Professor Kent Matthews, Associate Dean for Engagement & Professor of Money and Banking, Cardiff University, Michael Petley, Chief Investment Officer, ECU Group, John Mills, Chairman and Founder of JML,Professor Patrick Minford, Professor of Economics, Cardiff Business School, Iain Murray, Vice President for Strategy, Competitive Enterprise Institute (Washington DC),David Myddelton, Professor D.R. Myddelton, Emeritus Professor of Finance and Accounting, Cranfield School of Management.Ross Parker, Brian Reading, former economics adviser to Edward Heath, Professor Colin Robinson, Advisory Council Institute of Economic Affairs & Emeritus Professor, Surrey University, Matthew Sinclair, Senior Consultant, Europe Economics, Professor Phil Whyman, Professor of Economics, Business, Economics and International Business, University of Central Lancashire,Dr Geoffrey Wyatt, Heriot-Watt University

https://forbritain.org/economists/supporters/

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by danieldk on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:00AM (#12424354)
The problem is that it is not in the EU's best interest to give the UK the best possible deal, especially with many populist parties ready to request an exit if the UK deal works out well.

The whole process will be immensely complicated: the deal should be bad enough for the UK to instil fear for an exit, but good enough to avoid an economic collapse.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tajen on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:25AM (#12424477)
> instill fear

Is that how Europe is governed? I think any country should be allowed to leave without condescending comments by anyone. I prefer staying in Europe, but if the majority of my fellows prefer the opposite, then it's democracy. Who are we to judge they are "stupid", "country-side, or "senile", like I've read all across newspapers, or even fascists, like I've heard too?

If Europe relies on hating the people who have a different opinion, twisting their vote to say it meant something else, and govern them with "fear" and "bad deal" (your words), then...

...then this is not the Europe I want to be part of.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by rbanffy on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:54AM (#12424631)
I wouldn't mind if it's their informed opinion. What we see in this case is that they were sold a lie, one that'll eventually collapse into an ugly, harsh truth.

The best deal possible is a Norway-like arrangement, which would be unacceptable to nationalists.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by karma_vaccum123 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:30AM (#12424829)
Your comment basically confirms, on a more subtle level, what the GP post is saying.

You have no factual basis for claiming these people are asserting false facts or voting based on false facts. Brexit is a vote on what the future should look like, and no one has a factual basis to predict the future.

tl;dr people you disagree with aren't fraudulent by default

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by aaronbrethorst on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:33PM (#12425222)
Demonstrably untrue: http://m.huffpost.com/uk/entry/uk_576d0aa3e4b08d2c5638fc17

And in Trump's case (describing immigrants as "rapists" and "murderers") it is also demonstrably false http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-mythical-connection-between-...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by danieldk on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:36AM (#12424866)
Is that how Europe is governed? I think any country should be allowed to leave without condescending comments by anyone.

I think people can handle condescending comments. The problem is that you cannot reap the benefits without paying dues, which is what the Brexit camp promised. It's in the interest of the remaining EU members to make this clear, or the whole union will crumble. It's likely that this will throw back Europe to nationalism and protectionism, which is counter-productive.

(Europe's history is littered with wars, if we don't want to consider the previous centuries, look no further than former Yugoslavia or Ukraine.)

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tajen on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:11PM (#12425076)
> ...without paying the dues, which is what the Brexit camp promised

This assumes the voters are gullible. But what if they are grown-ups who didn't literally believe Johnson, and made a decision based on rational arguments, would you accept it? Examples:

- What if, for example, voters wanted fewer immigration at all costs, and what if their elites refused to give them a referendum on this topic? Then they may decently choose to vote against their elites' interests on the next question they're asked. And boom! there goes Europe. Tough luck, but extremely bad politics too.

- What if rural workers and retired people, who demonstrated 10 years ago against the low benefits and who see violence, alcoholism and drugs raising, what if those people were genuinely getting the short end of the London intelligencia?

In both situations, it ends with "If you break my toys, I'll break yours". If you keep accepting more immigration / not reducing unemployment in countryside England, then we'll break the Europe that makes you so rich.

