News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by tokenadult on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:28PM (#7550050)
What is that makes the United States such an attractive place to immigrate to for people whose skill sets could take them almost anywhere in the world? (In other words, why is that successive sessions of Congress can basically count on lots of people desiring to live in the United States, thus setting up an environment in which immigration regulation is restrictive rather than open?)

(I'm genuinely curious about this, as an American who has lived overseas--with the proper visas of course--for three years in the 1980s and for three years spanning the turn of the last century. I've only lived long-term in one other country, so I still could learn a lot more from all of you who participate here on HN about why people leave their country of birth, which is surely disruptive, to go to another country to live. What's the big deal about living in the United States?)

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by msvan on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:14PM (#7550313)
I live in Northern Europe. It's arguably superior to the US in many ways, but there are some things which we cannot get here.

One thing is size. The US has 300+ million people, whereas my country only has a few million. All communities are smaller here; interesting things get here later or not at all (with bad localizations) because the market is too small. Things are tinier, quieter and get less traction.

Another thing is that there is something of a cultural identity crisis going on. We cannot match the enormous cultural influence of the US, and so a lot of our culture is American. If you've ever talked to someone from Northern Europe and wondered "why does s/he speak English so well?" it's not because of school. One half of our cultural identity is located on the other side of the Atlantic, and we keep in touch with it mostly through backlit screens.

The deluge of information and entertainment that has come from the US since it became a superpower has served as a really efficient marketing strategy. We're not terribly interested in moving to Oklahoma. We have been sold on New York, San Francisco, Los Angeles and other metropolises in the US, because that's what we read and hear about. These places are perhaps not better than Northern Europe to settle down and start a family in, but they certainly seem more exciting.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by total on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:45PM (#7550704)
> ...and wondered "why does s/he speak English so well?" it's not because of school.

As an American, I've always been surprised when conversing with people from other countries considering their usage of English is not bad and is far better than those that are American natives. However, also as an American, I'm not surprised by the lack of skill in regards to the English language that is present amongst the population here (I'll use 'amongst' if I want, Chrome) due to the general disregard for the language (as if using the wrong form of your/you're is really that difficult or unimportant).

Edit: As is inevitable when one comments upon improper usage of a language, they tend to screw it up themselves. I have done just that. I will leave my mistake to commemorate it: "As an American, I've have always been..."

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by throwaway344 on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @06:43PM (#7556490)
The key distinction here is that native English speakers speak with whatever dialect that they grow up with. On the other hand, most ESL speakers try to learn a so-called "Prestige" dialect, like RP or General American. Thus, most fluent native speakers have a more prestigious accent and way of writing due to this, than those who speak English as a first language.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by total on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:17AM (#7557892)
That's a great point that I haven't thought of before! I tend to forget that when others learn a new language it is generally taught in the proper and/or polite manner.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by NAFV_P on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:44PM (#7550463)
> Another thing is that there is something of a cultural identity crisis going on. We cannot match the enormous cultural influence of the US, and so a lot of our culture is American.

I don't think that applies to music genres. I live in Gloucester, England which is practically in the middle of Jungle country.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by ebiester on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:42PM (#7550134)
There are only a few really good places to live for an educated worker. Japan, Australia, Western and Northern Europe, Canada, and the US. I will operationalize "good" as "an intelligent worker can make an exceptional living relative to their country of origin."

Each of these places only take a limited amount of immigrants each year. Some are more difficult based on the national language -- learning Danish isn't more difficult than English or French, but there are fewer learning resources to do so.

So, your best options for the greatest amount of opportunity is to learn English -- you have the UK, America, Canada, and Australia as potential landing spots. (This is, of course, not universal. Developing countries with French as a national language will prefer France, for example.)

So, the answer is that it's a way out.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by thmcmahon on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:05PM (#7550273)
Australia has an uncapped temporary migration program for skilled workers (http://www.immi.gov.au/Visas/Pages/457.aspx), the situation described in this article can not happen in Australia.

