News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @02:26AM (#50542940)
Not working for the copyright industry, and I fully understand your position and concerns, but I'd like to play devil's advocate here and ask what SHOULD government do in such a situation.

Let's take Cloudfare's phonebook analogy: say the yellow pages accept explicit ads for heroin dealers, stolen good resellers or(in a country where that's prohibited) prostitution - we can all agree that the problem is best resolved by arresting the heroin dealers. But what if these guys switch houses every day or are in a place police can't readily go? Off compose some already have the dealer's WhatsApp, but the main way new customers find them is through the yellow pages - would we not all expect the government to take action against the yellow pages until they stop? And if the yellow pages say 'but there are ten other company-name-to-address resolvers and they are also selling scam ads ripping off old people, so you are harming the citizens by penalising us', would anyone buy that argument?

I'm not saying you're wrong. But there is a clear policy problem and I can see how those with decision making power are choosing this route. It's also not your analogy, but I think the cloudfare article is pure pandering to those already convinced and handwaves the underlying problem that DNS resolvers pay a - tiny and easily replaceable, but real - role to facilitate law breaking.

It seems then the rather best argument is about the risk of censorship due to the global nature of DNS. I want to be able to criticise the Thai and Saudi kings. I want to talk about Tiananmen and prostitution and affirm my believe that god doesn't exist and homosexuals have a right to live.

So how do we bring these together? You and the other DNS can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime (whether you agree that the action should be a crime is irrelevant). It's unambiguously clear that DNS play a role, no matter how good you and the others are otherwise.

So currently the DNS are facilitating crime, and the reply is 'its unavoidable', and the reaction to legal action is to withdraw. I see both sides, and there is definitely no black and white answer - so isn't three a need for technical solutions? Not saying quad9 should offer this, but if the aim of 1111, 8888 and 9999 is an open internet, it seems there is a need to still offer governments some kind of solution to the problem?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by rantallion on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:31AM (#50543486)
> when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime

Claiming that DNS providers contribute towards cybercrime is like saying knife manufacturers contribute towards stabbings. Let's not blame the tools when when the fault lies entirely in the hands of those abusing said tools.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by ZiiS on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:44AM (#50543598)
Nuclear weapons are also just tools. Do you support anyone being able to buy them?
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by defrost on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:49AM (#50543650)
Tools for what?

They are not tools for building canals (tried that, didn't work).

They are not tools for lifting starships to space (back of the enveloped that one, didn't work).

No good for food preparation (although radiation is used) unlike a knife.

Nuclear weapons are pretty shitty tools - their only function is to threaten usage or be used to kill. At a city scale (mini nukes aside).

Do you support the village idiot buying a city killer weapon?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by LadyCailin on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:22AM (#50544927)
I agree with your argument, but I don’t want the village idiot buying a pistol or hunting rifle either. So I’m pro-regulation, even if the tool has legitimate uses.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by defrost on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:31AM (#50545006)
Fair cop - I'm Australian and we did regulate guns and that has worked for 20+ years .. although the regs may need a tweak as times have changed.

The main thrust above is that nuclear weapons aren't in the same tool category as either DNS (literal digital phone books) or knives (useful for many things unrelated to killing or injuring other humans).

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by woadwarrior01 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:59AM (#50544239)
Reductio ad absurdum.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:20AM (#50544395)
That's a good point, we should use that against the silly nuclear weapons claim.

"If you would ban nuclear weapons, you should also ban <something else>" is fully generic. Anything can be used for crime. Criminals could use picture frames for forgeries, so we should ban picture frames. Criminals could use buses to get to the scene of the crime, so we should ban buses. Criminals could use food to distract the victim, so we should ban food.

The reason nuclear weapons are prohibited and strawberries are not is that nuclear weapons are weapons of mass destruction. Whereas phone books, not so much.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by RHSeeger on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:21AM (#50545450)
Or, as I noted in another thread

> The question isn't if it facilitates crime at all. It's if it does so in a way that's impactful enough that the cost of removing/limiting it is worth the gain to society.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by lIIlllIlIIIlIll on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:21AM (#50544399)
Nope. Reductio ad absurdum is a technique for building proofs by contradiction.

