News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by donohoe on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @04:45PM (#10983710)
Which is hilarious because the reason I can't switch The New Yorker website to HTTPS is because of ads - which I'm getting from Google DFP which allows non-secure ad assets.

In short; Google will penalize me because I use Google.

The universe has a sense of humor.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by cryptoz on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @04:56PM (#10983812)
Similarly, Google claimed they would start penalizing websites that showed full-page ads for mobile apps instead of showing you the website. But every single time I try to get to Gmail, or Drive, or Calendar, or any Google service on the web using a mobile device, I'm shown a full page ad for a mobile app. Google has been doing this for years, and it seems like it's also been a year since they said they'd punish all sites that do that. But Gmail still turns up as #1 in search results for email, so does calendar, etc. It seems to me that they have whitelisted themselves and choose not to punish any Google property that breaks the Google rules, despite claiming to do so.

Edit: Typically, when a service tells me "no you can't use this service until you view a full page ad" I just give up and not bother continuing to the service. But the same is not true for Google. I reluctantly click through the full page ad every single time. It's incredibly annoying that I let them get away with this and still use the services. They are so outrageously arrogant about it and it bothers me greatly, but still, I don't change.

Edit 2:

Going to calendar.google.com: http://i.imgur.com/fNRhhYx.png

First results for searching 'calendar': http://i.imgur.com/l3A5Wlh.png

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by AJ007 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:44PM (#10985415)
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by airswimmer on Thursday January 28, 2016 @02:48PM (#10990694)
You are right. I think Google want people to get annoyed with this vignette ads if he or she uses google calendar. The user should install Google calendar the APP to be fully controlled by google. Then Google can just sends the user any ad what google like...

They all prefer user using apps rather than web pages. Google and others want to get fully control of users and make money...

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by magicalist on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:48PM (#10984197)
> First results for searching 'calendar': http://i.imgur.com/l3A5Wlh.png

Well in your screenshot it seems like you scrolled down on the "calendar" search results. I get some other random thing ahead of Google Calendar, in incognito or not.

It is really annoying (I too hate those things, I would have installed the app if I wanted the app), but the click through thing only happens once in my testing. Are you clearing your cookies regularly?

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by cryptoz on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:50PM (#10984212)
I scrolled down because the top of the page was a Google Ad for Google Calendar. I chose to show the first organic result. Here's the top of the page: http://imgur.com/cO84ogZ.png
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by airswimmer on Thursday January 28, 2016 @02:50PM (#10990711)
How about using a software to get rid of google ads?

I can erase google ads from DNS level. Users can never reach any google ad at all.

What you think?

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by psykovsky on Friday January 29, 2016 @07:34AM (#10994840)
Adaway was already invented ;)
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by mark_lee on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:00AM (#10987169)
The fact is they did penalize themselves for couple of times in history.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by tiagobraw on Thursday January 28, 2016 @09:52AM (#10988444)
Mostly when obliged to do so.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by rplnt on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:31AM (#10987427)
They also said not to "penalize" websites based on user agent. Yet they do it and have been doing it for years.

They also said to use valid html/etc while they didn't do it for cost saving/performance reasons. Not sure this one is still true.

My guess is that this list of preaching water and drinking wine is pretty long for Google. I think their view is they know what they are breaking so it is OK in that particular case. The rest of us has to suck it up.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by yeukhon on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:04PM (#10983875)
Yahoo shows YMail. Bing is the only one shows Gmail as first, although Yahoo technically uses Bing. You can pretty much say Yahoo actually "put herself above others" and more guilty than Google. In fact, I don't think Google is doing anything wrong. After all, Gmail is popular, and if you are doing a Google search, the user may be interested to know Google also offer email and most likely the user is already a Google user.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by jtreminio on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @06:51PM (#10984581)
> You can pretty much say Yahoo actually "put herself above others"

Do you mean `itself`? Since when are tech companies assigned genders?

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by nailer on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @06:57PM (#10984617)
Parent poster might not be from an English-speaking background.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by yeukhon on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:24PM (#10985295)
I am not, sort of. You can refer to a country by "she", so why is it inappropriate for a company? I don't see any issues. You can view a company as a mother too.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:58PM (#10986135)
That's an archaic and half-valid use, so stretching it to apply to a company makes it pretty much invalid.