On a permanent level, Australia has a permanent program of around 180,000 places a year in a country with only 22 million people.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by vorg on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @01:45AM (#7551619)
And those 180,000 places is only the front door into Australia. The back door is to immigrate to New Zealand, become a NZ citizen, then move to Australia. Because Australia and New Zealand have a single labor market, citizens of both can live and work in each others countries without any special permission or numerical restrictions. From my personal observations, virtually all immigrants to NZ move to Australia once they can, and frequently refer to New Zealand as Australia's back door.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by dwd on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @02:26AM (#7551716)
While true it's potentially harder to immigrate to New Zealand unless you come from Kiribati, Tuvalu or Tonga which have an extra entry option.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by vorg on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @06:47AM (#7552554)
Not sure what you mean by "potentially harder". I've met many people who immigrated to NZ because they couldn't get into Australia. They then moved to Australia within a month or two of qualifying for and getting NZ citizenship. It used to take 3 yrs of NZ residency (tho with very lenient allowances for time out of the country every calendar year) to become a citizen but was changed to 5 yrs around 10 yrs ago, so maybe the situation's changed a little since then.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by lancewiggs on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @07:43AM (#7552746)
Much easier as NZ has a simple points system.

But I don't understand why you'd want to leave, having lived in the US, UK, Australia, South Africa and NZ, the choice of NZ for ease of doing business and life is easy.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by dwd on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:47PM (#7564058)
Happy to stand corrected. Curious as to how they were disqualified. Was it current demand for their trade/qualification or something else?
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by vorg on Friday April 11, 2014 @05:58PM (#7575856)
In the 1990's it was easier to immigrate to NZ than Australia under the different points systems of the two countries. Virtually immigrant I spoke to in NZ got in because of qualification and work experience in China.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by tibbon on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:28PM (#7550637)
Given that, why aren't more people trying to get to Australia to work? Aside from spiders (a personal fear of mine) it seems to be a pretty awesome place.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by gregsq on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:14PM (#7551241)
I'm from the UK but have been staying in Australia for a little over a year now. I'm making a hardware gadget from scratch, and some of the people involved are here. I've also lived in the US for a while.

On Bloomberg I listened to an interview with the founder of Jetstar airlines, currently owned by Qantas, and who is now expanding a renewables business, who called Australia a resource exchange economy. Reading how cooks can earn $325K a year in gas projects, and noticing that the just signed Australia - Japan free trade agreement is mostly beef and agriproducts in exchange for TV's and other electronics, the sense initially is of lack of diversity in tech.

There's no way I could make my hardware project in Australia, not that I ever intended to. I haven't been able to find a single viable option for PCB manufacture. And if a company can provide them they're almost always farmed out to China in any case.

In the UK and the US, but also Europe it's just much richer in scope and size. There are some outstanding hardware facilities in the US. They're virtually non existent in Australia, at the right level of expertise and scale.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by benjamincburns on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:02PM (#7550794)
Lots of people are moving to Australia.

However, one big deterrent is proximity to the rest of the world. If you want to travel home to visit family, or due to an emergency - it's going to cost a lot of money and time.

Because of the distance, the logistics of physically moving there are also that much more difficult.

Then there are the mainstays - cost of living in/around major cities is quite high (though in the ICT sector earning potential is quite good), there are lots of scary critters, etc.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by jpatokal on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:47PM (#7550952)
Lots of people are trying, but it's not that easy. You can't get a 457 temporary working visa without an Australian company willing to sponsor you. The hurdles for skilled migration are fairly high (and getting higher all the time) and the process takes several years.

http://www.immi.gov.au/skilled/general-skilled-migration/

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by untog on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:19PM (#7550860)
It's far away, and as a developer I don't think you can earn as much as you would in the US. Certainly to be more HN specific, the startup scene is not much to talk about.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by wyclif on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:38PM (#7551310)
I was interested in migrating to Australia for a while, mostly because it's closer to where my wife's family lives. But it's just so expensive to live in Australia and the pay scale isn't nearly as good as the US or UK. On top of that, they have so many barriers to getting a skills visa it's just not worth it.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by jedmeyers on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:31PM (#7550900)
Earning less than a unionized plumber is sometimes degrading.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by xyzzy123 on Monday April 07, 2014 @10:52PM (#7551183)
Why? It takes about 5 years to become registered plumber in NZ/AU.

