He is using Maltodextrin for carbs. It likely contains Glutamic Acid and has a horrible glycemic index. You might as well eat sugar. I don't know what he is using for protein; but, I guarantee it sucks. The correct approach would be to use cross flow microfiltered whey protein because it retains all of the essential amino acids. It's also as expensive as Greenwise/Whole Foods chicken. Cheaper methods tend to lose certain essential amino acids.
Another issue is the absence of toxins. Believe it or not, consuming the toxins contained in whole foods makes us more robust. There is actual research that has analyzed these effects.
This is similar to the phenomenon where children who grow up desperately poor and literally living in dirt have a markedly lower rate of autoimmune diseases than first world kids.
The same dose delivered fast does much more damage than the dose delivered slowly.
At least that's the theory. The NRC works on the principle that the speed doesn't matter - it's just the cumulative that counts.
It's not a settled matter, although the research does seem to point in that direction.
It might also cripple you instead.
http://www.truenutrition.com/p-1100-whey-protein-isolate-cfm... <-- 11.89/lb
Per gram of protein, this is far cheaper than organic chicken.
http://www.truenutrition.com/p-947-whey-protein-isolate-cold...
If you're willing to try Cold Filtration, you can purchase it for $9.40/lb.
This doesn't include the 5% off coupons that TN has year round. (AND028 is my personal one.)
You can get all the right vitamins and minerals. On that note, don't use calcium carbonate like he does unless you want kidney stones; use calcium citrate.
You can get high quality CFM whey protein assuming you're okay with getting all your protein from whey (grilled chicken is still a better idea for other reasons).
However, the carbs take up a lot of volume. You can use steel cut oats, potatoes, sweet potatoes, white rice... (brown rice has arsenic) You will find that it doesn't fit well in the shake. It's easier to eat it as food. My experience so far anyway...
I started doing it because I really hate cooking. I don't even want to boil water for five minutes in the morning to make oatmeal. I don't use it for any kind of super-shake or full meal replacement, but that and some fruit for breakfast seems to work for me pretty well.
Hopefully I'm not unknowingly totally killing myself, heh.
[0] http://www.amazon.com/Bobs-Red-Mill-Gluten-22-Ounce/dp/B003L...
Mind you, I really enjoy eating my food and am not looking for a shortcut to "just get nutrients".
Experiments have been done with mannose to try and recover a genetic disorder where the bio-availability of mannose has been impaired. A kid was fed with mannose in what was assumed to be the right amount of the correct monosaccharide. Turns out he ends up having a toxic reaction to the mannose, even though it goes part-way to curing his particular disease.
I know researchers in this area that don't eat red meat because they're worried about the incorporation of particular sugars into their body that are not natively found in humans. I never really understood why I looked down on biology when I was younger. It's one of the most complex and intriguing problem spaces in the world, and well worth investing your time (on the order of decades) to try and figure something out.
I expected Rob to run longer and more detailed trails than it appears he has. As in a few hundred people eating nothing but Soylent for a year.
There will be problems with the initial manufacture, and he highlights them in the risks section. But I notice the lack of anyone from say a pharma QC background who would be able to control the risk of overdosing on an ingredient by properly testing the batches during production. Maybe the production facility have the skills to do that?
Within a year, whatever can go wrong probably will have. Either they will be in a lot of trouble, or it will be pretty safe to buy (and a huge achievement). I guess you could say the same for coinbase.
NOTE:
The OP was behaving badly, but was desperately well motivated. He provided a useful link where a food scientist rubbishes Soylent - http://www.businessinsider.com/rob-rhinehart-food-substitute...
One of the things which has interested me about this whole affair since it was first posted was the reactions of people who put timeframes on their interest "I'll be interested to see what happens after a month", "...after three months", "...after a year", "...after a decade". I wonder at what point people are going to say "well ok, that's long enough, I've seen enough".
I think this is interesting from the point of view of someone who doesn't enjoy cooking most of the time and most of the stuff I cook when I'm in work mode is probably deficient nutritionally. I also think as a portable, storable and efficient food source the potential is pretty amazing, and I don't think the fact he's not a biochem or nutrition guy is an excuse to ignore the principle of what he's trying to do here. I would definitely like to see some more critical appraisal (and there certainly seems to be some in some of the comments here).
Why will it be a huge achievement?
Most of it's demo will eat it about 50% of the time, eating conventional instant meals and restaurant foods the rest. If it's healthier, or at least different from 'mostly eating microwave lasagne', it should improve their health.
Also, I see it as a great way to control calories. I don't have a weight problem, but most people I do just eat huge portions and snacks. Measuring out powder will help them.
But that's if the guy who eats it all year doesn't lose a kidney month number 9 because they added too much Vitamin A and call his lawyer.
No, he's produced something people can eat for a year without great ill effect in that year.
You can very likely smoke cigarettes for a year without ill effect. That tells you next to nothing about its long-term effects.
Most people eat huge portions and snacks for the physical pleasure the underlying food brings, not because they rationally think "I need huge portions to get my minimum daily intake of carbs/fats/vitamins".
