News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:37PM (#10354392)
You're exactly the kind of person this article is pointing out, because your ability to be wiped away by the market is a precarious position to be in.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by runako on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:45PM (#10354465)
I think you're implicitly doing an asset allocation for the poster.

> Cash on hand or it's invested in stocks, bonds and my home.

That could be $100k on hand in checking, $600k in stocks/bonds, and $200k in home equity, with $0 in a savings account. Asset allocations that don't use savings accounts are not necessarily 'precarious'.

Also, it's worth noting that most financial advisors do not recommend that you keep a significant portion of your assets in savings accounts. Primary reason is that by not being in assets that deliver returns, you are losing money to inflation, even at these low levels of inflation. (Also, you have to save a ton more if you don't let your money multiply.)

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:49PM (#10354520)
You are, as far as I know, entirely correct. I still think the survey was designed specifically to find these people who exist in this manner, and I think your criticisms are valid when placed against the thrust of the survey.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by misiti3780 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:59PM (#10354618)
everytime someone says that, I always think of a great quote by Nouriel Roubini:

"asked whether he invests in stocks, he replied, "Not as much these days. I used to have a lot in equities—about 75%—but over the past three years, I’ve had about 95% in cash and 5% in equities. You’re not getting much from savings these days but earning 0% is better than losing 50%."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nouriel_Roubini

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by enoch_r on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:23PM (#10354852)
Since June 2009, when that interview was conducted, the S&P500 has more than doubled, not including dividends, so I hope he switched back or he did, in a sense, "lose" 50%.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by 6stringmerc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:18PM (#10355345)
Counter point:

Numerous financial experts assert the current valuations within the stock market do not reflect the underlying fundamentals; or, in other words, ZIRP allows for cheap debt in the bond markets which many firms are using to aggressively buy back stock, thereby artificially inflating the market value. Thus, "a correction" is due and his statement is still valid from a conservative investing standpoint.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by scoreponok on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:48PM (#10355584)
This is hindsight bias. The markets could have easily went the other way. Market timing is notoriously futile. If you want to play "what if?" and pick arbitrary dates then he could have as easily put his cash position into equities lets say beginning of October 2008? Then his advice would seem very wise indeed.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by enoch_r on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:16PM (#10356318)
I agree, market timing is futile. Roubini is unwise not because he lost money, but because he believed he could time the market. Mountains of evidence suggest that the RoR on stocks is positive and higher than that of lower-risk assets, Roubini claimed that the opposite was temporarily true. This is a good example of an attempt at market timing that failed.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by astrange on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:56PM (#10357226)
Even if he'd done that he would be better off than using a savings account.

http://dqydj.net/sp-500-return-calculator/

Picking arbitrary dates to buy a lot of equities and then not selling them isn't market timing; trying to trade repeatedly on the right dates is. That's how you lose all your money.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by runako on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:12PM (#10355293)
Other commenters weigh in with excellent counters. However, the OP (and I) didn't split between equities and cash.

It would have been very rare for one to have -- while trying to be prudent -- constructed a portfolio of assets across checking accounts, equities, bonds, and primary residence that saw anything like a 50% loss from peak to 2008-crisis trough.

Note that the checking account loss was 0%; bonds did not perform as badly as equities; and in the vast majority of the US, residential RE did not fall 50%. Also note that if one did not choose the absolute generational bottom to liquidate the entire portfolio, the actual losses would have been lesser still. In other words, allocating across a diverse set of assets would have protected from the worst of the downside (while letting you participate in the historic run in equities since).

Irrational fear of volatility is going to have a lot of people retiring much later than they would like, with less money than they would like.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:47PM (#10355090)
Really bad advice. The stock did stupidly well after that.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by rconti on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:01PM (#10355205)
When the market goes down, you can still hold. Or you can sell before the bottom. I was playing in the market in 2008, I got out after the down lost about 2000. Paid off all my debt, got back in at lower prices! Worked great.

