News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by patio11 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:06PM (#10354092)
There's a conversation to be had about many Americans living in precarious financial situations, but the reason why most Americans don't currently view their savings accounts as priorities is because in the current interest rate environment savings accounts and CDs are products with vanishingly little to recommend them.

The APY my bank offers is one basis point. That's $1 per year for every $10k held in the account. You can imagine that if I suddenly found $100k burning a hole in my pocket I would not immediately think "Sweet! All I have to do is stuff that it the bank for a year and then I can almost afford an entire movie ticket!"

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by nostromo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:16PM (#10354199)
Also, the article title is very different than the actual survey question:

> How much money do you have saved your savings account?

That's a very specific question. A person with $5k in their checking account or a person with $100k in a retirement account might still answer that they have no savings.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by tootie on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:31PM (#10354341)
My net worth is probably top 5% or so and I haven't even had an open savings account in 10 years. Cash on hand or it's invested in stocks, bonds and my home.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by fluidcruft on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:15PM (#10356308)
ITT the top 20% pat themselves on the back and imagine their life-bubbles are somehow similar to that of the poor. "It's the data that's obviously flawed."
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by tootie on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:02AM (#10359695)
Surely, but then you have to subtract 20% from the number in the headline.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by donjh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:23PM (#10355900)
The thing that I don't understand about this logic is that in the event of an economic downturn or disaster, if you lost your job the market would also be on the decline - the worst time to sell. Isn't it better to keep a couple month's expenses in savings, even if only for the peace of mind?
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by lmm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:27PM (#10356415)
Everything has a cost - however much you're holding in cash you're effectively burning ~3% of that each year. How quickly do bills come due? If I lost my job tomorrow I could take a payment holiday on my mortgage (since I've made overpayments) and pay for food and the like with my credit card (and in my specific case as a contractor I'd have what I'd earned last month, but I appreciate that doesn't apply to everyone); I'd certainly have a few months' leeway to sell some stocks/bonds/whatever, and what you lose in a slump is less than what you gain during the boom period.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by robrenaud on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:49PM (#10356102)
Does it matter?

Sure, consider that $10k or whatever that you need for a couple months after you lose your job. In an economic downturn, if your stocks/bonds lose half their value, it costs you $20k of pre downturn, investment dollars rather than the $10k of pre-down turn dollars if the money was in a savings account.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ryandrake on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:54PM (#10354575)
Curious, not criticizing: What is your plan if you get sick or laid off, or for some other reason need a large amount of cash immediately? I always thought it was common advice to keep ~6mo living expenses in cash savings for emergencies.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ChuckMcM on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:01PM (#10354647)
I don't know about the poster but my investment account gives me access to it as "cash" if I chose to exercise that option, the brokerage essentially loans me the money and briefly and then sells some of the stocks in a pre-arranged priority to cover that cost. The "real" life implementation of this is that my kid's college tuition is auto-deducted from that account, so if the cash on hand balance got to 0 it would liquidate money markets, and then long term stock holdings, to cover the draft.

That said, I personally have tried to balance dividend (income) paying stocks and short term bonds (6months to 1 year) which feeds into the cash balance, so that covers some of it.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by johnward on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:48PM (#10355586)
If you have a 401k you could potentially borrow against it if absolutely necessary. My plan allows 4% loans in which I pay myself the interest and a very small fee goes to the plan holder. I'm assuming the 6 months of living expenses is an extreme situation.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ChuckMcM on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:58PM (#10355675)
Well in 2009, during the real estate crash and subsequent Great Recession, people were out of work for a lot longer than 6 months. Of course financial planners don't really talk about those sorts of seismic events. That historically hasn't been an issue for engineers, but there are groups that are disproportionately affected (like older engineers).

Because I'm built the way I am I've always saved in the context of how long I could live on my savings with the goal of increasing that number until it reached infinity. That first level I call 'Raman level retirement' where you could live forever[1] off your savings if you ate only Ramen, up to the the point where you can live off your savings and keep your current lifestyle (which actually takes less income than most people thing), to actually living a more lavish lifestyle without day to day employment.

[1] Of course you intercept the life expectancy line at some point, and you have to build into your model ever increasing health care costs or a one time lump sum to emigrate somewhere that has a national health plan.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by zo1 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:34PM (#10354966)
Most of my savings is invested in index funds. Pretty much all of them allow you to withdraw the full amount in 3 days or so.

Granted, do you have any idea what such a scenario might look like? Odds are, it can wait. Even large medical operations if you don't have medical insurance (where I live), simply require a modest deposit before they start the operation or expensive procedure. Though I do think they ask for some sort of proof that you have the money on hand.

But, again, most people here have enough money to pay for private healthcare insurance, or they rely on the free state hospitals.

Car, insured. Medical, insured. Bond payments, predictable.

So, I'm trying to figure out a valid plausible scenario where a large amount of "cash" is required in a very short amount of time. Any ideas?

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by stevewilhelm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:04PM (#10355725)
There is a difference between liquid and volatile. Index funds are definitely a liquid instrument, but they are very volatile.

For funds that you know you will need in the next six months to three years, it is recommended to keep the funds in a liquid and very stable investment.

Personally, I use a California (I live in CA) tax free short term bond fund.

What type of expenses do I keep in this kind of fund? Tax payments I know I already owe (capital gains from an IPO for example), child's college tuition payments, planned major house repairs / remodels, pending car purchases, and as others have mentioned six months of living expenses in case of layoff or other emergencies.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ryandrake on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:08PM (#10355268)
Mostly medical costs or getting laid off are the scenarios I'd be worried about. Even if you're insured, medical bills add up and you tend to be billed very soon after care is provided.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by 6stringmerc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:22PM (#10355383)
In a scenario where you are found at fault in an accident (eventually / as the outcome), both legal fees and the judgment of having to pay out could put immense strain on your fiscal outlook in both the short and long term. Note I picked the word "accident" because it's something that is theoretically insured against but may not be sufficiently mitigated as a personal risk. E.g. umbrella is too small.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by msallin on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:17PM (#10363331)
Sure, you could liquidate your investments if need be, but you'll get hit with high short-term capital gains taxes if you sell equities you've held for a year or less. If held longer than a year, you'll pay long-term capital gains taxes, which are substantially lower.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by rtkwe on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354642)
Stocks are a pretty liquid asset in those cases. And for things where the need for money is sooner than a sale would go through it could be put on a Amex/credit card and paid at the end of the month. Totally guessing but they've also probably got a fair amount of money in a checking account as their 'cash on hand'.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ryandrake on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:46PM (#10355579)
But stocks are risky. Murphy's Law strikes and your stocks are all down 10% when you need the money the most. That doesn't sound like the way to go for an emergency fund.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:04PM (#10355730)
You don't put that money in a stock market. And than it goes up by 10%. What's worse?

Either way you've lost money you could have had. Humans tend to be loss averse though.

In both situations you probably have liquid equivalents at hand

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ryandrake on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:32PM (#10357801)
Losing 10% is clearly worse than losing 0% while watching someone else (irrelevantly) gain 10%.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Friday October 09, 2015 @04:49AM (#10358855)
It's opportunity cost. If it goes up 10% without putting money. That's 10% you could have had if you made the right decision.

The stock market going down 10%. That's 10% you could have had, if you made the right decision.

Logically its the same. However humans loss averse, which makes one seem worse.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by astrange on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:50PM (#10357197)
Stocks and bonds of all kinds are available as ETFs that can be sold anytime. And you almost certainly don't need to sell the whole thing at once, so running low on principal value isn't that much of a problem. (Instead it's a tax break.)

https://www.betterment.com/resources/personal-finance/safety...

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by rtkwe on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:39PM (#10356022)
Even in that unlikely scenario they'd still have access to most of their money, it'd feel pretty bad to have to sell into a 10% loss but it's not the end of the world if it's a true emergency scenario. That's also a manageable risk that you can avoid with well diversified investments.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by brianwawok on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354637)
6 months is usually far too long to keep in direct cash / savings.

I think 2-3 months direct cash/savings/checking is fine, then move excess cash to CDs or something semi-liquid. You totally CAN get money out of CDs, just sometimes lose your interest. If you have some kind of CD ladder or such going on - you can have a new CD coming out every 1-3 months anyway, which will give you the cushion you need after savings run out.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hwstar on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:23PM (#10355902)
I disagree with this. If you are semi-retired like me, you need to have enough cash on hand to weather a market downturn of 1-3 years. That way you are not selling stocks at fire sale prices to keep a roof over your head and food on the table.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by icebraining on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:56PM (#10356962)
Who said anything about the stock market? Short term CDs usually have a fixed rate, you don't ever sell them at a firesale price.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hwstar on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:23PM (#10357097)
CD's are terrible investments at the moment. A 1 year CD doesn't offer a much better rate than a FDIC money market account, and I certainly would not invest in a longer term CD at the moment.

When interest rates tanked, I moved all of my CD's to money market accounts when the term was up.

