Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by thaumasiotes on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:38PM
(#6493587)
This is definitely a benefit to the readers, and potentially (though not definitely) to the community as a whole. However, it's much worse for the reviewers.
I hear so much about how researchers provide papers to journals for free, and review papers for journals for free, and then the journals (are presumably evil to) charge high fees to anyone who wants to read the papers. How much can we pile on the reviewers before they stop doing it?
Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by tigroferoce on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:51AM
(#6494531)
Good point. But it is a key point that making reviews is part of your job as researched and you MUST take it very seriously. I received so many reviews poorly written, just few lines saying "OK for me". I really think that this way of reviewing is wrong. Reviewers should take care in their job and they should be ready to face a public discussion on why they decided to accept a paper.
Note that IMHO is OK to be anonymous while refusing a paper because otherwise a reviewer may be put under lot of pressure.
I've always advocated that the reviews behind an accepted paper SHOULD all be public and publicly distributed along with the paper.