What was done here was a false equivalence. Defending DNS neutrality because DNS is a tool being equated with defending free access to the most horrific weapons systems ever devised by calling it "just a tool". Absurd, yes. Reduction ad absurdum? No.

Much like "begging the question" is not something which invites further inquiry, but assuming your conclusion is true, and "strawman" is not weakening the opposing argument but inventing a weak argument to refute instead of addressing the real one, "reduction ad absurdum" is not making preposterous conclusions from an argument and pretending it invalidates the argument, it is following some theorem to an absurd conclusion to show that it is in fact flawed for leading to contradiction.

I'd say a reduction ad absurdum was attempted but merely a clumsy strawman fallacy was achieved.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:48AM (#50545142)
The tactic is actually called "proving too much"
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cromka on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:00AM (#50543751)
>> facilitates crime

> contribute towards cybercrime

Do you see how you manipulate here? If you stick to the original words, are you going to say that knife manufacturers do not facilitate stabbing? Because I'd say they do. Just like gun manufacturers do.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by RHSeeger on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:20AM (#50545427)
But so do cars, the entire internet, the phone book, public transportation, cell phones, and nearly everything else. Any that is used during the committing of any crimes anywhere is facilitating crime.

The question isn't if it facilitates crime at all. It's if it does so in a way that's impactful enough that the cost of removing/limiting it is worth the gain to society.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:20AM (#50545984)
Car manufacturers have to make sure their care are road legal. The phone book deletes entries facilitating crime. Cell phones need to respect safety standards and rules (think of east Asia's obligatory shutter sound).

Fully agree with you on the final question. The answer by cloudfare is 'no', the French government says 'find a way'.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by monkeywork on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:34AM (#50546139)
So does a mother facilitate a murder when the son/daughter she birthed later kills someone?

We need a return to personal responsibility, no a gun manufacture or a knife manufacture didn't facilitate a crime - the criminal did - and in both cases if guns nor knives never existed they would have found some other item (sharpened stick) to do the same thing.

Regulation on knives and guns to limit their harm is fine - not because the OBJECT is dangerous but because we can't trust the humans to not do shitty things with it - but lets stop blaming them for the actions of people.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by toofy on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:20AM (#50543908)
i likely lean more towards quad9s position in this instance, however, if a bar or club is proven to be a thoroughfare for fentanyl or heroin dealers and hotbed for crime, the bar will absolutely be expected to make very real good-faith efforts to remove the dealers. and if they don’t, if the government chooses to, they can and will absolutely remove their liquor license.

if they say “we can’t afford bouncers” or whatever, we don’t give them sympathy, we say “then your business plan is wildly flawed. bars and clubs always attract people who try to peddle drugs. this is well known. clubs are expected to have security and you get no sympathy as you failed to consider basic shit in your business plan. we’ll give the liquor license to someone who is smart enough to include a budget for security in their business plan.”

again, i do likely lean towards quad9s position in this instance, but on a larger scale, the lack of accountability we give to some companies just because they’re online is a bit absurd. it’s not at all clear to me why, until recently, we’ve been refusing to hold some to even basic standards we would hold other businesses. “aww you didn’t consider the most obvious and basic likely things to happen or how to mitigate them in your business plan? awww bummer, carry on.”

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:30AM (#50544477)
> however, if a bar or club is proven to be a thoroughfare for fentanyl or heroin dealers and hotbed for crime, the bar will absolutely be expected to make very real good-faith efforts to remove the dealers. and if they don’t, if the government chooses to, they can and will absolutely remove their liquor license.

This is the thing where people claim slippery slope is a fallacy when they want to start requiring liquor licenses and then start teflon-coating the slope immediately thereafter.

> it’s not at all clear to me why, until recently, we’ve been refusing to hold some to even basic standards we would hold other businesses.

The answer is that we don't do any such thing with the vast majority of other businesses. FedEx isn't expected to open your packages and check for contraband. The bus driver doesn't interrogate you about where you just came from or what you're planning to do after you get off the bus. The hardware store isn't expected to care why you're buying a shovel.