What is key is to only open a money market account at an institution with a long term track record of staying above average on rates compared to thier competition. You want to avoid the institutions which constantly raise and (and then lower) thier rates. Bankrate.com is a good way to research these.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ac29 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:50PM (#10357196)
A 1 year CD is a terrible investment, but a lot of 5 year CDs have very generous early withdrawal penalties. Unless you are making over 2% in your FDIC-insured money market account, a 5 year CD is probably a better investment.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hwstar on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:58PM (#10357899)
The withdrawal penalties can be anywhere from 6 to 30 months interest for a 5 year CD. 6 months seems pretty rare with only a few institutions offering it.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ghaff on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:38PM (#10354997)
Although pretty much all essentially risk-free investments these days have interest rates so low, you're getting into fine-tuned optimization territory for most people. It's fair that if you have a big wad of cash that you really want to protect from capital losses, it's probably worth putting it in something other than cash. But the gains are minimal.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by refurb on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:18PM (#10354809)
Get a $30K line of credit with your bank. Don't touch it unless there is an emergency.

Borrow when you need it, then you have some time to figure out what assets to sell to pay it back.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by dangrossman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:58PM (#10354611)
You sell the stocks and bonds and have cash the same or next day. You can also take a home equity loan.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by dannypgh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:50PM (#10355124)
If the market declines significantly, and you're still a long-term bull (inherent to the buy and hold strategy), you probably don't want to sell until the asset recovers.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by rconti on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355216)
But is it worth missing out on the potential gains of 6 months' income doing nothing, just so that if you hit an emergency (by definition a rare thing) you don't sell during a down period?

I mean, keeping the money in savings virtually guarantees 'losses' in real terms.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by dannypgh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:02PM (#10356215)
shrug maybe, maybe not. I sometimes have rather low cash reserves; credit cards and a checking account that lets me overdraft for free (via margin borrowing) can give me a bit of liquidity. But credit cards come due every month, and margin borrowing can always result in a margin call, so it certainly does feel like a risk. Having a bit of cash around gives you some peace of mind, but what's that worth depends quite a lot on the individual.

I believe there's a significant risk of deflationary times ahead - the prime rate over the last five years really makes much of that argument for me. It is not a given that keeping the money in a savings account guarantees real losses.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by throwaway342526 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:39PM (#10355008)
The typical advice is ~6mo in liquid assets. Not cash.

Stock is considered a liquid asset.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by msallin on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:14PM (#10363320)
If you meet the income requirements (>$116k if single, >$183k if filing jointly), you can contribute up to $5,500 per year into a Roth IRA which can also double as an emergency fund if need-be. You can withdraw all your contributions with zero penalty anytime for any reason. You just can't withdraw your earnings on those contributions without a penalty.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by tootie on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:02AM (#10359692)
I can put $10K on my CC and not have to pay for 30 days which is plenty of time to cash out investments. I'd rather take the hit on selling low in an emergency then proactively give up gains by having cash sit idle for years.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by walshemj on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:10PM (#10356279)
You sell bonds or near cash equivalents like t bills, gilts , consols etc
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:37PM (#10354392)
You're exactly the kind of person this article is pointing out, because your ability to be wiped away by the market is a precarious position to be in.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by runako on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:45PM (#10354465)
I think you're implicitly doing an asset allocation for the poster.

> Cash on hand or it's invested in stocks, bonds and my home.

That could be $100k on hand in checking, $600k in stocks/bonds, and $200k in home equity, with $0 in a savings account. Asset allocations that don't use savings accounts are not necessarily 'precarious'.

Also, it's worth noting that most financial advisors do not recommend that you keep a significant portion of your assets in savings accounts. Primary reason is that by not being in assets that deliver returns, you are losing money to inflation, even at these low levels of inflation. (Also, you have to save a ton more if you don't let your money multiply.)

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:49PM (#10354520)
You are, as far as I know, entirely correct. I still think the survey was designed specifically to find these people who exist in this manner, and I think your criticisms are valid when placed against the thrust of the survey.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by misiti3780 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:59PM (#10354618)
everytime someone says that, I always think of a great quote by Nouriel Roubini:

"asked whether he invests in stocks, he replied, "Not as much these days. I used to have a lot in equities—about 75%—but over the past three years, I’ve had about 95% in cash and 5% in equities. You’re not getting much from savings these days but earning 0% is better than losing 50%."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nouriel_Roubini

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by enoch_r on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:23PM (#10354852)
Since June 2009, when that interview was conducted, the S&P500 has more than doubled, not including dividends, so I hope he switched back or he did, in a sense, "lose" 50%.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by 6stringmerc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:18PM (#10355345)
Counter point:

Numerous financial experts assert the current valuations within the stock market do not reflect the underlying fundamentals; or, in other words, ZIRP allows for cheap debt in the bond markets which many firms are using to aggressively buy back stock, thereby artificially inflating the market value. Thus, "a correction" is due and his statement is still valid from a conservative investing standpoint.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by scoreponok on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:48PM (#10355584)
This is hindsight bias. The markets could have easily went the other way. Market timing is notoriously futile. If you want to play "what if?" and pick arbitrary dates then he could have as easily put his cash position into equities lets say beginning of October 2008? Then his advice would seem very wise indeed.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by enoch_r on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:16PM (#10356318)
I agree, market timing is futile. Roubini is unwise not because he lost money, but because he believed he could time the market. Mountains of evidence suggest that the RoR on stocks is positive and higher than that of lower-risk assets, Roubini claimed that the opposite was temporarily true. This is a good example of an attempt at market timing that failed.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by astrange on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:56PM (#10357226)
Even if he'd done that he would be better off than using a savings account.

http://dqydj.net/sp-500-return-calculator/

Picking arbitrary dates to buy a lot of equities and then not selling them isn't market timing; trying to trade repeatedly on the right dates is. That's how you lose all your money.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by runako on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:12PM (#10355293)
Other commenters weigh in with excellent counters. However, the OP (and I) didn't split between equities and cash.

It would have been very rare for one to have -- while trying to be prudent -- constructed a portfolio of assets across checking accounts, equities, bonds, and primary residence that saw anything like a 50% loss from peak to 2008-crisis trough.

Note that the checking account loss was 0%; bonds did not perform as badly as equities; and in the vast majority of the US, residential RE did not fall 50%. Also note that if one did not choose the absolute generational bottom to liquidate the entire portfolio, the actual losses would have been lesser still. In other words, allocating across a diverse set of assets would have protected from the worst of the downside (while letting you participate in the historic run in equities since).

Irrational fear of volatility is going to have a lot of people retiring much later than they would like, with less money than they would like.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:47PM (#10355090)
Really bad advice. The stock did stupidly well after that.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by rconti on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:01PM (#10355205)
When the market goes down, you can still hold. Or you can sell before the bottom. I was playing in the market in 2008, I got out after the down lost about 2000. Paid off all my debt, got back in at lower prices! Worked great.

I also have $1 in my savings account.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by dragontamer on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:28PM (#10354902)
> "Fame and Fortune: Nouriel Roubini" Times Online, June 21, 2009

Nouriel Roubini lost 260% gains + dividends between 2009 and today. So... I wouldn't really count on this guy's advice at all.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by misiti3780 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:21PM (#10355367)
that is very true, but a lot of people that couldnt afford to lose money lost that and more (percentage wise) in between march - sept. 2008. Your best bet is to put money in vanguard index funds targeted for your ideal retirement year and check it once a year - but for people that are trading single stocks/options/.etc, i think Roubini is right - he is also 55 so he is and should be a lot more conservative than someone that is in their early 20s/30s
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by nommm-nommm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:45PM (#10355075)
>most financial advisors do not recommend that you keep a significant portion of your assets in savings accounts.

This, of course, depends entirely on the individual and their circumstances.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by runako on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:14PM (#10355309)
Obviously, if you're planning on using 85% of your assets in the very near future, that's an exception.

But in general, if your financial advisor suggests going 95% cash for the long haul, you should probably get someone else.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by nommm-nommm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:54PM (#10355637)
I have less than "recommended" (depending on who you ask) in an emergency fund (but I do still have one). Why? I have a spouse with a large income and it is doubtful crisis will hit us both at once. I also can reduce my spending without a problem in the short term - most of my spending isn't fixed expenses it is experiences that can be curtailed very easily. Someone with a large mortgage may want to keep more in their emergency account - that's all I'm saying. Age has a lot to do with it also - if you are young you can ride out large dips in the market.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:45PM (#10354464)
What? Let's assume he's intelligent and has good diversification (eg. he mentioned bonds, stocks, home, and cash -- probably in a investment account). If all his financial positions got "wiped out" in a broad-sweeping financial collapse, then "cash in savings" would be equally worthless.

In the meantime, he has a home to live in. Plus, most investment accounts give you easy access for withdrawals (eg. debit cards) or the ability to borrow while transfers or sales settle. I fail to see how it's precarious.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:48PM (#10354498)
You're the second person to say this, but how would "cash in savings" be equally worthless? Maybe I'm not understanding, but it's pretty difficult to actually lose money in a savings account, that's the whole point.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354633)
He mentioned having some of the funds as "cash on hand." Let's assume it's some sort of investment (eg. sweep) account, like at Charles Schwab [1]. The funds are FDIC-insured, just like a savings account; they are also just as accessible as a savings account. But they are actually an investment account, from which you can trade stocks, bonds, etc.

