News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by duncan_bayne on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @02:26AM (#8256075)
To quote Rand:

"There is no way to legislate competition; there are no standards by which one could define who should compete with whom, how many competitors should exist in any given field, what should be their relative strength or their so-called “relevant markets,” what prices they should charge, what methods of competition are “fair” or “unfair.” None of these can be answered, because these precisely are the questions that can be answered only by the mechanism of a free market."

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by pgeorgi on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:53AM (#8256248)
It's not about legislating competition.

It's about Uber avoiding regulations (that the taxi coops already implement): insurance for passengers, insurance for commercial car use, car checkups every year instead of every second (like for private cars), yearly health check for the driver.

That's essentially it, and as soon as Uber follows the rules, they can operate freely. They can organize it themselves (with employed drivers) or require their freelance drivers to do so.

If their business model doesn't allow for that, their business model is flawed, and the German society has no obligation to bear Uber's costs just so they can feel "disruptive".

[edit: it's somewhat more involved given that the court refers to PBefG, which as a whole needs some creative interpretation to allow for Uber to work, eg. running things as "car rental with driver" (which requires that customers don't state where they want to drive to beforehand). Still, Uber tries to work around any and all regulations, and it's no surprise that this won't be tolerated, and for good reason.]

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by yoodenvranx on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:58AM (#8256263)
There is also the thing that cabs in Germany always _have_ to provide service, regardless of vacation, weather and so on. A private might decide to operate only at those times of the day with a lot of potential customers but that is not possible for official cab companies. The same goes for heavy rain and snow and so on.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by _pmf_ on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:05AM (#8256288)
> There is also the thing that cabs in Germany always _have_ to provide service, regardless of vacation, weather and so on. A private might decide to operate only at those times of the day with a lot of potential customers but that is not possible for official cab companies.

In my experience as a German waiting for a taxi after midnight in a suburban area (but with a major road going through), this is a merely theoretical construct. I've called 3 taxi providers in the rough area; the result was a brisk 1.5 hour walk home because they did not seem all to interested in dispatching a driver to that location at that time. I might have a theoretical legal handle on this behavior, but I doubt this has ever been successfully challenged in court (since the providers can always weasel out by claiming the did not have and free drivers at this moment).

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:17AM (#8256320)
You don't have to challenge this in court. There's a regulation authority that you can report the case to. That's unlikely to help in an individual case, but if there's multiple cases it will trigger a reaction.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by wooter on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @12:54PM (#8258718)
whereas a negative review for a driver has an immediate, measurable effect. when can we throw out this old BS 'regulation authority' mentality
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:39PM (#8259646)
Who are you going to write the negative review to if no driver decides to pick you up? All of them that didn't show up? On what grounds? No Uber driver is required to provide service to any area at any time, whereas at least under the current german regulation someone is, namely the owners of the taxi license(s) for that area.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by wooter on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:53PM (#8260635)
you have clearly never used Uber.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by pjc50 on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:18AM (#8256525)
yearly health check for the driver

The other rules are plausible, but what on earth is this about?

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by DanBC on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:56AM (#8256680)
There are plenty of illnesses that require a driver to temporarily hand in their driving licence.

A yearly health check will look for signs of those illnesses.

Examples might be poorly controlled diabetes; epilepsy; sleep apnea; etc.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by DominikR on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:43AM (#8256637)
Would you want to get into a cab where the driver had his last health checkup 30 years ago? (especially eyesight)

Here, it is not sufficient for a driver just to believe he is capable of doing the job, the state requires that he proves his capability and therefore guarantees every passenger that he is capable.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by agos on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @09:08AM (#8257271)
Other than the possibilities others have already stated, a health check for drivers can include a drug test.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by zo1 on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:08AM (#8256482)
"That's essentially it, and as soon as Uber follows the rules, they can operate freely."

The legislation is perhaps not about stifling competition or anything. But it has the end result of reducing competition by raising the barriers to entry.

Not only that, but it actively prevents competition (e.g. low-end providers) by making a whole segment of the market illegal. It's just the nature of regulation being universal to the country as a whole. i.e. it doesn't allow people to make their own judgements about what safety level they want based on their willingness to pay/not pay for it. In essence boiling down to "you get the extra safety, even if you can't actually use the service because the extra safety bumped up the cost"

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Tomte on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:19AM (#8256534)
You've understood it! We Germans want this "market" to be illegal.