You could try to convince people to use the word that way, but at present it's just not done. Companies are 'it' or you can talk about the people that make up the company as 'they'.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by FigmentEngine on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:15PM (#10986223)
given that they are not a native speaker this seems over the top. Also maybe consider Sapir–Whorf before stating universal rules..
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:23PM (#10986255)
What? I'm talking about English, not universal rules. The non-native speaker is the one that shouldn't be making assertions about what phrases do or do not have 'issues'.

Also Sapir-Whorf is dumb.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by pluma on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:57AM (#10987340)
If you try to dictate how language must be used you're just being ignorant of how she constantly evolves through her use by different speakers.

So, there.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:52AM (#10987645)
I'm not. I'm merely pointing out that such a use is going against the way English has been changing over time.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by bryanrasmussen on Thursday January 28, 2016 @07:50AM (#10987829)
English as she is spoke does this?
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by mynameisvlad on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @09:21PM (#10985639)
One of the reasons a country has feminine gender is the association with the motherland (ie. one's native country).
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by pollen23 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:10PM (#10985896)
Not all countries have feminine gender, just check https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fatherland
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by schoen on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:30PM (#10986010)
I never thought about the question of whether, in languages that require nouns to have grammatical gender, particular countries may have a different grammatical gender from others, but on reflection I already know examples where they do in Portuguese: o Brasil, o Canadá (amusing to me because of the national anthem), but a Argentina, a Alemanha.

I wonder if this also happens in German; the only examples I'm thinking of offhand are feminine (die Schweiz, die Türkei) but now I'm not at all sure that there isn't a masculine one too!

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by schoen on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:45AM (#10986740)
Apparently Iraq, Iran, Yemen, the Congo, Lebanon, and Chad are masculine in German: https://german.yabla.com/lessons.php?lesson_id=409
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by pluma on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:51AM (#10987325)
Actually I can't think of many cases where German would use pronouns with countries. The reason these are masculine is because they are typically referred to using a definitive pronoun (literally "the Iraq", "the Iran", etc). It's more common with names of regions -- which may indicate that these countries used to be mere geographical regions (rather than sovereign nations) when the names entered the German language.

It also happens with countries like the UK, the US, the Czech Republic and so on, but obviously for the same reasons as in English.

I can't actually think of a country that's feminine in German. The "die" you often see is actually indicating plural (e.g. "die vereinigten Staaten", the United States; or "die Niederlande", "the Netherlands").

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by schoen on Friday January 29, 2016 @04:41PM (#10998709)
When you use pronouns for anaphora, would you use "es" for all countries, or is it plausible to imagine "er" or "sie", as with common nouns?

For example: Vor drei Monaten waren meine Mutter und ich in der Schweiz; wir haben _____ wirklich schön gefunden.

Would you accept "sie" here as a reference to Switzerland (because it was referred to as "die Schweiz"), or "es", or both? My intution is "es", but I'm not not a native speaker and non-native German speakers notoriously over-apply "es" to inanimate things.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by pluma on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:48AM (#11011424)
I'd use "es" because it refers to the experience of being in Switzerland rather than the country itself.

But Switzerland is another example of a country that is typically used with an article. Consider the sentence "Ich fahre nach ____" with a country name. It doesn't work for countries like Switzerland ("nach Schweiz" sounds wrong, you'd instead say "in die Schweiz" -- same as "nach Kongo" vs "in den Kongo").

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by schoen on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:13PM (#11015019)
Thanks! Can we force the sentence to be about the country itself?

- Was meinen Sie über die Schweiz?

- ____ ist schön. / Ich finde ____ schön.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by lorenzhs on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:15AM (#10987379)
Several countries have articles in German, most don't. Plural countries (USA, UAE) have the plural article, which in the standard form is the same as the feminine article ("die") which makes for even more confusion, but when used in a case changes differently ("in den USA" vs "in der Schweiz") :)

Some feminine countries: Switzerland, the Dominican Republic, Mongolia, Slovakia, Turkey, Ukraine, Central African Republic.

Male, in addition to your own list: Niger (!= Nigeria), Sudan, Vatican.

Neutral: UK (because kingdom is a neutral noun in German), potentially others

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by mynameisvlad on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:54AM (#10986568)
In their native tongues, sure. But we're not talking about Afrikaans or French, we're talking about English. And since Britannia is feminine, English would have developed with the word "motherland" representing the native country.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by yeukhon on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:41PM (#10986053)
But if you have a child company, wouldn't you expect to associate the parent company with a feminine gender before a masculine gender? That's what I am getting at. An organization has that "motherland" feel in some way.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by mynameisvlad on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:01AM (#10986593)
Not really, no. Motherland is a very specific term that's been ingrained into English most likely because of the close personal relationship between people and their native countries, which would have been Britannia for many English speakers when the language was developing. There isn't really that same deep and universal connection when talking about organizations, so a similar term probably wouldn't develop anytime soon.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by pluma on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:56AM (#10987337)
Sure, but what about ships? If you've read any sci-fi, the term "mothership" should spring to your mind. Or "motherboard" in hardware.