Of the (mostly affluent) people I know... none of them possess a traditional savings account. Most use a checking accounts for direct deposit and a brokerage account. There's no reason to have a traditional savings account.

[1] http://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/investing/accounts_produ...

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:53PM (#10355142)
Because in diversified portfolio, to loose it all the following must happen. All listed companies must have completely collapsed. Goverment must have basically collpased to loose all value on the bonds.

If that happens its probably the financial amagedden anyway.

If the stock market falls by 50% i still have 70% of my portfolio. I'm OK with that.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by msandford on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:39PM (#10355519)
Right but these days there's a lot of correlation between assets and all the big moves happen in response to monetary policy. In an environment where everything doesn't hinge on extremely low interest rates I'm in total agreement, but you're really exposed to policy risk in the market right now.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:50PM (#10355603)
I agree that many assets are now correlated stocks and bonds for example.

But for a bond to go to absoulte 0, would take a lot.

Also I'm not sure that small increases in the interest rates would that much of a disaster. We've been in situations with low interest rates before, and increments in the interest rate didn't harm stocks in the long term.

In many ways it's a positive indicator, that goverments see a positive future.

When the fed announced that the interest rates were on hold. Stocks went down.

There is a lot of lose money in the system though from low interest rates.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by fancyketchup on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:26PM (#10354887)
Because the set of events that could "wipe away" your (reasonably-intelligently diversified) assets has a large intersection with the set of events that could "wipe away" your saving account in a bank. Things like nuclear war, global pandemic, etc.

Yes, the FDIC does insure savings accounts, but that's only useful so long as the FDIC exists.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:37PM (#10354983)
I don't agree! I think much worse things would have to happen to dissolve the FDIC than would have to happen to lose a significant portion of your investments in the bond/stock/real estate markets.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by scott_karana on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:55PM (#10354591)
> in a broad-sweeping financial collapse, then "cash in savings" would be equally worthless.

> how would "cash in savings" be equally worthless? Maybe I'm not understanding, but it's pretty difficult to actually lose money in a savings account, that's the whole point.

The cash wouldn't be lost, but it would have reduced purchasing power in a recession. And if inflation is steep, you're actively "losing" money.

It would be "worthless" in the context of long-term investing, because nothing would have long-term worth.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by antientropic on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:25PM (#10354879)
Why would the cash have reduced purchasing power in a recession? Sure, that would be the case if there was high inflation, but that certainly wasn't the case with the 2008 crisis.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by mywittyname on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355219)
You have that backwards, during a recession Cash is King. $10,000 in summer 2009 bought you a hell of a lot more of practically anything than the same amount a year previously.

People with cash on hand in 2009 made out like bandits. Cheap stocks, cheap houses, cheap cars. Everything was cheap, cheap, cheap.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:54PM (#10355147)
> You're exactly the kind of person this article is pointing out, because your ability to be wiped away by the market is a precarious position to be in.

Any scenario where the stock market declines by 99% ($100k to $1k) would basically mean the collapse of the entire financial system. I doubt your bank savings account would be very useful in that scenario.

Moreover, I don't think this article is actually talking about people who do save but just choose to save into high-return assets. I save 80-90% of my income, but it all goes into index funds. Does that mean I am not "a saver?"

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355226)
> Moreover, I don't think this article is actually talking about people who do save but just choose to save into high-return assets. I save 80-90% of my income, but it all goes into index funds. Does that mean I am not "a saver?"

Not at all. This article is about people who aren't saving because they don't think its necessary or because they can't afford to.

An emergency fund IS NOT an investment. It is insurance; treat it as such.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:21PM (#10355888)
> An emergency fund IS NOT an investment.

Why should one have an "emergency fund?" I would genuinely love to hear a good argument for why keeping any cash assets when one has significant liquid investments, as I've never encountered one.

Insurance companies invest their premiums. Why shouldn't I?

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:30PM (#10356822)
Insurance companies and banks are required to maintain a minimum amount of safe/liquid (read: cash) reserves.

> I would genuinely love to hear a good argument for why keeping any cash assets when one has significant liquid investments,

Can you describe an asset (besides US treasuries) that you can be assured of its value in a volatile market? Even money market funds have broken the buck before (~2008).

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:56PM (#10357454)
> Can you describe an asset (besides US treasuries) that you can be assured of its value in a volatile market?

My point is emphatically not that your stocks will maintain their full value. But even at their lowest, their value will be more than enough to cover any emergency fund. A 50% drop on $100k will still leave you with $50k.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:24PM (#10357557)
Which would ruin your investment outcome for years (if not decades, depending on the value of your portfolio at the event in question). If stocks take a loss that bad, you need the ability to not sell off to get liquid cash. That is what an emergency fund is for.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:07PM (#10357933)
Ah, but now that your argument is based on decreasing returns we can just do expected value analysis.

Fortunately, many people have already done this, including Betterment: https://www.betterment.com/resources/personal-finance/safety...

Weighted by the probability of happening, you are better off investing all your money. Period.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:22PM (#10356369)
>>Any scenario where the stock market declines by 99% ($100k to $1k) would basically mean the collapse of the entire financial system.

Yet if you owned real estate[Land, Houses], they stand exactly as they are. While the numbers in the bank database turn to 0 after the collapse and companies go bankrupt and never recover. If you owned real estate, your money will recover in the very next turn.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:04PM (#10356652)
Agreed, but that's kind of off topic.

Real estate is yet another asset class which should be included in a diversified investment strategy, but my point was that there's no evidence that money should be kept in a bank savings account.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ChuckMcM on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:56PM (#10354596)
I think you're confusing loss of value with loss of savings. So if your stocks lose half their value, then you now have "less cash equivalent savings" but you still have savings. Even in the dot com crash (where I was not diversified and had a lot of tech stocks) the reduction in value across the board was, in aggregate, about 70% even though some stocks it was 99.9%. But all of that was "ok" because I didn't need that money to live on, it was "savings".

Similarly with house values, if you own your home outright it doesn't matter if the real estate market crashes, you can still live there. But it might make moving less desirable (or not if you can find a good deal somewhere else).

The article is talking about people who find themselves unable to pay for repairing a vehicle after an accident without going into credit card debt. That can start a spiral into insolvency.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by HLRoku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:41PM (#10354433)
I don't really follow how having money in stocks, bonds and a house is somehow capable of being wiped away by the market when a savings account in a bank wouldn't be in dire straits with such an economic upheaval to render those 3 investments useless
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:47PM (#10354488)
I'm sorry you don't follow, but it should be fairly obvious that stocks can crash, bond markets can collapse, and home prices can plummet, whereas money in FDIC insured savings accounts would only be lost in the event of a catastrophic, country-jeopardizing event, in which case we'll all have bigger problems.

I'm not meaning to attack anyone personally, I just think this survey is trying to suss out what percentage of Americans are in a position such that an economic downturn would hurt them severely.

I also don't know much at all about finances, so take what I'm saying with a jar of salt.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:59PM (#10355185)
Not even the worst stock crash in history was a 99% drop.

Also, you are almost 100% wrong about the intention of the article. It's not that they're trying to make some point about people's poor asset allocation, it's just sloppy reporting.

If their actual point was that people had too much money invested, wouldn't the most obvious and actionable advice for the "What to Do If Your Savings Fall Short" section be to sell some shares and transfer the cash into a savings account?

It's on you to prove why your financially unwise viewpoint is correct.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:54PM (#10356951)
The attitude you're bringing to this conversation makes me entirely unwilling to continue. Sorry.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:57PM (#10357462)
I think you're the one who might need an attitude adjustment. Instead of providing reasoning for why cash is necessary, you continue to belittle people who invest their assets.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Retric on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:04PM (#10354670)
I really don't see a significant advantage to using a savings account with a bank. Keeping 50k in a checking account vs savings account costs you less than 5$ a month before taxes which is just not worth the effort of opening a second account for someone that's keeping 50k cash on hand.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by zardo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:58PM (#10354616)
A market crash severe enough to whipe out stocks, bonds, and real estate, is also going to effect fiat currency. In order for the FDIC to actually cover the saving accounts for the defaulted banks, we would have to create many many new dollars.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Symmetry on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:55PM (#10354589)
If the stock market falls by even just 80%, which is probably the minimum I'd call "wiped out" then things are bad enough that your savings account can't be trusted either.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by jzig on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:04PM (#10354668)
I strongly disagree with you and believe FDIC insured accounts can be trusted beyond a market fall of just 80%.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355218)
Market fall of 80% in a portfolio that has been diversified isn't that bad. Say you 50% in shares. It has lost 80% of that 50%. That's not so bad. You still have a chunk of savings.

If goverment bonds loose all their value, it means goverments are close to failing.