Just like erecting skyscrapers that cannot withstand a summer breeze or storing nuclear waste on a city landfill.

If Americans want to do it differently, be my guest. Yes, you're more focused on individual freedom than the rest of the world. Fine with me.

But maybe you could try to understand that Germans are very safety-oriented. And maybe you could just accept that instead of telling us that we're not doing things like America and therefore we're wrong.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by zo1 on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:41AM (#8256628)
"You've understood it! We Germans want this "market" to be illegal."

Not all Germans, seeing as people are actually using Uber in Germany. That's the point I was trying to make. Tyranny of the majority, I suppose, unfortunate, but apparently "the best we got".

Side note: I'm not actually American. Please don't stereotype and make assumptions based on opinion/nationality, even if it is a good one such as "focused on individual freedom" and "Germans are very safety-oriented", etc.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:11AM (#8256744)
Some germans also buy beef lasagna that's actually horse interlaced with yucky medications, because it's cheap. A lot of germans buy computers at media markt and at the same time complain that the nice guy fixing computers around the corner has to close. He was always so friendly and gave so much recommendations about which parts to buy, where to I go now to get proper advice. We buy bread at the supermarket and complain that it's not the same as back then, when we'd still eat hand-made bread where every loaf was different (I could always tell when the baker was out for a long party by the shape of the rolls).

People are very bad at judging what's in their best interest, especially since often their personal interest at the time when doing the transaction conflicts with they long-term best interest or the societies interest. And so, to some level, some things (like taxi companies) are regulated in germany. This is obviously an imperfect system, but I remain unconvinced that free market rules all is a better system.

There are certainly individuals who prefer Uber and who's interests align very well with Uber, but I'm uncertain that's a majority. That's certainly annoying to those individuals, but that's life in a society, we all have to give at some point. Germany. This is obviously an imperfect

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:19AM (#8256532)
Try calling yourself an engineer in Germany and see how well that goes. That's also a 'barrier to entry', you have to study and prove that you're capable by passing a bunch of exams. How unfair!

Some regulation is good, depending on the field. Public transportation is in my opinion one of those fields (and engineering another).

Uber could fairly easily comply with these laws but it would cut into their profits and that is the reason why they have chosen to ignore the law and to cut their drivers loose the moment something happens (such as when a driver is involved in an accident).

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by cousin_it on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:00AM (#8256271)
In the past few months I've been trying to find strong arguments against free-market beliefs. Here's what I have so far:

1) Saying that some businesses ought to disappear due to the invisible hand of the market, is just like saying that things ought to stay down due to the invisible hand of gravity. The market is a powerful force, but that doesn't mean its outcome is always what we want.

2) It's a feature of the free market that firms go out of business all the time. But from a market point of view, people are like small firms that sell labor. We don't want a system where people can "go out of business" and be unable to survive, because that's inhumane.

It looks like (1) proves that we need some restrictions on competition, and (2) proves that we need some redistribution. We may quibble about how much, but taking a Strong Principled Stance against these things seems wrong.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Padding on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:27AM (#8256349)
> But from a market point of view, people are like small firms that sell labor. We don't want a system where people can "go out of business" and be unable to survive, because that's inhumane.

You're conflating issues here. Something (or someone) that's not adding any value to an economy has no place (and no reason to participate) in it.

That being said, letting people starve is obviously inhumane. However, the answer to this isn't opening up bullshit positions in the economy, by introducing artificial inefficiencies, in order to accomodate those otherwise "useless" people. Regulations (ideally) are there to keep the markets efficient (in the long term) by maintaining "fairness". Not to ensure that individual humans don't starve.

Keeping people, that are unable to support themselves, alive and well is a welfare issue, and is not otherwise adressed by markets (directly).

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by cousin_it on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:03AM (#8256708)
Hmm. I guess many free market proponents also conflate these issues, when they claim that free markets and wealth redistribution are opposed to each other.

That said, I have sympathy for the idea that markets and welfare can work well together. I've long suspected that "the welfare state is a libertarian's wet dream", e.g. a system of universal basic income would allow more people to become entrepreneurs because the risk would be lower. Not sure how Ayn Rand missed that point.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by holri on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:28AM (#8256192)
The court says they are violating laws. What has this to do with a free market? Is a free market one without laws? Is anarchy free market?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:12AM (#8256309)
Other than maintaining liability insurance like any other driver, I don't see the need for any of these added protections. IMO consumers do not want to pay the cost of these protections and they should be able to make their own well-informed choices instead of being forced to buy them by the state.