You know, you evoke crumbling and wars. I know nothing more pushing a country to wreckage than a divide between the rich and the poor. Which may be what happened in England.

If we want peace, it's important to listen to what other people want. I hear people blame the rise of xenophobia all across Europe. Maybe if we stop tagging anyone who suggest fewer immigration as xenophobic, and listen to a quarter of their proposals, then they won't need to vote for the extreme right?

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by aaronbrethorst on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:35PM (#12425236)
They were gullible. They were told that NHS would be better funded after brexit than before, among other lies.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Tycho on Sunday September 04, 2016 @03:57PM (#12426403)
Do you have any actual examples of people complaining that they were misled and would have voted differently if this particular issue (NHS) had been clarified for them?

Personally I have not seen any examples. I've just seen sore losers on the Remain side latching onto this one vague campaign poster and declaring that the people (other people, obviously) were fooled and the result is therefore, in some way, illegitimate.

It's quite possible that the entire referendum campaign period was basically irrelevant. People have been discussing and forming opinions about EU membership for years. It's not like evaluating a new electoral candidate.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by aaronbrethorst on Sunday September 04, 2016 @04:12PM (#12426474)
Yes. A Google search for

    brexit misled
Quickly turns up articles like this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/06/27...

    The unemployed father of two who is married to an
    Irish wife watched the crash of the country's
    currency, the pound, with increasing worries on
    Friday. But one development in particular made
    him change his mind [about his 'leave' vote]:
    “My son has mental health issues and I feared
    a privatization of our health care system,
    which is currently for free,” Kerin said.
    ...On Friday morning, UKIP leader Nigel Farage
    went on national television to say it had been
    a “mistake” that some campaigners promised the
    money currently being transferred to Brussels
    would be spent on health care. "Nigel Farage
    betrayed us," said Kerin.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tajen on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:49PM (#12425326)
You think 52% of the UK voters are gullible?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by aaronbrethorst on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:01PM (#12425396)
I'd argue that enough were to give Leave the win. 37% of British people saw health care as one of the most important issues facing the UK in a June survey[1], and better health care was one of the key issues pushed by the Vote Leave campaign.

[1] https://www.ipsos-mori.com/researchpublications/researcharch...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tajen on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:48PM (#12425684)
> I'd argue that enough were to give Leave the win.

In your document I read "48% people think that immigration is one of the most important issues facing Britain, just ahead of the EU referendum". The Remain camp proposed to increase immigration.

48% voters for the Leave camp as a start, that's pretty pretty high! Plus whatever % they convince about leaving Europe for other reasons. Total 52%, I'm surprised the result isn't higher actually.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by aaronbrethorst on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:18PM (#12425851)
What's to say that Leave is going to be able to keep to their promises on immigration either?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tajen on Sunday September 04, 2016 @03:08PM (#12426134)
Credibility is another question entirely - Look, that's how democracy works. People vote, some are gullible in both parties, some have received fewer education, some newspapers will be biased until we mandate them to only publish information of the leading party, and, yes, politicians lie. It may not be the best system we have. But that's the best system at the exception of every other we know today. No-one gets to discard the results of a vote based on how they think things should go.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:12PM (#12425087)
Why can't they? Canada does.

Apart from desire to punish the UK, what prevents the EU and the UK from coming to a CETA like agreement (exactly as Boris and May have expressed support for)?

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Scarblac on Sunday September 04, 2016 @04:59PM (#12426683)
Nothing, except that sort of thing takes about to decade to negotiate.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Scarblac on Sunday September 04, 2016 @05:07PM (#12426710)
The thing is that there are pro-leave parties in many other countries, and the parties in power (all pro-stay) are fighting them to stay in power.

The same kinds of argument are made everywhere, with the pro-stay parties predicting bad deals for the leaving country, economic trouble, et cetera. They probably honestly believe that will be the result for a country leaving the EU.

Now the UK is leaving, and the deal they get must be approved by all remaining countries (they all have vetos).