If real estate is loosing all its value. It means people have no money to buy houses

If all 3 is going on the same time, some serious stuff is going and I'm not sure your goverment backed account is really that secure.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by riskneural on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:09PM (#10355271)
100k in stocks after a shock crazy crash of 70% can still be painfully liquidated for 30k.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by goodcjw2 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:57PM (#10355169)
Given the interest rate so low, saving is definitely a "smart" answer. Keep cash and keep invest seems to be a "wise" choice in our current market. So, it might be the market (or policy maker) to blame...
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by pyrrhotech on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:16PM (#10354797)
Agreed, I'd answer $0 because I don't have a savings account. Even if they asked in all bank accounts, it would be about $1500 or less depending on the day of the week. Yet I own a home with 50% equity, a car and have a 6 figure retirement account and separate 6 figure taxable account. What they really should ask is what is your net worth or at least what is your liquid net worth, but I suppose that would be confusing to a lot of Americans.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by segmondy on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:21PM (#10354837)
Nopes, folks would count their home equity, furby, baseball cards and figurine collections into their net worth.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ChuckMcM on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:48PM (#10354501)
That was what I was wondering as well, since savings accounts are such poor vehicles for saving these days in terms of a return I'm sure a lot of people just leave the money in their checking account.

That said, its really really important that if you can't save some money every month, and don't accumulate savings year over year (those are importantly different things!) That is a signal that you are living beyond your means, budget down and find ways to reduce your burn rate.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by AjithAntony on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:54PM (#10357215)
In fact they are probably better off in checking because a lot of banks offer ridiculous benefits like high interest on checking in exchange for swiping your debit card 5-12 times a month.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by washadjeffmad on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:29PM (#10363828)
I just encouraged my SO to move what she'd held in savings to start off her retirement. Now her savings account is just a small emergency buffer with automated minimum monthly transfers to prevent maintenance fees.

The only reason I still have a savings account is because I expect interest rates to go up again at some point in my lifetime, and, as petty as it is, I didn't want my credit score to take that temporary dip for closing the account.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by cko on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:21PM (#10354243)
There's something to be said for having cash available - here and there, opportunities pop up for me that I can take advantage of. For example, recently I lent money at very high interest, short-term. If I suddenly get interested in prototyping electronics I won't even hesitate to buy an Arduino, sensors, and a few books. Little bits of cash is useful to "try things out."

Plus there's the "better sleep at night" factor.

People with little to no cash won't likely consider these things. Having that cash won't likely give you any good return, but there's the "freeing up your mind", "capitalizing on opportunities", and "sleeping better" things to consider.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by imperialdrive on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:30PM (#10355436)
I resonate with your comment. Thank you. I value sleep over all things. My life and daily decision making revolves around "Will I lose sleep over this?"

I sleep sooooo well at night. Sometimes I wonder if the richest and most powerful people in history sleep this well? Hehe, having a couple years of travel in savings works wonders :-D

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by russell_h on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:09PM (#10354734)
Sure, but there aren't many reasons not to keep that cash in a checking account. For a while I just kept all of my cash in a checking account because it actually paid a higher interest rate than my savings account from the same bank.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by forgetsusername on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:55PM (#10354592)
>There's something to be said for having cash available - here and there, opportunities pop up for me that I can take advantage of.

But, by definition, every time you take advantage of an opportunity, you sacrifice cash on hand. You can't always have cash on hand and always be able to take advantage of opportunities, unless you have infinite money. They are opposing forces; your money is either "in cash" or "in opportunities".

It reminds me of arguments to have "dry powder" to buy equities when there is a market correction. But that means you're sacrificing current returns for potential future returns, and unless you can anticipate the future market results, the results of the strategy are ambiguous.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by mod on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354645)
What?

You don't have to take advantage of every opportunity.

I generally buy anything that sparks my interest, and manage to bank a lot more cash than I spend.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by forgetsusername on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:25PM (#10354877)
>You don't have to take advantage of every opportunity.

That's irrelevant. The point is, strategies like, "always have cash on hand to take advantage of opportunities" don't really make sense, because the more you do of one means the less you can do of the other.

This is economics in a nutshell; determining the tradeoffs between two scarce resources, in this case cash and "opportunities". The solution isn't "more of both" unless the resources are infinite.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Spooky23 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:25PM (#10354282)
If you need liquid savings, cash is king.

I opened a savings account with my son a few weeks ago. In my day, those accounts paid 3-7%. There was a story of compounding interest to tell. Now, I feel like I'm teaching my kid to be a sucker.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hugh4 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:37PM (#10354396)
I think if I ever have a kid I'll let him open a "bank of Dad" account which pays a decent interest rate just to get him into the habit of investing.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:59PM (#10354620)
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:31PM (#10354931)
MMM has at least two rental properties and is a phoney.

He can teach his kid to be a rentier by borrowing long and taking advantage of the separation between the value of labour vs assets when fiat money is over-issued by private banks.

And how to run a web-site about being frugal whilst deriving rental income from three families who cannot save because they are busy working hard to keep MMM pumping out half-truths on the internet.

Can we all take up three times as many houses as we need and live off the rental income siphoned off from the labour of others? No.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:00PM (#10355199)
How does owning rental properties invalidate his message of "avoid rampant, unnecessary consumerism"? Certainly, not everyone can derive their retirement income from rentals (the numbers don't work out). But lucky for you: There are other forms of investment.

BTW: I currently rent. It's the financially prudent thing to do in my situation, and I certainly don't begrudge my landlords for it -- they're the ones locked into an illiquid, overvalued asset.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:02PM (#10355214)
Because rampant consumerism isn't the issue. Most families are responsible with their money. Their greatest expense? Rent/mortgage which is pushed up by:

1. bankers issuing insane amounts of debt that out-pace wages

2. speculators borrowing from said banks to "invest" in pushing up living costs for families (ie people like MMM)

The media loves to portray people as feckless idiots but the real problem is economic rent extraction by people who are adding zero value to society. That is the rentier - they generate no wealth merely appropriate it.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:25PM (#10357335)
>>Because rampant consumerism isn't the issue.

Sorry to break the bad news to you, but rampant consumerism actually is the issue.

>>Most families are responsible with their money.

No, in fact their spending decision don't even remotely reflect any sense of responsibility.

>>Their greatest expense?

If you think, smaller delta spending doesn't matter. Alas, I'm sorry that's the whole point behind indulging into consumerism without even realizing you are.

>>Rent/mortgage which is pushed up by

Demands.

>>bankers issuing insane amounts of debt that out-pace wages

You always have the option to move to the city outskirts, where houses are affordable. It will take more effort to commute and all, but cheap has to count for something. And you could save money to borrow less.

>>real problem is economic rent extraction by people who are adding zero value to society.

Houses don't get build out of fairies dropping suitcases full of money outside people's houses. They earn it, work for it. And make investments.

You are all welcome to invest and grow. But just because you don't want to, it doesn't make others greedy and evil.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:58PM (#10357681)
Housing money is not earned. It's made out of nothing by banks and then used to put a claim against a significant portion of a person's salary. As lending standards get looser prices go up.

Land speculators and money men capture all productivity growth.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:31PM (#10357798)
I'm not sure what you are talking about. Price of a house is not some thing banks get to decide, at least not directly. They only get they to decide the amount of interest they should collect to stay profitable after lending you money that you borrow to purchase a house.

Price of a house apart from the raw materials depends on various thing like supply-demand factors. But that is the case with any investment.

If you are having problems with investments in general where people can get rich by starting small but growing non-linear with time, then you are literally ruled out to ever be rich.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Avshalom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:26PM (#10355413)
If you work at say Target 40 hours a week, squeak in the occasional overtime and work on every holiday you take home about 12-15k a year after taxes that's about half of what MMM gets from rent.

MMM hasn't come within ten grand of frugality in his life.

It doesn't strictly invalidate his message but it's a grain of salt that should not be forgotten.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:04PM (#10355726)
I get that he earns a lot from rent. But I still don't understand the animosity. Would you be equally up in arms if he just invested in municipal bonds -- the bonds that pay for your parks, roads, fire stations, police upgrades, and schools? There are reasonable tax-free bond funds (eg. PMF) that pay >6% annually.

I've read most of his posts. He harps on things like biking instead of buying a new car. Or "why spend $150/mo on a cellphone bill when you can use Google Fi for half that?" Using that latter example, that's a difference of $900/yr -- or 8% of your Target family's net annual income; enough to make a downpayment after just a few years.

To be honest: It seems like y'all are taking away the wrong message. The problems you see are legit, but directing your animosity at a guy providing free, online insights and advise seems misguided. YMMV.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Avshalom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:27PM (#10355930)
The animosity isn't specifically at MMM. People who think "have you tried spending less" is insight, thats what who we hate. Believe me poor people are way ahead of you on the spending less money idea.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hugh4 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:56PM (#10356157)
That advice isn't aimed at people who are genuinely poor, it's aimed at middle class whiners who earn middle-class money and still complain that they "can't get ahead" and "will never be able to retire".

MMM has never claimed to be frugal -- indeed, he likes to talk about the "extravagance" of his $25K pa spend for a family of four.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Avshalom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:01PM (#10356202)
>MMM has never claimed to be frugal -- indeed, he likes to talk about the "extravagance" of his $25K pa spend for a family of four.