I also have $1 in my savings account.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by dragontamer on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:28PM (#10354902)
> "Fame and Fortune: Nouriel Roubini" Times Online, June 21, 2009

Nouriel Roubini lost 260% gains + dividends between 2009 and today. So... I wouldn't really count on this guy's advice at all.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by misiti3780 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:21PM (#10355367)
that is very true, but a lot of people that couldnt afford to lose money lost that and more (percentage wise) in between march - sept. 2008. Your best bet is to put money in vanguard index funds targeted for your ideal retirement year and check it once a year - but for people that are trading single stocks/options/.etc, i think Roubini is right - he is also 55 so he is and should be a lot more conservative than someone that is in their early 20s/30s
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by nommm-nommm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:45PM (#10355075)
>most financial advisors do not recommend that you keep a significant portion of your assets in savings accounts.

This, of course, depends entirely on the individual and their circumstances.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by runako on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:14PM (#10355309)
Obviously, if you're planning on using 85% of your assets in the very near future, that's an exception.

But in general, if your financial advisor suggests going 95% cash for the long haul, you should probably get someone else.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by nommm-nommm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:54PM (#10355637)
I have less than "recommended" (depending on who you ask) in an emergency fund (but I do still have one). Why? I have a spouse with a large income and it is doubtful crisis will hit us both at once. I also can reduce my spending without a problem in the short term - most of my spending isn't fixed expenses it is experiences that can be curtailed very easily. Someone with a large mortgage may want to keep more in their emergency account - that's all I'm saying. Age has a lot to do with it also - if you are young you can ride out large dips in the market.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:45PM (#10354464)
What? Let's assume he's intelligent and has good diversification (eg. he mentioned bonds, stocks, home, and cash -- probably in a investment account). If all his financial positions got "wiped out" in a broad-sweeping financial collapse, then "cash in savings" would be equally worthless.

In the meantime, he has a home to live in. Plus, most investment accounts give you easy access for withdrawals (eg. debit cards) or the ability to borrow while transfers or sales settle. I fail to see how it's precarious.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:48PM (#10354498)
You're the second person to say this, but how would "cash in savings" be equally worthless? Maybe I'm not understanding, but it's pretty difficult to actually lose money in a savings account, that's the whole point.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by beambot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354633)
He mentioned having some of the funds as "cash on hand." Let's assume it's some sort of investment (eg. sweep) account, like at Charles Schwab [1]. The funds are FDIC-insured, just like a savings account; they are also just as accessible as a savings account. But they are actually an investment account, from which you can trade stocks, bonds, etc.

Of the (mostly affluent) people I know... none of them possess a traditional savings account. Most use a checking accounts for direct deposit and a brokerage account. There's no reason to have a traditional savings account.

[1] http://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/investing/accounts_produ...

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:53PM (#10355142)
Because in diversified portfolio, to loose it all the following must happen. All listed companies must have completely collapsed. Goverment must have basically collpased to loose all value on the bonds.

If that happens its probably the financial amagedden anyway.

If the stock market falls by 50% i still have 70% of my portfolio. I'm OK with that.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by msandford on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:39PM (#10355519)
Right but these days there's a lot of correlation between assets and all the big moves happen in response to monetary policy. In an environment where everything doesn't hinge on extremely low interest rates I'm in total agreement, but you're really exposed to policy risk in the market right now.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:50PM (#10355603)
I agree that many assets are now correlated stocks and bonds for example.

But for a bond to go to absoulte 0, would take a lot.

Also I'm not sure that small increases in the interest rates would that much of a disaster. We've been in situations with low interest rates before, and increments in the interest rate didn't harm stocks in the long term.

In many ways it's a positive indicator, that goverments see a positive future.

When the fed announced that the interest rates were on hold. Stocks went down.

There is a lot of lose money in the system though from low interest rates.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by fancyketchup on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:26PM (#10354887)
Because the set of events that could "wipe away" your (reasonably-intelligently diversified) assets has a large intersection with the set of events that could "wipe away" your saving account in a bank. Things like nuclear war, global pandemic, etc.