The concept of "some larger entity that spawns smaller entities" seems to generally lend itself to the mother/daughter terminology if you want to be poetic about it.

That said, whatever happened to artistic liberties?

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by psykovsky on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:49AM (#10988075)
In Portuguese we also say motherland. I doubt it's a Saxon thing, given Portuguese is a Latin language.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by pdappollonio on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:43PM (#10984946)
This. I would've written the same by mistake.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by solotronics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:22PM (#10984765)
No offense meant but why not get the app?

I understand not wanting an application for a news website or something like that but something you use often like google calendar it would seem like the application would be better than the mobile page.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by cryptoz on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:31PM (#10984837)
I do have the app. And that fact makes this double-annoying. When trying to visit a website, I'm told not to do that. That would be annoying on its own, and in fact it was for the first few years that it happened. But that's not at all what is frustrating me right now. What's super annoying is that Google claimed last year that they would penalize websites that do this, because they find it annoying too. Except they have done no such thing. I'm calling out Google's hypocrisy on who gets to show full-page ads without being penalized - Google does and nobody else?

If they want to show full-page ads and be super annoying, then fine, I'll deal with it. But don't pretend to be against it when you do the same practice yourself.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by nodamage on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @09:17PM (#10985622)
> I do have the app. And that fact makes this double-annoying.

It really just shows the sad state of mobile advertising when they're showing you ads for an app you already have.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by robin_reala on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:19AM (#10986657)
On the other hand, I like that websites are unable to query my phone to find out what apps I have installed.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by nodamage on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:43AM (#10987452)
Yes I agree with you, I don't want any random website to be able to query my phone to find out what apps I have installed either.

However, if I'm on a specific app publisher's website, I wouldn't mind letting them know (through some mechanism) that I've already installed their specific app.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by nostalgiac on Thursday January 28, 2016 @02:00AM (#10986790)
Sad state?

How do you expecet them to know all the apps installed on your phone? And if they DID know this information, people would be up in arms about privacy or lack there-of.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by imtringued on Thursday January 28, 2016 @02:13AM (#10986835)
It's google. They know that you downloaded the app from the Play Store and used the app to connect to their servers directly. They already have plenty of information.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by nodamage on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:38AM (#10987445)
Yes, showing you an advertisement for an app you've already installed is bad UI/UX, regardless of the reason why. On the publisher side, it's also a wasted ad impression.

I don't expect them to know all the apps installed on my phone, nor do I think they need that much information to solve this particular problem.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by id on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:17AM (#10987225)
If they don't know it, they shouldn't make assumptions.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:36PM (#10984882)
Why do you assume they're not being penalized?

Showing that they rank above "timeanddate.com" doesn't mean a lot.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by cryptoz on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:41PM (#10984933)
Being ranked #1 in a Google search for 'calendar' does mean a lot. Also, let's say they are penalizing themselves, but the penalty isn't enough to change their ranking. Why, then, would they claim that they are making this change because it's better for users to not have these ads but to still run these ads themselves?

> Our analysis shows that it is not a good search experience and can be frustrating for users because they are expecting to see the content of the Web page.

https://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2015/09/mobile-f...

This would imply that they know the experience is bad for users, they know that the penalty won't hurt their ranking, and so they will continue to show the bad experience regardless? That's just as bad as them not penalizing themselves for the full page ad.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:54PM (#10986121)
A penalty that doesn't knock down one of the largest sites on the internet can still be a big deal to everyone else.

I assume different departments run calendar and search.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by crottypeter on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:45AM (#10987457)
Not if you want to allow attendees to edit your event.

This is missing from the android app. So you have to browse to the calendar on the web and ... this.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by SystemOut on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:46PM (#10985423)
Google DFP allows it because publishers (e.g. the New Yorker) aren't ready to switch all their traffic HTTPS. If they wanted to they could turn the switch and be HTTPS and tell DFP to only serve secure creatives.

One of the larger difficulties for publishers is that many of the 3rd party SSPs aren't ready to go full HTTPs and so publishers are reluctant to make the switch because it reduces demand sources.

