It's about Uber avoiding regulations (that the taxi coops already implement): insurance for passengers, insurance for commercial car use, car checkups every year instead of every second (like for private cars), yearly health check for the driver.
That's essentially it, and as soon as Uber follows the rules, they can operate freely. They can organize it themselves (with employed drivers) or require their freelance drivers to do so.
If their business model doesn't allow for that, their business model is flawed, and the German society has no obligation to bear Uber's costs just so they can feel "disruptive".
[edit: it's somewhat more involved given that the court refers to PBefG, which as a whole needs some creative interpretation to allow for Uber to work, eg. running things as "car rental with driver" (which requires that customers don't state where they want to drive to beforehand). Still, Uber tries to work around any and all regulations, and it's no surprise that this won't be tolerated, and for good reason.]
In my experience as a German waiting for a taxi after midnight in a suburban area (but with a major road going through), this is a merely theoretical construct. I've called 3 taxi providers in the rough area; the result was a brisk 1.5 hour walk home because they did not seem all to interested in dispatching a driver to that location at that time. I might have a theoretical legal handle on this behavior, but I doubt this has ever been successfully challenged in court (since the providers can always weasel out by claiming the did not have and free drivers at this moment).
The other rules are plausible, but what on earth is this about?
A yearly health check will look for signs of those illnesses.
Examples might be poorly controlled diabetes; epilepsy; sleep apnea; etc.
Here, it is not sufficient for a driver just to believe he is capable of doing the job, the state requires that he proves his capability and therefore guarantees every passenger that he is capable.
The legislation is perhaps not about stifling competition or anything. But it has the end result of reducing competition by raising the barriers to entry.
Not only that, but it actively prevents competition (e.g. low-end providers) by making a whole segment of the market illegal. It's just the nature of regulation being universal to the country as a whole. i.e. it doesn't allow people to make their own judgements about what safety level they want based on their willingness to pay/not pay for it. In essence boiling down to "you get the extra safety, even if you can't actually use the service because the extra safety bumped up the cost"
Just like erecting skyscrapers that cannot withstand a summer breeze or storing nuclear waste on a city landfill.
If Americans want to do it differently, be my guest. Yes, you're more focused on individual freedom than the rest of the world. Fine with me.
But maybe you could try to understand that Germans are very safety-oriented. And maybe you could just accept that instead of telling us that we're not doing things like America and therefore we're wrong.
Not all Germans, seeing as people are actually using Uber in Germany. That's the point I was trying to make. Tyranny of the majority, I suppose, unfortunate, but apparently "the best we got".
Side note: I'm not actually American. Please don't stereotype and make assumptions based on opinion/nationality, even if it is a good one such as "focused on individual freedom" and "Germans are very safety-oriented", etc.
People are very bad at judging what's in their best interest, especially since often their personal interest at the time when doing the transaction conflicts with they long-term best interest or the societies interest. And so, to some level, some things (like taxi companies) are regulated in germany. This is obviously an imperfect system, but I remain unconvinced that free market rules all is a better system.
There are certainly individuals who prefer Uber and who's interests align very well with Uber, but I'm uncertain that's a majority. That's certainly annoying to those individuals, but that's life in a society, we all have to give at some point. Germany. This is obviously an imperfect
Some regulation is good, depending on the field. Public transportation is in my opinion one of those fields (and engineering another).
Uber could fairly easily comply with these laws but it would cut into their profits and that is the reason why they have chosen to ignore the law and to cut their drivers loose the moment something happens (such as when a driver is involved in an accident).
1) Saying that some businesses ought to disappear due to the invisible hand of the market, is just like saying that things ought to stay down due to the invisible hand of gravity. The market is a powerful force, but that doesn't mean its outcome is always what we want.
2) It's a feature of the free market that firms go out of business all the time. But from a market point of view, people are like small firms that sell labor. We don't want a system where people can "go out of business" and be unable to survive, because that's inhumane.
It looks like (1) proves that we need some restrictions on competition, and (2) proves that we need some redistribution. We may quibble about how much, but taking a Strong Principled Stance against these things seems wrong.
You're conflating issues here. Something (or someone) that's not adding any value to an economy has no place (and no reason to participate) in it.