Yes, the FDIC does insure savings accounts, but that's only useful so long as the FDIC exists.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:37PM (#10354983)
I don't agree! I think much worse things would have to happen to dissolve the FDIC than would have to happen to lose a significant portion of your investments in the bond/stock/real estate markets.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by scott_karana on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:55PM (#10354591)
> in a broad-sweeping financial collapse, then "cash in savings" would be equally worthless.

> how would "cash in savings" be equally worthless? Maybe I'm not understanding, but it's pretty difficult to actually lose money in a savings account, that's the whole point.

The cash wouldn't be lost, but it would have reduced purchasing power in a recession. And if inflation is steep, you're actively "losing" money.

It would be "worthless" in the context of long-term investing, because nothing would have long-term worth.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by antientropic on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:25PM (#10354879)
Why would the cash have reduced purchasing power in a recession? Sure, that would be the case if there was high inflation, but that certainly wasn't the case with the 2008 crisis.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by mywittyname on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355219)
You have that backwards, during a recession Cash is King. $10,000 in summer 2009 bought you a hell of a lot more of practically anything than the same amount a year previously.

People with cash on hand in 2009 made out like bandits. Cheap stocks, cheap houses, cheap cars. Everything was cheap, cheap, cheap.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:54PM (#10355147)
> You're exactly the kind of person this article is pointing out, because your ability to be wiped away by the market is a precarious position to be in.

Any scenario where the stock market declines by 99% ($100k to $1k) would basically mean the collapse of the entire financial system. I doubt your bank savings account would be very useful in that scenario.

Moreover, I don't think this article is actually talking about people who do save but just choose to save into high-return assets. I save 80-90% of my income, but it all goes into index funds. Does that mean I am not "a saver?"

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355226)
> Moreover, I don't think this article is actually talking about people who do save but just choose to save into high-return assets. I save 80-90% of my income, but it all goes into index funds. Does that mean I am not "a saver?"

Not at all. This article is about people who aren't saving because they don't think its necessary or because they can't afford to.

An emergency fund IS NOT an investment. It is insurance; treat it as such.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:21PM (#10355888)
> An emergency fund IS NOT an investment.

Why should one have an "emergency fund?" I would genuinely love to hear a good argument for why keeping any cash assets when one has significant liquid investments, as I've never encountered one.

Insurance companies invest their premiums. Why shouldn't I?

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:30PM (#10356822)
Insurance companies and banks are required to maintain a minimum amount of safe/liquid (read: cash) reserves.

> I would genuinely love to hear a good argument for why keeping any cash assets when one has significant liquid investments,

Can you describe an asset (besides US treasuries) that you can be assured of its value in a volatile market? Even money market funds have broken the buck before (~2008).

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:56PM (#10357454)
> Can you describe an asset (besides US treasuries) that you can be assured of its value in a volatile market?

My point is emphatically not that your stocks will maintain their full value. But even at their lowest, their value will be more than enough to cover any emergency fund. A 50% drop on $100k will still leave you with $50k.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:24PM (#10357557)
Which would ruin your investment outcome for years (if not decades, depending on the value of your portfolio at the event in question). If stocks take a loss that bad, you need the ability to not sell off to get liquid cash. That is what an emergency fund is for.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:07PM (#10357933)
Ah, but now that your argument is based on decreasing returns we can just do expected value analysis.

Fortunately, many people have already done this, including Betterment: https://www.betterment.com/resources/personal-finance/safety...

Weighted by the probability of happening, you are better off investing all your money. Period.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by kamaal on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:22PM (#10356369)
>>Any scenario where the stock market declines by 99% ($100k to $1k) would basically mean the collapse of the entire financial system.

Yet if you owned real estate[Land, Houses], they stand exactly as they are. While the numbers in the bank database turn to 0 after the collapse and companies go bankrupt and never recover. If you owned real estate, your money will recover in the very next turn.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:04PM (#10356652)
Agreed, but that's kind of off topic.