Of course those countries will only agree with a harsh deal for the UK -- one, they really already honestly believe that that would be the result for any leaving country, and two, it is great ammo in their fight for power against pro-leave parties in their own countries. They get to show that their predicted doom comes true.

I'm not sure politics is always hating "the people who have a different opinion", but it's certainly doing everything to get power in your own hands instead of theirs.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by avar on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:57PM (#12425741)

    > Is that how Europe is governed? [...] I prefer staying in
    > Europe, but if the majority of my fellows prefer the opposite,
    > then it's democracy.
It's democracy in action in the UK & EU that you can leave.

How does democracy have anything to do with the UK then getting some sort of preferential treatment for trade once they're out?

That would not be in the democratic interests of the remaining EU citizens who don't want to see the EU crumble any further.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tajen on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:24AM (#12429097)
The position in your first 2 lines is entirely valid in my opinion. I was condemning the hatred, but it's entirely valid for each country to negotiate for their best interest, especially, I reckon, since the UK received preferential treatment when they were in.

> in the democratic interests of the remaining EU citizens who don't want to see the EU crumble any further

It's in the democratic interest of the remaining EU citizen to know that they won't get hatred if they ever decide to leave EU. The democratic interest is in freedom.

I'm looking at the increase of power of international law, and its democracy, the fact that they override country-level laws, and the track record we need to set for future agreements. We're negotiating with powerful countries who have a track record of spying, blackmailing and subverting other democracies to make them sign agreements against the will of the people. Once signed by our leaders, TTIP is unrevokable. This is not in our democratic interest. In democracy, all laws are voted and can be changed. It may incur costs (e.g. the loss of not having free trade anymore) but it shouldn't incur any fine, hatred, or condamnation based on moral standard.

A positive outcome of the Brexit on the TTIP/EU/WTO/OTAN/Climate/... would be if international agreements faced a referendum by the People every 10 years. That way, we'd ensure the people are in on the laws that apply to them.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:08PM (#12425056)
I know a lady who's married but isn't super happy in the marriage. When she discussed possible divorce with her husband, he promised that he'd bog her down with paperwork, unreasonable alimony demands and just an extremely messy and unpleasant divorce. No settlement, it's going to multiple levels of court and will take years.

Assuming your comment is meant as an argument for remain, it's an equally good argument for this woman not to get divorced.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by douche on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:24PM (#12425173)
Interesting. Generally, it's the man that gets raked over the coals and every cent in his pocket vacuumed out, restraining orders taken out, family court, loss of access to children, etc, etc, ad nauseum.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by ZenoArrow on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:23PM (#12425514)
What difference does that make here? It's an analogy. Feel free to swap the genders used in the analogy so that you can comment on the main point being made without getting distracted.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by sbmassey on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:00PM (#12424997)
It may not be in the EU's interest to give a good deal, but it is definitely in Europes interest to do so.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by timthorn on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:12AM (#12424429)
No, there's a reasoned argument against the need to remain in the single market that has traction amongst politicians: http://www.conservativehome.com/thecolumnists/2016/09/daniel...
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by T-A on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:06AM (#12424388)
Doesn't look that way, unless it's a really reckless negotiating tactic: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-09-03/may-s-brex...
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by jerven on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:50AM (#12424298)
Problem is the EEA option depends on 31 veto possibilities !!! what will the UK have to give up to avoid those vetos? Not every country in the EU does a lot of trade with the UK and those will want their pound of flesh, now that the UK has foolishly put it on the table.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by eps on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:56AM (#12424330)
Vetoes are pretty much guaranteed, and not because of little trade with the UK, but as a warning to other EU members considering the UK route. You can't have the cake and eat it.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by dogma1138 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:08AM (#12424399)
I don't think there will be vetos renegotiations are comming up with Switzerland and later Norway, Denmark is also up for grabs so is Poland once the Euroblock exemption will expire.

