Who cares if it isn’t googleable. There’s other ways to build community and other avenues to be recognized for your work.
AI search results are inserting themselves as intermediaries in that process of discovery. This is the opposite of what the net achieved, and its reducing the rate at which potential group members ever find community.
I don't think this will play out as you imagine there, because those platforms will drown out human made content with ai copycats until nothing but the already established players are left
It's funny. Until a couple years ago I really hated walled gardens like facebook groups, discord and other app-only communities. But now I find myself defending them, as a last frontier against automation, where you can still hangout with real humans online...
The difference is that Google aggregates content from everywhere, so you don't need a pre-existing relationship with any of those places to find content. If you want to find a YouTube video without Google you have to go to YouTube to search for it. That's great for YouTube, but it makes it virtually impossible for any other video platform to get a foothold.
The beauty of Google is (was?) that it was a way to get traffic if you weren't already the incumbent. What you're suggesting is that we should give up on having new platforms and just stick with the existing ones, even if they're terrible now or they decline in the future. That's not fun.
Google was great for finding products and services, but poor at finding the type of communities we are describing.
Google is also in the unique position of selling both search ads and display ads. And they know what a visitors ad exposure is for links in the search results. They make money on both sides of the click.
(I do work for Alphabet so make of that what you will, maybe the Upton Sinclair quote does apply.)
Won't the people who are interested in connecting with like minded individuals click through anyway? The 40% who aren't clicking now are the people who were just coming to get the info and bounce, they weren't the ones connecting with like minded individuals.
Sites that were too big to just be run as a couple hours a week hobby project level, for years, relied on all traffic, including people who only read a page or two, to generate money via ad revenue. And the site being big, and existing in search results meant it was there for that core audience of people who might build community there.
All this is undone if hosting a site is no longer rewarding because you get no actual visitors and no community forms, while your content is just repackaged by commercial AI.
And I say this as a definite net promoter of AI. I just am honest that from a content publisher’s point of view, yup, they are getting screwed hard here - there’s no upside for them.
The biggest problem is the general shift by which most of the world uses smartphones to access the internet, not computers. This medium seems to discourage traditional web content at a societal scale. A lot of younger people barely ever open a browser, their internet use is exclusively through apps. That causes traditional web content to gray out and become even less appealing to audiences.
I was taken aback when I learned that my obscure blog (no app; 1k page views/day average) gets 70% of its traffic from smartphones, congruent with your observation.
Since I solely use my laptop to produce my blog I was taken aback and immediately checked to see how it looks on my phone — something I'd never done.
To my surprise and delight it displays perfectly there: in fact, it looks much better.
FWIW just for lulz the other day I tried the iPhone Kindle app to see what it was like to read books there. I used white type on black background: excellent! Easier, sharper, all around better than my latest gen Kindle Paperwhite, which is what I use to read in bed at night.
I won't use screens (read phones/tablets/laptops) in my bedroom so I'll stick to the Paperwhite there.
And the costs of putting something on line were commensurate with the number of people who needed to be paid to accomplish that goal. When Al Gore made the first website in the early 90s, it probably cost a few pennies of electricity and the effort of some grad students who worked for a few more pennies. Today, putting a website online involves paying a lot more companies who have massive bottom lines to support.
And that's before we get to the other problem: what's under the AI summaries, and what's often "cited" by the summaries, is LLM slop too, because it's now practically free to create on any topic. For example, I searched for info on a vintage calculator just yesterday, and ended up on this page:
https://www.calculator.org/calculators/Calfax_Calfax.html
It's just data scraped from real hobby websites to boost their page rank. And everything is like that now. No subject is too insignificant for LLM spam because the cost is negligible.
These are far more common than niche hobby collectible communities, and if those communities love bringing people together those people can still hang out together!
People who are looking for others with a similar passion—which, if it’s a niche interest, sounds quite nice—still have access to search results or the sources shown on the AI summary.
But for the vast majority of things, we don’t need 29 sites competing for SEO on “Which channel is the US Open on?”
IMHO, Wikipedia has similar culture problems to Stack Overflow, just less extreme, and its editor decline trend started before AI and AI overviews.
Due to those culture problems, eventually Wikipedia will be completely dominated by people dedicated to pushing ideological agendas and others who just like throwing the book at newbies.
different thing is that it allows joirnalism... that can quote wrong from wikipedia
this topic is in my opinion much smaller than AI slop learning om AI slop
for the impact of wikipedia on journalism (mankind?) the circular reporting cases are relatively minor
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_reporting
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_citogenesis_...