The cynic in me thinks this is less about consumer protection and more about well-funded taxi lobbies which benefit from the regulatory capture.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by claudius on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:19AM (#8256327)
Consumers by and large want to pay for these protections (at least they want everyone else to pay for them), which is why they elected MPs to implement them. If the general public perceived it unnecessary to pay for them, they could elect appropriate politicians to remove the added protections, but it is not up to a single company to decide “nah, not worth it” and break existing laws.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:33AM (#8256370)
So, the free market proponents argue that in that case the consumers should be able to choose freely between the two options.

That's pretty much the crux here: should consumers have the ability to 'opt-out' from these protections or not?

My beef with that is that taxi's are seen as public transport and people expect a certain level of service rather than a free-for-all where one driver will be courteous and professional, the car clean and serviceable, the next will rip you off and be a jerk.

Uber takes care of this in part by using a feedback mechanism, but - Unfortunately for Uber - in Germany these things are a bit more organized than elsewhere and the German taxi system - in those cities where I have used it - is actually quite reasonably priced and the drivers are typically professional and the cars are clean and well maintained.

So from that point of view they don't add value, they just undercut the existing drivers by sidestepping the regulations. And that is unfair competition.

The solution is simple: Uber should certify their cars and drivers for the German market under the same rules as the rest of the drivers and taxi companies, then undercut them on price and overdeliver on service.

That really would be the free market in action.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:44AM (#8256402)
Well, part of the innovation with Uber is that they're able to deliver the same or better service without the regulatory cost. If the feedback mechanism functions as well or better than special licenses/health checks/knowledge tests/what have you, why not pass those cost savings of that innovation on to consumers?

The regulations sound good and all, but I can tell you from personal experience that Uber takes feedback very seriously whereas dispatcher companies and regulators couldn't care less about it and pretty much nothing's ever going to happen to a taxi driver that was rude to you or took a circuitous route.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:51AM (#8256422)
> Well, part of the innovation with Uber is that they're able to deliver the same or better service without the regulatory cost.

What regulatory cost?

Professional liability insurance (which is mandatory for the transportation of people) and higher frequency car certification are not 'regulatory costs' they are costs that industry and government have arrived at as a reasonable compromise between the pull of the market and the ability of taxi service providers to make money whilst providing a safe and professional service to the customers.

Regulatory costs would be 'buy a permit at $1M' or something like that. I don't see that in this judgement, it is just about Uber totally ignoring the law.

> If the feedback mechanism functions as well or better than special licenses/health checks/knowledge tests/what have you, why not pass those cost savings of that innovation on to consumers?

I'm all for that. If after Uber complies with the law their margins are such that they can operate more efficiently they will own the market.

> The regulations sound good and all, but I can tell you from personal experience that Uber takes feedback very seriously whereas dispatcher companies and regulators couldn't care less about it and pretty much nothing's ever going to happen to a taxi driver that was rude to you or took a circuitous route.

I've never had a German taxi driver that was rude to me or that took a circuitous route. (I wished I could say the same for my hometown, Toronto, Bucharest, Rome or New York, the other places where I regularly used taxis).

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:15AM (#8256510)
My comments aren't meant to refer to the German situation in isolation.

In a lot of jurisdictions complying with some of the consumer protection laws is more expensive to the consumer than a feedback system alone while offering little to no additional benefit. Things like medallion laws, knowledge tests, etc. These laws will never get changed unless Uber breaks them and demonstrates that they are, in fact, unnecessary.

I'm not familiar with the German regulations and the article is light on details but if it's as simple as liability insurance and an extra car-checkup I doubt Uber would be opposing this so vehemently. They already provide commercial liability insurance to US drivers, for example.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:35AM (#8256610)
> I'm not familiar with the German regulations and the article is light on details

Ah, ok, never mind me then.

It's hard to argue from assumption, but this is not the only article about this subject, there are many more and this case has been working its way upward for a while in this court and others.

Essentially the German authorities position is that Uber is operating an unlicensed taxi company. Uber is welcome to become licensed but refuses to do so, which allows it to compete with the existing taxi companies but without the associated costs.

The existing taxi companies feel that this is unfair and have brought suit, which the courts have now decided has enough merit to warrant an injunction.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:28AM (#8256350)
Germany is not a direct democracy. Theoretically it could be that 100% of the constituents oppose these protections, but still elected MPs which support them. There are plenty of issues that are more important and more likely to influence one's vote than the price of taxis.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by lispm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:00AM (#8256693)
> Germany is not a direct democracy.