If the EU is über harsh on the UK, especially if it will come from either the Eurocrats like Juncker or from one of the smaller states it will not fly well with both EU and EEA members up for renegotiations.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by no1youknowz on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:53AM (#12424316)
There has been a flurry of activity behind the scenes.

Philip Hammond was recently in China [1] and discussed the possibility of trade agreements with them and other representatives of other countries who were also there.

Australia has already mentioned opening up trade agreements [2] with the UK as well.

There is even talk of trading with the common-wealth [3].

The point is this, things are moving forward. Just because it's not in the news. Which the majority it won't be until it's ready to be announced. Doesn't mean that nothing is happening.

Also I don't know how old you are. But before the UK entered the EC which it was known back then. The UK was trading with the entire world. Now, it has the possibility of accessing the EU market AND trading with the world. Which I think is a great prospect for the UK.

Edit: To address the downvotes. When the UK was trading within the EU. These trading agreements were done by the EU for all the member-states. They were negotiating as one trading block.

Now that the UK is out of the EU. She can trade speaking for herself, not having veto's by France or another country. Go look it up.

Also [4]: EU-US trade agreement fails. Now the UK is free to open up trade talks with the US.

[1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36877573

[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/09/03/g20-theresa-may-i...

[3] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/07/29/a-bright-future-a...

[4] http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/704752/EU-USA-trade-deal...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by flexie on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:07AM (#12424395)
Ah, but if you are old enough, you might remember that long before 1973 the UK spanned the world: India, Pakistan, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Canada. You even had 13 colonies south of Canada. And if you are that old, you might remember that they didn't like the UK way of trading.

I hope the UK will never get back that glory.

The EU never prevented UK from trading with the rest of the world. If anything, it enabled the UK to keep some commerce that would otherwise have bypassed the UK for France or Germany, as the Japanese memo also suggests.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by timthorn on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:52AM (#12424616)
> The EU never prevented UK from trading with the rest of the world

Upon joining the EU, the free trade arrangements that the UK had with Commonwealth countries were dissolved.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by lispm on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:00PM (#12424996)
Well, the EU either has or is negotiating trade deals with 30+ Commonwealth countries...

http://eulawanalysis.blogspot.de/2015/11/the-eu-or-commonwea...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by rbanffy on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:03PM (#12425028)
It's very unlikely those treaties would be readily restored now. Two relevant things changed: the partners have made new treaties with other countries and now the UK needs the treaties more than their prospectie partners.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by flexie on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:07PM (#12425421)
And new trade deals were entered into with many of those with the EU as a party.

Now they are EU trading partners, interested in remaining such, and to the extent UK agreements would collide with their EU agreements they are not prone to giving up any advantages they might have for the sake of dealing with their old oppressors.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mattmanser on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:04AM (#12424688)
So, we shouldn't leave the EU, but super-states are bad...

Great reasoning.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by lispm on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:00AM (#12424350)
> Now, it has the possibility of accessing the EU market AND trading with the world.

Wonderful. Something which clearly is not possible while in the EU. I never understood why the EU did not allow that. The UK never had a chance to successfully trade within the EU and trade with other countries was strictly forbidden.

Brexit will change all that. Congratulations!

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mpweiher on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:31AM (#12424835)
>trade with other countries was strictly forbidden.

Huh? All EU countries trade with countries outside the EU all the time.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by franciscop on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:02PM (#12425022)
I think it was sarcasm ;)
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by gpderetta on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:13PM (#12425096)
Sarcasm, obviously.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mpweiher on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:00PM (#12425387)
Now that you mention it. Alas, with the level of discourse on this topic it's sometimes hard to tell :-)
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Scarblac on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:10AM (#12424409)
Given that the UK is smaller than the EU as a whole, they have less negotiating power. The deals will necessarily be worse than what the EU can negotiate.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by madeofpalk on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:56AM (#12424331)
Was the UK not trading with the entire world when it was in the EU?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tim333 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:21AM (#12424458)
It's still in the EU and still trading with everyone. The kind of things we could change by leaving would be to say drop tariffs and subsidies on agriculture which would make food cheaper but put a lot of UK farmers out of business and so not be politically popular.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by wuschel on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:46AM (#12424578)
Please correct me if I am wrong - as I understand, the referendum for the BREXIT is not binding.

