> For starters, tell us why this is inherently bad.
Deflation, by providing a risk free return for sitting on currency, leads to a slowdown in the real economy by reducing both output (reduced consumption) and productivity (reduced investment).
A fundamental, but slightly tangential question: is that a bad thing?
What if modern societies are running too hot and need to cool down? 'Reduction', 'slowdown', 'productivity loss' -- these are negative in a purely economic context. But economics is a means to an end, not an end in itself. The end, I believe, (to borrow an American term) is the 'pursuit of happiness'. I don't think modern, developed societies are doing very well in that particular pursuit. It feels as if we're on a treadmill -- try to run faster and it turns faster, and you need to keep running faster just to stay on it.
This may not apply to developing societies, who are still grappling with the lower layers of Marslow's hierarchy like food, health and education, but doesn't it seem like we have overshot? When we can afford to obsess over the number of cores or dots per inch on a handheld device, I think we can afford to slow down a bit. Perhaps a deflationary economy is just what we need.
People shouldn't feel pressured to keep producing despite having ample savings just to keep up with the wealth erosion caused by inflation. /opinion
Also: if the Bitcoin unit had been redefined so that the maximum number was 21 quadrillion, we might not have this debate. Nothing's changed fundamentally, but it is a number that for a laymen is a lot closer to infinity than 21 million.
Some people will choose to buy 2x as many t-shirts, making them (roughly) 2x happier. Or some people will buy the same number of t-shirts and have extra money to do other things they want. And most importantly, some people who couldn't afford t-shirts now can. But nobody is forced to chase material goods, they buy what they choose to.
The fact that this process is replicated across virtually all products in the economy is what lifts people out of poverty. We still have plenty of people struggling to make ends meet in the USA, something like half of all people live paycheck-to-paycheck.
The only people who benefit from deflation are those with large amounts of capital and no debt, which is an incredibly small portion of the population that isn't struggling under the current system of low inflation.
I used to worry about this aspect of bitcoin but now I just think, let it happen. Maybe a world in which we aren't forced to consume just to keep our net worth wouldn't be so bad. Maybe we don't need investment in yet another company selling more useless crap we don't need. Maybe we don't need to work five days a week to be happy.
> Some people will choose to buy 2x as many t-shirts, making them (roughly) 2x happier
More choice has been proven to lead to greater dissatisfaction. Aside from better healthcare I don't think our modern world makes us any more happy and fulfilled.
Intentionally slowing economic growth is a cruel sentence for those less fortunate than yourself so that you can be "happy".
So what you're saying is that inflation leads to deflation -- did I get that right?
"Use it or lose it" is a powerful motivator.
1. Money does not have to be fiat money to be inflationary. The government could achieve the same end in a fairer, more controlled manner without deceit simply by issuing a wealth tax, or a currency tax. However this would reveal the robbery too plainly and thus be unpopular. Inflation is an easier way that relies on deceit, sophistry, and obfuscation.
2. The people who benefit the most from inflation are people in government (who can fund themselves without taxing the populace) and banks/borrowers (who can create money to lend without the explicit cooperation of savers.) Neither group engenders sympathy.
3. Saving is a good thing and we need more of it. Many of society's problems can be directly traced to a lack of savings: pensions for the aged need to be provided because people do not save enough during their working years; health care must be provided because people do not save enough to be able to pay for it themselves; and investments must be funded by government because the savings are not available privately. Inflation discourages savings.
4. The wording "risk-free return for sitting on currency" is deceptive, implying that people who can have a risk free return won't work. This is not true and is best illustrated by computer technology which has been undergoing deflation since its inception decades ago. One can simply wait five years and likely be able to obtain today's hot, expensive technology for very little, likely for free. Yet despite this risk-free return for sitting on currency, people still choose to spend on technology they know is depreciating.
5. Contrary to the deception promulgated by those who profit from inflation and by the people who are deceived by them, a deflationary currency would encourage saving and sound investment while discouraging speculation and irresponsibility. For example, rather than allowing venture capitalists to fund risky new ventures with their own money, our inflation-funded government officials use public money to fund politically-connected companies like Solyndra. In a hard-money world, government would be a lot smaller, more focused on providing the services the public actually agrees to pay for, while the general populace would be more responsible and future-oriented, knowing that their savings now will determine their retirement.
For more on this, see the writings of Murry Rothbard, e.g. http://mises.org/daily/1829.
And no, I'm not saying Bitcoin or a return to the Gold Standard is the future, just that it's foolish to think a currency of limited supply "just doesn't work". At one point, it was completely natural and obvious to everyone that the supply of money was and should be limited.
[1] https://philebersole.wordpress.com/2010/11/17/inflation-thro...
Right, Bitcoin wouldn't be deflationary if the economy simply stopped growing.