Disclaimer: Work for Google in advertising

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by michaelt on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:05AM (#10986997)

  One of the larger difficulties for publishers is that
  many of the 3rd party SSPs aren't ready to go full HTTPs
Right, but Google can motivate or improve the third-party advertisers to update much more effectively than publishers can - just Google hasn't chosen to do that yet.

It would be easy to proxy http-only ads from through a CDN that added encryption. Or to charge a premium to http-only ad networks, and ramp the premium up over time.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by SystemOut on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:37AM (#10987110)
How do you think Google can motivate 3rd party advertisers? I'm talking about the Rubicons, Pubmatics, etc. Google doesn't have any real leverage over them. Other than the fact that as publishers do move to SSL (because of the SEO penalty that non SSL sites have) they won't use the SSPs that don't demand or can't insure 100% SSL for their buyers. So in effect Google is putting pressure on them to do it.

I don't understand your next part at all. Who would charge a premium to http only networks? Those sites don't actually rely on Google for delivery.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by tyingq on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:33PM (#10984083)
This is also effectively true for the more broadly used Google Adsense (not just DFP). They do support displaying adsense, but then screen out all non-https ads. Which, of course, results in a lower CPM.[1]

[1]https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/10528?hl=en

>>In short; Google will penalize me because I use Google

+++

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:00PM (#10986140)
To be fair, sites without ads are a better experience than sites with ads.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by tyingq on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:03AM (#10986402)
Sure. I like free things as well.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by st3v3r on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:54PM (#10991688)
I dunno. Sites that can't pay the bills tend not to give good experiences, due to not being able to do things. Like exist.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:16PM (#10992305)
Depends on what the bills are for. Most sites that don't have content-production staff need twenty bucks a month for hosting, plus an occasional prod from a sysadmin.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by tyingq on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:42PM (#10992442)
Are there some types of content where the author, photographer, etc will produce it without direct compensation? Sure.

Are there others where that's not practical? Also, yes. Maybe not things that you need, but this problem does exist.

At the moment, there's not a model, outside of ads, that works very well for that sort of thing. There are some subscription/micropayment schemes that seem promising, but nothing that works as well as ads do.

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:48PM (#10992473)
I didn't say it was supposed to work for all sites, just that st3v3r is ignoring a huge swath of the internet by implying that nonprofessional sites don't exist.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by newjersey on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @04:49PM (#10983740)
They're trying to nudge their customers for a while. It is just a little difficult when that's one's biggest source of income.

For example, https://support.google.com/dfp_sb/answer/4515432?hl=en

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by tyingq on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:47PM (#10984190)
Also funny, because for many sites that run DFP or Adsense...that's their biggest source of income.

So, G is rationalizing their slow pace with the same reason that's not good enough for others :)

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by toomanybeersies on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:21PM (#10985955)
Google is a large company, with multiple branches.

I can't remember what services it is now, but there was some Google service that was deranked because it broke some Google search ranking policy.

It shows some integrity for the company that they're (sort of) operating their search engine objectively.

I presume that google doesn't uprank sites that specifically use Adsense versus other competing ad services?

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by ianremsen on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:21AM (#10986661)
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by incompatible on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:53PM (#10985057)
I have a page hosted on Google Sites. It seems that Google Sites doesn't support HTTPS on custom domains either.
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by joeblau on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:36AM (#10987287)
That is interesting. The Ads team is the same group that recommended turning off Transport Security in iOS 9 so you can run your Google's unencrypted Ads stack[1]. I'm sure there are two different departments that are fighting two totally separate wars. I've definitely seen this pattern in huge companies where one team is trying to push an agenda that forces another team to reshuffle their priorities.

[1] - http://googleadsdeveloper.blogspot.com/2015/08/handling-app-...

Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by JohannesH on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:44AM (#10987310)
It is really hard for DFP to not allow non-secure creatives as long as you can create 3rd-party creatives. They do try to detect non-secure assets though, so they won't run on secure pages. See: https://support.google.com/dfp_premium/answer/4515432?hl=en
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by jrochkind1 on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:17PM (#10983972)
I'm jealous that you get to work for the New Yorker website. Any openings?
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by iqonik on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:26AM (#10987253)
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by donohoe on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:09PM (#10986199)
Yes! Send me an email to discuss: [email protected]
Re:Google Will Soon Shame All Websites That Are Unencrypted by hussong on Thursday January 28, 2016 @07:02AM (#10987675)
Reminds me of PageSpeed Insights bitching about assets loaded from Google (fonts, scripts, css).