Thinking that people with a weight problem will switch to a flavorless white goop it's just not realistic.
As I say, I'm waiting a year before having anything to do with this. But I hope it is okay. Because I'd like the product, but also because someone will eat it for a year now.
Have you eaten any food today? I assume you have or intend to. How many scientists did you consult before you did so? If it was none, then you haven't done your due diligence, and you're a fool. It's harsh to say so, but it's your own fault if you suffer ill-health through your laziness and stupidity.
You're willing to dismiss everyone as being fools for not taking the time to do what you're proposing, yet you won't do what you're proposing and post the results.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Size_Me
I thought we were lovers of Science on this site? I thought we believed in testing claims through evidence, not some slick marketing video.
The founder has blogged in detail about the evolution of the recipe and effects on his body, http://robrhinehart.com/ (site currently appears to be down).
It's not science.
I'm disappointed to see that blog -which mean people correctly pointed out is not scientifically useful- is being used to sell this product.
That sounds like a pretty reasonable argument to me. Pointing out that the soylent proponent's "evidence" does not stand up to scientific scrutiny does not sound like "argument from authority".
1) Have some (at least one) long term, large cohort, controlled studies proving the efficacy of this diet.
2) Be someone I can trust with being careful and honest with your scientific method over a long period of time.
So saying that you shouldn't trust some mixture put together by some computer programmers in their 20's is just a shortcut to the the two statements above. He (assuming gender here) was absolutely right in his assertion.
Why don't you summarize them here, and ask if the people behind Soylent have utilized them?
"Is it safe? We have been testing Soylent on ourselves for several months and the data shows it to have a positive nutritional benefit."
The well established, scientific method is a double-blind clinical trial, in which neither patient nor investigator know whether the patient is receiving the substance being tested or the control substance.
The founder claims he is healthier than when he started. That's confirmation bias. We have no way of telling because this "experiment" is not at all scientific. When he started and people pointed out just how hopeless the experiment was we were told to shut up and let him get on with it because it was only him being affected and if he wanted to do it let him go ahead. But now we see the problem - that hopeless experiment is being used to sell this product.
I can point you to a range of crack pots who claim their supplement makes them feel much better. One example is all the blue people with colloidal silver. (Do a Google Images search for [colloidal silver] to see.)
You only need common sense to realise that this single product cannot be safe for everyone.
What type of flour does it contain? They say it's hypo-allergenic, so it shouldn't have any gluten in.
God, you are just embarrassing yourself now. Please just stop.
Actually, he's not. He's presenting an argument. You're presenting a personal attack.
What's distressing is that you're being upvoted for it.
Because I'm right, and he's wrong. For fuck's sake, everyone on here needs to educate themselves about the basics of nutrition before commenting on something they don't understand.
What you have here is a bunch of 20-something coders, most of whom don't know jack shit about cooking or biology but wish they didn't have to think about cooking so they could spend more time working on their Rails or iPhone apps, getting excited that one of their own has "disrupted" a new industry.
In reality, it's just another example of the blind leading the blind. But failures in the food industry don't just end with a site shutting down and some commenters on HN complaining about losing their favorite service while some others explain why it didn't survive. They can end with people in the hospital or in the grave.
Why not educate people, rather than call them wrong?
The reasons you're not being convincing are:
- you attack based on age.
- you attack based on lack of credentials.
- you attack based on the idea that someone might get hurt, when you don't have any evidence Soylent is dangerous.
- your entire tone is one of talking down to your audience.
If your arguments had substance, you wouldn't need to resort to any of that.
http://www.businessinsider.com/rob-rhinehart-food-substitute...
> you attack based on the idea that someone might get hurt, when you don't have any evidence Soylent is dangerous
It's like talking to a brick wall. How many times do I have to tell you? The burden of proof is on the people making Soylent. You can't just apologize after the fact, when people are already in the hospital.
Or, to reach more into our own history, they're the modern snake oil.
You'll need to post some sort of citation in order to convince anyone of that.
Is This the End of Popping Vitamins?, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405297020464450457665...
“From a practical standpoint, this study does not change the fact that the majority of consumers could benefit from taking an affordable multivitamin,” said Andrew Shao, vice president of scientific and regulatory affairs with the council. “It is better to meet these recommendations than not, and consistently taking a multivitamin over the long term could help fill these nutrient gaps and may help consumers lead healthier lives.”
The article ended with a conclusion from the study's author:
Dr. Neuhouser said she realizes that many people who are devoted vitamin users will be skeptical of the finding that they are receiving no benefit from a daily multivitamin.
“I don’t want to disparage people who take multivitamins — it’s their choice as a consumer,” Dr. Neuhouser said. “What we’re presenting is the science showing it’s neither beneficial nor harmful. If they want to choose to spend their dollars elsewhere this might be a good place to do so. Perhaps they can buy more fruits and vegetables.”
My take-away from these studies is that unless you have a vitamin deficiency, taking multivitamins does nothing. And if you have a specific vitamin deficiency, then you may be better off just taking supplementation of that vitamin; a general multivitamin will only help because it happens to contain what you are deficient in.
