https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/10/18/egg-prices...
What a strange concept. It kind of implies some kind of hierarchy or class system of domains, presumably with Google and Microsoft at the top.
I’ve had my own domain, hosted on Google for over ten years but when I moved it onto my own mail server Google sent all mail from me to junk. Everyone else accepted my mail fine, even Microsoft, but any Google Mail user i sent to it went to their junk folder. I had to migrate back to Google in the end.
As someone that has run mail servers for decades, don’t even get me started on all the “unwanted mail” - including malware and phishing - that I’ve had to deal with from gmail accounts.
"Putting everything on a server (and asking the world to rewrite all of its software along the way) may seem attractive if you build servers, but it ignores the real concerns and needs of many customers."
These were quotes from Paul Maritz (a VP at Microsoft) made about 27 years ago to the WSJ[1] in a back-and-forth discussion with a Sun executive (Pat Sueltz). Some of the comments were quite prescient, others aren't.
This is true. However:
1. We now have tens of millions, maybe even hundreds of millions, of users who have little experience with traditional desktop computing. They grew up on Web services that they access primarily using smartphones, Chromebooks, or web browsers on desktop computers. There are many people with little-to-no experience with desktop applications like Microsoft Office and the Adobe Creative Suite, but they do their work on Web applications such as Office 365 and Google's suite.
2. Even for traditional desktop computer users, they often spend considerable amounts of money updating their environments once every few years. Windows has excellent backwards compatibility, but most people aren't interested in running Office 97 and Photoshop 5.5 on Windows 11 even if those programs can run on Windows 11. I like Office 97, but I need to deal with modern Office documents, plus I want the improved multi-language support and extra features that have been added in newer versions of Office. The Mac is much more aggressive about cutting off support for old programs; my PowerPC Mac OS X software can't run on my Apple Silicon Macs, and even support for Intel Mac programs will be dropped soon.
Because so many computer users these days didn't start off with traditional desktops, and also because of upgrade churn, this is how we ended up with the current situation, where many people rely on centralized solutions.
For most self hosted services, can probably get away with "set it and forget it attitude". But host a couple of publicly available services (immich to share photos with family not in your vpn for example), and asking that of the common person is a bit much.
This would also not be "free" which is pretty much the main selling point of these centralized services. Of course they use your data to create ad profiles, sell it to data brokers, and/or incorporate into data set to train LLMs.
Decentralized is possible, but it’s going up against forces that collectively have trillions of dollars at their disposal (albeit most is probably spent on stock buybacks and exec comp)
"If it goes wrong, they fix it".
I'm honestly not sure how that's different from the modern internet?
A lot of the people responsible for it all going so wrong are present on this very forum. We made good money doing it, but in return what could've been one of the most positive liberating technologies in history ended up another lever of centralization and control instead.
I regret my part in it. I wonder how many feel the same. Clearly, a lot of people are still happy to push on. There's IPOs to be done and stock to vest, after all!
I remember that every time there was a choice between a positive choice and the easy choice, the average person always chose the easy one. There were plenty of alternatives to Facebook yet billions of users went to Facebook. The whole Snowden thing probably registered less acutely than the final season of Game of Thrones with the voting public.
Yes, people like us built the both good and bad platforms, but ultimately the decision which one to use was on the users, and they chose the world we have now.
Basically, I see recent history as Eternal September and the Internet turning into, through sheer volume of demand, into Super Cable TV.
It's difficult for me to understand your view so hoping you can expand on it.
I agree with this statement, but not with your conclusions from it. It is precisely because users don't care and choose the easy way out that we have a greater responsibility. Why did we fail to make the good future easy and appealing? Why did we build the bad option at all? The only honest answer I can come up with is selfishness and greed. The bad option didn't end up being easy by accident. It ended up easy because people like you and I were given mountains of money to optimize extraction and addiction.
> Yes, people like us built the both good and bad platforms, but ultimately the decision which one to use was on the users, and they chose the world we have now.
As an engineer, you are responsible for what you build and its impact on the world. If you build a very convenient, but unsafe bridge and it collapses with people on it, you don't get to just say "oh but the people chose to go on it!". We're the experts. We're the ones that are supposed to know and make good decisions, that's what we were entrusted with and that's what we failed to do.
I agree that most average people do things that lead to bad places, but I don't think it absolves us from responsibility.
Accepting your argument: let's say "we" all decided not to design the "bad" thing. But the money's still on the table for whoever does. So, "we" can all not build it, and then "they" will.
Either way it gets built, and finger wagging at "us" after the fact does nothing to solve it or prevent it happening.
That is a choice you made and you are responsible.
(using “you” figuratively here, not accusing you personally of anything)
In reality, of course, it is a self-fulfilling prophecy.
The only way we could've prevented poor outcomes is by acting as us. As the dramatic changes of the industrial revolution have shown us, labor is immensely powerful at resisting the corrosive demands of capital if it acts in unison. Famously, the labor struggle also included dealing with scabs, or "them".
These are not new ideas. They are lessons we failed to heed out of aforementioned greed and selfishness, often dressed up as trendy tech ideology.
Price is vaguely related to efficiency, so that's what the private sector optimizes for. Think about that next time people complain about Government efficiency.
As one NASA chief said: "if we could blow up rockets as much as SpaceX did, yeah we'd be much faster and cheaper"
If the NASA blows up some rockets for fast development, people get angry, politicians get scared, funding gets cut, important leaders get fired. So they have to try really hard to guarantee no failures. Everything takes way longer and costs way more. They still fail sometimes, and just as often a project is cancelled before completion, but that's way better than an explosion, politically.
AWS et al. (yes, even Microsoft) are far more reliable than the smaller players, let alone your own rig. The flip-side is that when we go down, we all go down together, and I'm fine with that.
I'll take my own rig 1000 times out of 1000 for reliability. This would be true even if AWS, Microsoft and the rest weren't parasites looking to constantly spy on me.
How are you defining it?
YouTube videos—download.
Music—all stuff I ripped from my own CD collections. Newer digital purchases (Bandcamp) are backed up with everything else.
Magazines from archive.org and worldradiohistory.com—local.
Etc.
Early Apple history is often spiced up with tales of Woz's exploits using blue boxes, exploiting an inherently insecure centralized communications network.
We Millennials mock our parents yet mimic their behavior. Memetic hyper-parasitism.
The only thing I saw was memes and news events, 0 direct impact.
For most people in the country, despite being online constantly, they would have never known.
If anything it shows that many aspects of the Internet ARE decentralized well, even within one company. I can use a device with apps and accounts that aren’t dependent on the device manufacturer’s uptime.
The only chance we have for a more reliable world is if these outages and hacks become more and more common. Institutions and people will be forced to wake up and find more local and diverse alternatives...