That's not true. Elements of direct democracy are for example available at the local level. Here in Hamburg the politics is supporting it. For example the mayor of Hamburg is openly supporting it:

http://www.abendblatt.de/politik/deutschland/article12940132...

http://www.abendblatt.de/politik/deutschland/article12939565...

If people here in Hamburg/Germany would be unhappy with it, then they could vote over such a topic, if there is enough interest.

We already have elements of direct democracy.

http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksentscheid

For example we voted here to buy back the energy utilities, sold a few years ago.

Just recently a non-binding public voting was a done about a new possible tourist attraction.

Here you can see the list of `Volksabstimmungen` we had here in Hamburg in the last years:

http://www.hamburg.de/contentblob/104078/data/volksabstimmun...

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @07:00AM (#8256870)
To be fair, since this is a federal law and Volksentscheid are only possible up to state level, this wouldn't change anything in this case.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by lispm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @12:16PM (#8258446)
The states could propose a change of the federal law, the Personenbeförderungsgesetz.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:51PM (#8259726)
I'm fairly sure that this is not possible to enforce via Volksentscheid. Its state legislation, so the details differ, but as far as I understand in most states the referendum can only decide over a proposed law. In some states a general guideline for the parliament can be decided over (Berlin, HH and Schleswig-Holstein) but those are only recommendations.

I'm not certain if it would be a valid course to create a law that forces the parliament (or rather the states representatives in the Bundesrat) to propose a law. That might create a legal problem: What if the proposed law gets changed or rejected in the Bundesrat etc. You're free to try, but I doubt that course of action will work.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by vertex-four on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:57AM (#8256440)
Then perhaps the price of taxis is not so important as to break the law to provider cheaper taxis.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:21AM (#8256334)
Well, Uber argues the same way. They also tried to cite the german constitution and argue that the law is unjust and violates the constitution. If that's really their opinion then the right course of action would be to apply for a permission, get denied, fight in court. Then the law would be repealed. But you don't get to choose which laws apply to you, just or unjust. You can decide not to follow the law (for example in civil unrest) and then go to court and fight it, but you don't get to say "I consider that unjust, so the law does not apply to me".
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:33AM (#8256371)
You can decide not to follow the law (for example in civil unrest) and then go to court and fight it, but you don't get to say "I consider that unjust, so the law does not apply to me".

I don't understand the difference.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:41AM (#8256394)
Civil unrest implies you decide not to follow the law, but in turn face the consequences - go to court, get fined, maybe imprisoned in the hope to show publicly that the laws that lead to the imprisonment are unjust, creating pressure to change the laws. It doesn't mean that you decide that the unjust laws just not apply to you and then get a free out of jail card.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by watwut on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:09AM (#8256488)
Where did this come from? The requirement that you have to put yourself voluntary in jail or worst if the rules are aggressive enough is ridiculous. Civil unrest is when you are trying to solve larger societal problem through it. You are disadvantaged by doing it whether you turn yourself to law or not.

The difference against Uber is that they are not trying to solve some injustice or political problem. They are trying to get advantage over competition by ignoring the rules competition follows. It is just trying to get an advantage for themselves.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:59AM (#8256452)
I can see the difference when the action is unseen, and you have to draw attention to it to go to court, but I don't see how it applies to a service done in public like Uber. Should they be suing themselves?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:07AM (#8256479)
Well, they're now getting sued. The other option would have been to apply for a permit, get denied a permit, go to court. They chose not to but rather offer their service despite it being clearly in violation of the law. I feel no pity for them.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:35AM (#8256609)
But isn't that what you argued for? Uber has decided to not follow the law (offer their service) and go to court.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:03AM (#8256710)
Sure, to some extend yes. But Ubers public line of defense is "this unfair law should not apply, have mercy with us." (which is incredibly whiny). Now if the CEO would say "I believe this is unfair and I'll go to prison for it.", that would gain some respect with me :)
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by holri on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:18AM (#8256326)
Well, than the Germans have to vote for a more liberal government. But they did the opposite, the liberals just lost their parliament seats.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:23AM (#8256341)
Just because the government is elected democratically doesn't mean individual laws are just or reflect the will of the constituents.