How is it 'risk free return'? What guarantee is there that the currency will continue deflating?
In the case of Bitcoin, the return would not be risk free. In the long run bitcoins would gain in value at roughly the rate of increase in gross world product. Bitcoins value would fluctuate at least as much as that of a global stock index fund. There would be added volatility due to changes in demand for money.
But what does the "answer" in FAQ say?
Spending energy on creating and securing a free monetary system is hardly a waste. Also, services necessary for the operation of currently widespread monetary systems, such as banks and credit card companies, also spend energy, arguably more than Bitcoin would.*
i.e., nothing really. Not even a back-of-the-envelope estimate of the power densities (either per putative stored value unit, or per transaction volume) of BTC v. fiat currencies. Just a flat assertions like "...is hardly a waste", or "...arguably..."
> At today’s value of roughly $1,000 per bitcoin, the electricity consumed by the bitcoin mining ecosystem has an estimated carbon footprint [...] [of] 0.03 percent of the world’s total greenhouse gas output [...] If bitcoin’s value reaches $100,000, that impact will reach 3 percent of the world’s total [...].
The value of bitcoin is not at all related to the network's energy consumption. It's not even related to the network's hashrate, and even if it was, mining is becoming more and more energy-efficient. It's hard to take the article seriously after this.
Depends on your definition of waste. If you don't value BTC or agree with its crazy libertarian ideals at all then it's a waste by definition. If you can imagine secure crypto-currencies with different characteristics (centralised, controlled supply) then you can make them in a way that doesn't require all this constant make-work, and what's more you can make them support offline transactions and all sorts of other cool stuff.
But that's only if you don't subscribe to libertarian ideals, which I don't.
Well, since you asked: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=why+is+deflation+bad%3F
From your link: "Spending energy on creating and securing a free monetary system is hardly a waste."
This doesn't address any of the arguments brought up in the article Charles linked to: http://pando.com/2013/12/16/bitcoin-has-a-dark-side-its-carb...
>At today’s value of roughly $1,000 per bitcoin, the electricity consumed by the bitcoin mining ecosystem has an estimated carbon footprint – or total greenhouse gas emissions – of 8.25 megatonnes (8,250,000 tonnes) of CO2 per year, according to research by Bitcarbon.org. That’s 0.03 percent of the world’s total greenhouse gas output, or equivalent to that of the nation of Cyprus. If bitcoin’s value reaches $100,000, that impact will reach 3 percent of the world’s total, or that of Germany. At $1 million – which seems farcical but which may not be out of the realm of possibility given the artificially limited bitcoin supply – this impact rises to 8.25 gigatonnes, or 30 percent of today’s global output, and equivalent to that of China and Japan combined.
Can someone explain to me the validity of simply multiplying the value of Bitcoin against its current percentage of world's total greenhouse gas output? How is the carbon footprint of Bitcoin attached to the price of Bitcoin? I don't expect that the recent halving in price caused everyone to pack up their mining rigs and returned carbon emissions to 0.015% of global emissions.
Not to mention this author somehow manages to keep a straight face when arguing that Bitcoin could possibly account for more emissions than China and Japan.
The logic is very simple. If electricity costs X dollars per joule, and freshly-mined bitcoins cost 1.1X or 2X or 5X dollars per joule, there will be vast numbers of people taking advantage of this opportunity for arbitrage and making a huge profit. The exact number depends on the price of mining rigs and how risk-averse people are, but a small multiplier doesn't change the underlying logic.
>I don't expect that the recent halving in price caused everyone to pack up their mining rigs and returned carbon emissions to 0.015% of global emissions.
Most people with marginally profitable equipment would shut it down if the price of bitcoin dropped below the price of electricity. But since mining equipment is expensive and risky and has a large lead time, I'll guess that almost all of them were mining at well over double the cost of electricity, and even after the drop they're still making a profit.
Drop bitcoin to $100 and you'll see only the most efficient chips left running at a trickle of income, with the production of mining rigs roughly as efficient as burning dollar bills for warmth.
Drop it to $20 and everything shuts down, except for people deliberately losing money in an effort to pop up the network.
Edit: added and fixed calculation at the end
I suspect that hash rate will usually keep the electricity needed for mining just slightly over the price of the electricity, with the price differential made up by enthusiasm and expectation of future increased value of mined coins.
Yeah, there are more details in how participation affects the network and how there will probably not be total abandonment, but it's largely irrelevant to the issue of total electrical consumption so I ignored it. And it's more fun to talk about a super-rapid price change capable of destroying bitcoin entirely than a boring slow drop in network capacity.