And imagine how well that sarcasm goes with those of us who have never seen 25,000.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hugh4 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:28PM (#10356421)
And if you're in that situation then MMM isn't for you. People in that situation need a blog on how to earn more money, not one on how to spend less.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by markyc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:43PM (#10356519)
poor people are way ahead of you on the spending less money idea

not always true.. I know quite a few who still smoke, own a car even if they don't really need it, buy the extra expensive, small can of coke, and generally follow convenience over financial planning.

these things do add up. will they help them buy 3 houses and live on the passive income? don't think so, but it definitely would help them pay for their home faster

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:32PM (#10355459)
Yes you get it. And guess what? When they put the minimum wage up the rentiers will all put the rent up. All productivity gains are captured by the landlord in a system of land enclosure.

Land value tax now. Do away with income tax and let people keep the value they add.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ghaff on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:43PM (#10355051)
I think you're being a bit unfair. I have no doubt he is pretty frugal. That said, I'm not a huge fan of his schtick but recognize that there are people who probably benefit from the over-the-top exhortations to avoid spending money. A lot of people fritter away a lot on things that they don't need and may not even especially enjoy. Which has been my main takeaway on those occasions when I've skimmed his site. Whatever works.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:49PM (#10355111)
The frugal stuff is rubbish. He can be frugal because the main outgoing for any family is rent. He's taking in two rents. The rest is just a cheap show.

The reason why we are all suffering is because of rentiers. It's not because we have slightly expensive data plans on our phone. Rentiers are using this to explain away the real problem. This guy is along for the ride for the web-clicks.

Go on his site and ask a question that gives the info that he has two rental properties and see if he lets it through moderation. Be polite as you can. He won't. MMM knows where it's at.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kdamken on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:15PM (#10355322)
Except that it's not rubbish. Most people do spend large amounts of their paycheck on things they don't need. Just because he makes good money doesn't mean his concepts of saving a large percentage of what you earn aren't sound. They apply to all income levels, even more so for the lower ones.

Following his advice and sticking to a budget has gotten me from saving nothing every month to saving at least half of my take home on the same salary. Most people spend their money without thinking and then look for external sources to blame when they run out.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:22PM (#10355385)
He's not playing it straight. He's deriving income as a rentier but saying we can all live like him. We can't because rentier income by definition is income with zero value added.

These guys hiding in the grey area are very damaging. Maybe you were a total fool with your money, but for most people they are on the breadline not because houses are expensive to construct, not because fuel is expensive but because they have to pay a significant portion of their labour to rentiers.

People like this put the blame on the individual. No - it rests with the rentier.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Elepsis on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:19PM (#10355872)
You are starting from the inexplicable premise that these properties he rents out were somehow ill-gotten, and not the direct consequence of him saving significant amounts of his income while he worked a totally normal job and investing them intelligently in property.

And of course landlords (since you're obviously using rentier as a pejorative) DO provide a valuable service: housing to people who either value the flexibility of renting or don't have the finances to buy housing where they live.

Your apparent disagreement with the entire system of rental property around the world is certainly principled, but singling out Mr. Money Mustache as some kind of hypocrite for earning money off his investments is absurd on its face. Are you also opposed to people buying dividend-issuing stocks?

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by lmm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:37PM (#10356483)
> Most people do spend large amounts of their paycheck on things they don't need.

Maybe. Or maybe they're spending their paycheck on things that they do need because they have to work for a living, they can't live by renting out their assets like MMM can. Example from the other branch: MMM can say "buy a bike instead of a new car" because he had the privilege of putting his "job" (rental properties) as close as he liked to his house. Most people don't have that option.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kdamken on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:36PM (#10356846)
Yes, we all have bills that need to be paid. But many people (especially those who aren't making great money) continually and stupidly buy stuff they don't need, not even realizing they can't afford it. You make 35k a year? Then you really shouldn't be buying a brand new iPhone with a large data plan, or a new car with monthly payments that eat away at your already limited income. Or maybe instead of going out for lunch everyday for work, you should pack something. People love to complain about not having money without taking any responsibility for their spending habits.

Also, if you've read more of his stuff you'd know he worked for a decade before he retired, saving up a significant portion of his income by staying frugal. He didn't just magically have two houses to rent out.

I'm not sure where the insane hatred towards renting out a property is coming from. A lot of the time the landlord doesn't actually make much money off of it. Even if the rent covers their mortgage payment (which it often doesn't), if something serious breaks or needs to be repaired, they're on the hook for that and may end up losing money on it that year.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by lmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:34AM (#10360243)
You're right that I don't know MMMs specifics. But I think at this stage I'm justified in being skeptical of anyone who claims to be self-made - far too many people gloss over their inherited advantages. It's possible he's one of the exceptions.

No doubt much of his advice is correct, and all of it well-intended. But one has to be careful about advice from people in very different circumstances. They can get it disasterously wrong.

Landlords absolutely do make large, unearned amounts of money. Think about it for a minute: MMM is a finance expert, why would he put his money there if it didn't generate the best return. The idle rich (rentiers) in general are hated, but landlords in particular make additional money through sharp practices. The profession inherently involves (legal) tax avoidance, because a landlord makes a lot of their money through appreciation of their properties which is not taxed, and their rental income is usually taxed at a lower rate than ordinary earnings. Finally, while it's unfair to pin this on MMM, many landlords take advantage (wittingly or not) of their tenants' ignorance of their rights.

Finally, when a rich person says "it's easy to make money", it's a very small step from there to "the reason I have more money than you is that I'm smarter/more self-controlled/etc." Which is often a lie; often inherited privilege has a much bigger impact than personal qualities.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by adebtlawyer on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:29PM (#10362709)
> their rental income is usually taxed at a lower rate than ordinary earnings.

Not in the US. Rental income is income. I think you may be referring to deductions, which exist, but are not nearly as advantageous as taxing rental income at a lower rate outright.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by JoeAltmaier on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:38AM (#10360272)
We're all embedded in an economic infrastructure, that's unavoidable. Its not black/white. Everything from the internet to traffic lights helps speed commerce, and all of us inherit benefits from society.

So circumstances are everything, that part rings true. We're born into a good bit of that, and trained into the rest. From accent, to attitudes about race and religion we spend our lives accumulating advantages and albatrosses.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ghaff on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:48AM (#10359046)
I'm really not sure how this thread turned into a honeypot for "Kill the landlord" types. Especially given how things turned out the last time public policy decided to make it relatively easy to get mortgages even for people who were a bit shaky on being able to make regular payments and cover upkeep.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:52AM (#10359420)
Again this is totally the wrong end of the stick. We have loose credit, that's what rentiers love. Credit is a claim on your labour and they can issue it with zero effort.

Sub-prime hurt the poor, since 2008 with QE we've seen the gap widen as more banker credit is created and flows into land prices.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ghaff on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:58PM (#10355179)
It's "renters" BTW. [EDIT: Scratch the previous. I am, of course, wrong about the renters correction. Misread.] I'm not sure what he did to get your back up so much or when being a landlord became such a terrible evil. Also, "we" are not suffering. Yes he has a schtick and probably a pretty profitable one. His general advice is probably good for some but mostly isn't my thing because I like restaurants and traveling and that sort of thing. And I certainly don't care enough to go to his site and ask questions.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:05PM (#10355241)
> when being a landlord became such a terrible evil.

It's not being evil per se, but being an economic leech of sorts. The only reason people need to rent is because of the requirements to own (down payments, emergency funds to cover your mortgage in tough times so you don't lose your equity). Its an arbitrage between someone on financially sound footing versus someone not so.

Disclaimer: My family has a landlord or two in it. I make my disdain for what they do known. If I had Facebook money, I'd create a B Corp to provide housing to people that gave them a non-transferable equity stake, co-op style. A small amount would be "off the top" for management of the organization and for upkeep of the properties. I would make the org fully transparent ("Buffer Style") and ruthlessly accountable.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by fancyketchup on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:24PM (#10355915)
> The only reason people need to rent is because of the requirements to own (down payments, emergency funds to cover your mortgage in tough times so you don't lose your equity)

So, in other words, the landlord is selling a service? In exchange for a monthly fee, you don't have to do any of the crap (down payments, mortgages, property taxes, maintenance) it takes to own a home?

Do you view farmers the same way? If it weren't for the fact that you need to eat to survive, you wouldn't have to buy their product! And what do they do anyway? Just plant some seeds in the ground and wait for them to grow! Those damn leeches!

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by lmm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:39PM (#10356494)
The landlord is selling the service of "having a lot of money". It's usury by the back door.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:28PM (#10356812)
Not even having a lot of money. Their service is having a credit score high enough to obtain low-rate mortgages, which they then arbitrage against "market rate rent".

People complain we shouldn't subsidize people buying homes who can't afford them. Then why the f____ are we subsidizing landlords instead?

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:53AM (#10359426)
Yeah you get it. Worrying how bad HN is at economics.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:01PM (#10356196)
> Do you view farmers the same way?