There's no incentive for the government to side with the consumers on this issue since politicians profit through taxi medallions, political contributions from taxi companies, etc and it's not a big enough issue for anyone to change their votes.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:37AM (#8256385)
I doubt that there's a lot of political contributions from taxi companies. The market is very different from the US - in Berlin the 7000 Taxis are mostly owned by companies having anywhere between 1 and a handful of cars. A medallion costs the administration fee and can be freely obtained, they're more or less unlimited.

Certainly, the cab owners are somewhat organized and have some influence, but the degree is much lower than that. Uber alone has more lobbying power.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by krrrh on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @08:31AM (#8257136)
This is such a key point that so many people are missing by getting caught up in "Europeean regulation = anti-innnovation" clichés. The German laws requiring adequate insurance and inspections are mostly reasonable consumer-protection regulations, and not nearly as protectionist as the taxi regulation in many US cities. It's actually a much more open and free market than in cities where Uber has had most of its success.

It's rare that one can't flag down a taxi on a busy street within a couple of minutes in Berlin, and they are almost without exception clean modern cars with courteous drivers. The MyTaxi app has already brought regular Berlin taxis up to par with Uber for the smartphone-inclined. https://de.mytaxi.com/

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by WildUtah on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:19AM (#8256528)
Then Uber's prospects in Berlin aren't that good anyway. Maybe that's why they're willing to be so patient and fight things out in court.

In US cities, the taxi companies are collecting monopoly profits and providing bad service. Their scam is protected from competition by strict nonsense regulations by local governments. The local governments support the taxi companies for bad reasons like corruption and ignorance. Uber is better because it is subject to competition and is not a monopoly.

In a city with functioning taxi competition, Uber's only advantage is its software, its brand, and its network. Local companies could easily compete very effectively against that.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by holri on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:53AM (#8256429)
The broader issue here is that Europe and especially Germany has a regulated market. The voters voted for that for generations. It is not only taxi but all sorts of professions that have similar or even more restrictive laws.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:01AM (#8256460)
For any given regulatory issue, there is a core group of self-interested voters or political donators who support the regulation, and everyone else who doesn't care much one way or the other. This results in lots of protectionist legislation and regulation even if the majority of people are neutral or mildly opposed.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by holri on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:18AM (#8256523)
The reigning CDU and also the in the past reigning SPD are well known for their protectionism and regulation. If voters would not like that they would have voted the FDP. This has nothing to do with corruption, but with Europe's and Germanies history back to the guilds [1] from the dark age.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guild

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by zo1 on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:47AM (#8256652)
A free market is one that isn't affected by government laws, by definition.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by claudius on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:16AM (#8256166)
Thankfully, this is not intended to legislate competition but the safety of passengers and other users of the tax-financed public roads.

Your point being?

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by _pmf_ on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:59AM (#8256268)
> "None of these can be answered, because these precisely are the questions that can be answered only by the mechanism of a free market."

By that logic, we should happily accept monopolies, cartels and huge conglomerates.

The notion that the free market is beneficial to society as a whole was a cute idea, but the slave workers of Foxconn are probably not quite in agreement.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by simonh on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:12AM (#8256311)
The workers in south china queue round the block for hours to apply for jobs at Foxxcon and other high tech manufacturers. They're some of the best paying manufacturing jobs in the area and are lifting hundreds of thousands of families out of rural poverty.Some become team leaders, get involved in negotiating wages and working conditions, or take classes and move up to secretarial and administrative positions. Many of these workers are women and are returning to the countryside with experience, training and even line workers often have the capital to start their own businesses. As a result it's also leading to a sea change in the position of women in rural society.

http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/30/opinion/chang-chinese-factory-...

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by adamnemecek on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:07AM (#8256294)
How do you know that you can completely ignore someone's opinion? They quote Ayn Rand.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by sschueller on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @02:36AM (#8256090)
A truly free market is not ethical. A certain amount of regulation is required to protect people from each other.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by nhstanley on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:28AM (#8256352)
Yup. In a truly free market, murder is totally fine. Kill your competition, literally! There's a reason we don't live in Randian fantasy worlds.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jasonisalive on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:06AM (#8256473)
No, that's not true. Free != permissive of nonconsensual interactions.

For a free market to work, there must be common respect for individual autonomy. People must enter into contracts of their own free will.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aikah on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @08:53AM (#8257212)
> For a free market to work, there must be common respect for individual autonomy.