As such, there is a lot of fuss and hot air about things that will possibly not materialize. Not to mention all those speculative business affairs..

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by m0nty on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:56AM (#12424639)
It isn't legally binding, and although the Prime Minister said she doesn't intend to consult parliament about it, parliament will still need to repeal the European Communities Act which took us into the EU in the first place. So they could say "no", but I think it unlikely in the current political climate.

It is binding in the sense that it's "the will of the people", albeit by a slender margin, and it's kind of tricky to just ignore that. I personally suspect the Prime Minister is not highly committed to Brexit (she campaigned against it) but can't be seen to be "sabotaging" it by action or inaction, so she's got her game-face on. But she might come back later and say "it just won't work" or "Europe has offered us a better deal on immigration if we remain in", so let's have another referendum.

> a lot of fuss and hot air about things that will possibly not materialize

Or they might materialize, and it could turn out to be a Bad Thing, which is why people are worried about it. The continuation of the current status quo seems highly unlikely, whatever happens.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by wuschel on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:04AM (#12424690)
I understand, thanks for elaborating on that matter.

In a way, a clean way to do it would to be a call for elections, and a proper mandate - either to stay in, or stay out. But that might not happen, considering the nature of the political game.

I agree about the reasons to worry, and to have a proper discussion. Things tend to get out of hand sometimes when it comes to media.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by m0nty on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:40AM (#12424881)
> a clean way to do it would to be a call for elections

Absolutely, but the weakness of the opposition Labour party and the near-annihilation of the Liberal Democrats at the last election mean (as things stand) it's mostly a foregone conclusion that the Conservatives will win. So to their way of looking at things, they will have two mandates to leave.

It's an extraordinary situation, though. I said to my son on the morning the result was announced, this will affect all of us for the rest of our lives. I still don't think I was being hyperbolic. Seasoned politicians and commentators are saying it's our biggest political crisis since WW2 or Suez, and that's even coming from people who seem to support Brexit.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by gsnedders on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:56PM (#12425367)
The Labour situation probably also makes it unlikely for it to be plausible to call for elections, as to call an early election in the simplest way requires a 2/3rds majority of the House in favour (i.e., 431 votes, 101 seats more than the Tories hold). The alternative, which the Tories in principle could do alone, is pass a motion of no confidence in the Government, wait two weeks, and then the House falls to an election (this assumes that all Tories would vote as a block, thereby making it impossible for a motion of confidence to be passed in those two week).
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by sverige on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:59AM (#12424995)
I thought the vote for stay in or stay out was already had. Are you proposing to do it over and over until you get the result you want, then declare that this is the mandate?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by wuschel on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:07PM (#12425796)
As mentioned above, the vote has been made - but is not legally binding. I completely agree that one should respect the vote of the voters - after all, isn't that one of the basis of our western political systems?

On the other hand, what if the electorate did not vote out of protest, was misinformed by the politicians or media, or simply not educated enough to make the proper choice? Apart from the shocking failure of an established western democracy to make a good economical and political choice, what are the consequences at stake here?

For our startup, for instance, it means that we considered dropping potential R&D partners from the UK. For the UK economy, the consequences might be devastating.

In general, I am all for removing UK's special privileges, and their counterproductive attitude towards the EU. But I also do not want to see them go. The EU would loose a member state, and the UK might desintegrate (Northern Ireland and Scotland sure want to stay in the EU!).

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by sverige on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:26PM (#12425892)
> On the other hand, what if the electorate did not vote out of protest, was misinformed by the politicians or media, or simply not educated enough to make the proper choice? Apart from the shocking failure of an established western democracy to make a good economical and political choice, what are the consequences at stake here?

Well, that has always been the risk with democracy. People disagree, one side of a vote wins, the other side loses.

