In my experience as a German waiting for a taxi after midnight in a suburban area (but with a major road going through), this is a merely theoretical construct. I've called 3 taxi providers in the rough area; the result was a brisk 1.5 hour walk home because they did not seem all to interested in dispatching a driver to that location at that time. I might have a theoretical legal handle on this behavior, but I doubt this has ever been successfully challenged in court (since the providers can always weasel out by claiming the did not have and free drivers at this moment).
The other rules are plausible, but what on earth is this about?
A yearly health check will look for signs of those illnesses.
Examples might be poorly controlled diabetes; epilepsy; sleep apnea; etc.
Here, it is not sufficient for a driver just to believe he is capable of doing the job, the state requires that he proves his capability and therefore guarantees every passenger that he is capable.
The legislation is perhaps not about stifling competition or anything. But it has the end result of reducing competition by raising the barriers to entry.
Not only that, but it actively prevents competition (e.g. low-end providers) by making a whole segment of the market illegal. It's just the nature of regulation being universal to the country as a whole. i.e. it doesn't allow people to make their own judgements about what safety level they want based on their willingness to pay/not pay for it. In essence boiling down to "you get the extra safety, even if you can't actually use the service because the extra safety bumped up the cost"
Just like erecting skyscrapers that cannot withstand a summer breeze or storing nuclear waste on a city landfill.
If Americans want to do it differently, be my guest. Yes, you're more focused on individual freedom than the rest of the world. Fine with me.
But maybe you could try to understand that Germans are very safety-oriented. And maybe you could just accept that instead of telling us that we're not doing things like America and therefore we're wrong.
Not all Germans, seeing as people are actually using Uber in Germany. That's the point I was trying to make. Tyranny of the majority, I suppose, unfortunate, but apparently "the best we got".
Side note: I'm not actually American. Please don't stereotype and make assumptions based on opinion/nationality, even if it is a good one such as "focused on individual freedom" and "Germans are very safety-oriented", etc.
People are very bad at judging what's in their best interest, especially since often their personal interest at the time when doing the transaction conflicts with they long-term best interest or the societies interest. And so, to some level, some things (like taxi companies) are regulated in germany. This is obviously an imperfect system, but I remain unconvinced that free market rules all is a better system.
There are certainly individuals who prefer Uber and who's interests align very well with Uber, but I'm uncertain that's a majority. That's certainly annoying to those individuals, but that's life in a society, we all have to give at some point. Germany. This is obviously an imperfect
Some regulation is good, depending on the field. Public transportation is in my opinion one of those fields (and engineering another).
Uber could fairly easily comply with these laws but it would cut into their profits and that is the reason why they have chosen to ignore the law and to cut their drivers loose the moment something happens (such as when a driver is involved in an accident).
It's about Uber avoiding regulations (that the taxi coops already implement): insurance for passengers, insurance for commercial car use, car checkups every year instead of every second (like for private cars), yearly health check for the driver.
That's essentially it, and as soon as Uber follows the rules, they can operate freely. They can organize it themselves (with employed drivers) or require their freelance drivers to do so.
If their business model doesn't allow for that, their business model is flawed, and the German society has no obligation to bear Uber's costs just so they can feel "disruptive".
[edit: it's somewhat more involved given that the court refers to PBefG, which as a whole needs some creative interpretation to allow for Uber to work, eg. running things as "car rental with driver" (which requires that customers don't state where they want to drive to beforehand). Still, Uber tries to work around any and all regulations, and it's no surprise that this won't be tolerated, and for good reason.]