If there's no benefit on average, then there's no reason to recommend on average (disclaimer: I take a chewy multivitamin because I remember being convinced by evidence that manganese is a bad thing to supplement, and most multivitamins have 2mg of it).
A multivitamin doesn't work in the role that this is used marketed for, so...
Think about "junk dna", and the underlying culture that end up creating it as an idea: "this does not appear to do anything, must be junk". The key take away for me is that we simply are underestimating what we do not know about the world, dislike labeling things as unknown, and can financially benefit from applying simplifying assumptions on an industrial scale.
So I'd take these formidable claims with a huge grain of salt.
More importantly, I fail to see what's new with the idea of powder / shake food. This shit has been around.
He is healthier than when he started? By what metric and for how long will that last?
It's none of the things that we get from food that we haven't identified as important, or that this dude didn't think were sufficiently important to include, or anything else along those lines. He's repeatedly had to adjust his formula to account for deficiencies he's discovered in his glop along the way.
Do you honestly think he's done ironing [1] out the kinks in his forumla?
[1] Deliberate phrasing: one of the things he missed was iron. Can you even begin to trust the nutritional knowledge of someone who missed something as basic as iron?
Um, so is food. All food.
Do you have any idea how many chemical reactions happen when you make and cook food? Have you studied each and every chemical reaction?
PS. I'm not trying to say this is a good idea. But complaining it's bad because it's "chemicals" is ridiculous. Read this thread - there are plenty of well reasoned arguments against it.
Your use of the word "chemicals" is naive and on par with those silly chain emails that go around every few years warning of dihydrogen monoxide.
What is food if not chemicals?
Food Scientists are people who research food that is already on the market.. (or in the best case research food that is about to be put in the market by a high profile food processor with money to spare, but in that case they don't have your best interest in mind, just that you don't die immediately)
Plenty of pseudoscientific snake oil products get sold for decades without research and evidence behind it. Colon cleanses, homeopathy, etc.
What the heck are snake oils? I've never heard of that.
http://www.nestlenutritionstore.com/departments/therapeutic-...
Nor are either of them biochemistry, a subject considerably more complicated than optics or basic electro-magnetism.
Yes, and that is a physical system which has very clear delineated results. Hypothesis: Might burn down houses. Did any houses burn down over a 5 year period? Y/N?
Biology is way more complicated than that. There are many more possible outcomes, and its not as simple as "am i healthier now or not?"
> he's doing a lot of research, experimenting
Oh, is he? Where's his data? What's the statistical significance of his results?
This is pure hubris! This idea has been pursued for decades by people who have dedicated themselves to scientific rigour.
I'll say it again. The founders of Soylent have Engineer's Disease. They think because they're engineers they're experts in food science. That's delusional.
Surely you are intelligent enough to realize that this is not a serious attempt at fixing anybody's "food crisis", and rather it's a convenience product aimed at affluent Westerners? I mean, disregarding that $65/week is higher than the average income in many parts of the world -- and far more than roughly 50% of the world's population can afford -- they're marketing this through the Internet! It costs nearly as much as my grocery bill, and I'm white and live in America!
This isn't in the category of "feed the world" products, which is why academia has had and will continue to have little interest in something like this. In fact, many people have through the years done similar things in a more ad-hoc fashion: a cousin of mine ate a diet consisting almost entirely of yogurt when he had no cooking equipment beyond a yogurt maker, and there's a rather infamous tale of some dude who lived entirely on raw beef:
http://www.rawpaleodiet.com/testimonials/lex-rooker-usa/
He's still doing it, by the way. It seems to work.
And yet it would take a doctorate in insanity to think that any of these propositions could "feed the world", when we have trouble distributing enough simple dry rice to meet everyone's basic calorie requirements.
As long as Soylent makes up less than 75% of your diet, and you still eat some vegetables, I'd give you a roughly 100% chance of being just fine. Even if you really go whole hog on the stuff, it probably won't be that bad -- people have eaten worse diets. Much worse.
For me, the central discovery here is not that a monotone food product is possible -- that's easy, just take some reasonably healthy foods and stick them in a blender -- but that people actually like to live this way. If you'd asked me before this all began, I'd have bet they'd all get bored in a month.
From the linked article:
50% of the food produced globally is wasted, and food makes for the largest component of municipal garbage. If not for this waste there would be plenty of food to adequately nourish everyone alive. 2 million people are killed annually by smoke inhalation from indoor cooking stoves alone. 70% of americans are overweight or obese. 1 in 7 people globally are malnourished, and 1 in 3 in the developing world suffer from deficiency. Countless others are living hand-to-mouth, subsistence farming, hindering economic development. Even in the developed world, agriculture is the most dangerous industry to work in by occupational injuries and illnesses, and obesity is on the rise.
By taking years to spoil, dramatically reducing cost, and easing transportation and storage, soylent could have a dramatic effect on hunger and malnutrition.
Now, not having any idea how difficult it is to scale production of a physical product is a pretty serious form of ignorance, so my apologies if anyone can verify that Rhinehart intends for anybody to believe this.
Was it really necessary to post this, or a variation of it, five times?