That being said, letting people starve is obviously inhumane. However, the answer to this isn't opening up bullshit positions in the economy, by introducing artificial inefficiencies, in order to accomodate those otherwise "useless" people. Regulations (ideally) are there to keep the markets efficient (in the long term) by maintaining "fairness". Not to ensure that individual humans don't starve.
Keeping people, that are unable to support themselves, alive and well is a welfare issue, and is not otherwise adressed by markets (directly).
That said, I have sympathy for the idea that markets and welfare can work well together. I've long suspected that "the welfare state is a libertarian's wet dream", e.g. a system of universal basic income would allow more people to become entrepreneurs because the risk would be lower. Not sure how Ayn Rand missed that point.
The cynic in me thinks this is less about consumer protection and more about well-funded taxi lobbies which benefit from the regulatory capture.
That's pretty much the crux here: should consumers have the ability to 'opt-out' from these protections or not?
My beef with that is that taxi's are seen as public transport and people expect a certain level of service rather than a free-for-all where one driver will be courteous and professional, the car clean and serviceable, the next will rip you off and be a jerk.
Uber takes care of this in part by using a feedback mechanism, but - Unfortunately for Uber - in Germany these things are a bit more organized than elsewhere and the German taxi system - in those cities where I have used it - is actually quite reasonably priced and the drivers are typically professional and the cars are clean and well maintained.
So from that point of view they don't add value, they just undercut the existing drivers by sidestepping the regulations. And that is unfair competition.
The solution is simple: Uber should certify their cars and drivers for the German market under the same rules as the rest of the drivers and taxi companies, then undercut them on price and overdeliver on service.
That really would be the free market in action.
The regulations sound good and all, but I can tell you from personal experience that Uber takes feedback very seriously whereas dispatcher companies and regulators couldn't care less about it and pretty much nothing's ever going to happen to a taxi driver that was rude to you or took a circuitous route.
What regulatory cost?
Professional liability insurance (which is mandatory for the transportation of people) and higher frequency car certification are not 'regulatory costs' they are costs that industry and government have arrived at as a reasonable compromise between the pull of the market and the ability of taxi service providers to make money whilst providing a safe and professional service to the customers.
Regulatory costs would be 'buy a permit at $1M' or something like that. I don't see that in this judgement, it is just about Uber totally ignoring the law.
> If the feedback mechanism functions as well or better than special licenses/health checks/knowledge tests/what have you, why not pass those cost savings of that innovation on to consumers?
I'm all for that. If after Uber complies with the law their margins are such that they can operate more efficiently they will own the market.
> The regulations sound good and all, but I can tell you from personal experience that Uber takes feedback very seriously whereas dispatcher companies and regulators couldn't care less about it and pretty much nothing's ever going to happen to a taxi driver that was rude to you or took a circuitous route.
I've never had a German taxi driver that was rude to me or that took a circuitous route. (I wished I could say the same for my hometown, Toronto, Bucharest, Rome or New York, the other places where I regularly used taxis).
In a lot of jurisdictions complying with some of the consumer protection laws is more expensive to the consumer than a feedback system alone while offering little to no additional benefit. Things like medallion laws, knowledge tests, etc. These laws will never get changed unless Uber breaks them and demonstrates that they are, in fact, unnecessary.
I'm not familiar with the German regulations and the article is light on details but if it's as simple as liability insurance and an extra car-checkup I doubt Uber would be opposing this so vehemently. They already provide commercial liability insurance to US drivers, for example.
Ah, ok, never mind me then.
It's hard to argue from assumption, but this is not the only article about this subject, there are many more and this case has been working its way upward for a while in this court and others.
Essentially the German authorities position is that Uber is operating an unlicensed taxi company. Uber is welcome to become licensed but refuses to do so, which allows it to compete with the existing taxi companies but without the associated costs.
The existing taxi companies feel that this is unfair and have brought suit, which the courts have now decided has enough merit to warrant an injunction.
That's not true. Elements of direct democracy are for example available at the local level. Here in Hamburg the politics is supporting it. For example the mayor of Hamburg is openly supporting it:
http://www.abendblatt.de/politik/deutschland/article12940132...
http://www.abendblatt.de/politik/deutschland/article12939565...