That's why that utopia cannot work. Because individuals will always use the shortest and quickest way to get what they want at the expense of others. Anarchism and Communism have/had the same problem as for their simplistic understanding of human nature which can only lead to wrong the conclusions,and the wrong ideas,even though the thought that led to these conclusion might be genuine.

If a precondition states that ,in order for a system to work, people should "naturaly" respect this or that rule, well your system is broken at first place.

Mankind is about order and chaos,and balance between them.People cant regulate themself.Sometimes they accept order because it suits their interests and see the benefits,but during most of human history chaos "ruled".And there is no guarantee most of the order that led the "western civilization" will last.

> People must enter into contracts of their own free will.

Define free will. If someone cant understand all the consequences of his actions before taking a decision, that's not free will. And noone can get the entire picture, or that person would be god himself.

And who will enforce contractual obligations ?

These 2 preconditions in order for your system to work are metaphysical at best,I would consider them a lie,because they cannot be fufilled.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by pgeorgi on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @07:54AM (#8257027)
> People must enter into contracts of their own free will.

That requires a degree of abundance (so people can refuse to enter contracts) that makes competition obsolete. As is, people are required to enter into contracts else they perish.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by thu on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:08AM (#8256299)
Free market can destroy itself, for instance by the creation of a monopoly. How to apply the mechanism of the free market, as good as it can be, if it disappears ?

Anyway here, it's not about competition (that's what they want you to believe it is), it's about regulations (e.g. ensure some safety rules).

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:29AM (#8256353)
Free market can destroy itself, for instance by the creation of a monopoly.

Can it? Are there any good examples of a market with a significant size (with enough profits to support multiple suppliers) devolving into a monopoly without any "help" from outside the market?

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by gambiting on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:55AM (#8256436)
US and Comcast situation? The market is huge(pretty much everyone needs Internet), the profits are huge as well, yet in a lot of places Comcast has dominated the market.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:31AM (#8256595)
Comcast hasn't dominated the market through market forces, it bought it from AT&T in 2001. Comcast has now ~21M customers - AT&T Broadcast, which they bought, had 22M.

AT&T, has one should know, was a legal monopoly; hardly a free market participant.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by rhino369 on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @11:43AM (#8258198)
Acquisition is a free market tool.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:10PM (#8258801)
But the acquisition didn't create the monopoly; that was created by a company with legal privileges. I never claimed that markets automatically dissolved monopolies created by State policy. What I asked is if there are examples of free markets turning into monopolies.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by cygx on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @02:10PM (#8259150)
> But the acquisition didn't create the monopoly; that was created by a company with legal privileges.

But this is exactly what is happening here: Uber tries to get the legal privilege of being exempt from German regulations.

> What I asked is if there are examples of free markets turning into monopolies.

Cartelisation, anyone?

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:50PM (#8259719)
But this is exactly what is happening here: Uber tries to get the legal privilege of being exempt from German regulations.

I don't see how; how are they preventing others from doing the same?

I'm not saying what they're doing is okay, but there's no privilege, anyone else (including incumbents) can decide to ignore the law and provide taxi services without the proper licenses.

Cartelization

Well, the you can surely provide an example of a cartel which has achieved monopoly without any help from States, just as the result of market failure.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by cygx on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:11PM (#8259855)
I don't see how; how are they preventing others from doing the same?

There's a saying in Germany - Wo kein Kläger, da kein Richter (sort of a legal principle: Non ultra petita). Uber only could get away with breaking the law because no one complained. Someone now did. Case closed.

Well, the you can surely provide an example of a cartel which has achieved monopoly without any help from States, just as the result of market failure.

You really need references for that? It should be obvious. There are markets that lend themselves to big business. As soon as a few big players have cornered the market, it is in their best interest to play nice with each other so that 'everybody' wins (at the cost of their customers, of course). This creates a de-facto monopoly that might or might not be viable long-term (backstabbing probably will happen someday).

Historically, there's been a lot of that going on. The most recent case I remember were some German sugar manufacturers, but I could probably come up with hundreds of cases; it would be a waste of my time, though.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:58PM (#8260419)
There's a saying in Germany - Wo kein Kläger, da kein Richter (sort of a legal principle: Non ultra petita). Uber only could get away with breaking the law because no one complained. Someone now did. Case closed.

I'm not seeing how is this relevant.

You really need references for that? It should be obvious. There are markets (...)

Yes, yes, I know the theory. It's just that in practice, it doesn't seem to actually have facts behind it. At least when people give examples (e.g. Comcast) there's almost invariably an extra-market process pushing things.