Because they're not the police and they're not supposed to be.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by trashb on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:14AM (#50547293)
In your example the bar or club is not liable, they don't need to legally get a bouncer because there are people in there dealing (assuming they are unaware). The dealing is the illegal behavior and the perpetrator of that is the dealer, not the bar owner. The crime is totally separate from the liquor license, there is no reason why the liquor license should be removed in this case. The only way for the place to be liable is if it can be proven the owners where aware and negligent, in that case the owners would be punished but the liquor license should not be in question.

In most western countries and the law follows the concepts "Presumption of innocence" and "Direct Perpetration" that reasoning seems to be getting lost in a lot of modern discussions about law enforcement (age verification is one). I would suggest you read up on the foundation of rule of law.

Following your example, just because you chose to call Quad9 (a public address resolver) to ask for the address of that bar does not mean they should censor that information because you may(or may not) be going there to buy/sell drugs. That is ridiculous requirement, besides you could've asked your friend for the address anyway. The police should arrest the dealer in this case.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by tuyiown on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:33AM (#50544029)
It's not about blaming manufacturers. It's about blaming importers of knives non-complying to local laws and regulations.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cloudie78 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:42AM (#50544101)
And what would those be?

You’re trying to create a circular argument here when the exact topic of discussion is what those local laws and regulations should be

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by tremon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:53AM (#50544668)
And how is the DNS system in any way an "importer of knives" and not more like a delivery company?
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:48AM (#50545139)
It's not even that. It's the phone book where you find the phone number of the knife delivery company.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:15AM (#50545931)
Delivery companies have some due diligence obligations.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by CJefferson on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:42AM (#50545616)
Most countries have rules about the knives you can produce, and how you can sell them.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:45AM (#50545650)
Obviously they are! That's the whole point of the discussion. A bank facilitates money laundering unless it does something against it. The yellow pages print ads for heroine if they are not careful. Email and phone providers will facilitate spam unless they take measures against it. And similarly the French state argues that dns are helping to find illicit sites.

That's not their intent clearly, and their role is very minor. But the question is how much responsibility they have to prevent it. That's the entire substance of the debate. France says they are responsible, quad9 says they can't do anything about it. Neither party questions that there is a role.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by throw0101c on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:45AM (#50546243)
> Let's not blame the tools when when the fault lies entirely in the hands of those abusing said tools.

To get a bit philosophical, Marshal McLuhan would (somewhat) disagree with this: the tools we make and use certainly shape our actions (and the perception of the environment we live in).

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by throwawayqqq11 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:14AM (#50543866)
"Hey hosters, where ever this DNS record points to is banned, servers need to be shut down and handed over to LE."
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:29AM (#50546069)
Indeed focus should be on hosts, but 1. French law has no impact if the servers are outside France and 2. The site owners can rotate the domain to a different server, and the DNS will happily inform everyone, so it seems the DNS plays a role
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by mr_toad on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:34AM (#50544038)
[delayed]
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by fmo1973 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:57AM (#50544222)
The Phone book analogy only makes sense if Quad9 in that scenario is the postman that delivers the phonebook to your door. Are you planning on suing the postman for the advertisements in the phonebook?

If you follow that analogy, registrars are the Yellow Pages and they should be doing the due diligence, not the postman.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:50AM (#50546298)
Indeed, somewhere and the line the analogy breaks down, but just to be clear this was Cloudfare's analogy, not mine. I suppose more fitting would be the service you used to call to ask for numbers (run in most places by the same organisation that printed the yellow pages).
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by ragazzina on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:59AM (#50544236)
> but the main way new customers find them is through the yellow pages

After finding them on the yellow pages, the customers call them with cellphones, so cellphone makers are also responsible?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:51AM (#50545713)
Reasonable argument. Some governments do indeed ask providers to cut numbers known to facilitate illegal stuff.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:09AM (#50544302)
> And if the yellow pages say

The first problem with using the analogy this way is that Cloudflare isn't the yellow pages, they're the package carrier delivering copies of the yellow pages. You're essentially demanding that they open everyone's mail, read it and rip out the pages you demand to be censored.

And even if they did, the user who wants a service like that would then just pick a different package carrier.