Many plumbers are also qualified in drainlaying, gasfitting and roofing as well. If you work with gas then lives depend on the quality of your work.

You also have to be physically fit, willing to get up early and sometimes deal with really unpleasant situations (e.g. wade through shit).

"Average" plumbers in AU might only get 60-80k (seriously, check the ads), which is actually not that great an ROI on the investment.

It's not until you specialise, become senior, go out on your own or start doing lots of overtime that you make money.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by jedmeyers on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @03:45AM (#7551973)
Can I do my own plumbing if I do it according to the codes and I am not in a union? Also why do I have to pay for a plumber that is qualified in drainlaying, gasfitting and roofing when all I need is to fix a small leak in my faucet? It's like when you need to reinstall Windows on your PC you cannot do it yourself and have to get a software engineer for $500/hr who can write assembly code and knows the difference between merge and quicksort.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by buzaga41 on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:54PM (#7550745)
Is `educated worker` some kind of euphemism for genius/top of the game or something? I am an educated worker, and probably everyone else around here.. Seems like a bit-too-broad statement(I for one am not currently interested in immigrating not one bit)

Anyway, I always thought the best would want to move to the US because it's there's top work, e.g.: there's no Tesla or SpaceX elsewhere and a top engineer would probably want to be doing this kind of work... Same with scientists that are working on ambitious research. But maybe I'm thinking about H1b as more of `top of the top, get your asses here` and it's more like `ye you're skilled enough you can try`, dunno.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by lolwutf on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:03PM (#7550261)
With the advent of remote work upon us, I find it hard that you'd be limited to those countries.

In fact, literally the ENTIRE WORLD is your oyster, assuming you can reliably, regularly find power, wifi, and a team that'll work with you on your timezone's timeframe.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by potatolicious on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:34PM (#7550415)
Remote work is lowering some barriers, but others aren't so easily fixed.

I'm a first-gen immigrant. My family originally moved because of rampant pollution due to unrestrained industrialization, as well as geopolitical risks (having air/bomb raid drills in school isn't really that fun). Telecommuting doesn't really fix these.

Suffice it to say, emigration/immigration is a Big Deal for the people who do it, and for the most part it isn't being done simply because the jobs are better. There are usually far more fundamental concerns behind the decision, a better economy is just one factor out of many.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by chc on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:32PM (#7550402)
The "advent of remote work" may be upon us, but a lot of places aren't really on-board yet. Go look at any job listings site — remote work is very much not the rule.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by ebiester on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:56PM (#7550508)
It's not that easy to emigrate from developing world to slightly more advanced developing world in many cases. Sometimes, it's easier to go straight to the top 20.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by JetSpiegel on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:23PM (#7550367)
> In fact, literally the ENTIRE WORLD is your oyster, assuming you can reliably, regularly find power, wifi, and a team that'll work with you on your timezone's timeframe.

So, this is about what the parent said.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by PhasmaFelis on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:39PM (#7550684)
Those are some pretty big assumptions.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by hrktb on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:20PM (#7550615)
I'll add that part of the US has mild weather, and that makes it more attractive than Canada or Northern Europe to a lot of immigrants (someone from Ghana might not want to spend winters in Sweden for instance).
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by lancewiggs on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @07:48AM (#7552771)
You missed South Africa, Hong Kong, Singapore, China, New Zealand, most of South America, Malaysia, Middle East and so on and on. Personally I put New Zealand on top of the list - as many other lists do along with the Nordic countries.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by JamesArgo on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:59PM (#7550242)
Canada will take anyone with an engineering degree.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by avmich on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:24PM (#7550369)
What do you mean by "take"? Canadian employers aren't very familiar with a concept of working visa in practice - they prefer you to first have a permanent residence, then they can talk about hiring you. To get permanent residence, you have to pass the process, which is many months long.