But you can't simply accuse the winning side of being misinformed or uneducated or irrational unless you are willing to accept that they view you in the same light. And making that argument publicly, as the Remain side has very vocally since losing, only hardens the position of those on the other side that you know nothing and are not worth listening to since you obviously don't see the good that will come from their victory.

So all the rest (economic devastation, EU disintegration, counterproductive attitudes) might be exactly what they desire. And they're in the majority, in a democracy. If you dislike that, perhaps democracy isn't really your preferred form of government.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by wuschel on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:47PM (#12426021)
Generally, I do agree with you. Voting power, even if it is just one vote, comes with responsibility. And one should respect a vote, and also demand from a voter to behave in a mature, educated and responsible way.

> So all the rest (economic devastation, EU disintegration, counterproductive attitudes) might be exactly [...]

I doubt that one can draw a straight line from the outcome of the referendum to a fatalistic, self destructive attitude of the population of the UK. There are many factors at play here - protest votes against the political establishment, general abstinence, phobia against EU bureaucracy, nationalistic tendencies et cetera. I am not in the picture here, since I have never lived long enough in the UK to understand the tendencies at hand.

> perhaps democracy isn't really your preferred form of government.

I will not comment on that apart from the remark that every form of human government has its suboptimal characteristics. Democracy is not such a bad solution - apart from the fact when it fails.

All in all, again, the EU will survive the BREXIT, albeit it will take damage. The UK might not.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by sverige on Sunday September 04, 2016 @03:04PM (#12426120)
> demand from a voter to behave in a mature, educated and responsible way.

What does that mean? Votes voted either "Leave" or "Remain." That's it. It's a binary choice.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by wuschel on Sunday September 04, 2016 @04:34PM (#12426567)
That means that we should take it as a lesson to improve our way to handle decisions like that.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mattmanser on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:02AM (#12424678)
No, it's happening. As in like the most likely thing to happen next is that it will happen.

It's not binding as in they could theoretically put it to an MP vote and reject it, but it would be utter political suicide for any party that did. So it's only not binding only if you're completely and utterly delusional.

There would be riots, a major swing to UKIP, lots of 'safe' MPs would lose their seats, etc., etc.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tonyedgecombe on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:02PM (#12425398)
I'm sure it would get put to another vote based on some material change to the situation. My guess is with restrictions on free movement many people would change their mind.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by georgeecollins on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:19PM (#12425138)
It is fundamentally undermining of the legitimacy of a democracy to ignore the popular vote in a national referendum. Although the majority now may believe it is the right choice, the precedent would inevitably come back to haunt you.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by gsnedders on Sunday September 04, 2016 @01:02PM (#12425402)
There's precedent, though, in the form of the Scottish devolution referendum in 1979. 51.6% voted in favour of a Scottish Assembly, but as enacted to be considered to pass it needed 40% or more of the registered electorate to vote in favour—with only 63.7% turnout, it was only 32.9% of the registered electorate.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by dominotw on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:49AM (#12424934)
There is some early data

  When Economic Doomsayers Stumble: Cautionary Tales From Brexit, Grexit and U.S. Budget Battles
http://www.wsj.com/articles/forecasts-of-brexit-gloom-may-be...
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by yummyfajitas on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:59AM (#12424994)
I made the prediction on June 27 (the first trading day after Brexit) that all of this is overblown.

Proof: https://twitter.com/stucchio/status/747493530277294082

I'm up 14% (67% annualized) on EWU (UK index) and VGK (Europe Index) since then - it's a nice chunk of money in my pocket.

There are so many doomsayers here. When are you guys going to go short?

It's a lot easier to criticize the outgroup than it is to put your money where your mouth is.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mikeash on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:56AM (#12424970)
You'd think all those politicians campaigning for it would have worked out these details in advance. Too bad politicians actually doing their jobs doesn't seem to be in fashion these days.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by agumonkey on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:01AM (#12424357)
GBP stopped falling though. Dunno if it's because brexit stalled or because the market thinks brexit will be fine.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Amezarak on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:52AM (#12424953)
Falling GBP mean UK exports become increasingly competitive, it's not a great measure of "this is bad news for Brexit!" in the first place.

