Re:Soylent Campaign
by DanBC on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @06:14PM
(#5747301)
> The founder has been doing this for 4 months and he is healthier than when he started.
The founder claims he is healthier than when he started. That's confirmation bias. We have no way of telling because this "experiment" is not at all scientific. When he started and people pointed out just how hopeless the experiment was we were told to shut up and let him get on with it because it was only him being affected and if he wanted to do it let him go ahead. But now we see the problem - that hopeless experiment is being used to sell this product.
I can point you to a range of crack pots who claim their supplement makes them feel much better. One example is all the blue people with colloidal silver. (Do a Google Images search for [colloidal silver] to see.)
Re:Soylent Campaign
by ceejayoz on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @10:43PM
(#5748513)
CBCs and chem panels are useful for diagnosing disorders, but they're hardly something you can use to determine "oh you're healthier than your previous also-healthy state".
The founder claims he is healthier than when he started. That's confirmation bias. We have no way of telling because this "experiment" is not at all scientific. When he started and people pointed out just how hopeless the experiment was we were told to shut up and let him get on with it because it was only him being affected and if he wanted to do it let him go ahead. But now we see the problem - that hopeless experiment is being used to sell this product.
I can point you to a range of crack pots who claim their supplement makes them feel much better. One example is all the blue people with colloidal silver. (Do a Google Images search for [colloidal silver] to see.)