Broadly, the people in areas with datacenters understand that AI is leading to a loss of control and concentration in power and money. A lot of these moneys have been on the receiving end of this sort of screw job for generations. Their skepticism is earned, and the way our field has tried to ram these projects through with what I will try to gently call a "ship it" ethos has not helped.
This is probably a health reset for the field overall, and for the country. A number of the leadership of these companies have seemed to develop manifest destiny or messiah complexes that are offputting to most people. Polling data supports this.
It's local problem., but it's not just a local problem.
I'm sure these guys aren't dumb, but they certainly act pretty dumb. What really solidified it for me was the choice they made to build data centers literally right next to neighborhoods and then run incredibly loud gas turbine generators 24/7. Even if they were legally allowed to do that, how they did they imagine it would go explicitly signalling that they couldn't give two shits about people living in the community? It's definitely some combination of incompetence and hubris to not predict the resulting backlash.
It won't. These people are fully convinced that literally everyone but them are all just clueless morons pushing back against their godlike genius because we're all jealous of their wealth and power.
Welcome to NIMBY
In other words, welcome to NIABUDSAGTTYGAOP, BATPESLETSGWFLSTL
But I get how that's not as fun to engage with for pithy internet rhetoric.
“Nono, I’m not NIMBY, I just want to set up some goalposts that I can arbitrarily move whenever I want. I just want veto power. Trust me, I’ll use it responsibly”
Decades of no housing follows
That’s my point.
... you sure about that one chief?
After that, when more Litography machines have been built and facilities constructed, that may change. But even then I don't see how this will reduce component prices below the pre-AI-boom numbers? Chip production was already very efficient and already had very good economies of scale. Any attempt to ramp up production quickly will just lead to higher costs in facility construction, that need to be recouped. (Unless AI is a bubble that bursts, at which point components will be cheap, but only for a moment)
Other than war, price pressure is the only lever we have for abundance. Pressure on.
But the chips land on our soil and are programmed by our companies (often by immigrants).
I think if we forfeit our spot it could be pretty bad economically.
Your point is that the arguments are topologically similar but you are ignoring the impacts.
I think there's a better case that building additional housing causes an impact on people nearby than there is that data centers do - because the people who would live in that housing are a type of impact on the people who already live nearby - and I'm still extremely unsympathetic to NIMBYs because NIMBYism is the main reason my own housing costs are so high. Data center opposition is even less justified than housing opposition.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/07/27/electrici...
Datacentres are generally built where poor people live. If you are on minimum wage and suddenly someone increases your electricity bill by $300 because of data centres, on top of all the other increases tied to things like energy insecurity... I can understand why people would consider that an impact.
I think in a residential area that would be more profitable than a slaughterhouse. Slaughterhouses don't really pencil out in busy neighborhoods.
A monopoly over a piece of land can never be absolute because it exists in the context of the socioeconomic network around it, everything the landowner does necessarily affects the quality and value of the properties around them. The rights of the landowner cannot be considered in isolation from the rights of everyone affected by the landowner's actions. The political legitimacy of property rights is contingent on enough of society believing that they are worth enforcing, so it's not just ethical but strategically sensible for landowners to not be antisocial with their land.
If I decided to buy the property next to yours and use it for large-scale hobbyist production of my favourite fermented fish sauce, as is my right as the landowner, I'm sure you'd come around to my way of thinking in fairly short order.
But you want him to come out and say something that he doesn't believe (and has personally contradicted): that he's opposed to data centers as a point of principle, because you're ideologically convinced that that is his viewpoint, because to you that's the only reason someone would put up any type of roadblock to data center build-outs.
Er... I mean, if that's the case, then, fine, I guess?
I do not believe that this is actually the case. People build heavily regulated industrial facilities all the time.
The AI boosters appear to have badly failed in convincing local communities of this.
Perhaps that should have started off with an informative AI positive PR campaign rather than ... whatever it was that put local communities off the notion.
At the very least, laws need to prevent the second case.
DCs do not raise utility rates, utility companies raise rates in response to demand, but aside from that nitpick there is a bigger problem here. If the DC is not connected to the grid then the DC is going to generate power on its own, using inefficient (due to the small scale) and polluting systems (e.g. turbine generators).
