News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ArtTimeInvestor on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:34AM (#50054330)
Hardware wallets are not a solution to self-custody.

If one would make a list of things that can go wrong, starting from the supply chain that delivers parts to the manufacturer, malicious employees at the manufacturer, mistakes the manufacturer can make, attacks on the delivery chain from the manufacturer to the user, to mistakes the user can make creating, using and storing their keys - the list would contain hundreds of points.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by nkrisc on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:22AM (#50054755)
Then can you give an example of what you would consider a solution, whether hypothetical or real?
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by fps-hero on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:44AM (#50054953)
Banks and payment providers (Visa Mastercard AMX) provide services beyond simply a store of wealth and a mechanism to transfer it.

Actually 2FA, hardware biometrics, behaviour based fraud prevention and personal confirmation of suspicious transactions. If you’re using credit they can refund fraudulent transactions, and there is the chargeback mechanism. This is probably banking system dependent, but in AUS there is a refund mechanism for mistaken/fraudulent traditional bank transactions.

BTC has effectively none of the safety net, and humans are fallible. We need the safety net. It’s the hugest barrier to adoption. Exchanges do a far better job of managing the risks than trusting your wealth to a hardware wallet.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by motionlessveloc on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:14AM (#50055276)
You sure about that last sentence?

https://de.fi/rekt-database

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by fps-hero on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:52AM (#50056496)
I’m not saying they are perfect, but on aggregate they are better than hardware wallets. Legally they will be responsible if your money is lost. They are about as close as you can get to the type of legal assurances provided by a bank.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by fps-hero on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:04AM (#50056652)
Anacdote, I have a friend who is a locksmith. I needed his services one day, gave him a call, and it turned out his day job had evolved since I last talked to him 5 years ago.

Basically, he was now just a safe cracker. He is a a locksmith, but 100% of his full time hours are cracking safes. He didn’t even carry around the stuff in his van to repin a lock. He gave me mates rates but the shop had to do it.

This man was attending multiple callouts, per day, to crack into a safe. Because of, you guessed it, human fallibility.

In a city with with millions of people, basically a hundreds of people needed a single locksmiths service because they had locked themselves out of there own “personal store of wealth”.

I’ve heard zero such examples through traditional banking, with the exception of stolen cards.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by eichin on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:04PM (#50080198)
... this sounds like the "use random password, discard it, always log in via the email-recovery path" approach, applied to the physical world :-)
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by maxbond on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:31PM (#50082037)
The poor man's magic link and the rich man's combination concierge.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ameliaquining on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:08AM (#50055211)
The safety net makes you less secure against the U.S. government, but more secure against everyone else. That's the right choice for almost all users, but I still think it's at least kind of good that people have a choice.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by miki123211 on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:49AM (#50055694)
In financial systems with a basis in law, no transaction is ever final. It doesn't matter what the protocol says or what the technology is capable of, if the judge says that the transaction must be reversed, you get it reversed, even if that means delivering cash in briefcases or something like that.

In systems with a basis in technology, final means final. If the North Koreans take your money, your money is taken.

This piece from Patrick mcKenzie explains this well https://www.complexsystemspodcast.com/episodes/the-900m-wire...

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:31PM (#50078271)
> In systems with a basis in technology, final means final. If the North Koreans take your money, your money is taken.

This seems obviously not true. If someone in New York steals your money then courts in New York can order them to give it back even if it's Bitcoin. If they don't comply then they get held in contempt until they do or the police seize their computer with the keys on it etc.

If the person who stole it is in North Korea then the courts with jurisdiction would be the ones in North Korea, which may not be to your advantage, but how is it any different from what happens after the money was transferred to a bank in North Korea? Or, for that matter, what happens if someone in North Korea has the stolen money deposited into a US account and then spends it before you get around to reversing the transaction?