Am I substantially missing something?

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by refurb on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:51PM (#7550492)
I think the gp is referring to Canada's point system. As long as you have enough points, then you will be admitted into Canada.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by avmich on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:48PM (#7550717)
But how long is the wait?

In US, if - and that's a big if - you're lucky enough to win H-1b early April, you may start working early October. Is there anything as fast with Canada? Without employer agreeing to hire you even though you don't have a working visa - i.e., you have to apply for one?

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by Mikeb85 on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:35PM (#7550667)
Yes. Skilled worker visas which don't require employer sponsorship, and are open ended.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by avmich on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:45PM (#7550703)
Hmm, http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/information/times/perm/skilled-... lists processing times in months. Options with many months of wait are known, but are there anything faster? Say, 90 days?
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by Mikeb85 on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:04PM (#7550799)
Not really. To get sponsored by an employer you need a labour market opinion and there are certain conditions (like no Canadian candidates applying for said position during a certain time period).
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by turar on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:46PM (#7550945)
Nope. Unless anyone is someone who has 1 year experience (not just a degree) in one of just 24 allowed occupations, AND can get an application before a small cap is reached. http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/skilled/complete-appl...
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by EduardoBautista on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:18PM (#7550858)
If I recall correctly, almost all the nordic countries accept English to fulfill their language requirements.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by jpatokal on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:51PM (#7550967)
For temporary workers, sure, But if you want citizenship, better start honing up your Finnish conjugation.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by joering2 on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:29PM (#7550640)
> There are only a few really good places to live for an educated worker. Japan, Australia, Western and Northern Europe, Canada, and the US.

You need to pull your eyes out of your ass. The countries you mention are far from being superior; perhaps "good enough", but frankly nothing too fancy. You need to visit Hong Kong or Singapore to see how highly qualified immigrants live there like kings.

Japan has serious environmental problems and their government does not stand up to the transparency one would love their government to comply with [1]. They are rolling into huge economical depression too.

Australia. Have you ever been there? Spend couple months you will be surprise how alienated you will feel. My friends live there for 15-20 years and they will never be a part of the community. They will always feel like outsiders; mostly recognized by their accent. Australians divide themselves among those who were born here, and all outsiders who came to steal jobs. Its the mentality. It wont change. Australia has their own environmental problems too and politics & taxation goes through the roof (viva la Queen that fixes everything through more taxes).

European Union is on a brink of collapse; some countries are openly discussing living EU. Its rotten to its core by very well hidden corruption [2]; Ukraine situation that helps Russia shows their real aspirations does not help either.

Canada, they are still under Queen that can suspend the parliment anytime she wants to [3].

Then we come to US. I think its a matter of "the grass that is greener on the other side". I mean, how many of those folks applying for visa know anything about US more than from movies about "land of the free home of the brave?". Politics? How many know who Nancy Pelosy or Henry Reid are? For all they know America has this good man named Obama who gave everyone free healthcare so it can't get better than that. Did they hear about Justina Pelletier, Cliven Bundy, Kelly Thomas or hundred of thousands other cases of governmental abuse?

[1] http://enenews.com/japan-times-sources-reveal-fukushima-radi...

[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/eu/10614864...

[3] http://stevescomments.wordpress.com/2008/12/06/the-queen-of-...

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by dang on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:36PM (#7550671)
You need to pull your eyes out of your ass.

This is inappropriate language for Hacker News. Please don't address another user this way, regardless of how wrong you think they are.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by doktrin on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:56PM (#7550752)
This is a silly and hypocritical critique. All countries have their flaws, but you're really not being fair or objective.

