Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by seanmcdirmid on Friday October 04, 2013 @12:28AM
(#6493709)
You might only get 9 reviews though if you pass into the second or third rounds. Controversial papers in the PL conferences I haunt will get more reviews out of necessity; better to add more reviewers to help break ties.
Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by arjunnarayan on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:21AM
(#6495848)
Yes. According to the OSDI 2012 proceedings introduction, all papers in the third round had 9 reviews. No paper was accepted or rejected with less than 51% of the PC member's assent.
Re:The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
by seanmcdirmid on Friday October 04, 2013 @01:20PM
(#6496642)
That is good and bad, it definitely skews toward safe non controversial papers.
Incidentally, I have deanonymized several reviews already. When you go to conferences, and some researcher asks the exact same question and has the exact same opinion as reviewer C, chances are... Sometimes the recognition is mutual as they realize what they just revealed (thankfully that has only resulted in humorous chuckles, at least in my life. But I can see how it can go wrong so easily!)