Which is in turn where this falls apart:

> but there are ten other company-name-to-address resolvers

It's not that there are ten others, it's that there are ten million others. Anyone can set up a recursive DNS server. Which makes it a ridiculous place to attempt to set up a barrier.

On top of that, it breaks any existing or future means of actually verifying that your DNS server isn't giving you forged DNS records, because you're demanding that it give the user forged DNS records.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Vinnl on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:18AM (#50544375)
> isn't three a need for technical solutions?

I don't think anyone's saying that technical solutions are by definition unnecessary. Whether or not it is, is just not relevant to the matter at hand.

Roads facilitate crime. Opposing the removal/blocking of roads is not approving of crime, and it's not on the opposer to propose a better solution to crime. The cost of blocking roads easily outweighs the benefits of reduced crime, and that is all that is needed to decide not to do it.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:56AM (#50545770)
the roads aren't a service provider and can't selectively filter specific cars. But we do in Europe have low emissions zones were people with high emissions vehicles and thus without the right plate or stickers do indeed get fines.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by teddyh on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:29AM (#50546080)
So if the license plate readers for those low emission zones could scan for stolen cars, is it their obligation to do so? Could the low-emission-zone people be sued for facilitating crime, just for failing to block stolen cars?
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:44AM (#50546227)
Generally these are run by the authorities themselves or a contractor, so the answer is likely that they do such scans if they are told to look for a specific plate. But no one is asking the DNS to look proactively, but rather to block specifically indicated ones. So the correct analogy is not 'should they look proactively for', but rather 'can they qrefuse to look for when told by the proper authorities through a formal reporting channel'.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Vinnl on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:32AM (#50546112)
I feel like we're getting too deep into the weeds of the metaphor here. Low emission zones seem like a markedly different mechanism than having Quad9 intervene.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:46AM (#50546257)
You're right, I was responding to the specific road analogy by trying to show that while you can't make a road block someone, governments do indeed impose and enforce specific road restrictions. So indeed not really relevant to the main discussion.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by necovek on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:31AM (#50544490)
I think you are mixing your analogies.

Yellow pages example was used for the "comprehensive listing of all phone numbers" property, not for the ads.

Perhaps think of it as actual street addresses and house/building numbers assigned by local city council instead?

If a criminal activity happens at "address X" — which is a way to locate a particular property in a town, just like a domain name is translated with DNS to an actual internet IP — do you hold the maps provider (like Google or Apple Maps, or OpenStreetMap) accountable for that address still pointing to the house at that address? Should navigation stop working to this address? Should authorities be alerted when someone puts that address in into their navigation software?

City councils are "distributed" in the same way domain names and TLD registrars are, so map providers aggregate the data from all of them. Some councils are "rotten" and probably take bribes and do who-knows-what when assigning addresses and do not take care of the crime in their jurisdictions. Just like some TLDs and domain owners.

Are "navigation providers" really the place to tackle this issue?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Grombobulous on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:54AM (#50545188)
The reason the analogy is the yellow pages rather than the white pages is because domain names are purchased just like ads in the yellow pages are purchased.

White pages are like an IP address. Yellow pages are more like a purchased domain name.

So let’s say in the Netherlands where prostitution is legal, there are a bunch of yellow pages ads for prostitutes. Should France have to allow those yellow page ads in France where prostitution is illegal?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by thomascountz on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:07AM (#50545301)
I think your metaphor is unworkable. Internet users do not interact with IP addresses directly, this is why you need a "phonebook" (DNS). A domain name is, for all intents and purposes, the only way to participate as a host or provider on the network—it is the only way to have a "phone number," so to speak. I don't believe it's valuable or accurate to qualify a domain name as an ad and an IP address as the interface of connection.

If we focus on the functional usage and not the technical implementation, I think the analogy could be more that domain names are like phone numbers and IP addresses are like DTMF tones, but even that is imperfect.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by gjvc on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:35AM (#50546148)
[delayed]
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by RHSeeger on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:16AM (#50545376)
> The reason the analogy is the yellow pages rather than the white pages is because domain names are purchased just like ads in the yellow pages are purchased.

