News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:58PM (#8260419)
There's a saying in Germany - Wo kein Kläger, da kein Richter (sort of a legal principle: Non ultra petita). Uber only could get away with breaking the law because no one complained. Someone now did. Case closed.

I'm not seeing how is this relevant.

You really need references for that? It should be obvious. There are markets (...)

Yes, yes, I know the theory. It's just that in practice, it doesn't seem to actually have facts behind it. At least when people give examples (e.g. Comcast) there's almost invariably an extra-market process pushing things.

The most recent case I remember were some German sugar manufacturers, but I could probably come up with hundreds of cases; it would be a waste of my time, though.

Yes, it probably would. Convincing me is not a very good use of anyone's time :)

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by cygx on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:24PM (#8260536)
I'm not seeing how is this relevant.

You were arguing that anyone else can decide to ignore the law and provide taxi services without the proper licenses. This obviously only works if you avoid getting caught, but Uber did not exactly fly under the radar. What they had going for themselves was an unusual entrance to the market, but that only kept them safe until their competitors complained to the authorities.

Convincing me is not a very good use of anyone's time

I did not say that. But it's not hard to do this 'research' by looking at Wikipedia or Google. Some examples I dug up in the last 30 seconds:

Tchibo/Melitta/Dallmayr (coffee), Südzucker/Nordzucker/Pfeifer & Langen (sugar, the one I was talking about), Unilever/Procter & Gamble (washing powder), De Beers (diamonds), possibly your friendly neighbourhood drug dealer (hey, I can watch TV with the best of them ;)).

As long as you don't get caught, it's good business sense - at least for a time. And that's why it will happen, time and again - no extra-market processes necessary.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @07:12PM (#8260706)
Yeah, but for example, calling the sugar production market in Germany "free" is absurd. Agriculture subsidies and quotas are the core of the EU. You can't blame the market for working incorrectly when you heavily restrict its most important mechanism - competition.

De Beers is also a good example - how can it be a free market participant when its biggest mines are joint ventures with the States of Namibia and Botswana?

I haven't looked at the other examples yet, but I find these frankly unconvincing.