News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:36AM (#8256378)
Thank you for the insights. A quick reply: >Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons Correct. But mostly because they made a mess of their nr1 job: transporting people Today we have new and far better ways t regulate a driver's behavior. Payment in advance, navigation to check the route and a easy way to judge the driver afterwards. That takes care of most of the complaints.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:39AM (#8256388)
But that still leaves the certification of the vehicle, and with the number of kms taxis drive that's not a luxury. Your regular TUV checkups are targeted at regular drivers, not professional drivers. Your insurance company also won't like it if you start ferrying people around on a 150K km/year plan when paying for the statistical chance of getting in an accident based on 40K km/year.

In all these cases Uber drivers are using rules and regulations (and statistics) applicable to personal transportation and applying those towards a business.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:51AM (#8256419)
And here we get to the heart of the matter: Individual or group responsibility. Everyone is responsible for their own insurance. Every individual has to communicate an estimate of the miles/km they plan to drive in a year to receive a correct insurance. If you fail to do so, you will loose your insurance. No need to regulate this extra and above the systems already in place. As for yearly or 2-yearly checkups of the car, both are also tied to usage. Most people will drive in and around the city, not accross the country. (This is also why Rand has a place in this discussion promoting the über-individual. I also don't always agree with her conclusions but she did address a lot of concerns of her time, half a century ago).
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:00AM (#8256454)
At a guess, insurance companies and passengers alike are not in a position to verify all these issues when they sign up / catch a ride. So some laws were passed and Uber is now ignoring those laws.

That private individuals can lie on their application forms and skip certain tests that are required is not a businessmodel.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:09AM (#8256486)
I really don't think they'll be a Uber driver without the correct papers... And even if they did, they won't be for long.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by jacquesm on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:10AM (#8256492)
Who will check them?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:54AM (#8256430)
>Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons Correct. But mostly because they made a mess of their nr1 job: transporting people

This is not how I feel about it in Germany. Whenever I needed a cab, I got one, for a fair, reasonable price. Might be a little longer if I'm out in the fields or when a thunderstorm hit Berlin and there's no public transport, but sooner or later, I was picked up. Taxis are treated as part of the public transport system here, they have obligations (must transport everyone for the same price, must provide basic service at any time, regulated rates, ...) and in return receive benefits - effectively a monopoly on the taxi market.

Now, if we decide to repeal the benefits and allow UberPop, how are we going to make sure we fulfill the obligations? No, surge pricing is not a solution. There's probably a solution, but I'm very much not convinced that Uber is the solution, so until someone presents a genuinely better system, I'll stick with what we have. It's not perfect, but good enough.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:27AM (#8256567)
Is there a law forcing Taxi drivers to go to work during a hurricane or New Year's Eve or something? If not, how is the current system of not being able to find a ride better than Uber's system of making you pay a fair market price for it?
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:33AM (#8256599)
Yes, at least in Germany, there is. Taxi companies are obliged to provide a minimum level of service or loose the license. The administration can even order a license holder to expand his business if there's public need. (http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/pbefg/__21.html)
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by aianus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:44AM (#8256639)
I can't read German, do you mind telling me the details of the minimum level of service? If it's per week or per month it doesn't solve the problem when there's inclement weather or a holiday or a conference, etc.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:55AM (#8256674)
The law itself does not specify the level, it grant the authority do decide to the relevant authorities. (For example the administration in Berlin), so things will vary depending on where you are.

Generally speaking I haven't had any problem finding a cab in Berlin. The longest wait was after a thunderstorm took out most of the public transport a couple of years ago and that took like 20 minutes somewhere in the outskirts. I usually either flag one down on the road or use the smartphone app.

Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by digitalengineer on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:12AM (#8256499)
You make a strong case for the existing taxi-companies. They sure do sound a lot better then Amsterdam taxi's. If they are so loved, I really don't see why they should protest... They will win over client any with their superiour service.
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany by Xylakant on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:27AM (#8256569)
They don't protest against Uber as such - they do protest that Uber is skirting the obligations that cost them money and use those savings to undercut their prices. Which is a fair point to make. Uber could easily license their cars as regular taxis and outcompete the regular taxi service. They might even provide better service at the same time - I'm all in favor of that. But they choose not to and then whine about how backwards we all are here that we can't see progress.