I would complain more about
1) death of forums
2) reddit being plagued by bots, artificial upvotes
3) reddit mod problem (mods can create a community, but also mods cannot be removed. removal would be a problem due to brigading, but there is no mechanism to remove bad mods)
4) HN becoming reddit / eternal September
Maybe not directly, but what about sources that were AI generated? How would that even be vetted?
Any most of them haven't done any real writing in years. They stand atop their domains angrily fighting off anyone who dares to update something without kissing the ring. They don't do research and only contribute through deletions and reversals of other people's writing.
I have a few relatives infamous enough to have Wikipedia entries. Every time I have tried to update them, a mod has pounced. Where my grandfather died ... nope. That cannot be changed without me submitting heaps of personal information to some rando mod. And good luck going anywhere near article about legal topics. Lawyer? Published expert in your narrow field? Not good enough. It's armchair lawyers only on wikipedia.
Between SEO spam as the precursor then AI generated SEO spam and then just AI.
I used to enjoy stumbling on random things and learning/seeing into a world I didn't know existed (usually related to tech/science/history) but the signal/noise has changed radically and not in favour of the signal.
We need a different version of the www. Google controls the www though via the adChromium codebase.
The wholesale ripping off started in the late 90's and we are already deep into the "feeling it". DRM, standalone apps for everything, consolidated corporate internet with paywalls all over.
I'm sorry, I just cannot take anyone on the internet who bemoans IP laws seriously. We all ad block everything and pirate stuff as needed, this is the moral high ground of the internet for 25+ years. Hell LLMs are the worst pirates anyway because they won't even let you just cleanly download the IP you want to steal.
Copyright has little or no value for small blokes and bloketts like us. I think that part of the problem with copyright is that we are blending rent-seeking with acknowledgement of one's contribution in the creation of IP.
I dare say, most of the value of “copyright” for us small players is that it is part of the discovery process through which people with jobs and money find us. My writings and code have led customers to me (in a good way).
I don't mind what the LLM hovers up of my so-called creative efforts as long as people can find me. And that perspective is, I think, the core complaint people have about Google's AI searches. At least, that's how I read the article.
It was never a question of resources and it was never a conflicting goals issue. From Google's standpoint, SEO spam is an existential threat because if somebody solves filtering for it, everyone will switch to that competitor.
It is simply a hard problem to solve at scale. Successful spammers live on the razor line between the signals Google has for useful content and wasting people's time.
The element Google can't control for is human nature. SEO spam sites are built to keep organic users reading long enough to tip the quality signal in the site's favor. Savvy users like those in this conversation know what they look like, but remember that most of the internet is not composed of sanity users. So the signal Google mostly gets from those pages is that they are holding user attention, and holding user attention, and holding use your attention because the site is annoying to retrieve information from is difficult to distinguish from holding user attention because the site is good.
Once you've created something, whether it's an album or a blogpost, they are like your children - or as Kahlil Gibran wrote:
They come through you but not from you,
And though they are with you yet they belong not to you.
When people's interest is piqued, they may investigate more deeply, and that may lead them to other people in the same way. Discord servers are doing pretty well.Personally, I'm a follower of Bowie's definition of success, in that success is about how much you influence other people, because it's purer and happens even if they hate you.
CREATING SOMETHING
__________________________________
.-' '-.
.' '.
/ \
/ \
| Curiosity |
| Joy |
| Art |
| Experimentation |
| Learning |
| Self-expression |
| Play |
| Discovery |
| |
| ___ |
| Making things .-' '-. |
| just because / MONEY \ |
| you want to \ / |
\ '-.___.-' /
\ /
'. _.'
'-.________________________________.-'
Monetisation is just one possible consequence of creation. We've somehow mistaken it for the purpose. Because capitalism.Of course more often than not the reference links within LLM responses don't really relate to what they're saying - LLMs act like highschoolers, "I need X references to back up my essay, so I'll find some things that sound relevant and put them in as footnotes".
Right. Why? That's a nightmare that Google built for us. They lined the pockets of SEO spammers, and because it was their business, they made talked the talked but were never willing to truly deal with the problem.
But even in your SNL example, to show you the answer, Google AI needs to take it from someone who actually made an effort to put this information online. Network programming is an rare corner case where the person doesn't mind the bot slurping it up because the goal is to get people to watch SNL, not to visit a website. But there is so much non-commercial content on the internet that is really getting hosed right now, and that people probably simply won't be putting online anymore because they don't want to do free labor for OpenAI or Google.
As a practical example, there's a lot of hobby historian communities dedicated to specific places, periods, or types of collectibles, and the only reason they exist is to bring people together and share their finds and wisdom. If you're a historian of Kinder Surprise toys or old military uniforms or whatever, and Google is now taking your work without letting you connect with like-minded individuals, there's really little incentive left.