You lambast Japan for a lack of government transparency just as you finish extolling the virtues of Hong Kong and Singapore. You also conveniently fail to mention the salary required to live "like a king" in either of those two locations. Singapore ain't cheap. In fact, it's the world's most expensive city by several measures [1].

H1-B is pretty broad, and most applicants are certainly not eligible for mid six figure salaries in the finance hubs of Asia. "Highly qualified" for the purposes of this discussion does _not_ necessarily mean rolling in the dough.

Lastly and most comically : Canada's parliament being desolved by the Queen? That's patently absurd.

[1] http://www.bbc.com/news/business-26412821

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by frandroid on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:52PM (#7550731)
I don't think it's inappropriate language, but I find your statement that the Queen can suspend Canadian parliament any time she wants is totally incorrect. The case you link to is an exceptional one that had no jurisprudence, and was most likely decided by the Queen's representative, not the Queen herself, which is not an insignificant difference. This was the aftermath of an election with a minority government result, which almost never happens in our First Past the Post system. Your misrepresentation of this case is more offensive to my eyes than your language. My HN values intellectual correctness over proper language. :)
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by dang on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @04:59PM (#7555983)
Of course truth is more important than civility. But the two are compatible—there's no tradeoff.

It would be great if we had a way to correct all false statements on Hacker News, but we don't. That shouldn't prevent us from addressing the corrosion of the discourse by garden-variety incivility. Pulling out those weeds is one of the big things we all can do to make HN more conducive to truth-seeking discussion in the first place.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by ollysb on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:01PM (#7550255)
As a developer you can live anywhere that has a decent internet connection. That's a pretty large portion of the planet these days...
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by nowarninglabel on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:27PM (#7550385)
I've traveled pretty extensively across the world for work and very few places have an internet connection that compares to even a modest broadband connection in the US. Not only that, I deal with this problem weekly from our partners in 75 countries across the world who don't have good internet connections. As well, you're discounting the world's oceans. I've worked on a ship where we provided an extremely limited internet connection that would not be suitable for rapid development work.

I'd say it's a pretty small portion of the planet that has a decent internet connection, but the detail is how you define "decent".

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by scv119 on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:16PM (#7550328)
Sorry, there is no DECENT internet connection in China
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by seanmcdirmid on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:32PM (#7550403)
And yet, I still am able to work here. Barely, but still (helps that we have our own line from the office).
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by ollysb on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:24PM (#7550874)
"Large portion of the planet"... you've got North America, South America(some exceptions), Europe, a good chunk of Asia and Australasia. That's a pretty reasonable selection of places to live isn't it?
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by sbashyal on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:52PM (#7550204)
As an immigrant, I believe that US education is the number one cause for most of this. I did my undergraduate degree from Nepal and came to US to go to Grad school. Most of the engineering course content is American and most of us end up being inspired by the pioneers - Dennis Ritchie, Linus, Bill Gates, John Carmack to name a few

Once you are here, and have a degree, there are opportunities here that are not there back home and hence the interest in working visas.

Consultancies are another catalyst - in cases where the candidates do not manage to get a job right out of school, consultancies act as a bridge where they file immigrant visas for the candidates and then help them find companies that are in need of their skills.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by kparaju on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:56PM (#7550220)
It's good to see someone else in HN from Nepal :) We are a rare bunch.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by zizee on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:40PM (#7550125)
85,000 people is a tiny amount of people all things considered. Australia had 129,250 placed for skilled immigrants in the 2011-12 period and that's with a population of around 10% of the US.

I'm not saying that the US is not a popular choice for people wanting to immigrate, but I think that it is more that there is a good quality of life to be had, with the added bonus of being an English speaking country (which is the most popular choice as a 2nd language learn).

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by conanbatt on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:41PM (#7550132)
I can speak for Argentina in this case: first and foremost, an average entry-level programmer in argentina might make 600 dollars a month. There is no consideration for your degree in that regard.

Second but not least, because ARgentina grows so much on outsourcing contracts, the quality of the job to do is poor and uncommitted. Product management in Argentina is almost non-existent. This means that the most likely job you will get is contracting-"do as the guy that pay exactly wants even if you know for a fact that there are better ways to do it" work.