In fact, if it remains at the levels it's at, it will cancel out the additional tariffs UK exports into Europe would see as non-members of the EU.

The whole thing is really quite overblown.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by dogma1138 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:03AM (#12424376)
The GBP stopped falling because the UK government spend about 250bln GBP to stop it from falling further.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by wavefunction on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:31AM (#12424500)
They bought 250bln GBP, right? I'm no expert on monetary policy but I thought the way to counter a falling currency was to buy the currency with other foreign currency reserves.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by blibble on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:00PM (#12425007)
the Bank of England offered to provide 250 billion of liquidity to banks, which is not the same thing as the government spending it buying foreign currency
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by agumonkey on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:11AM (#12424416)
Was it reported in mainstream news ?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by porker on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:14AM (#12424437)
If you count the Financial Times as mainstream, yes.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by agumonkey on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:23PM (#12425163)
Not my radar but mainstrean indeed.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by mpweiher on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:33AM (#12424849)
It stopped falling, for now, but has steadied at a significantly lower level. Don't know how this can be interpreted as markets thinking that brexit will be fine.

It just looks like the market has priced in the current situation, which is worse than before, but doesn't yet know what will happen, because nobody really knows.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by agumonkey on Sunday September 04, 2016 @12:22PM (#12425161)
My reflection was "negative". If companies emitted signs of trouble and England seen as the Titanic, I thought the GBP would keep crashing; the fact that it wasn't led me to believe the British market was still fine and could handle more stress on its own in the future.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by Scarblac on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:02AM (#12424370)
The second can't be true as long as nobody knows what Brexit is going to mean.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by m0nty on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:03AM (#12424685)
Nothing's actually happened yet. It's a "phony war" until Article 50 is invoked.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by michaelbuddy on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:53AM (#12424313)
It's not just to 'limit immigration'. It was also to no remove the decidedly unneeded layer of unchecked lawmakers who at any time can run wild and criminalize UK citizens, who then have no recourse.

Given that the UK economy is doing well, what is there to talk about? Most people are relieved to have that monkey off their back.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tfgg on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:01AM (#12424358)
> ... unchecked lawmakers who at any time can run wild and criminalize UK citizens ...

Assuming you're referring to the EU Parliament, the EU has little say in UK criminal law -- as opposed to various cooperation agreements and bits of harmonizing how criminal justice is carried out.

https://fullfact.org/europe/what-would-brexit-mean-criminal-...

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by joshvm on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:03AM (#12424372)
Those unchecked lawmakers were also responsible for a level of governmental oversight which is unprecedented anywhere else in the world. That's not a bad thing at all, but you can't sell Remain to an electorate by saying "The EU stops us doing stupid stuff to you".

That monkey was responsible for a huge number of regulations which benefit EU citizens, again, because it forces the government to take action that they would otherwise be too unwilling or lazy to take.

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by rayiner on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:07AM (#12424396)
The U.K. already had plenty of government oversight. Why on earth does it need even more from bureaucrats in other countries?
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by tim333 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:27AM (#12424485)
A lot of it relates to trade so we could have the single market. If you're going to have a border free market where you can order your ingredients from any country you need them to be made to the same regulations.
Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by joshvm on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:23AM (#12424787)
Oversight by whom? I agree that the UK government can be held accountable by the public, probably more so than many countries. However if the government agrees to pass a stupid law, there's very little the public can do about it.

Can you provide a specific example of something that you think has been over-regulated by the EU?

https://fullfact.org/europe/eu-facts-behind-claims-uk-influe...

(I'll take the downvote to mean that you don't have an example?)

Re:Japan's Unprecedented Warning to UK Over Brexit by kalleboo on Sunday September 04, 2016 @11:42AM (#12424896)
> Can you provide a specific example of something that you think has been over-regulated by the EU?

I recall Leavers on Facebook looking forward repealing stifling EU legislation restricting higher-wattage toasters and vacuum cleaners