Re:Soylent Campaign
by ry0ohki on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @06:06PM
(#5747244)
And Benjamin Franklin was a printer, but he still invented the lighting rod and bi-focals.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Soylent Campaign
by enraged_camel on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @06:15PM
(#5747312)
How many people were put in harm's way when he was inventing those things?
[deleted]
Re:Soylent Campaign
by knowtheory on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @06:16PM
(#5747322)
More to the point, bifocals and lightning rods are not intended for internal consumption.
Nor are either of them biochemistry, a subject considerably more complicated than optics or basic electro-magnetism.
If Franklin was wrong about lightning rods, maybe it would have burned down your house. He also experimented with dieting etc... The point is that someone can study a lot on a topic and be more informed then someone who has gone to school for the subject. The Soylent guy isn't just mixing random stuff together, he's doing a lot of research, experimenting, and not suggesting you make it your only source of food.
Re:Soylent Campaign
by knowtheory on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @10:01PM
(#5748351)
> If Franklin was wrong about lightning rods, maybe it would have burned down your house.
Yes, and that is a physical system which has very clear delineated results. Hypothesis: Might burn down houses. Did any houses burn down over a 5 year period? Y/N?
Biology is way more complicated than that. There are many more possible outcomes, and its not as simple as "am i healthier now or not?"
> he's doing a lot of research, experimenting
Oh, is he? Where's his data? What's the statistical significance of his results?