So, more pay + more interesting work is enticing enough. Also, having worked in the US gives you a halo if you come back.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by wosos on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:13PM (#7550308)
Exactly this, in El Salvador for example your employment options grow an order of magnitude if you've any experience working in the US.

Also, you have the possibility to learn about bleeding edge tech in situ.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by ycskyspeak on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:04PM (#7550267)
It makes sense to compare the purchasing power parity and not just the dollar amount. Argentina is an up and coming destination for tech folk but the standard of living and opportunities offered are not at par with the US (specifically the valley)
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by photon137 on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:08PM (#7550286)
Great universities.

English as the primary language (great learning resources available for it all across the globe).

Real economic mobility - you can really make it big if you're smart, persevering and slightly lucky. Who you know matters to a certain extent in all countries, but the significance of that factor is less in the US as compared to the other countries, in my opinion (others may disagree, of course).

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by mkohlmyr on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:38PM (#7550437)
(Personal opinion) It isn't the United States that's attractive. It's the tech-hubs within it. I would never seriously consider moving anywhere but a handful of cities / areas in the US. The eco-systems in those places are still years ahead of London or Berlin.

I moved from Sweden to the United Kingdom to attend university for similar reasons. The university culture is different (much better) here, and there is more of a hub factor to the campuses, which offers many advantages socially and otherwise.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by purringmeow on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:55PM (#7550504)
I am an Eastern European living in Central Europe.

I moved because University and because of the better living/work conditions.

However, if I had the chance I would probably move to the US. Maybe CA, but I am still on the fence. The things stopping me are the super expensive health care, work-life balance and higher crime rates.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by hibikir on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:58PM (#7550232)
Money, and a corporate culture where being good at your job is, at least in some way, part of the equation.

For instance, a programmer in Spain makes about a third as he would in the midwest, with the same cost of living. He'd also be able to find a job by having skills that fit what companies need, instead of being about being a good friend of the CTO's nephew.

And that's a developed country in the EU. Imagine the same thing, in one of those places that have immigrants that move to Spain.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by curiousDog on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:57PM (#7550759)
To me it's the universities and the already existing multi-culturalism. Everyone here is an immigrant in some way.

Also, multi-culturalism seems to be growing organically here in the U.S rather than being shoved down people's throats like in Europe. This leads to fewer instances of racism and a more accepting climate where every one has some degree of mutual respect. I don't think that's the case in Western Europe where from what I hear, refugees are being brought in huge numbers angering the local population.

Last year, i visited Switzerland and Austria and was called nigger multiple times by random passers on bicycles whilst walking (and I'm not even black and pretty fair for an Indian guy). Fuck that shit.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by voteapathy on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:57PM (#7550514)
Well, the simplest answer is that incomes are way higher for certain positions, even for significantly less skilled work. I mean, engineers are a dime-a-dozen in China, but the pay is lower and STEM work is not nearly as glamorized as it is in the US right now. Doctors too. All the praise goes to business and financial managers.

Of course, if you're an international trailblazing software-engineering guru, yeah, you'll get fantastic opportunities pretty much anywhere. However, even fairly low-level IT work in the US can feed a new family (depending on your geography, of course), which is not the case everywhere in the world. And with recruiters banging down peoples' doors throwing jobs in peoples' faces, it's no wonder foreigners want to stay in the US.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by smtddr on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:47PM (#7550177)
>>What is that makes the United States such an attractive place to immigrate to for people whose skill sets could take them almost anywhere in the world?

So, I'm highly critical of USgov but USA, with all its alleged faults, is still considered the "Land of opportunity" by a lot of people. If you have tech-skills and you need a country where the internet doesn't cost you a kidney-per-month(and barely works), electricity is reliably provided during core working hours; combined with the perception that Bay Area / Silicon Valley tech scene is where the money & smart people are at.... there you have it.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by balls187 on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:40PM (#7550122)
> What is that makes the United States such an attractive place to immigrate to for people whose skill sets could take them almost anywhere in the world?