The problem isn't what kind of technology you use, it's that someone can transfer stolen assets into a jurisdiction that won't help you get them back. Regardless of what payment system you use, they can get the same effect by using the stolen money to buy gold bullion or similar and have it shipped to them in their jurisdiction, and once it crosses the border they're not giving it back.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by rlpb on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:31PM (#50078273)
> if the judge says that the transaction must be reversed, you get it reversed, even if that means delivering cash in briefcases or something like that

So if I pay cash for something, I can get it back if a judge orders the counterparty to do so.

Why is cryptocurrency not the same? Can I not go to a court and get an order, exactly the same?

Of course I may not know the counterparty's identity or they may be in a hostile jurisdiction, but how is that different to cash that has escaped my jurisdiction?

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by hnfong on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:06AM (#50086373)
You're exactly right. That is why you do not do business with an entity you do not trust outside your jurisdiction.

It's just that incidentally, "entity you do not trust outside your jurisdiction" also includes basically your average crypto peer.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ButlerianJihad on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:12AM (#50086435)
Which is exactly why I ceased divulging all my credentials to KeePassXC and friends. And why I remain skeptical about Yubikey.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:33PM (#50079141)
> If the North Koreans take your money, your money is taken

If you wire your money to North Korea, forget about it for a week, and then ask a court to intervene you aren’t getting your funds back.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by kasey_junk on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:47PM (#50079334)
Are there any American banks that will let you wire money to North Korea?
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:10PM (#50079621)
No. But pretty much any American bank will let you wire to a new Chinese or Singaporean account that sweeps funds every evening to other jurisdiction.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by kasey_junk on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:21PM (#50080830)
Ok but then you are dealing with criminals willing to run up against those governments.

That’s not an incremental change in risk over a crypto transaction.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:23PM (#50081596)
> but then you are dealing with criminals willing to run up against those governments

Sure...? If you get scammed you probably are. My point is immutable transactions aren't unique to crypto. They're just a lot more difficult to stumble into with real finance.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by lrvick on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:06PM (#50058426)
I have worked for and/or audited the majority of exchanges, that mostly white-label a much smaller number of players.

I have yet to see a single one, not one, that had a system of custody that did not allow any one of hundreds of people, most not even employees, to walk away with all of the funds.

There are no standards for security that apply to crypto custodians and the mostly fail to do the bare minimums.

If you use even a top ten custodian, operate under the assumption that the funds are in multi billion dollar plaintext wallets sitting on AWS servers the whole team has ssh access to from the same laptops they "npm install" random shit to all day.

Honestly if you do not feel confident custodying crypto yourself, you should probably not own any.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by user43928 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:29PM (#50078236)
And if you do feel confident, you probably shouldn't own crypto either.

Even if you are not hacked, or otherwise lose access to the funds, they are not unlikely to become worthless simply due to the system with the stable coins collapsing.

The liquidity can easily disappear, much more so than with Fiat currency or other assets linked to real economies.

You cannot protect yourself from being scammed in that way, even if you do hold on to your keys.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by lrvick on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:00PM (#50080151)
Good to hedge bets. The value of Fiat can go to zero at any time too. Especially when leadership is always talking about printing trillions of dollars to give every citizen checks.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by user43928 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:22AM (#50083688)
That's like saying you're hedging against economic troubles by trading stock options on margin.

I mean crypto might seem like such a hedge, comparable to gold. But really it's a wealth redistribution scheme where already the current valuation depends somewhat on trusting exchanges that issue stable coins.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by alerighi on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:40AM (#50084869)
Reason why I consider BTC to not have sense, it makes sense only compared to cash, and when you want cash? Illegal activity or tax evasion.