I challenge this assertion. The white pages are exactly what DNS is - you rent a phone number and the association of your name to that phone number (in the phone book).

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Grombobulous on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:20AM (#50545426)
A DNS name can be revoked even though I’m paying for it, a physical address of my primary residence can’t (unless I stop paying rent/mortgage/taxes).

But I do acknowledge what you’re saying and where you’re coming from. Maybe I’d chalk this up to “most analogies anre imperfect.”

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by belorn on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:01AM (#50545804)
The real world analogy for an IP address is a geo-coordinate, and the underlying protocols favor that an IP address range keeps it association with the physical location.

Street addresses is the human readable form that translate into a position. They are as close to domain names as you can get in an real world analogy.

Yellow pages are the equivalent of paying Google Ads to advertise your product.

If prostitutes in the Netherland are paying French news papers in France to advertise prostitution, then the correct response is to stop the French news papers. Destroying maps of the Netherland, or closing the border to the Netherland would both be massive overreaction and would harm the diplomatic relationship between the countries. The Internet analogies of those are DNS blocks, or the use of a national firewall.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by necovek on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:31AM (#50546108)
I might even compare IPs to plot/parcel/land IDs maintained by official registries instead of lat/lon coordinates — this is a bit more static, but still malleable (eg. with zoning changes and re-plotting/re-parcellation). But no comparison is perfect for sure :)
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by belorn on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:31AM (#50546756)
The malleability could be a factor, but I would say that its not a absolute factor when it comes to addresses. The true north pole is a non-malleable physical address as it will never change, but the north magnetic pole is a malleable physical address that is constantly changing its physical location.

I guess it also depend a bit on how one want to look at it. A physical location will have their lat/lon coordinate change very slowly as continents slowly moves. Nothing in this world is truly ever static.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:02AM (#50545821)
No analogy is perfect, this was cloudfare's :-)

I think in your example the question is less the address, which is a real physical property, and more whether searching google maps for 'dan's drugs' should show an address. Google will remove such listings if they are reported.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by necovek on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:27AM (#50546056)
FWIW, search for "dan's drugs new york" returned "Danny's Pharmacy" for me in Google Maps today — hopefully Danny's is not in trouble now ;-)

Of course, all analogies break down at some level, especially when comparing the physical world with digital: while addresses (and even plot IDs with re-plotting and zoning changes, if you want to equate them to IP addresses for instance) can change, it is a relatively slow moving and rarer occurrence than re-pointing a domain at a new IP address. Where I am at, new developments in suburbs usually start with numbered streets and then evolve into deserving citizen's names over several years (sometimes decades).

Analogies only work if we focus on the part that makes them analogous — if we don't, they usually break down quickly :)

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by halJordan on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:45AM (#50546944)
The analogy is not broken. Should Google Maps be permitted to show ads and addresses for things that are clearly illegal? The answer is obviously "no" but for some reason you're doing a Westworld "I dont see anything here"

Now, a correct rebuttal would be to point to reddit where there are subreddits for every geographic location to find local drug dealers.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by tremon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:51AM (#50544642)
> say the yellow pages accept explicit ads for heroin dealers

You say that like DNS advertises piracy. Please explain how the domain name system is in any way comparable to a user-searchable database for services, and not simply a postal code database linking alphanumeric codes to physical locations?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:10AM (#50545887)
I'm not saying that, rather this is France's legal argument. And no one disputes that the DNS translates crime.com to a specific server ip, so makes it easier to find. I'm wondering exactly where the responsibility ends as quad9/cloud are say they shouldn't take any action even if they are told 'please don't translate crime.com'. I see their point but I also see the French authorities point that they do place a minor role.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:47AM (#50545137)
If my name is Frank Smith and I deal heroin, and in the phone book it says Frank Smith 555-1234, the phone book should take no action and the government should take no action against the phone book.

If it says Frank Smith (heroin dealer) 555-1234 the phone book is now advertising heroin and the government can make them remove that. If there's a whole section for heroin dealers the phone book themselves are now criminals for adding that section in.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Grombobulous on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:58AM (#50545223)
An argument could be made to say that in this analogy IP addresses are the white pages and domain names are the yellow pages.