Providing food for free is next on my list. I don't need labor. I just need clean energy and automation.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:12PM (#10357945)
Why not ask the whole world to slog themselves to death and serve you for free?

If they refuse to condemn themselves to such, you can always call them evil.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:29PM (#10363829)
I didn't quite get your comment. Did you have a problem that I'm trying to avoid using labor at all costs to achieve my goals? I don't think its wrong to give everyone what they need to survive without them needing to work if I don't need labor to do it. Perhaps you could enlighten me?
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hugh4 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:30PM (#10356429)
Uhh, and land.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:27PM (#10356803)
Technically, not with hydroponics. I can build up.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:04PM (#10357926)
>>It's not being evil per se, but being an economic leech of sorts.

I'm not sure from where this kind of thinking arises. Any investment is supposed to be a vehicle where your money increases without you having to directly work for it.

By that definition, all investments are wrong.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355221)
Ok you've really shown you have zero background in economics with that one. It's "rentiers", I can spell renters fine but it makes zero sense in the context above. Go read.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ghaff on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:27PM (#10355423)
On that one point, I misread and you are, of course, correct. We will however have to agree to disagree about the evils off living of rental income.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:42PM (#10355548)
Come on man up. Rentiers is peppered across - you never heard of it. If that's the case you haven't read enough to have an informed opinion.

Read some Henry George and get over my side of the fence :-)

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by whyleyc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355222)
I'm not sure you can argue MMM is trying to hide his rental situation given that he has published numerous blog posts discussing it in depth starting in 2011:

http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/05/23/get-rich-with-owni...

http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/06/29/good-times-for-lan...

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:08PM (#10355259)
His whole message of frugality makes zero sense in the wider context of his behaviour. He's giving advice to everyone but if everyone behaved as he did the world would end because we can't have a world where every family derives a significant proportion of it's income from two other families for zero value added.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by whyleyc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:34PM (#10355474)
Of course you can't have a world where everyone becomes a landlord, but that doesn't mean this is a completely invalid form of income generation for some people (that's the benefit of being able to take a nuanced view of advice from others).

It seems like you are being reductive and misleading in characterising his position - First you argue he won't dare talk about rental income, then when examples emerge of him doing so you say that he is exhorting everyone to do it!

MMM talks at length about other sources of income generation too, but let's just ignore those:

* Stocks: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/05/18/how-to-make-money-...

* Peer-to-peer lending: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/08/26/the-lending-club-e...

* Carpentry: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/04/27/nicer-legs-and-som...

As for frugality this may not be a path to financial security for many but it sure is a refreshing departure from the "more, more, more" of modern life.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:46PM (#10355574)
No the more, more, more is from the rentier. They set the rent not at the cost to deliver but at the cost the market will bear. Which is the money left over after food/fuel which puts everyone living hand to mouth with no money in their savings accounts.

God he does p2p lending also. Yuk.

However let's get this straight, there are plenty worse than him out there but I do hate to see his holier-than-tho "be frugal" when in fact he's a rentier who can be "frugal" because he's a rentier.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by fancyketchup on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:20PM (#10355879)
And if everyone became doctors, who would you call to fix the toilet?
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hugh4 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:05PM (#10356238)
I don't see why it's an issue that he owns two rental properties. Of course he has investments of one kind or another, that's his shtick. Save money, but income-yielding investments, retire. Whether you buy properties or live off the dividends of your XOM shares (or more sensibly, do both) is immaterial.

If your point is that it doesn't scale because its literally impossible for everyone to have two investment properties -- well, yeah. Frugality doesn't scale well. If everyone else stopped buying shit they don't need and working more than they needed to, production would go down and yields of all investments would suffer. So it's not actually a good idea to persuade everyone to quit buying shit they don't need, but it's advantageous for every individual to do so.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by OrwellianChild on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:41PM (#10355034)
If I may paraphrase:

"MMM can teach his kid how to make money on investments in real estate and make profits from renting his owned (financed) assets.

He can also teach his kid how to share what he's learned about not over-spending on depreciating assets."

Then there's something in there about people who choose to rent being taken advantage of by people who choose to be landlords, but I don't understand it well enough to take your meaning.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:43PM (#10355044)
Don't paraphrase me, thanks.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by jacobmarble on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:25PM (#10354875)
Yet another excellent read from MMM.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:31PM (#10354939)
How many rental properties does he have? Think he just survives on being frugal and dollar cost averaging? Think again.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by t2015_08_25 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:39PM (#10355516)
I like the cut of your jib.

I've been considering buying rental properties to supplement my income, but something deep inside somewhere, based on living close to people well below my income level as one of a 4-unit building, prevented me from doing it.

When I tried to compute how much rent I would charge, I realized I would be profiting simply by taking money from them because they have been unable to accumulate capital at the pace I have been. While that does indicate some skill on my part - hey, I scrimp and shop wisely - I don't feel it morally qualifies me to skim from others. That would be paying myself twice. When I scrimp and shop wisely, I benefit from having extra savings, but using that savings to get more from others without adding more value is something I don't feel right doing.

I could morally accept money as a landlord based on my labor doing maintenance and time spent bookkeeping, I suppose. That - speaking as a current tenant - does have some value, but I just don't think it would be much, approximately that of a day laborer or accountant for several hours a week. So screw it, i'll make a lot more money creating something of real value.

Thank you for helping me recognize and articulate this, branchless.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by OrwellianChild on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:49PM (#10356552)
I'm really confused... The thing of value you are providing as a landlord is housing. How is it skimming? Putting money towards a house/condo instead of investing it in business has an opportunity cost. You lose out on the profits from dividends/interest/cap gains. That has to be replaced. If you charge too much rent, other people will under-cut you. The price is set by available housing. Where is the deceit?

Do you feel you would owe people the freedom to use your property free-of-charge? What about the mortgage payments you endure? The maintenance/upkeep (roofs, siding, carpet, plumbing, electrical, all amortized over the life of the building)? Should this be a loss you take in order to let someone else sleep in your house?

Disclosure of bias: In Seattle where I live, the cost of real estate is higher than the prevailing rents, when you factor mortgage payments, maintenance, utilities, HOA, etc. This makes it a little easier for me to see the equity in pricing between rentals and owned homes. It may be different in your parts of the world.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by t2015_08_25 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:14PM (#10356726)
It's got nothing to do with deceit or skimming, it's power. There is no fraud, it would be simply taking advantage of people beyond the amount of value that I would be interesting in providing.

Your allusion to a market that would correct the price doesn't account for a market which no tenants can enter because none of them can afford the entrance (a 20% down payment).

They'll get the benefit of housing no matter how much I would charge, but if I charge more than the value of the maintenance and accounting them I would be exploiting them, taking advantage of their inability to produce capital in the time it's taken me to produce it. And everyone else who is in the position I am could exploit them just as easily so the market doesn't help there.

It's like gas prices: if so many gas stations can compete, how come they prices aren't driven down to nothing? Because of the entrance cost to the market. You can't start a well and refinery, so you have to go to one of the established ones.

For luxury items like phones, art, fancy cars, etc., I don't care about charging people a lot of money. But for water, air, food, medical and housing, which people have no choice to acquire or consume I'm not going to gouge them.

This is not some rational choice about what a person or market theory can or should do, this is my personal code of ethics.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by OrwellianChild on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:31PM (#10356824)
Not trying to change your mind, and I appreciate the chance for a dialogue... Your perspective seems based on the idea that housing (shelter) is a basic need and should be provided for, and at some fundamental level I'm inclined to agree. (In my mind, it would be pretty basic housing...)

I did want to call attention to your gas prices example... Gas prices are driven down to approximately the cost of getting more oil out of the ground, refining it into gasoline, and transporting it to your local Chevron. These are costs inherent to "making gas" - it's not free. The same goes for housing, so whether you'd have renters pay it or have the government pay it for them, someone's going to have to cut down trees, pour concrete, level land, install plumbing, etc.

This is this "value" of the housing I'm talking about, which is separate from the moral right to shelter that seems to guide your judgement on the issue. Thanks for being willing to engage me in the discussion!

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:27PM (#10357991)
>>Your perspective seems based on the idea that housing (shelter) is a basic need and should be provided for

There is a very unfortunate problem with this line of thinking. It takes a lot of effort/money to build a house. You need to procure raw materials, pay for human labor and various other expenses, this is apart from acquiring land.

And the problem with this kind of 'equality for all' argument towards housing is you are assuming, that a good quality home should either come at a cheap price or some one being ready to pay and make up for everybody else. Both of them are problematic, why should every single economic link in the chain related to building a house suffer? Or why are we expecting some people to pay taxes and have houses built for every one else?

You don't have the right to anything unless the cost of achieving that is literally free or negligible.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:50AM (#10359415)
This is so wrong it hurts. The cost of the "house" is the land. Building houses has never been cheaper. Just like everything else has never been cheaper.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by jdenning on Saturday October 10, 2015 @10:39PM (#10367817)
I don't think this is correct - construction costs are currently below the all-time peak, but they have been steadily increasing. According to the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB):

"The average construction cost of a single-family home in the 2013 survey is $246,453. This average is significantly higher than the 2011 average construction cost of $184,125, and is the highest it has been since 1998. Although the cost of construction per square foot remained relatively stable in 2009 and 2011 ($82 per square foot, and $80 per square foot, respectively), it jumped to $95 per square foot in 2013."