A person that doesn't have anything to hide is happy to leave it's money in a bank where, under EU legislation, it's guaranteed up to 100k euros per account (so you can have multiple accounts in multiple banks so you are safe), that is no matter if the bank goes bankrupt, the money is stolen, or whatever else you will have your money back.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by whywhywhywhy on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:33AM (#50054847)
Use a device that’s mass produced enough it can’t be targeted e.g a MacBook, then keep it airgapped and don’t do normal computing on it.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by Gigachad on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:57AM (#50055077)
Hardware wallets are air-gapped. The issue here was a distributor got acquired and then snuck a chip in that could read the spi link between the microcontroller and the screen. The chip had its own cellular modem and could send the passphrase that was shown on the screen to the attackers.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by wongarsu on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:19AM (#50055333)
If you sell a device specifically for storing large amounts of liquid assets, that puts a huge target on that device. You are basically asking for supply chain attacks

An ordinary MacBook does not have that issue. If you are a high-value target, you can further decrease your risk profile by buying it from a random physical store, further preventing targeted attacks.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ameliaquining on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:05AM (#50055172)
The post you're replying to is arguing that it wouldn't be feasible to do that with a MacBook (at least if you buy it off the shelf at Best Buy).
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by LoganDark on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:03AM (#50055143)
Nobody said hardware wallets aren't air-gapped. They said take something normal and usual enough not to be an attractive target for bespoke crypto stealers, and then airgap that to make your wallet.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by alwa on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:24AM (#50055382)
Boy that was a slog, to dig deep enough through the slop to find the technical details…

In retrospect @gigachad’s summary is worth as much as both articles combined, but for the Clauded technical source (with pictures!) that Ledger’s Claude-release refers to: https://www.tibane.net/research/ledger-nano-x-implant

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by throwawayfifo on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:08PM (#50078788)
>Hardware wallets are air-gapped.

The ones with hidden eSIMs aren't!

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by QuadmasterXLII on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:54AM (#50055049)
airgapped pre crypto devices are extra safe: break out the ti82! don’t buy a ti82 for this purpose, it has to be one you had in your closet. If a blog post describes how to code it in TiBasic then affiliate links a calculator in ebay, well…
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by fsflover on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:09PM (#50078804)
Qubes OS can be more secure than airgapping in some cases: https://doc.qubes-os.org/en/latest/introduction/faq.html#how...
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by mianos on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:25PM (#50081610)
As dense as MacBooks are, it is nearly trivial to fit a spying device inside them, especially compared to small hardware wallets like Ledger Nanos. As secure as macOS is, once a device is inside the chassis, there are numerous ways to read data. USB serial is easily decodable, as are the many SPI, I2C, and other buses inside the machine.

Keyboard traffic is plain. Bluetooth access depends on where you are positioned. DVI is not hard to decode for capturing the entire screen. KVMs are so small now that one could easily be snuck in. Even though the motherboard is very compact, there is space above it and near the batteries.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by teravor on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:44PM (#50082129)
by buying a mass produced generalist device (preferably from a randomly chosen vendor) and then restricting it to a specialized purpose you are effectively negating a targeted attack.

I always assumed the people buying those crypto gadgets were idiots.

also, if Apple falls to a supply chain attack like this where their laptops are backdoored crypto theft will be problem number #10.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ArtTimeInvestor on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:29AM (#50054813)
There is none yet.

If there was one, someone would write down the steps necessary and put them on the internet. But I have never seen a sound description of how to self-custody Bitcoin in a safe way.

The hardest part seems to not even be the one that currently creates all those problems - the hardware and software used. The hardest part is storing the key (for example a seed phrase). If anyone says they know a way to safely store Bitcoin, my first question is: How do you store the key?

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by skinfaxi on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:29AM (#50055443)
Where do you store your bank password? Couldn't the same be used for a seed phrase?
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by rspeele on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:47PM (#50078501)
The sensitivity of my bank password is much lower than a seed phrase because most bank transactions can be reversed as long as I notice them in time and prove my identity to my bank.