If people here in Hamburg/Germany would be unhappy with it, then they could vote over such a topic, if there is enough interest.
We already have elements of direct democracy.
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksentscheid
For example we voted here to buy back the energy utilities, sold a few years ago.
Just recently a non-binding public voting was a done about a new possible tourist attraction.
Here you can see the list of `Volksabstimmungen` we had here in Hamburg in the last years:
http://www.hamburg.de/contentblob/104078/data/volksabstimmun...
I'm not certain if it would be a valid course to create a law that forces the parliament (or rather the states representatives in the Bundesrat) to propose a law. That might create a legal problem: What if the proposed law gets changed or rejected in the Bundesrat etc. You're free to try, but I doubt that course of action will work.
I don't understand the difference.
The difference against Uber is that they are not trying to solve some injustice or political problem. They are trying to get advantage over competition by ignoring the rules competition follows. It is just trying to get an advantage for themselves.
There's no incentive for the government to side with the consumers on this issue since politicians profit through taxi medallions, political contributions from taxi companies, etc and it's not a big enough issue for anyone to change their votes.
Certainly, the cab owners are somewhat organized and have some influence, but the degree is much lower than that. Uber alone has more lobbying power.
It's rare that one can't flag down a taxi on a busy street within a couple of minutes in Berlin, and they are almost without exception clean modern cars with courteous drivers. The MyTaxi app has already brought regular Berlin taxis up to par with Uber for the smartphone-inclined. https://de.mytaxi.com/
In US cities, the taxi companies are collecting monopoly profits and providing bad service. Their scam is protected from competition by strict nonsense regulations by local governments. The local governments support the taxi companies for bad reasons like corruption and ignorance. Uber is better because it is subject to competition and is not a monopoly.
In a city with functioning taxi competition, Uber's only advantage is its software, its brand, and its network. Local companies could easily compete very effectively against that.
Your point being?
By that logic, we should happily accept monopolies, cartels and huge conglomerates.
The notion that the free market is beneficial to society as a whole was a cute idea, but the slave workers of Foxconn are probably not quite in agreement.
http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/30/opinion/chang-chinese-factory-...
For a free market to work, there must be common respect for individual autonomy. People must enter into contracts of their own free will.
That's why that utopia cannot work. Because individuals will always use the shortest and quickest way to get what they want at the expense of others. Anarchism and Communism have/had the same problem as for their simplistic understanding of human nature which can only lead to wrong the conclusions,and the wrong ideas,even though the thought that led to these conclusion might be genuine.
If a precondition states that ,in order for a system to work, people should "naturaly" respect this or that rule, well your system is broken at first place.
Mankind is about order and chaos,and balance between them.People cant regulate themself.Sometimes they accept order because it suits their interests and see the benefits,but during most of human history chaos "ruled".And there is no guarantee most of the order that led the "western civilization" will last.
> People must enter into contracts of their own free will.
Define free will. If someone cant understand all the consequences of his actions before taking a decision, that's not free will. And noone can get the entire picture, or that person would be god himself.
And who will enforce contractual obligations ?
These 2 preconditions in order for your system to work are metaphysical at best,I would consider them a lie,because they cannot be fufilled.
That requires a degree of abundance (so people can refuse to enter contracts) that makes competition obsolete. As is, people are required to enter into contracts else they perish.
Anyway here, it's not about competition (that's what they want you to believe it is), it's about regulations (e.g. ensure some safety rules).
Can it? Are there any good examples of a market with a significant size (with enough profits to support multiple suppliers) devolving into a monopoly without any "help" from outside the market?
AT&T, has one should know, was a legal monopoly; hardly a free market participant.
But this is exactly what is happening here: Uber tries to get the legal privilege of being exempt from German regulations.
> What I asked is if there are examples of free markets turning into monopolies.
Cartelisation, anyone?
I don't see how; how are they preventing others from doing the same?
I'm not saying what they're doing is okay, but there's no privilege, anyone else (including incumbents) can decide to ignore the law and provide taxi services without the proper licenses.
Cartelization
Well, the you can surely provide an example of a cartel which has achieved monopoly without any help from States, just as the result of market failure.
There's a saying in Germany - Wo kein Kläger, da kein Richter (sort of a legal principle: Non ultra petita). Uber only could get away with breaking the law because no one complained. Someone now did. Case closed.