Also, regarding the relative impact of land cost vs construction costs:

"NAHB’s most recent construction cost survey (conducted in August and September of 2013) shows that although lot sizes are shrinking, both the cost and size of the home are on the rise. The average home in our survey was built on 14,359 square feet (about a third of an acre) of land, had 2,607 square feet of finished area, and sold for $399,532. The average share of the home’s sales price which goes to construction cost jumped from 59 percent in both 2009 and 2011 to 62 percent in 2013. Finished lot costs, accounting for the second largest share of the sales price, dropped from 22 percent in 2011 to 19 percent in 2013."

The situation might have changed since this survey in 2013, but this is the most recent information I was able to find.

EDIT: Source - http://nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?genericContentID=221388

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:41PM (#10355537)
Glad to help. Spread the word and don't accept the empty US rhetoric that "it's just business, baby".

Good for you for having some back-bone.

Deriving income by adding value is fine. The rentier just takes.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by a_c_s on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:06PM (#10355246)
He publishes his family's spending every year: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2015/01/16/exposed-the-mmm-fa...
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:11PM (#10355277)
That's not his income. I see his mortgage / rent is zero. So if we all had no mortgage/rent to pay MMM would see his income fall as he has rental properties.

I'm sure many families renting would love to "build stuff out of wood" but most have to have both parents working to pay the rent and bills. If only they had no mortgage. Still it's tough what with all the speculators in the market feeding off basic human needs so back to work for them.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Vraxx on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:13PM (#10361629)
Well if everyone buys property and owns it I think he could find enough demand for property to be able to sell his property and invest it in something else with returns.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Avshalom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:41PM (#10355538)
right 25 grand--no house or car payment because he was in the right jobs at the right time and could afford to buy most families' largest expenses outright (over 50% of income between the two)--and he still managed to spend the entire pre-tax income of about 30% of american households.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by OrwellianChild on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:56PM (#10356598)
I can't tell anymore whether it's okay by you for people to make money, buy property, or otherwise be better off than anyone else...

The man worked, earned money, and bought things with it. Not everyone has these opportunities, true. He got lucky. None of this comes to bear on his present situation. Regardless of whether he has rental income, MMM's managed to whittle his spending down to a level affordable by the median household income in the U.S. On that merit alone, I consider his advice worth listening to (if not taken with a grain of salt to my own personal circumstances).

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by zardo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:37PM (#10355998)
Well he doesn't claim to live frugally, he claims to live an over the top lifestyle of fabulous wealth and luxury.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by megablast on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:14PM (#10357289)
> he gets occasional cash gifts from relatives and a salary from me that consists of 10 cents for every mile walked or biked as part of family life

Hmm, not sure if you are serious, but this ain't great.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by claar on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:51PM (#10354542)
Thanks -- I'm stealing this great idea.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by sliverstorm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:13PM (#10354771)
Although there's something special about the responsibility of having your very own account, very own card, very own PIN...
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by slig on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:27PM (#10354894)
Then you can deposit an "decent interest rate" manually on their account.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by artmageddon on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:43PM (#10354449)
It's probably worth pointing out to him that there are other benefits such as not having to worry about losing the money or having it stolen from you. I agree with your assertion though, it wasn't that long ago that my savings account was netting me $7/day and thus covering all my commuting expenses for the month.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by refurb on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:20PM (#10354825)
But what was your real interest rate when they were paying 3-7% in interest?

Back in the 1970's savings accounts were paying 15%+. However, inflation was double digits as well. You'd be lucky if your real interest rate was more than a few percent.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Spooky23 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:08PM (#10355771)
That's not what I'm talking about. I was yielding 5% interest on an ING Direct account in 2006 -- not exactly a crazy time for inflation.

If you look at historical retail interest rates, 3-5% rates were typical in ordinary times.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by refurb on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:17PM (#10355854)
I don't disagree, real interest rates are weird right now.

Just trying to call out that it's the real interest rate that matters, not the nominal rate.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by branchless on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:35PM (#10354973)
This. Now real interest rates are negative as inflation stats don't reflect reality. So 0.5% when prices are rising well above this.

Almost nobody on hear is speaking of "real" rates. Disturbing.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by hiram112 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:56PM (#10355162)
I agree. Just because the price of eggs and computers aren't going up doesn't mean inflation is flat. The Fed's printing machine has massively (re)inflated almost all major assets including housing, education, and non-disposables.

BTW, this is not the first time I've seen a comment mentioning this fact being downvoted. I would be more than happy to debate this with anyone who disagrees.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by mkempe on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:37PM (#10358012)
The price of eggs has been going up.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by rhizome on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:58PM (#10355178)
Even so, under ZIRP it's really weird how little passbook savings returns these days.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by odonnellryan on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:13PM (#10354769)
I remember earning quite a few dollars with < 1K in a savings account when I was a kid. Was awesome to watch it grow. Now I just keep my cash in a checking account. When Chase or TD sends me a "deposit 10k get $500" I consider it.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by sliverstorm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:14PM (#10354778)
Cash is good, but I get a better interest rate in my checking account.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by deckard1 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:43PM (#10354453)
I don't think that's the case here at all. You're talking about people that are both savvy enough to have a savings account and familiar enough with investments to know that a savings account is bad compared to other investments. On top of also knowing another place to put their money (many people completely fear the stock market and all index products). The average American is just not sophisticated at all here. We're talking about a nation that isn't familiar with balancing a checking book (thanks to debit cards everywhere).

Many people that can invest elsewhere simply don't. Because they do not know about investing. They may be lawyers or doctors. But their money just accumulates.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by 6stringmerc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:05PM (#10354688)
If there was one takeaway I was surpised by from "The Millionaire Next Door" it was, to paraphrase, high income professions like Law and Medicine tend to spend at very high rates, frequently invest poorly, and rarely accumulate a significant amount of wealth as a ratio to their income. The greatest wealth building households were two income, upper-middle class, with good, conservative savings habits. At the time of publication I think it was more valid than today, re: the change in distribution of wealth in the US over time.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Nadya on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:49PM (#10354516)
This is the situation I am in. I'm not savvy enough to make investments that have meaningful or significant returns - so it all goes into a savings account.

I have 1 years' expenses saved and it just slowly accumulates because I don't know how to make a safe return on it. I don't want to invest say, 3 months savings only to lose it...

Definitely the "play to not lose" mentality rather than a "play to win" mentality but I see little reason to change that behavior.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by nemo44x on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354632)
You are actually taking on more risk than if you had some invested in different vehicles. The truth is you're losing more money by not having any of it generating higher potential yields. Likewise, putting all your money in higher yielding vehicles (for instance, call options) is a lot of risk too.

There's a calculus to understanding how much you should have put into different vehicles (including cash in a savings account) to take on the most conservative position.

The way you're playing is you are forfeiting and losing by taking on more risk than you think. It's weird to think about but you need to factor in inflation and cash becomes worth less when it is just sitting there. It isn't volatile but it is mainly deterministic. Some diversity in your arrangements would protect you better.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Nadya on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:43PM (#10355046)
> The truth is you're losing more money by not having any of it generating higher potential yields.

I'm aware of this and can account for this loss. What I dislike is an unknown potential loss that I can't readily account for.

For example - if I invest $50k I need to account for the possibility I might lose the entire $50k, or a portion of it. Being realistic, I'm unlikely to lose it all, but even if I only lose $5,000 that puts me off from making that investment. It's very risk-averse behavior, which many people with a confirmation bias are against. Their $50k investment may have returned $150k and they begin to question why I wouldn't make that investment.

In other words, even if 3/5 people make $150k, as a risk-averse person, I see myself as already being part of the 2/5 people that lose the $5,000.

The only forms of investments I've ever done are playing the markets on MMORPG's. The markets are predictable, safe, and I can readily make a 8-10% ROI each night. If I could make investments like that in a real market I would in a heartbeat! :P

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by snikeris on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:16PM (#10355328)
Check out Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fail-Safe_Investing

It's a relatively low risk way to invest.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by AjithAntony on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:17PM (#10357299)
Investigate the "robo advisors" like betterment and wealthfront. You are exactly their target audience. You can safely ignore the general FUD you will read about their fees. The people writing that it costs too much are far more sophisticated than you and have traded a great deal of their time researching investing to be able to invest "cheaper" on their own. If you are extremely price sensitive, then you should look at wisebanyan which is "free", or use a referral link to join wealthfront to get the first $15k managed "free".
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by antimatter on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:56PM (#10354594)
I'm in this exact same situation. I have very little trust in my knowledge of any other form of investing. Would much rather take the safe route.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ryandrake on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:03PM (#10354664)
It makes sense to hold savings in a savings account or CD if you're worried about risk of loss. The stock market is very volatile and you can lose your shirt if you don't know what you're doing. Ask me how I know this.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by KirinDave on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:12PM (#10355292)
Compare your savings interest rate to the rate of inflation.