That is a broad question.

Probably because unlike most other countries, we're a nation of immigrants, and while our policies may not be perfect, we have empathy for people who want to move here, and work hard for a better life.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by sien on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:01PM (#7550254)
Technically the title is a little misleading.

The Australian E3 visa has not been filled. If you need skilled engineers think of seeing if you can recruit some Australians.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-3_visa

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by jacques_chester on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:49PM (#7550960)
The E3 isn't equivalent to an H1B. It has many advangtages, but there's no path to permanent residency.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by total on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:49PM (#7550721)
The title certainly is misleading, but a read of the short article clears that up pretty quickly considering they mention H-1B visas by name.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by cloudhead on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:41PM (#7550128)
Lets just say it's not about the country itself, but the companies based in the US. In other words, the opportunity to work on really interesting problems with the best people in the field.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by xyzzyz on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @08:16AM (#7558823)
What is that makes the United States such an attractive place to immigrate to for people whose skill sets could take them almost anywhere in the world?

As a European who spent his last 3 summers in the US, and now participating in H1B lottery, my motivation is pretty simple: money, and also prestige stemming from working for a well-recognized tech company in the core of SV that will follow me when I get back my home country, or immigrate to some country I find more desirable.

Spending few months in Bay Area and in Seattle made me pretty disillusioned about the whole "land of the free" thing, about equality and justice for all. It also made me concerned about my own personal safety, something I never ever felt back home.

But for the salary, I find that Canada is in almost every way superior for immigration purposes, not to mention Germany, Switzerland, Denmark or Sweden.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by epynonymous on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:59PM (#7550243)
several things:

1. stability of the political system 2. percentage of large companies that originate (i.e. google, facebook, vmware, etc) 3. open opportunities with respect to social class

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by joe_the_user on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:38PM (#7550112)
What evidence do you have that the US is an attractive place at all, relative to other advanced or semi-advanced nations? More applicants than places does not prove that much in a world of scarce jobs.

People are dying, literally drowning in the Mediterranean, to get into Europe. As I know, people still apply to work in Qatar even as they engage in work practices that well be "nothing less than murder"in the process of constructing their World Cup stadiums.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_FIFA_World_Cup#Migrant_wor...

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by refurb on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:43PM (#7550150)
About 13% of the world's adults -- or about 630 million people -- say they would like to leave their country and move somewhere else permanently. For roughly 138 million people, that somewhere else would be the U.S. -- the No. 1 desired destination for potential migrants. The U.K., Canada, and France also rank among the top choices for potential migrants.

http://www.gallup.com/poll/161435/100-million-worldwide-drea...

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by sentenza on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @03:31AM (#7551917)
Your quote is fantastic, as it brings to light an important point: Language is an extremely important motivator for destination selection.

The list contains the UK and France, but not Germany or the Netherlands.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by hnnewguy on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:50PM (#7550200)
>What evidence do you have that the US is an attractive place at all

You don't have to look very hard to see that the US is still very attractive for migration: about 1 million people, legal, permanent, per year for almost 3 decades[1] (and 1.5MM "temporary"). For comparison, Germany had about 800k in 2011, France 150k, UK 500k.

[1]http://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/immigrat...

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by pacaro on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:14PM (#7550319)
This document is hugely important to understand. Thank you for posting.

I always found Table 6 to be the most interesting, particularly in debates about immigration — I have a green card as a 9 year long EB3 process (Employment Based, 3rd class - the CIS doesn't value Philosophy degrees as highly as engineering degrees!)

To take the last year for which data are published, 2011

A partial breakdown of new Permanent Resident status issued—informally “green card”

    Family sponsored                  206,585
    Immediate relatives of citizens   209,984 
    Employment based                   14,955
In round numbers for every green card issued on basis of employment, 28 are issued to family members of citizens. This is pretty much the inverse of popular understanding of immigration.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by dragonwriter on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:22PM (#7550362)
> In round numbers for every green card issued on basis of employment, 28 are issued to family members of citizens. This is pretty much the inverse of popular understanding of immigration.

