Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by tigroferoce on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:51AM
(#6494531)
Good point. But it is a key point that making reviews is part of your job as researched and you MUST take it very seriously. I received so many reviews poorly written, just few lines saying "OK for me". I really think that this way of reviewing is wrong. Reviewers should take care in their job and they should be ready to face a public discussion on why they decided to accept a paper.
Note that IMHO is OK to be anonymous while refusing a paper because otherwise a reviewer may be put under lot of pressure.
Note that IMHO is OK to be anonymous while refusing a paper because otherwise a reviewer may be put under lot of pressure.