> If we had, instead, a system where the review process was transparent and persisted for the useful life of a work
That is a very interesting idea. (Reviews are currently confidential and usually anonymous -- only the author and editor sees the reviews, and only the editor knows who wrote them.)
Not only would this reduce blatantly petty reviews, it would also give some recognition to the work that goes into reviewing a paper. It's currently an important but very thankless job. It's considered polite to acknowledge reviewers at the end of the paper (even if they remain anonymous), but it's often not done.
The bottom line is I, as a powerless grad student, am _very_ comfortable with the level of reviewing competence I have witnessed (and been a part of).
The proposal to deanonymize reviews has a huge flaw: Namely, there's no way I (as a grad student with no political power) will write a critical review of somebody famous if I know I won't remain anonymous.
The risk of blowback is too damn high. (And given the small pool, writing style would probably be sufficient to deanonymize, if my entire trail of reviews were public). There's no way I have the balls to write a critical review of a paper by, say, Robert Morris or Larry Peterson, for some prestigious venue such as SOSP, when I'm asked to write a review. Unless I know for sure that there's absolutely no risk whatsoever of being identified.
Look. Reviewing is thankless and hard. Anonymity exists so that we can be critical and not risk career suicide. Last year at OSDI I received 9 reviews, and they were all exemplarily thoughtful, even the obligatory "strong reject" one of them. The problem of "petty reviews" _has_ a solution: The program committee is self policing, and the reviews are not anonymous within the PC. (For example, at SOSP this year, there are 28 PC members.) You know that most of your reviews come from this gang of 28. You might have one or two externally solicited experts in addition, but that too is not anonymous _to the PC members_. If there's a culture of meanness, the PC members and PC chairs can fix this by internal policing (and they do).
Essentially, anonymous experts review publications in much the manner they do now, with no risk of their identities being revealed. A separate set of review-reviewers then rates the publication-reviewers themselves, scoring them on a standardized quantitative scale (1-10) based on the validity of their claims and the depth of their assessment. In this manner, experts collect an "aggregate reviewer rating" of sorts analogous to an h-index [2], call it an R-index.
This R-index can then serve to select accurate reviewers for future publications. A high R-index could also be included as a positive bullet point on a CV, providing some reward for reviewers to put a high degree of effort into their otherwise unrewarded reviewing work.
A few potential flaws are evident: what is one to do if early reviews are scored poorly, and you are no longer able to provide new reviews to increase your R-index? A grace period before scoring could potentially remedy this, ie) an R-index is not assigned until a reviewer has written >10 reviews.
[1] - http://www.frontiersin.org/Computational_Neuroscience/10.338... [2] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H-index
But basically existing program committees (in computer science) do serve that meta-moderation purpose (without the empirical R-index metric). The entire PC does get to see the deanonymized reviews of the other program committee members. If someone's just being an unhelpful jerk, they're probably not going to get invited back in the future.
I completely agree that there's a lot value in anonymity when reviewing, and I don't think it should go away. Blowback over disagreeing is very, very real, and I've experienced it myself (though it was from presenting something at a conference that disagreed with part of a previous publication, rather than as a result of a review).
However, I do think public and optionally non-anonymous reviews could be helpful.
(Incidentally, you had _9_ reviewers for a single publication?? Holy cow... In the geosciences, I've never heard of more than 3, and it's usually only 2. That's one thing that would really help in my field. More reviewers results in a broader review, rather than a particular person's pet peeve.)
Incidentally, I have deanonymized several reviews already. When you go to conferences, and some researcher asks the exact same question and has the exact same opinion as reviewer C, chances are... Sometimes the recognition is mutual as they realize what they just revealed (thankfully that has only resulted in humorous chuckles, at least in my life. But I can see how it can go wrong so easily!)
I do know that I have received many cursory reviews where the reviewer did not fully read the paper. I have often wondered if single-blind the other way would be better: reviewer signs their name, but paper authors are anonymous. While this may fix the crappy review problem, it is susceptible to what you fear.
I would hope that those cursory reviewers resulted in feedback from the other PC members that fix the issue (either through improved future reviews, or not being invited back to be on the PC.)
This is not entirely true. I've talked with several people involved in research (math and CS). The ideal is that only the editor knows who wrote the reviews. However many fields do not have that many people who are qualified to review cutting edge results. This means that it is possible to get an idea of who your reviewer is based on how he wrote. Of course, although the people I talked to said they often can figure out who reviewed them, they cann't actually confirm that they are right (and I definitely cannot).
I've always advocated that the reviews behind an accepted paper SHOULD all be public and publicly distributed along with the paper.
I hear so much about how researchers provide papers to journals for free, and review papers for journals for free, and then the journals (are presumably evil to) charge high fees to anyone who wants to read the papers. How much can we pile on the reviewers before they stop doing it?
Note that IMHO is OK to be anonymous while refusing a paper because otherwise a reviewer may be put under lot of pressure.
I think you're spot on with this comment. That's exactly what we're building at publons.com. Check it out.
If a paper claims a significant result, it will eventually get tested.
If it claims an insignificant result, it might never get tested. That's ok, little harm done because it is insignificant.
I recognize that, in many ways, physics has it easy: there are few sciences that reduce as well as it does and that offer ways to isolate variables like it does (even if it requires multi-billion dollar machines and years to make that happen). But it is still a shining exemplar of gradual evidence building theories to find more evidence, and there are many, many fields that aren't anywhere near that.
Not to mention that research is all about who comes in first; the incentive to validate published work is by and large not there. I recall a Nature article on data reproducibility: only 11% of the TOP, PEER-REVIEWED PAPERS were able to be reproduced[1].
[1] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v483/n7391/full/483531a...
Skepticism is at the very core of science.
Partly to blame are the "non-fiction/science&nature" book category, and the journalist/writer cross-breed who chain-write in newspapers, magazines and churn out books from their articles every year.
At first, the really good ones were a welcome addition to Science literature, for bringing the science to our daily lives. But then they became part of the "where it bleeds, it leads" culture, sans proper journalism and sans scientific thought.
Scientists may make fun of how journal articles are covered in newspapers and blogs, but the negative effects of such coverage are quite real.
I feel all these debates are kind of pointless, because no-one I know treats a published article as gospel. We make up our own minds about the paper.
Wait, maybe they do understand but they also understand that the general public doesn't understand.
In my experience it's more like: Most scientists ignored it. Others were interested but had too much teaching to pay attention to it. A few people got pissed off and tried to prove it wrong. A few other people got excited and tried to build on it.
Most scientists I know (physics) don't have this idea. They know publication is just a step. Most grad students learn at some point that just because it's published doesn't mean it's correct.
Publication is a checkpoint, not a finish line, for any theory or experimental result.