Let’s say a heroin dealer puts their name in the yellow pages in the plumbers section. Obviously that’s not the phone book’s fault. But then the phone book company is informed that Joe’s Plumbing is actually a heroin dealer that has been evading police. Now the phone book company is aware and inaction is an action.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by croon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:27AM (#50545486)
Is the plumbing related to the heroin dealing? They can't take payment to list illegal activity (heroin dealing), but they can take payment to list plumbing. As a company, I might take it down for PR reasons when informed, but the government shouldn't be able to dictate that (and I'm a fairly staunch regulation-is-necessary supporter). It's too easy to abuse. It's the governments job to stop the illegal activity, and then the yellow pages loses the listing that way.

If they can't, it's either because of incompetence, underbudgeting, or more likely because the legal framework is not as clearly in their favor as corporate lobbying try to paint.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Grombobulous on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:33AM (#50545537)
Read my comment again, as soon as they become reasonably aware that it’s not a legitimate plumbing business that changes things.

Quad9 definitely became aware when content rights holders sent them whatever precursor to a lawsuit they sent them.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by croon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:38AM (#50545576)
> Read my comment again, as soon as they become reasonably aware that it’s not a legitimate plumbing business that changes things.

If they got paid to list a plumbing business they may continue listing a plumbing business. Whether it is a plumbing business or not is someone elses job.

> Quad9 definitely became aware when content rights holders sent them whatever precursor to a lawsuit they sent them.

It's not Quad9's job to litigate that. Quad9 isn't hosting anything that may or may not be illegal.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by Grombobulous on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:01AM (#50545815)
That is not how life works. When a person or business is aware of something especially in a documented fashion, their choice to act or not act becomes a conscious decision that may or may not have legal consequences if some other entity experiences harm as a result.

No, it’s not Quad9’s job to litigate that, in fact here they were litigated against by another private company and they lost their case.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by croon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:09AM (#50545882)
Which is why they're leaving the jurisdiction. Thankfully that judicial behavior is thus far limited to countries with an oversized sports (media) market, which isn't my barometer for justice.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:01AM (#50546439)
Pretty much every country does this. They're just playing cat and mouse.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by croon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:07AM (#50547210)
> Pretty much every country does this.

No?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:19AM (#50545419)
They should revoke the Joe's Plumbing business license and then the yellow pages can remove it because it doesn't exist.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by gpm on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:57AM (#50545775)
Isn't this even more direct? Let's say a heroin dealer puts their name in the yellow pages under a new category called "wesellheroin"... copyright infringement domain names are frequently openly advertising in the name itself that their purpose is copyright infringement.

Quad9's position seems to be that even when the request they are responding to is openly asking for something illegal (i.e. "please tell me the IP address for hire-a-hitman.cn") and someone has gone and told them that "hire-a-hitman.cn" is in fact a site for hiring hitman and a court has ruled that they must stop directing people to it they should still be allowed to direct people within the courts jurisdiction to it so long as those people take very simple steps to avoid announcing they are within the courts jurisdiction.

Of course the actual crime at hand is copyright infringement - but none of their arguments rest on that.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:01AM (#50546446)
If I had a plumbing business (not a heroin business) legally registered as "Wesellheroin Plumbing Ltd" should the phone book be allowed to deny listing?

What if my legal name happens to be Wesell Heroin?

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by gpm on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:14AM (#50546568)
[delayed]
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by cowlevel on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:07AM (#50547197)
Does free speech really cover tortious interference? If I run a phone company and a gravedigging business should I be allowed to deliberately misdirect calls to other gravedigging businesses to mine?
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by gpm on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:30AM (#50547518)
No, but declining to list (note: not listing with a false number) a business on the basis that their name suggests they are a criminal organization is very far from that.

"Free speech" is a fairly generic term where the boundaries vary between countries, but generally it means that but for carve-outs you can say and not say what you want. Carve outs generally include things like "commercial speech intended to mislead".

I'd also expect that in many places with reasonably robust free speech laws might require to not refuse listings because the lister is in some list of protected classes (e.g. gender, ethnicity, ...). But nowhere is "apparently actively committing crimes" a protected class.