If you actually want to address the utility bill impacts of DCs, you should require them to pay the local community. We have a similar arrangement for oil drilling -- to avoid a situation where companies pile onto oil fields and put derricks up on every property, we instead have the companies pay people who own the land above the oil being extracted and that is why Beverly Hills is such a wealthy neighborhood. Give money to the local community in proportion to the electricity consumed by the data center.
Frankly we should require DCs to pay even more when they are not attached to the grid to discourage pollution.
> Datacenters must not touch our waterways at all
...at all? Not even with a connection to the local water utility? That would mean there cannot even be a toilet in the building.
Data centers are industrial operations and should be treated as such -- I do not know of any other industry where this kind of absolute isolation from the local community is being called for, and there are plenty of concerns about industrial water use beyond data centers.
Like I said, it is a nitpick and there are bigger problems here.
Yes, that's what the politicians in question are proposing.
You know, like workers seizing the means of production.
But then in the next breath condemning the concept of socialism. But probably because JD Vance himself has redefined socialism to mean forcing girls to play with boys in sports.
It needs to be carefully thought out (Congress does not have the best record on this -- see e.g. the ban on onion futures). As I suggested elsewhere, a better idea would be to require DCs to pay the local community in proportion to the electricity consumed by the DC, and an even larger payment to the local community if the DC does not get its power from the grid (to discourage less efficient/more polluting power generation). Yes, rates would be higher, but people would be compensated with cash and it would be a big incentive for industrial users to be more energy efficient and a small nudge for residential users.
That's less than a half truth.
Here's the full version:
Utility companies raise rates in order to build new power plants for the sole benefit of a single big biz customer who demands that all pay for the new plants his big biz needs.
- Any new datacenters being built cannot raise utility rates
- Some of the revenue generated by the datacenter must be set aside to improve power reliability
- Datacenters must not touch our waterways at all
- Datacenters must be built using union labor”
Deal. This sounds like a great list. Just get the state to pass this as a law and set anppropriate enforcement mechanisms and then just let data centers go ham if they meet this criteria? No more “per community meetings”, buy the land build the data centers. The municipality can figure out the exact benefits that works for that community from the giant tax coffers.
This seems imminently fair to me and we can also expect corruption to round down to zero.
Note that the utility monopolies are posting record profits that have increased steadily over the last decade.
This was always a silly idea. You either have health competition or state ownership. Monopolies is literally the worst of both worlds.
The benefit with regulated monopolies are that you have a separation of control between regulation (from PSC/voters) and monopoly (running its business).
If the current regulatory regime isn't producing the desired results, it can be changed.
With straight state ownership, things are much more entangled.
Indeed, forcing those datacenter employees to carry their pee home with them will make them think twice about replacing us with AI
Even if a good willing CEO wants to do what's right, he is pressured not to do it by the unlegislated free market - his company is at (economical) disadvantage with the opposition, putting the company at risk or not meeting his obligations to shareholders. Let's not blame consumers either, because they cannot be informed about consequences in the nth order either.
If the legislation is reasonable, everyone must play by the same rules, both the good and the bad willing CEOs. The companies gain trust, the government too, and the consumers (and affected citizens) win.
Because after decades of lies, one tends to just assume that pathological liars are gonna lie pretty much all the time?
They want the data centers, just NIMBY.
We need landfills but I don’t want to live next to a landfill. Maybe we could come to a compromise where you build the thing in a way that doesn’t negatively impact me.
https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/036/647/Scr...
>They want the data centers, just NIMBY.
Perhaps it's just you, because the votes say otherwise. Housing NIMBYism is people who already have homes preventing new ones from being built, for their own benefit (Price increases on existing stock). That's not what's happening with data centers.
You responded with “NIMBYism covers far more than just building homes” which is true but not what was being discussed.
Its because the current movement is insane and absurd made from completely imaginary flat earth level reasons, many of these protestors won't be happy with any dc at all even if they made it 10000 miles from their house. I am okay with reasonable dialog and compromise. I feel these people aren't. This is a uniquely strange phenomenon, I am not wholly ruling out the opinion of some who think this might be amplified ad sabotage by foreign powers, but then again one should never underestimate the native stupidity of americans. They elected trump twice after all.