Real estate is yet another asset class which should be included in a diversified investment strategy, but my point was that there's no evidence that money should be kept in a bank savings account.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by ChuckMcM on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:56PM (#10354596)
I think you're confusing loss of value with loss of savings. So if your stocks lose half their value, then you now have "less cash equivalent savings" but you still have savings. Even in the dot com crash (where I was not diversified and had a lot of tech stocks) the reduction in value across the board was, in aggregate, about 70% even though some stocks it was 99.9%. But all of that was "ok" because I didn't need that money to live on, it was "savings".

Similarly with house values, if you own your home outright it doesn't matter if the real estate market crashes, you can still live there. But it might make moving less desirable (or not if you can find a good deal somewhere else).

The article is talking about people who find themselves unable to pay for repairing a vehicle after an accident without going into credit card debt. That can start a spiral into insolvency.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by HLRoku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:41PM (#10354433)
I don't really follow how having money in stocks, bonds and a house is somehow capable of being wiped away by the market when a savings account in a bank wouldn't be in dire straits with such an economic upheaval to render those 3 investments useless
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:47PM (#10354488)
I'm sorry you don't follow, but it should be fairly obvious that stocks can crash, bond markets can collapse, and home prices can plummet, whereas money in FDIC insured savings accounts would only be lost in the event of a catastrophic, country-jeopardizing event, in which case we'll all have bigger problems.

I'm not meaning to attack anyone personally, I just think this survey is trying to suss out what percentage of Americans are in a position such that an economic downturn would hurt them severely.

I also don't know much at all about finances, so take what I'm saying with a jar of salt.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:59PM (#10355185)
Not even the worst stock crash in history was a 99% drop.

Also, you are almost 100% wrong about the intention of the article. It's not that they're trying to make some point about people's poor asset allocation, it's just sloppy reporting.

If their actual point was that people had too much money invested, wouldn't the most obvious and actionable advice for the "What to Do If Your Savings Fall Short" section be to sell some shares and transfer the cash into a savings account?

It's on you to prove why your financially unwise viewpoint is correct.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Laaw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:54PM (#10356951)
The attitude you're bringing to this conversation makes me entirely unwilling to continue. Sorry.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by morgante on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:57PM (#10357462)
I think you're the one who might need an attitude adjustment. Instead of providing reasoning for why cash is necessary, you continue to belittle people who invest their assets.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Retric on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:04PM (#10354670)
I really don't see a significant advantage to using a savings account with a bank. Keeping 50k in a checking account vs savings account costs you less than 5$ a month before taxes which is just not worth the effort of opening a second account for someone that's keeping 50k cash on hand.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by zardo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:58PM (#10354616)
A market crash severe enough to whipe out stocks, bonds, and real estate, is also going to effect fiat currency. In order for the FDIC to actually cover the saving accounts for the defaulted banks, we would have to create many many new dollars.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by Symmetry on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:55PM (#10354589)
If the stock market falls by even just 80%, which is probably the minimum I'd call "wiped out" then things are bad enough that your savings account can't be trusted either.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by jzig on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:04PM (#10354668)
I strongly disagree with you and believe FDIC insured accounts can be trusted beyond a market fall of just 80%.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:03PM (#10355218)
Market fall of 80% in a portfolio that has been diversified isn't that bad. Say you 50% in shares. It has lost 80% of that 50%. That's not so bad. You still have a chunk of savings.

If goverment bonds loose all their value, it means goverments are close to failing.

If real estate is loosing all its value. It means people have no money to buy houses

If all 3 is going on the same time, some serious stuff is going and I'm not sure your goverment backed account is really that secure.

Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by riskneural on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:09PM (#10355271)
100k in stocks after a shock crazy crash of 70% can still be painfully liquidated for 30k.
Re:62% of Americans Have Under $1,000 in Savings, Survey Finds by goodcjw2 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:57PM (#10355169)
Given the interest rate so low, saving is definitely a "smart" answer. Keep cash and keep invest seems to be a "wise" choice in our current market. So, it might be the market (or policy maker) to blame...