>future increased value
I did think about mentioning the enthusiastic fools that spend $10 today mining bitcoins they expect to be worth $50 some day, instead of spending $4 just buying the same number of bitcoins. But the bigger the price gets, the more marginal I would expect those people to be. And the more I can pretend the majority of bitcointalk doesn't exist, the better.
I believe it comes from here: http://bitcarbon.org/faq.html
> The Bitcarbon Methodology says that the carbon footprint of the Bitcoin mining network will be proportional to the exchange rate of Bitcoin assuming that 90% of the dollar value of Bitcoin is spent on electricity.
i.e. you're saying that money laundering is already difficult to trace. If I understand bitcoin correctly, it will make that almost impossible. I'm not clear why this is an argument in favour of the currency.
If that's the case why is it seen as (and indeed seem to be) such a great currency for illegal activity?
It's probably the most traceable currency ever. Even amateurs can follow the money trail.
Mixer will just mean that there is no certain way of knowing who's input to the mixer goes to what output. However that can be a bad thing to you, as you can be accused of money laundering especially if you receive money from mixer that also handles something that has been linked to drug money etc.
"Now tell me why didn't you use direct transaction but transferred your flower purchase into a mixer address well known for tax evasion/drug trafficking?"
Someone mixes with you to pay drugs to a silk road advertised wallet -> you could get interrogated and you'd have to reveal as much info as you have on the persons you mixed that particular transaction with.
Or you mix with someone who has not kept their wallet untainted -> they can get interrogated and thus reveal who you are.
Don't get me wrong here. I don't dislike bitcoin. People just tend to give it features that it doesn't have.
What bitcoin is: Awesome solution to the byzantine generals problem. It allows parties that do not trust eachother to verify that someone has exactly the amount of coins he claim to has. Basically it solves the digital equivalent of forged money. A bookkeeping service for parties that do not trust eachother.
What bitcoin is not: Anonymous in any way. Pseudonymous at maximum. Maybe safe to your spouse using techniques like that. Not a way to evade taxes, nor a way to easily facilitate any illegal fund transfers etc. It might be that way now but only because IRS has not put up an unit to analyze it yet. It is not anonymous against adversary with actual resources.
This is of course very much unlike BTC, which has a fixed number of coins at around 21 million.
> If gold goes up in relative value, then that creates a strong incentive for creating more gold mines, which then drives the price down.
Currently it's the same with BTC (higher price creates an incentive for more mining).
> This is of course very much unlike BTC, which has a fixed number of coins at around 21 million.
The idea is that mining rigs should still be useful after the 21 million BTC mark. Unless all BTC markets freeze, the rigs will earn their upkeep in transaction fees. The size of fees is regularly adjusted to make it worth their while.
It's not quite the same, the act of bringing more miners on board does not feed back into the supply chain, it just increases competition for BTC that were going to be mined anyway. There's a missing link there.
>> The size of fees is regularly adjusted to make it worth their while.
The size of the fees is voluntary for the person sending the transaction. We have already seen situations where some pools started leaving some transactions out of their calculations because it wasn't worth their while processing them. As rewards for block discovery drop this will get more common and fees may have to become more generous, or somehow formalised.
A transaction may be safely sent without fees if these conditions are met:
It is smaller than 10,000 bytes.
All outputs are 0.01 BTC or larger.
Its priority is large enough (see the Technical Info section below)
Otherwise, the reference implementation will round up the transaction size to the next thousand bytes and add a fee of 0.1 mBTC (0.0001 BTC) per thousand byte.I'm sure when the time comes something will be worked out, but it is most definitely voluntary rather than an enforced feature. Hell, do a quick google search for "Bitcoin no fees" and you'll find thousands of BTC supporters shouting about how it's so awesome as a payment method because there are no fees!
> For starters, BTC is inherently deflationary.
For starters, tell us why this is inherently bad. This statement also assumes that the BTC economy will grow forever.
> Bitcoin is designed to be verifiable [...] but pretty much untraceable
What would be bad about this if it were true? Paper bills work just fine, even though they are pretty much untraceable. By the way, this opinion is pretty much wrong, bitcoin is very far from being untraceable (IPs, exchanging BTC, etc.)
> Libertarians love it because it pushes the same buttons as their gold fetish
Ok, article is clearly emotional. How did this end up on the front page?
> Mining BTC has a carbon footprint from hell
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#Is_it_not_a_waste_of_energy.3...
> Bitcoin mining software is now being distributed as malware
Surprise. Thieves steal valuable things. This wouldn't happen without BTC, right?
> Bitcoin's utter lack of regulation permits really hideous markets to emerge, in commodities like assassination (and drugs and child pornography).
FINCEN would like a word with you. Also, how does it hurt the USD that it is used for assassination, drugs and child pornography?
It's ok that people hate bitcoin though, some people just let their emotions take control.