Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:21AM
(#8256334)
Well, Uber argues the same way. They also tried to cite the german constitution and argue that the law is unjust and violates the constitution. If that's really their opinion then the right course of action would be to apply for a permission, get denied, fight in court. Then the law would be repealed. But you don't get to choose which laws apply to you, just or unjust. You can decide not to follow the law (for example in civil unrest) and then go to court and fight it, but you don't get to say "I consider that unjust, so the law does not apply to me".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:33AM
(#8256371)
You can decide not to follow the law (for example in civil unrest) and then go to court and fight it, but you don't get to say "I consider that unjust, so the law does not apply to me".
I don't understand the difference.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:41AM
(#8256394)
Civil unrest implies you decide not to follow the law, but in turn face the consequences - go to court, get fined, maybe imprisoned in the hope to show publicly that the laws that lead to the imprisonment are unjust, creating pressure to change the laws. It doesn't mean that you decide that the unjust laws just not apply to you and then get a free out of jail card.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by watwut on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:09AM
(#8256488)
Where did this come from? The requirement that you have to put yourself voluntary in jail or worst if the rules are aggressive enough is ridiculous. Civil unrest is when you are trying to solve larger societal problem through it. You are disadvantaged by doing it whether you turn yourself to law or not.
The difference against Uber is that they are not trying to solve some injustice or political problem. They are trying to get advantage over competition by ignoring the rules competition follows. It is just trying to get an advantage for themselves.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:59AM
(#8256452)
I can see the difference when the action is unseen, and you have to draw attention to it to go to court, but I don't see how it applies to a service done in public like Uber. Should they be suing themselves?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:07AM
(#8256479)
Well, they're now getting sued. The other option would have been to apply for a permit, get denied a permit, go to court. They chose not to but rather offer their service despite it being clearly in violation of the law. I feel no pity for them.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by icebraining on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:35AM
(#8256609)
But isn't that what you argued for? Uber has decided to not follow the law (offer their service) and go to court.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:03AM
(#8256710)
Sure, to some extend yes. But Ubers public line of defense is "this unfair law should not apply, have mercy with us." (which is incredibly whiny). Now if the CEO would say "I believe this is unfair and I'll go to prison for it.", that would gain some respect with me :)