Right, well, that's the problem. Google wants to unify their services, but I don't want to use the thereby unified services, which are, after all, conceptually distinct anyway.
The complaint is that they're trying to unify their services. The explanation, when faced with that complaint, that they're trying to unify their services is a non-starter.
I mean, I'm sorry you feel that way. But it's an indefensible position.
Most users would send as emails to others the kinds of things they leave as comments on youtube?
Google reads my GMails from major airlines, and shows me when my next flight is when I Google Search for "when is my next flight". The flight also just pops up on Google Now on my Android phone. It also knows where I am, and where the airport is, so it tells me how long it will take to drive there.
When I Google search for La Cucaracha on my desktop, when I walk out to my car and look at my phone, it automatically suggests Navigating to La Cucaracha.
When I Subscribe to a YouTube video, it automatically shows up in my GMail as a feed.
I find value in these things, and I'm sorry you don't.
Well then good for you, and you should be able to merge all your accounts with Google into one; but why should this be almost compulsory?
What's more, if there's so much value into this, why does Google have to force its users to do it?
Quite often here on Hacker News we sit around and talk about how removing features or options from an App is often the best thing to do for usability. I think this is true. At the same time every time this comes up with regards to Google or some other large company the response flips around completely.
Ultimately I think the readership here is just the 10% of users that want the option, exactly the group we often say that should be ignored for the overall good of the product.
It's Google becoming more and more mainstream. It's Lowest Common Denominator Google.
Every revision, something else is gone. Another menu is missing, another option.
After scouring enough Google Support forums, tinkering in enough settings and trying enough workarounds, it's the only solution I can come to.
Google isn't the hacker search engine we fell in love with over a decade ago.
It's an advertising company looking to monetize on a user's lack of privacy to help connect them with advertisers. Adwords is 99% of their business. We can't just ignore that forever.
The lowest common denominator of user is the the type of user is probably most susceptible not controlling their privacy well enough and for Google being able to target them widely. How much does Google really care about us ad-block toting hacker types anyway?
Not happy with the options in there service, use something diffrent.
So you want your every identity online to be tied together? Your usenet posts to alt.sex.hello-kitty, your responses to ads on Craigslist, your interactions with old friends on facebook, your interactions with professional contacts on linkedin (if you use it), your interactions on some neighborhood blog, your political commentary on some political blog, whatever?
After all, if you were describing all of them, you'd use the word "I"!
Or do you acknowledge that there's clearly a balance of benefit and pain, and Google is merely slightly to the wrong side of where you'd want them to be?
The frustration comes from removing the option of customizing my profile for each service.
Banana72...? Oh, right, on YouTube VikingCoder is called Banana72.
I think you're asking for a feature which would confuse the hell out of most users.
I managed to find a decent looking study that somewhat supports my position [1]. Here's an interesting quote from the abstract:
"many (40%) were hesitant to consent to the release of their personal profile information; and (6) many (36%) ex- pressed concern with the use of SSO on websites that contain valuable personal information or, conversely, are not trust- worthy. We also found that with an improved affordance and privacy control, more than 60% of study participants would use Web SSO solutions on the websites they trust."
[1] https://cups.cs.cmu.edu/soups/2011/proceedings/a4_Sun.pdf
This is a very important discussion -- I'd love to see some papers that study the benefits of a single login / profile, rather then the negatives.
How people say they will act, and how they act, are completely different animals.
I think he had a Group Youtube channel. He logged in using his individual account onto his Group Youtube channel and it linked his individual G+ to the group Youtube. When he unlinked this, it disable his Group Youtube.
I think this is pretty serious stuff. If youtube allows you to group individual accounts, then you dont want to link a group channel to an individual account. I think thats the concerns being raised here.
Ultimately, do you agree with the direction, and can you forgive them for the missteps?
I mean, how many times was "re-install Microsoft Windows, and all of your applications" the only option?
I get that it's painful for some people, and I don't mean to diminish that. But my God, this guy wasted an entire afternoon on configuring his free service.</sarcasm>
The OP is merely expressing what a lot of people are experiencing, and not just technical people. I know plenty of non-technical people who avoid mainstream Google because it's like "getting a passport" and "signing over your life" just to upload a video.
The user experience of being part of YouTube is crap. The barrier to entry is too heavily weighted towards "registration" and "validation" rather than just having fun and joining something fun.
Email is NOT related to Youtube, not by any stretch. So you get emamiled when someone posts a video? Wow, that really is lame. That notification could happen a million different ways, including an email to your Yahoo email address.
Google forces completely different services to be connected. It's no longer possible to rate a video out of 5 unless you have a Google+ account. It's no longer possible to have a Google+ account unless you provide Google your mobile phone number and access to all your contacts, etc etc.
Youtube was once a cool service for YOU, US. Now it's a service for "content partners" and YOU/WE are permitted to join in, provided that certain commercially motivated conditions are met. That's crap. It's like a movie cinema denying entry unless you wear a (free) t-shirt advertising their cinema. VikingCoder would say "hey, it's a free t-shirt, what are you complaining about". Well, I just want to watch a film, I do not want to be locked into the Cinema's desperate social media marketing eco-system.
