I suspect that hash rate will usually keep the electricity needed for mining just slightly over the price of the electricity, with the price differential made up by enthusiasm and expectation of future increased value of mined coins.
Yeah, there are more details in how participation affects the network and how there will probably not be total abandonment, but it's largely irrelevant to the issue of total electrical consumption so I ignored it. And it's more fun to talk about a super-rapid price change capable of destroying bitcoin entirely than a boring slow drop in network capacity.
>future increased value
I did think about mentioning the enthusiastic fools that spend $10 today mining bitcoins they expect to be worth $50 some day, instead of spending $4 just buying the same number of bitcoins. But the bigger the price gets, the more marginal I would expect those people to be. And the more I can pretend the majority of bitcointalk doesn't exist, the better.
The logic is very simple. If electricity costs X dollars per joule, and freshly-mined bitcoins cost 1.1X or 2X or 5X dollars per joule, there will be vast numbers of people taking advantage of this opportunity for arbitrage and making a huge profit. The exact number depends on the price of mining rigs and how risk-averse people are, but a small multiplier doesn't change the underlying logic.
>I don't expect that the recent halving in price caused everyone to pack up their mining rigs and returned carbon emissions to 0.015% of global emissions.
Most people with marginally profitable equipment would shut it down if the price of bitcoin dropped below the price of electricity. But since mining equipment is expensive and risky and has a large lead time, I'll guess that almost all of them were mining at well over double the cost of electricity, and even after the drop they're still making a profit.
Drop bitcoin to $100 and you'll see only the most efficient chips left running at a trickle of income, with the production of mining rigs roughly as efficient as burning dollar bills for warmth.
Drop it to $20 and everything shuts down, except for people deliberately losing money in an effort to pop up the network.
Edit: added and fixed calculation at the end