The american law around this concerns whether there is a substantial legitimate government interest in overcoming the free speech rights. In your example I'd think the courts would find one for lying about the other companies number (but not for merely declining to give it). If the phonebook-gravedigging-company has a monopoly on phonebooks maybe a competition (in a lawful market) based one for refusing the other companies listing. But neither of those interests are applicable in the case of responding to DNS queries for criminal activities.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:14AM (#50545925)
Exactly. Now what to do if 9999 resolves franksheroine.com and they are told by the French authorities that that site is illegal?

I don't have an answer, but the cloudfare article simply says 'we shouldn't do anything, keep resolving' which feels off.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by justincormack on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:37AM (#50546159)
No the cloudflare article says (a) if that goes through cloudflare we can block access that way and (b) go to whoever is hosting the site and get it taken down
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by spwa4 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:24AM (#50545468)
> what SHOULD government do in such a situation

Well, they should immediately impose 10 000 000x stricter/higher penalties on all AI firms that committed far more serious copyright crimes, for starters.

Then calculate out what those penalties come to, on a daily basis, from when these companies actually committed those copyright violations (that was in January 2021 for Anthropic and 2016 for Meta, in other words they already owe 3600 times the daily penalty), and immediately impose those damages on the AI companies, to be paid out the authors of those books illegally downloaded and used for profit.

Seriously, that's step ONE. Because if this step isn't taken, can the court then just stop pretending copyright exists? Courts in France are specifically barred from applying the law selectively.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by goobatrooba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:53AM (#50546336)
You're right, and at the same time I'd say the police should not stop pursuing burglars just because there are also murderers about. So if both are a crime both should be pursued.

And I understand that while the cloudflare article makes it more about copyright, this is also about other crime.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by spwa4 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:57AM (#50546380)
Generally there is the legal principle that law CANNOT be allowed to be selective. So no, either you go after both violations of copyright or you just leave both alone.

And NO, you cannot do what the US congress claims they did: you cannot change the law. That doesn't change that these actions were crimes when the companies committed them, because even congress can't change the past.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by CJefferson on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:42AM (#50546217)
The thing is, Quad9 is already filtering out the heroin dealers, one of their major selling points is they filter out malware websites! So they can't claim they are 'just listing addresses'

So the only discussion becomes which illegal things are they filtering, and who gets to decide what things are on their filtering list.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by idiotsecant on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:00AM (#50546421)
The plain statement that DNS is facilitating crime is wild. People walk on sidewalks when they sell meth, should we rip out sidewalks?
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by palata on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:55AM (#50547040)
> It seems then the rather best argument is

Cloudflare didn't use the phonebook analogy as an argument. You did. They used the phonebook analogy to explain roughly how DNS works.

> about the risk of censorship due to the global nature of DNS

Exactly.

> So currently the DNS are facilitating crime

So are gun manufacturers. But actually, so are hammer manufacturers. Why aren't we looking for a solution preventing those being used for crime? Because it's actually hard.

> isn't three a need for technical solutions?

A need, surely. Is there a pragmatic technical solutions? Well if there was, then it would be a lot smarter to enforce that than whatever France is doing, right?

My point being that the best thing to do when we don't have a good solution (France doesn't) is NOT to do something that is not considered a good solution (by definition, since we just said we don't have a good solution) and claim it's better than nothing. Many times, bad solutions are worse than nothing.

Note: the "it's better than nothing" and "at least we are doing something" is often used against immigration. A bad solution to real problems. Why do politicians go for that? Because apparently people still don't understand that "something random" is not necessarily "better than nothing". They would if they were the targets of those policies once in a while, and that's exactly why it works with immigration: because those who are targeted and may actually understand that it's not always "better than nothing" don't have the right to vote.

Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by earthnail on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:10AM (#50547257)
Well, as for gun manufacturers: most countries heavily limit how guns can be sold.
Re:Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine by kukkeliskuu on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:05AM (#50547173)
Not necessarily. When a proposed "solution" causes bad consequences, that does not make it the responsibility of those to whom the proposed "solution" is harmful to create an alternative solution. It is also possible to just not implement the proposed "solution".