Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by colechristensen on Thursday October 03, 2013 @04:10PM
(#6491645)
You're absolutely correct, scientists don't suffer from any misconception that publishing equals truth. The general public, on the other hand, has little understanding of this.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by GrumpySimon on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:40PM
(#6493423)
Absolutely. I see peer review as a way of - hopefully - filtering out the most egregious crap, and fixing the worst errors in papers while rounding them off.
I feel all these debates are kind of pointless, because no-one I know treats a published article as gospel. We make up our own minds about the paper.
Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by talmand on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:11PM
(#6492079)
Nor do the reporters and/or editorials that cite such peer-reviewed papers that agree with their opinions.
Wait, maybe they do understand but they also understand that the general public doesn't understand.
Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by GrumpySimon on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:43PM
(#6493433)
I think this is an artefact of how science is taught: In 1953 Watson and Crick published a paper on the structure of DNA. Everyone smiled and nodded.
In my experience it's more like: Most scientists ignored it. Others were interested but had too much teaching to pay attention to it. A few people got pissed off and tried to prove it wrong. A few other people got excited and tried to build on it.