With bitcoin nothing is reversible so every step of the process is a huge security risk where you can fall off a cliff and experience financial permadeath of "your" crypto, assuming a sufficiently motivated attacker.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by everyday7732 on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:25PM (#50058740)
remember it? Write it down somewhere hidden if you have to.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by floss_silicate on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:20PM (#50078092)
There are a few out there, but this is probably the best: https://github.com/bowlarbear/yeti-2.0
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by mattmaroon on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:26AM (#50054797)
Using the banking system instead of crypto.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by littlecranky67 on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:32AM (#50055489)
get a brand new, cheap laptop or machine (even a raspberry pi works) that you randomly pickup at the store (no delivery order). Install debian 13, install electrum, airgap the device, reboot and generate 1-of-2 your wallet keys.

The wipe the device, use any non-debian other linux (or BSD) to generated the 2-of-2 wallet key.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by 0cf8612b2e1e on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:31PM (#50078274)
Why would you ever connect it to the internet? Air gap forever. Physically rip out the radio, only load software by CD (ideally not through a USB interface).
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by notyourwork on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:42AM (#50055603)
The existing financial system which provides protection to consumers. Crypto doesn’t solve the problem the general public assumes it does and hype has inflated its value dramatically.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by pants2 on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:19PM (#50063214)
MPC or multi-sig is a pretty good solution, you can require a 2/3 sign off from different custody solutions (ie. a hardware, desktop, and mobile wallet)
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by embedding-shape on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:06AM (#50054581)
> Hardware wallets are not a solution to self-custody.

Nothing in this world tends to be "the solution", everything has tradeoffs.

Say you want to do self-custody, what is then the best option? "Don't do self-custody" obviously isn't the solution, as the core use case here is self-custody, so what in your opinion is a better way, than hardware wallets?

If there is nothing better today than hardware wallets, then for now, they are "one of the better solutions" for how to do self-custody, even with the current tradeoffs. But again, I'm eager to hear what the alternatives are.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ArtTimeInvestor on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:20AM (#50054731)
There is no solution yet.

From a bird's-eye perspective, 3 things are needed: Create a key, derive an address from the key, store the key.

Creating a key safely is possible with dice. You would probably create a seed phrase instead of a key directly, but for this discussion it is the same.

Deriving an address from the key is hard and I have not yet seen a good protocol on how to do it. I have read through a bunch of descriptions of how people do it and they are all weak and brittle. The most popular seems to be "I order a hardware wallet and follow the instructions that come with it". But even people who put a lot of thought into it come up with weak and brittle approaches. I would think there is a way to do it safely. But I have never seen a description of one yet. It might involve multiple computers, multiple software implementations and a hell of a lot of work to create a multisig that is not prone to a single attack vector.

Storing the key is probably the hardest. The most popular way seems to be to store it in a drawer or a safe. So now those coins are just as safe as a piece of gold would be. Or they use a multisig and store the keys in multiple locations. Quite painful. As you have the ongoing problem of keeping those locations accessible and safe at the same time.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by thinkmassive on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:05AM (#50055880)
How is multisig "quite painful" in your opinion?
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ifwinterco on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @03:46PM (#50077561)
Say you've done everything right and used 3 coldcards spread across 3 geographic locations using 2of3 multisig.

You're feeling pretty proud of yourself, your coins are super safe.

Then it turns out the RNG in the coldcard mk2 was badly/maliciously implemented and is completely insecure. You need to move your coins right now.

You can probably see the issue

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by aftbit on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:56PM (#50078617)
You'd probably want to use diversity for this - do 2of3 multisig with a Coldcard, a Ledger, and a Trezor.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ifwinterco on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:17PM (#50079700)
Yes, but the complexity of the setup (which is already way too much for any non-cypherpunk normies) is starting to get kind of ridiculous.

I am still pro crypto and fascinated by the technology but we have to admit the original cypherpunk vision was unfortunately never going to work, we're going to end up with something else

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by embedding-shape on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:30AM (#50069527)
> There is no solution yet.