This is just false and I would have thought people would have realised that when it was tried against wind turbines.
Building without considering consequences at all, or building the way that capital demands, is how you end up with urban communities getting obliterated by highways (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Moses) or rural communities getting decimated by industrial plants (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mossville,_Louisiana) or indigenous communities getting destroyed by military testing (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium_mining_and_the_Navajo_...).
Being a NIMBY is wanting affordable housing... somewhere else.
Being a NIMBY is wanting more homeless shelters... somewhere else.
And of course most of the examples you give are irrelevant - they don't even involve private property or specifically involve the government taking private property.
Eminent domain used to seize private land is more similar to prohibiting construction on private land, than allowing it.
But I am in general for decentralisation and democracy.
I think the immediately preceding sentence pretty clearly laid out their rational. (Not saying I agree or disagree, just that I think your question was already answered).
Add effective enforcement with harsh penalties for "ask for forgiveness rather than permission" behavior. We've been on this ride too many times not to know what to expect.
We're still on the ride, and it's not gonna slow down to let any of us off.
What I'd like to see from my provincial government is the leadership and foresight to regulate that development in such a way that the waste energy from this DC is used to heat greenhouses in our very cold winters.
That could go a long way to bootstrapping a local greenhouse industry and to improving regional food sovereignty.
That's the kind of stuff that government should be doing. They stand at the intersection between all the various stakeholders and they handle the big levers that can force / coordinate them into doing things that increase value and quality of life for the people that elected them.
That's nice list, but it doesn't go far enough. It only addresses problems with the data centers themselves, but they are also a point of leverage against the entire AI industry. It's that industry that makes them so controversial and hated. If they were just power-hungry factories making bolts or solar panels or something, no one would care.
The rules should include something about preserving interesting, meaningful work for people; and making sure the economic benefits are genuinely dispersed and not concentrated. I don't want a repeat of "You lost your respectable, stable factory job, but here's some cheap flimsy shit from Walmart to make up for it. Why aren't you happy with the deal!?"
Under certain dogmatic economic assumptions. I'm fucking sick of TINA.
> What you can do is make sure the datacenters being built in your area benefit the area, otherwise they can go find somewhere else. If some other sucker state/county takes a one-sided deal, unfortunate but it's on them. Just don't be unreasonable and turn down actually beneficial offers.
The end state of capitalist AGI logic is to make nearly all existing people and their descendants obsolete, disempowered, and marginalized. We need to stop that change. It's perfectly reasonable to turn down an offer that throws you a couple bones to bait you down a road to an eventual bad outcome.
I believe you could not be more correct but it seems extremely difficult to get people to take any meaningful action, or even talk about this openly
I have stopped even saying anything like this aloud to people because the reaction I get is anywhere from "it won't be that bad you're exaggerating" to "you're a conspiracy theorist nutjob"
I'd argue, the biggest problem with AI is that it makes totalitarianism a lot more attractive, because it is an infinitely big state that controls all resources: so if AI becomes everything and deprives people of agency, it's no problem: government marshals all resources anyway and people have no agency even without AI if country is totalitarian - but it can also make quick decisions with no political bullshit.
I would like the Overton window to be where you are. Till it gets there, when people are still accusing opposition of being clueless, this is a good counterpoint and resting place for agreement.
Workers pay that cost through increased market prices which also drives up other prices. It's not inflationary because it's a real value adjustment but everyone can pretend it is while real term wages drop even further.
I find it difficult get to the genuine points, as the whole topic is piled high with “arguments”, PR, marketing, and other junk discourse being emitted from all sides.
- There must be community benefits agreements negotiated transparently with the local community
- Any new datacenters being built cannot raise utility rates
- Some of the revenue generated by the datacenter must be set aside to improve power reliability
- Datacenters must not touch our waterways at all
- Datacenters must be built using union labor
A lot of the communities that had datacenters built in them ended up getting steamrolled in negotiations by the tech companies because you had the local government (in small towns, this is people who work part time making a few thousand dollars per year) negotiating a deal with the Google/xAI/Oracle/etc corporate lawyers. I think it's fair to say that the buildout should be paused until fairer terms can be worked out on a federal level, rather than letting this continue to happen.