The most recent case I remember were some German sugar manufacturers, but I could probably come up with hundreds of cases; it would be a waste of my time, though.

Yes, it probably would. Convincing me is not a very good use of anyone's time :)

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by cygx on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:24PM (#8260536)
I'm not seeing how is this relevant.

You were arguing that anyone else can decide to ignore the law and provide taxi services without the proper licenses. This obviously only works if you avoid getting caught, but Uber did not exactly fly under the radar. What they had going for themselves was an unusual entrance to the market, but that only kept them safe until their competitors complained to the authorities.

Convincing me is not a very good use of anyone's time

I did not say that. But it's not hard to do this 'research' by looking at Wikipedia or Google. Some examples I dug up in the last 30 seconds:

Tchibo/Melitta/Dallmayr (coffee), Südzucker/Nordzucker/Pfeifer & Langen (sugar, the one I was talking about), Unilever/Procter & Gamble (washing powder), De Beers (diamonds), possibly your friendly neighbourhood drug dealer (hey, I can watch TV with the best of them ;)).

As long as you don't get caught, it's good business sense - at least for a time. And that's why it will happen, time and again - no extra-market processes necessary.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @07:12PM (#8260706)
Yeah, but for example, calling the sugar production market in Germany "free" is absurd. Agriculture subsidies and quotas are the core of the EU. You can't blame the market for working incorrectly when you heavily restrict its most important mechanism - competition.

De Beers is also a good example - how can it be a free market participant when its biggest mines are joint ventures with the States of Namibia and Botswana?

I haven't looked at the other examples yet, but I find these frankly unconvincing.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:24AM (#8256553)
That's a government granted monopoly, not a natural one.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by legulere on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:00AM (#8256274)
There are several real world examples where regulation was needed for a market (in contrast to a monopoly) to be created.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by malka on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:51AM (#8256241)
> There is no way to legislate competition

Reality checking in.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:09AM (#8256300)
Careful now. It's daytime in Europe, so the more Laisser faire (US-free-market-style) arguments have a higher change of getting down voted. This will correct a bit in about 6 hours when the East Coast wakes up. I'm not judging it, it's just the way us europeans are 'wired'. The taxi market is one ripe thats ripe for disruption. There's lots of demand and low, all-the-same companies offering a low quality/high cost service. It's also one thats build a lot of rules around it, some for the clients protection and a lot to prevent competition. Large established companies always prefer more rules because it absolutely kills new companies trying to enter a market.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:21AM (#8256335)
The taxi market is absolutely ripe for disruption. But GP did not provide any reasons why Uber should be the way to do it. Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons, not just to keep out the competition and as far as I know nothing stops Uber drivers from getting the same certifications as regular taxis. If they do that and they are still blocked or if they are denied certification then you have a genuine case of unfair competition. Until then Uber is tilting the playing field in their direction by offering a product that competes unfairly with the regulated drivers.

Maybe this is the only way in which such a regulation effort can be challenged but I'm not convinced of that.

As for the 'careful now' and so on bits, anybody quoting Ayn Rand verbatim without adding much to the conversation is probably going to get downvoted, it's not as if she's an authority in the field of economics, and most of her writing displays a shockingly bad understanding of the field.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:36AM (#8256378)
Thank you for the insights. A quick reply: >Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons Correct. But mostly because they made a mess of their nr1 job: transporting people Today we have new and far better ways t regulate a driver's behavior. Payment in advance, navigation to check the route and a easy way to judge the driver afterwards. That takes care of most of the complaints.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:39AM (#8256388)
But that still leaves the certification of the vehicle, and with the number of kms taxis drive that's not a luxury. Your regular TUV checkups are targeted at regular drivers, not professional drivers. Your insurance company also won't like it if you start ferrying people around on a 150K km/year plan when paying for the statistical chance of getting in an accident based on 40K km/year.

In all these cases Uber drivers are using rules and regulations (and statistics) applicable to personal transportation and applying those towards a business.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:51AM (#8256419)
And here we get to the heart of the matter: Individual or group responsibility. Everyone is responsible for their own insurance. Every individual has to communicate an estimate of the miles/km they plan to drive in a year to receive a correct insurance. If you fail to do so, you will loose your insurance. No need to regulate this extra and above the systems already in place. As for yearly or 2-yearly checkups of the car, both are also tied to usage. Most people will drive in and around the city, not accross the country. (This is also why Rand has a place in this discussion promoting the über-individual. I also don't always agree with her conclusions but she did address a lot of concerns of her time, half a century ago).
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:00AM (#8256454)
At a guess, insurance companies and passengers alike are not in a position to verify all these issues when they sign up / catch a ride. So some laws were passed and Uber is now ignoring those laws.