Again, "best solution we have available" for self-custody is hardware wallets, so we're back to square one.

Imagine if I tried to discuss and argue about things like this on a TypeScript submission? "No, this won't actually solve the problems of TS" I say, "What is the solution then?" someone asks me and I reply "There is no real solutions to those problems, just use Clojure, problems avoided!", completely missing the point.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by bsza on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:12AM (#50086428)
> Say you want to do self-custody, what is then the best option?

A $5 USB stick with Tails on it. You can make as many clones as you want, so no need for a recovery phrase. It's not specialized hardware, so there's no incentive for anyone to look for money on it (plus it's encrypted). If you want to be extra tinfoil hat, make sure you only plug it into an air-gapped machine and copy any output (address, transaction hex etc.) onto another USB.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ripharamberip on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:43PM (#50090628)
thats what I did. But that simply is just too complicated for the average consumer.

The reality is that normal people need to have a simpler solution they can trust. For nerds like us booting up tails and creating cold storage paper wallets is fine but definitely a solution for the general public

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by akoboldfrying on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:57AM (#50054508)
Yes, but this threat analysis also holds for laptops and phones.

What do you use to access your bank account online? I use my laptop, or my phone.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by kasey_junk on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:01AM (#50054537)
If your money is stolen from a bank account via fraud you have recourse to get it back, and it’s pretty straightforward to do in most cases.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by SXX on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:05AM (#50054579)
Very often this is not the case. Debit / credit cards payments are quite reversible, but once a person send $100,000 or even $10,000 to a scammer it can be quite hard to recover.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by kasey_junk on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:18AM (#50054713)
Caused by an account take over? This is letter of the law stuff and something bank (and other financial firms) employees receive specific training on. The customers loss is capped and their bank is on the hook.

For inter-bank transactions involving a scam that causes the customer to “voluntarily” send money it depends on the rail. But US ACH rules cover reversals due to fraud and have pretty substantial rules about it.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by SXX on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:33AM (#50055506)
All the countries have rules about it. Except if your credentials been compromised it can take weeks before you find out that money gone from your account.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by lmz on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:13AM (#50054656)
Even banks find it hard to recover: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Bank_robbery
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by Gigachad on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:59AM (#50055092)
Usually how it goes is if someone hacks your account or steals credit card info. You get refunded. If a scammer convinces you to willingly send the money, you’re out of luck.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by nkrisc on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:14AM (#50054666)
Because the scammers are instructing victims to use methods that are difficult or impossible to reverse, such as gift cards or cryptocurrency.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by rwmj on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:09AM (#50055225)
Don't buy gift cards and send them to random people would be a good rule to live by.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by sfn42 on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:14AM (#50055984)
Yeah, "everyone" knows that. Except the world har an incredible amount of people who fall for these kinds of scams. And there are less obvious scams around.

I almost fell for a strange scam a while ago. A Steam user by the same name as one of my existing steam friends added me. I assumed it was his second account and accepted. A few days later, he messages me, asking me to participate in a DOTA2 tournament. I had previously played DOTA2 with this person, he spoke to me in our shared native language which is not English and everything seemed in order. I said I haven't played DOTA2 in years so I'm beyond rusty, he said I don't have to play, they just need me to register so they have a full team for the signups and then they'll find someone else to play before the tournament starts. Sent me a link to a website requiring a signup and I can't remember what it was now but there was something about the signup that irked me. Maybe it was just creating a account, maybe it required a credit card or something I can't remember but I ended up looking at my steam friends list and noticed both the accounts were online. So I sent a message to the other account asking if this is them, he said no and then I noticed the same scammer had added another mutual friend so I messaged them too warning them about it.