Navigating to La Cucaracha, i.e., literally to The Cockroach?
Is there really a place called La Cucaracha? I would have expected Google to show ads for exterminator services or maybe a link to a YouTube video featuring the La Cucaracha song … ;)
I've always wondered how Chi-Chi's stayed in business, BTW.
It's the attempt to push Google+ on me that I dislike.
Where do you draw the line? GMail, Calendar, Drive, Contacts, YouTube, Google+, Android, Chrome, Voice, Hangouts? Should they all have different sign-ons?
Is Google forbidden from integrating signons for all future companies it acquires?
It is the unification of user profiles that is causing all the uproar.
Just to clarify, I am making a distinction between being able to sign into a Youtube profile with a Google account and forcing the same profile across all Google properties.
Judging from my preferences, and based on my (limited) anecdotes, it seems that users appreciate the convenience of single-signin solutions, as long as each property they are signing into has a profile that can be managed separately.
Forbidden, yes; held hostage by their users for all the free platforms they provide in exchange for all the theoretical dollars they generate in page views
If you used a single site for gmail, youtube and G+, integrating it all into a single service, then you'd have a point. But they're different sites, different services. It's nice if you can use a single account for them all, and if it's easy to move content from one to the other, but that's not the same thing.
In UX discussions this always comes up as one that sucks.
Basically the Google UX, to me, is "Here's a bunch of stuff that we have. Good luck!"
They need to seriously put the unifying UX of their entire brand from end-to-end as their top priority, so that you go to Google and can actually use what they offer in a cohesive way, instead of with piecemeal walled-off divisions of inconsistency.
It's a huge problem to be sure, and there's no easy solution. This blog post is just a description of one annoying symptom.
Meanwhile, what Google thinks of as good UX these days is removing features from their already minimal individual products. See: New Maps; Gmail New Compose. Their priorities are upside-down and I have no confidence they can turn their ship around...
The core of the Google UI at the moment is: "Hey, move your mouse around the screen or just click somewhere and maybe something useful will slide out from where we've hidden it!"
I exaggerate, but only slightly....
If anything, you're understating the frustration of the new GMail compose UI. My browser window hasn't gotten any smaller, but the amount of important information displayed at any given time by GMail continues to decrease.
"Oh, you don't really need to see who you're sending this e-mail to, nor could you possibly care whether they're a To:, CC:, or BCC:, so we'll just hide them all behind a single line."
"While we're at it, we'll make you use your mouse to see what formatting and linking options are available. Never mind that they're always in the same place, we just feel like hiding them from you, you know, to watch your mouse squirm!"
"As an added bonus, we'll move the cursor back to the top of your composed text when our silly algorithm decides to unhide the quoted text! For free!"
> Never mind that they're always in the same place
Except sometimes they're not. Select an email and "More" shoots over from being the third item in the menu bar to being the seventh.
Then there's "Archive" which can either have its own button or magically appear as a dropdown menu item. And so on.
Drives me crazy....
The real problem is that the elimination of privacy that Google has so meticulously pursued has left their communities dull and idol, producing poor quality and non-stimulating content.
Now I am going to think twice about upvoting that crazy youtube video, and something more mild will take its place in the rank hierarchy?
What happened to the cool internet?
Even with the new rating system, the comments on Youtube are the best example of human stupidity.
Why should the entire planet know where I like to eat? Where I live? What I do in my spare time with apps? What my hobbies are? This is a massive privacy loss, and thus I don't review anything on google's platform.
Anonymous reviews have value, even if they are more susceptible to being gamed.
... just sucks to have the soda can burst out because you know, my freezer is integrated in the washer. And my nexus battery now weights 100Ton. But thankfully LG will buy some small truck brand and solve that too!
...sounds retarded, but that's how I see what's google is doing. A total lack of connection to who uses their services and with common sense. All their services more or less already worked like this, with open APIs and decent standardized integration. but they decided to move away from it and use g+ as the glue. which they are probably sniffing.
That's silly. If they wanted to unify their services, they'd turn youtube channels into G+ profiles. And they'd do it without any hassle for the users.
I'm sorry, but it's obvious that Google is desperately trying to inflate their G+ profile numbers by any means they can devise, because they won't admit to themselves that they've already lost the social network battle to FB. No amount of being apologetic and spin-doctoring can make this less obvious.
This if anything would inflate G+ profile numbers more.
I'm a homosexual, and living in a very conservative and homophobic part of France. I don't want any things related to homosexuality and the lgbt community posted under my real identity, because then any member of my family or any of my friends could stumble upon it and make problematical deductions.
Does that mean that I shouldn't be involved online in the lgbt community whatsoever, because it's not something my relatives support?
Another fairly easy counter-example would be the one of an anonymous online political activist. I don't get people who support that kind of arguments.