That private individuals can lie on their application forms and skip certain tests that are required is not a businessmodel.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:09AM (#8256486)
I really don't think they'll be a Uber driver without the correct papers... And even if they did, they won't be for long.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:10AM (#8256492)
Who will check them?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:54AM (#8256430)
>Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons Correct. But mostly because they made a mess of their nr1 job: transporting people

This is not how I feel about it in Germany. Whenever I needed a cab, I got one, for a fair, reasonable price. Might be a little longer if I'm out in the fields or when a thunderstorm hit Berlin and there's no public transport, but sooner or later, I was picked up. Taxis are treated as part of the public transport system here, they have obligations (must transport everyone for the same price, must provide basic service at any time, regulated rates, ...) and in return receive benefits - effectively a monopoly on the taxi market.

Now, if we decide to repeal the benefits and allow UberPop, how are we going to make sure we fulfill the obligations? No, surge pricing is not a solution. There's probably a solution, but I'm very much not convinced that Uber is the solution, so until someone presents a genuinely better system, I'll stick with what we have. It's not perfect, but good enough.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:27AM (#8256567)
Is there a law forcing Taxi drivers to go to work during a hurricane or New Year's Eve or something? If not, how is the current system of not being able to find a ride better than Uber's system of making you pay a fair market price for it?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:33AM (#8256599)
Yes, at least in Germany, there is. Taxi companies are obliged to provide a minimum level of service or loose the license. The administration can even order a license holder to expand his business if there's public need. (http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/pbefg/__21.html)
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:44AM (#8256639)
I can't read German, do you mind telling me the details of the minimum level of service? If it's per week or per month it doesn't solve the problem when there's inclement weather or a holiday or a conference, etc.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:55AM (#8256674)
The law itself does not specify the level, it grant the authority do decide to the relevant authorities. (For example the administration in Berlin), so things will vary depending on where you are.

Generally speaking I haven't had any problem finding a cab in Berlin. The longest wait was after a thunderstorm took out most of the public transport a couple of years ago and that took like 20 minutes somewhere in the outskirts. I usually either flag one down on the road or use the smartphone app.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:12AM (#8256499)
You make a strong case for the existing taxi-companies. They sure do sound a lot better then Amsterdam taxi's. If they are so loved, I really don't see why they should protest... They will win over client any with their superiour service.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:27AM (#8256569)
They don't protest against Uber as such - they do protest that Uber is skirting the obligations that cost them money and use those savings to undercut their prices. Which is a fair point to make. Uber could easily license their cars as regular taxis and outcompete the regular taxi service. They might even provide better service at the same time - I'm all in favor of that. But they choose not to and then whine about how backwards we all are here that we can't see progress.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by ulfw on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @10:37AM (#8257813)
Yes because establishing a monopoly of one big US company rather than say 200 local taxi cos in a city is such a fantastic US-free-market-thing to do. Hard to fight against a multinational corporation with the marketing power of $1,500,000,000 in funding behind it against a 'Meier Taxi' or 'Müller Taxi' - some dudes with 5 taxi cabs trying to make a living in a harsh market environment.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aikah on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @08:29AM (#8257131)
Since when disruption means disrespecting the law ? If your business is illegal it's going to get shut down,wether you are in Europe or USA. Or why dont you make an app that sales crack cocaine and sees what happens in USA ?

After all,there is a demand for that,there should be an app for that /s .

> Careful now. It's daytime in Europe, so the more Laisser faire (US-free-market-style) arguments have a higher change of getting down voted.

And please,stop hating on Europeans, your bigotry is showing.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @08:40AM (#8257165)
Iam European actually. I am not a bigot. I described a method of thinking. A perspective if you will. Most Europeans will try to see a debate from society's perspective and Americans from the individual's perceptive. Something that is persistent in a lot of discussions here between US and EU professionals.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aikah on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @09:08AM (#8257273)
grep my comment somewhere in this thread about order and chaos.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by RichardFord on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @12:22PM (#8258492)
Yep, the socialist/statist European downvoting mafia is on the march on this story as usual