That's the closest I've been to getting scammed that I can recall. I'm not sure what the scammer would gain from my signing up but I'm sure they had some kind of profit angle.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by Pannoniae on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:37PM (#50078367)
its a fake steam login! theyll phish you for your login and login into your account, messaging your friends...
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by sfn42 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:28AM (#50083745)
Oh yeah that might be the iffy thing that made me stop the signups, it probably required a steam login.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by nkrisc on Monday October 12, 2026 @01:07PM (#50059441)
And yet people still do it.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by iammrpayments on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:58AM (#50055792)
The truth is that banks often have pretty bad security and customer service, but the risk of getting caught after stealing crypto is virtually zero when compared to scamming someone’s bank account balance.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by chinathrow on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:48AM (#50054422)
But freedom.

Seriously, that's why we have banks, still.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by iammrpayments on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:07AM (#50054587)
Good luck trying send money abroad or dealing with a sudden unexplained account shutdown.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by chinathrow on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:18AM (#50054704)
I have had no problem sending or receiving money abroad, thank you.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by theplumber on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:26AM (#50054796)
yet
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by Dah00n on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:32AM (#50054842)
We are not all living in America, yet.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by ameliaquining on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:14AM (#50055284)
That's not really relevant; the U.S. government has enough leverage over the global (fiat) financial system that they can cause any account in any First World country to be shut down.

The actual reason to discount this is that account shutdowns are flashy rare events that reliably summon HN outrage, and so the kind of person who posts here overweights how likely they are, at least for people not on the margins of society. (If that weren't the case, the system wouldn't work and normal people wouldn't use it.)

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by theplumber on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:40AM (#50057108)
Well as far as I know banks in Europe (UK included) already ask you a lot of questions when you withdraw your money(I.e cash) or even when you wire various amounts( unless you have a good bank manager). My bank manager in Europe just told me straight that I don’t need to explain him anything but he has to call me anyway because of the bank policy(I.e to tick the boxes).

Next is a hold on your suspicious transaction, request additional documents for your own money, basically a lot of AML and KYC before you can use what’s yours.

I understand the reason why they do this but it feels to me you are no longer in control of your money/property and somehow they fail to catch people loading billions from shady sources so I would rather not keep my money in a bank (at least not a retail bank) if I had a sensible option.

Most people don’t care about this until they get trapped just like most people are /were OK with Paypal and other junk services.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by what on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:03PM (#50081883)
It sounds like your withdrawals/transfers are actually suspicious. You don’t give any details on amounts or frequency or anything else. But you are certainly doing something outside the normal.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by iammrpayments on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:01AM (#50082239)
Go to youtube and type “paypal froze my account”
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by what on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:13PM (#50098317)
He’s talking about actual banks, not PayPal. He is 100% doing something suspicious.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by artisinal on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:22PM (#50078959)
About one in five international money transfers fail for me. EU to EU countries. SEPA isn’t bulletproof. Outside office hours I have an even higher failure rate.

Ironically the failure rate when I use the American Visa or MasterCard is maybe 5%.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by Aurornis on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @03:49PM (#50077614)
> Hardware wallets are not a solution to self-custody.

Look back as recently as last year and hardware wallets were held up as the recommended way to do self-custody all over.

Whenever I brought up the issue of losing coins due to hacks or bugs, I was told that hardware wallets had solved this problem.

Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by tenuousemphasis on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:00PM (#50078673)
There have been more hacks, bugs, and coins lost from software or custodial wallets than ever have and likely ever will be lost from hardware wallets.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by odyssey7 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @09:50PM (#50081422)
People selling hardware wallets might pay good money to convince you of that. People not selling hardware wallets probably won’t pay for the reverse.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by 0cf8612b2e1e on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:33PM (#50078313)
Do passkeys next.
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:32PM (#50079122)
Passkeys don’t gate immutable financial transactions. (Pretty much everything you do in a bank’s website is reversible during the day to a few days out.)
Re:Ledger confirms hidden chip in crypto wallet amid $92M th... by Yizahi on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:52PM (#50080071)
Apparently in human societies "trust" is a feature and not a bug to be removed. Who knew, right? :)