Anonymity is difficult for naïve people to understand: that what you say, online or offline, can at any point in the future (potentially indefinitely) may arbitrarily be used against you in familial, legal, political, business, personal, romantic or any other context. This amounts to individuals unwittingly manufacturing ammunition and handing it to their enemies.
It's a nice ideal, but I think being anonymous is going to die in the next five years -- if it hasn't already.
Because there are so many other people out there that might be up to no good, so many laws (US commercial code, anyone) that an individual will create so much digital dirt over their lifetime, it becomes very easy to attack anyone that does not just keep most things private as a best practice. It's nearly impossible to know which digital bits will be at some point in the future X years taken out of context for political, employment, romantic, legal or other purposes.
"Three Felonies a Day" https://mailman.stanford.edu/pipermail/liberationtech/2013-J...
But there is a world between refusing anon, and suddenly and posteriorly displaying the real name of people on top of content they thought was anonymous. I don't claim to be particularly smart but if their popup was unclear for me, I can't imagine how it is for people who are less tech literate.
Real Names was protested to death the moment that Google+ came out; my understanding is that their compromise was that your entire Google profile was to use the same name, but that name could be a pseudonym so long as it was realistic. (If your legal name was weird, well, too bad, send in some ID.)
There's nothing we can do about this now, whining about it on HN. Choose to stop using YouTube, switch to a new account with a pseudonym, use Vimeo instead, start your own.
What I'm saying is that YouTube is a terrible place to have a lgbt community. Most of the closed-garden Internet is a terrible place to have a lgbt community, because all it takes is Zuck or Brin or some other "benevolent" dictator deciding to reveal all your secrets, and you're dead.
Like, there was that girl who was disowned by her parents once Facebook made group memberships public on profiles, because she happened to be part of a lgbt group at her university.
You're putting a hell of a lot of trust in Google or Facebook over what is, for you, a life-or-death situation.
Choose a community where people only use pseudonyms, and which isn't driven by corporate profits.
Edit: Also, a "anonymous" online political activist is going to live a miserable life; look at Snowden and Manning and Assange. You can't even send stuff to the newspapers any more without angry people coming to destroy your hard drives.
G+ doesn't really need propping up, most of the people I enjoy reading are on it, I get more engagement than I ever did on Twitter or FB with the people I'm interested in (note, not friends, but interests), and with a less infuriating comment system. I'd personally rather not have G+ turn into FB.
In fact, I take back my first sentence, now that I think about it, I'm somewhat fearful of YouTube adopting G+ comments, because rather than improving the civility and intelligence of YouTube's comment audience, it might destroy the civility and intelligence of the G+ community.
One could argue two ways here. On one hand I think it's actually interesting and instructive to read comments from anonymous sources - what people "really" think, without the filter of being tied to their real identity. On the other hand, there are countless examples of people proudly posting/tweeting/etc horribly sexist, racist, insulting, and idiotic things under their real names along with a profile picture of themselves, so it's not so clear that removing anonymity will transform the comments section into a particularly erudite and informative place.
Without my prompting, and after already indicating that I didn't want a Google+ account for my work account, Google displayed a distracting notification that I should add people to my (work) Google+ account, the account that I didn't create and definitely didn't want.
Sometimes I don't want to use any of those five other services. And if I happen to watch some YouTube videos at work from time to time, I don't really want those to be associated with my Google Apps work account.
So no, it is not a mistake to view it as Google forcing me to use social features that I don't want; that's exactly what it is!
I mean, I love G+, and my YouTube account now also sports my G+ avatar, but it's obvious that that kind of integration isn't for everyone.
There are older examples of problems with G+ integration: a year ago or so, G+ had that stupid "normal name" policy, and people who used an unusual name had their G+ account blocked. And if your G+ account was tied to a GMail account, that was also blocked. But if you only had a GMail account without G+, Google didn't complain if your name was unusual.
The main thing that sort of stuff accomplishes, is that it gives people a good reason not to use G+.
I don't regard that as grounds for anti-trust, but I do view it as ridiculous. And it's equally ridiculous for Google to try to trip users into using their other services by leveraging their overwhelmingly dominant search and video products. It'll be interesting to see if Google eventually claims that you can't separate G+ from YouTube and search, going down the same conceptual road as MS.
Microsoft had to rewrite the IE3 browser into components, and this componentization was very popular at the time. It won Microsoft a huge deal with AOL and meant ISPs could customize IE (which Netscape wouldn't allow), which also contributed to IE's victory over Netscape Navigator.
In the end, Microsoft won the browser case by 2-1 on appeal, and the US Justice Department lost it.
It's nothing like the Google case.
Ditto for sharing and contacts. You had separate 'contacts' in Gmail, Latitude, G+, Reader, YouTube, and probably others I'm missing. Users shouldn't be prompted to maintain N different copies of this information and manage it in confusing ways.
It's a mistake to view this as "they're forcing me to use the G+ social stream". It's more "they're consolidating my 5 different profiles and authentication credentials across services."
Google could axe the social stream and this would still make sense.