There are people that don't understand that the US immigration system is primarily family-based? I think lots of people think the motivation for immigration is largely economic (and that's also true, even for the family-based visas), but I don't recall encountering many people that had any mental model of the immigration system that didn't know that being allowed to immigrate legally was largely through family-based classes. Certainly, much of the public political drama centers around that fact (e.g., the whole "anchor babies" thing.)

(Although "Family sponsored" is not, as you present it, necessarily family-of-citizen -- the family-sponsored grouping includes visa classes for family members of Permanent Residents as well.)

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by Bluestrike2 on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:17PM (#7550602)
People may realize that familial relations can significantly shape immigration process, but they tend to greatly under-estimate the extent.

Immigration is almost always discussed in terms of fairness and, usually, "the line." But the metaphor is a bad one; instead of "the line," it might be better to think of the system as multiple, separate lines that are of varying distances from the destination. And honestly, some of those lines have some nasty obstacles laid out in front of them.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by dragonwriter on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:48PM (#7550716)
> People may realize that familial relations can significantly shape immigration process, but they tend to greatly under-estimate the extent.

I don't see any real evidence that's true, but, maybe it is.

> Immigration is almost always discussed in terms of fairness and, usually, "the line." But the metaphor is a bad one;

It's not really a metaphor at all, its a fairly literal description of the family-sponsored visa system which dominates immigration. At least as it pertains to the countries where immigration demand exceeds per-country quota, where qualified immigrants are literally on a wait list (in some cases one that will take a decade or more to reach them).

And I suspect it dominates the discussion specifically because the family-based part of the immigration system is the one most people know the most about.

> it might be better to think of the system as multiple, separate lines that are of varying distances from the destination.

Well, that would be even a more literal description of the family-sponsored system, since each category of visa has its own quota and queue.

Most of the rest of the immigration system doesn't really consist of lines...

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by pacaro on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:42PM (#7550693)
You're quite correct, “Family sponsored” also contains ‘Second: Spouses, children, and unmarried sons/daughters of alien resident’ which accounts for 96,633 immigrants in 2011, which is nearly half of this category, much larger than I had realized.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by refurb on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:56PM (#7550511)
That's a great point to mention. US immigration policy is heavily biased towards family reunification. If you become a US citizen, you can sponsor your parents and children (if they are under 18) immediately, there is no quota.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by chulk90 on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:45PM (#7550159)
We're discussing high-skilled immigrants. People trying to reach the southern European countries (especially Italy and Greece) or wanting to work in Qatar are a different kind of immigrants.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by thingylab on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:46PM (#7550169)
A pretty solid evidence is the consistently high number of people coming / trying to come to the US each year... Seriously, you wouldn't put up with all that immigration crap if it was not attractive.

> People are dying, literally drowning in the Mediterranean, to get into Europe.

Right. Don't you think that's an indication of proximity rather than attractiveness? (some) People from Africa might be poor and are dying to go some place else, but they're not stupid. They understand crossing the Mediterranean is easier than crossing the Atlantic...

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by balls187 on Monday April 07, 2014 @06:43PM (#7550143)
Humans will seek work wherever there is work to be had.

All that means is that there are jobs in Europe and Qatar.

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by davyjones on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:04PM (#7550802)
> What is that makes the United States such an attractive place to immigrate to for people whose skill sets could take them almost anywhere in the world?

Unrestricted Jus soli (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli#Unrestricted_jus_soli)

Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by serge2k on Monday April 07, 2014 @10:16PM (#7551060)
Well I moved to Seattle from BC because i got offered more money with lower taxes and more interesting job.
Re:US burns through all high-skill visas for 2015 in less th... by foolinaround on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:55PM (#7550500)
the US is reputed to have the best engineering colleges, that attract the best talent.