Well, the you can surely provide an example of a cartel which has achieved monopoly without any help from States, just as the result of market failure.
You really need references for that? It should be obvious. There are markets that lend themselves to big business. As soon as a few big players have cornered the market, it is in their best interest to play nice with each other so that 'everybody' wins (at the cost of their customers, of course). This creates a de-facto monopoly that might or might not be viable long-term (backstabbing probably will happen someday).
Historically, there's been a lot of that going on. The most recent case I remember were some German sugar manufacturers, but I could probably come up with hundreds of cases; it would be a waste of my time, though.
I'm not seeing how is this relevant.
You really need references for that? It should be obvious. There are markets (...)
Yes, yes, I know the theory. It's just that in practice, it doesn't seem to actually have facts behind it. At least when people give examples (e.g. Comcast) there's almost invariably an extra-market process pushing things.
The most recent case I remember were some German sugar manufacturers, but I could probably come up with hundreds of cases; it would be a waste of my time, though.
Yes, it probably would. Convincing me is not a very good use of anyone's time :)
You were arguing that anyone else can decide to ignore the law and provide taxi services without the proper licenses. This obviously only works if you avoid getting caught, but Uber did not exactly fly under the radar. What they had going for themselves was an unusual entrance to the market, but that only kept them safe until their competitors complained to the authorities.
Convincing me is not a very good use of anyone's time
I did not say that. But it's not hard to do this 'research' by looking at Wikipedia or Google. Some examples I dug up in the last 30 seconds:
Tchibo/Melitta/Dallmayr (coffee), Südzucker/Nordzucker/Pfeifer & Langen (sugar, the one I was talking about), Unilever/Procter & Gamble (washing powder), De Beers (diamonds), possibly your friendly neighbourhood drug dealer (hey, I can watch TV with the best of them ;)).
As long as you don't get caught, it's good business sense - at least for a time. And that's why it will happen, time and again - no extra-market processes necessary.
De Beers is also a good example - how can it be a free market participant when its biggest mines are joint ventures with the States of Namibia and Botswana?
I haven't looked at the other examples yet, but I find these frankly unconvincing.
Reality checking in.
Maybe this is the only way in which such a regulation effort can be challenged but I'm not convinced of that.
As for the 'careful now' and so on bits, anybody quoting Ayn Rand verbatim without adding much to the conversation is probably going to get downvoted, it's not as if she's an authority in the field of economics, and most of her writing displays a shockingly bad understanding of the field.
In all these cases Uber drivers are using rules and regulations (and statistics) applicable to personal transportation and applying those towards a business.
That private individuals can lie on their application forms and skip certain tests that are required is not a businessmodel.
This is not how I feel about it in Germany. Whenever I needed a cab, I got one, for a fair, reasonable price. Might be a little longer if I'm out in the fields or when a thunderstorm hit Berlin and there's no public transport, but sooner or later, I was picked up. Taxis are treated as part of the public transport system here, they have obligations (must transport everyone for the same price, must provide basic service at any time, regulated rates, ...) and in return receive benefits - effectively a monopoly on the taxi market.
Now, if we decide to repeal the benefits and allow UberPop, how are we going to make sure we fulfill the obligations? No, surge pricing is not a solution. There's probably a solution, but I'm very much not convinced that Uber is the solution, so until someone presents a genuinely better system, I'll stick with what we have. It's not perfect, but good enough.
Generally speaking I haven't had any problem finding a cab in Berlin. The longest wait was after a thunderstorm took out most of the public transport a couple of years ago and that took like 20 minutes somewhere in the outskirts. I usually either flag one down on the road or use the smartphone app.
After all,there is a demand for that,there should be an app for that /s .
> Careful now. It's daytime in Europe, so the more Laisser faire (US-free-market-style) arguments have a higher change of getting down voted.
And please,stop hating on Europeans, your bigotry is showing.
"There is no way to legislate competition; there are no standards by which one could define who should compete with whom, how many competitors should exist in any given field, what should be their relative strength or their so-called “relevant markets,” what prices they should charge, what methods of competition are “fair” or “unfair.” None of these can be answered, because these precisely are the questions that can be answered only by the mechanism of a free market."