You're literally better off with credit card rewards and paying down the debt monthly, in many cases. That's how bad most savings accounts are.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by derekp7 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:16PM (#10354794)
But the balance for those not sophisticated enough to invest on their own is 401k. And many jobs [citation needed] (at least the ones I've been at) automatically start you off at 3% contribution, and they will automatically increase it by 1% every year (up to 6%), coinciding with your raises, if you do not tell them to do otherwise. Plus, they will put it in a target fund based on your estimated retirement age (ex. 2035 fund) that starts off aggressive, then gets more conservative when you get closer to that year. So it is mostly foolproof for the average person (although not the best possible returns for them).
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ghaff on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:26PM (#10354882)
Sounds like those companies have been reading Richard Thaler (behavioral economist who advocates such nudges). That sounds pretty much exactly like the sort of program he advocates for. As far as I know, it's not very common though. I've never seen it at any rate.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by gipp on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:13PM (#10354168)
Well, they offer liquidity. I keep one for emergency living expenses; there's no real advantage over leaving it in checking, I guess, other than as a unit of organization, to explicitly mark it as "emergency funds".
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by steve-howard on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:30PM (#10355437)
I do this too. Funny enough, my checking account earns a higher rate on the first $10k than my "savings" account, but I use a split direct deposit to grow my emergency savings and then try not to look at the savings account to reduce the temptation to use it.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by vvanders on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:14PM (#10354187)
I'd be surprised if it's just savings percentage driving this.

As tech workers we're a bit more privileged in that we have access to salaries and opportunities that a lot of America doesn't have.

Less than 6 years ago I was very much in that 62% category as high cost of living was eating into our combined paycheck pretty heavily.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Shivetya on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:20PM (#10354235)
A lot of people get into the dangerous mentality that since the interest rates are not high that it somehow makes saving not a good idea, similar to many people in our industry who won't max out their 401k simply because the employer does not fully match.

With regards to savings and lack thereof, regardless of salary. Far too many people excuse themselves from budgeting because they believe they are stretched too far to benefit. Yet the primary benefit of a budget is to understand where all your money is going, from major bills to day to day expenses; which can be a simple as that morning coffee or a pack of gum.

Knowing where your money is going is the first step to getting yourself out of debt and a bad situation.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by HLRoku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:36PM (#10354389)
Correct me if I'm wrong but I thought the point was that savings accounts are not worth it, leading many people to say their saving accounts are barren, not that they don't have savings saved up.

Personally I'd fall into that category, I put all my money in checking since the interest is so poor in savings accounts I'd rather see that money go to some retirement fund or investment than see it get so little return in interest and restrict how much money I can take out of the account at any given time.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by maxerickson on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:45PM (#10354466)
A big chunk of people just don't have any money held in reserve:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10354263

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by HLRoku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:53PM (#10354557)
Well, that's depressing.

Almost hard to believe, to be completely honest -- but I might just be around the right group of people?

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by sbuttgereit on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:24PM (#10354272)
Don't forget, our government also encourages spending. Indeed, consider the entire premise of Keynesian Economics where the answer is stimulate demand (spending/consumption) over capital accumulation. Both major political parties buy into this idea.

Cars for Clunkers was about new sales: taking a possibly working asset, albeit an older one, and trading it in (with cash) on newer cars.

Interest rates are part of this and there are even suggestions going around now for negative interest rates. Why? To make savings less attractive and spending moreso.

Completely predictable and what our leaders want.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by draw_down on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:48PM (#10355107)
> There's a conversation to be had about many Americans living in precarious financial situations

There is! And much more interesting imo than whether the stats are borked because the savings are somewhere else than a literal savings account. Even taking this into consideration, I doubt the 62% figure improves very much.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by cheriot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:08PM (#10355774)
I've never wanted to downvote you before. I can relate to your complaint, but it's a distraction from the topic at hand.

If "savings account" excludes retirement and investment accounts then the article means nothing. If not, your assumption that a rate of return motivates the use of savings accounts is off.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by caseysoftware on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:13PM (#10354776)
> the reason why most Americans don't currently view their savings accounts as priorities is because in the current interest rate environment savings accounts and CDs are products with vanishingly little to recommend them.

According to the US Fed[1] and Bureau of Economic Analysis[2], there is a strong correlation that implies. exactly that.

1 - https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/PSAVERT

2 - http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/personal-savin...

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by thibaut_barrere on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:25PM (#10354288)
I'm curious about that - isn't it also culture-driven (spending habits) or maybe linked to education costs?

For instance in France, where "CD" equivalent (DAT) rates are fairly low as well currently, the saving rate (ratio between what is added to savings monthly, and monthly revenue) is 15.1% in 2014 (source: INSEE [1]).

Also, still in France, people will save /even/ if the interest rate is low.

[1] http://www.insee.fr/fr/themes/tableau.asp?reg_id=0&ref_id=na...

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by walshemj on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:19PM (#10356338)
But what are the counting as saving purely cash or does that include securities.

I am sure that in the UK that stocks and share ISA's are counted as savings

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ngokevin on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:30PM (#10354333)
Why not move your savings account to a different bank? If you are in the US, Discover or Ally banks offer nearly 1% APY. $100K would yield $1K per year.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by joeyo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:58PM (#10354608)
Even 1% is still abysmal. Some of that 100k should be in cash, because liquidity is useful, but long-term returns on capital should be much closer to 5%.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ansible on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:44PM (#10355065)
Yes, 1% is bad.

The "official" rate of inflation is low, but I think that it is bogus. Maybe pizza and cars haven't gone up in price much in the last decade, but other big things (such as education and health care) have.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by mywittyname on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:11PM (#10355279)
The official rate of inflation is intended to be a measure an increase in the overall money supply; it's an average.

The increased cost in certain segments is offset by deflation in other segments. While the healthcare market is booming, the energy sector has been decimated. In other words, life sucks if you're a sick oil worker, it's awesome if you're in medicine or production.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ngokevin on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:24PM (#10354864)
Of course, but if you're going to have any sort of savings account, might as well have a higher-yield one.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by bmm6o on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:09PM (#10354742)
Absolutely. At one point I had $10,000 in an ING Direct account. I wasn't getting rich off the interest, but the money was safe and accessible if I needed it, and seeing a few hundred bucks in growth in a year was satisfying. The APY rate went down literally every month, and now that account is closed. That money isn't gone but it's certainly not in a savings account.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by bdcravens on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:46PM (#10354476)
I think of savings as nothing but a safety net. Obviously you get past your immediate savings needs (say 3 months of expenses) and then start putting your money where it gets the best return.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by tomsun on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:09PM (#10355789)
I think a good way is to split your emergency fund with cash and credit. Sock 3 months of cash and get low interest LOC to cover whatever else comes up. That way you don't get opportunity cost of saving all your money into a low interest account.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by joering2 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:57PM (#10354607)
That's incorrect.

Similar numbers you could pull during 4.5% CDs we had just a few years ago (I still have couple of those on 10 years basis that every time I go to Bank of America, rep is trying to lure me to break it and "go have fun spend it", since obviously they don't make any money on 4.5% CD 6 years old CDs anymore).

Living in this country for a while, and comparing to my home Europe, I imagine US versus Europe to be like two party houses next to each other. One called "Europe", where admission is paid and when you get inside and everything you want cost money, up front. Music? Sure but you have to pay. Drinks - fine. pay before you drink. Etc. Eventually when you leave they will say "come back for more" and that's all. The party over there might be boring because invitees can only afford as much as they have in their pockets - not a lot. Versus US is totally different story. They welcome you without admission (just swipe your credit card), and party as much as you want to, virtually free. Music? Anything you want to just swipe your card. Drinks - sure, open a tab and you good to go! Everyone in US house has fun and colorful life goes on. Eventually you might seen US house being more fun, but surely more reckless with 18T in debt (T for Trillion). But also what I noticed is that a lifespan of someone's party in both houses eventually comes down to be their entire life!! So while normally when party house is getting closed down at 2am and everyone is forced to pay and leave, in real live living in USA, you party until you die and perhaps some of your debt is pushed toward your children, but that's all. So eventually you just don't care what will happen at 2am when the light are up. You be gone long before. And that "reckless" approach is what makes Americans don't want to safe. Eventually, there are just not enough incentive to save. Also, in Europe a person cannot bankrupt, only corporations. That makes a bit difference.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by pnathan on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:54PM (#10355144)
Yes, the cautious and financially conservative Americans I know do not regard savings accounts as meaningful. They don't bother with them except as "thing that I stuff cash into that isn't in working cash".
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by X-Istence on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:02PM (#10355212)
My bank offers 0.75% APR. For 10k I would get 6.25$ a month, or 75$ a year. Slightly more than yours, but still completely and utterly worthless in the long run.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by yuhong on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:56PM (#10356163)
I wonder what would happen if savings accounts was ditched completely at least from for-profit banks.