News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by Supermancho on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:06PM (#49714657)
None of these 3 problems have anything to do with it being a smart ring. Same problems that regular rings have, yet people still wear them.

1. Adulting: buying rings that are the right size. My tungsten wedding ring cannot be resized either.

2. Most people don't even lift. Those that do, dont mind taking off jewelry. I can see how this would be a problem for someone who wants to wear a smart ring for lifting. Sounds like an issue that should have been noticed earlier.

3. Adulting: moving the ring up and down your soapy finger and washing your hands properly.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by phyzome on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:24PM (#49714926)
I don't wear my wedding ring for similar reasons as described in this post. (Mostly reason #1.) But my wedding ring was $75, can be resized pretty cheaply if I'd like, and is harder to damage because it's just solid metal.

An Oura ring appears to be $400, easy to damage, can't be resized. Lots more room for regret there.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by dcss_gardener on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:23PM (#49714910)
Most people do not wear tungsten wedding rings. A wedding band can be resized and it's typical to have it resized several times during a long marriage. This is a legitimate downside of smart rings that is only shared with one niche-but-overrepresented-here option.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by nexus6 on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:57PM (#49715393)
My experience with devices with very small batteries is that they lose capacity (below 80%) quickly after a couple of years of daily use. By the time you need the ring resized, the battery might be worn out anyway.

It’s in reality a disposable product unfortunately, unlike a wedding band.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by rconti on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:14PM (#49716524)
The advantage of my tungsten wedding ring is I have 5 of them, some in different sizes, and it cost me less than $100 for them.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by godelski on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @03:34PM (#49717704)
Don't look up how they get removed from your finger at the ER
Re:Giving up on smart rings by dreamcompiler on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:23PM (#49718395)
EMT here. I've never had a patient with a tungsten ring but I'm pretty sure our ring cutters would not work. So I looked it up. Apparently you have to break them off with vise grips [0]. One more tool for my kit I guess.

[0] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=poM423pewRE

Re:Giving up on smart rings by MrDrMcCoy on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:55PM (#49718803)
Thank you for everything that you do! I imagine EMTs don't get nearly enough thanks amidst all the rush and horror.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by MaxikCZ on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @06:25PM (#49719706)
I looked it up and seems they just bash it with hammer? What are you eluding to?
Re:Giving up on smart rings by godelski on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @06:55PM (#49734157)
It is difficult to get off. If they can't smash it, they remove the finger. But if your ring gets caught you lose your glove. The one made of skin
Re:Giving up on smart rings by peab on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:51PM (#49717048)
smart rings aren't meant to last more than a couple years though - the rate of progress on these means that you're more likely going to be paying for a smart ring subscription than a physical object
Re:Giving up on smart rings by runjake on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:17PM (#49716565)
Since this is HN: About 25% of US males wear a tungsten wedding band. So, not most, but a sizable amount.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by morsch on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:38PM (#49716861)
The numbers you are probably referring to are for the market share in any given year.

https://www.jckonline.com/magazine-article/the-knot-2019-jew...

Since people tend to stay married for years, and tungsten wasn't as popular previously, the actual number of adult men wearing tungsten wedding bands is probably a lot lower, maybe around 10%.

Still a lot. Approximately nobody wears them in Germany; seems like an opportunity.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by adamrezich on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @03:07PM (#49717282)
Mine is serinium (a zirconium/titanium/nickel/etc. alloy), because it was cheap (because I was poor and wanted to spend more money on my then-fiancée's, of course). Serinium rings are also not resizable, and, from what I understand, they are becoming more popular (because they are cheap).
Re:Giving up on smart rings by rolisz on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:39PM (#49715125)
Cobalt Chrome ring wearer here (and my wife). Not so niche I guess
Re:Giving up on smart rings by ChrisClark on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:43PM (#49715194)
True, a sample size of 1 means it is extremely common
Re:Giving up on smart rings by tlavoie on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @01:58PM (#49716277)
TWO! Mine's cobalt as well. My wife picked it out when I'd lost my original gold ring (temporarily, cough). Besides looking interesting, apparently it was much less expensive than gold is these days.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by Supermancho on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:46PM (#49715240)
Rings that can't be adjusted are ubiquitous. Walk into almost any store that sells rings, most open-air stands that sell rings, and you will find some. It's true they aren't usually preferred, but they are common.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by dhosek on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @03:18PM (#49717457)
Odd, I was married for almost twenty years during which I think I took off my ring twice (maybe not even that much—if I recall correctly, I persuaded the surgical staff to tape my ring rather than have me remove it when I had surgery). Never had to resize it and it fit fine the whole time. I don’t know what lifestyle leads to a finger changing size dramatically during the lifespan of a smart ring.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by pessimizer on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @03:45PM (#49717871)
> I don’t know what lifestyle leads to a finger changing size dramatically during the lifespan of a smart ring.

Are you pretending that you are unaware that this can happen, or are you showing contempt for people who gain or lose weight? I don't find either useful.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by guydoom on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:35PM (#49718552)
Username checks out.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by anticorporate on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @08:38PM (#49720735)
To be fair to the parent commenter, I wondered the same thing, and I'm someone whose weight has fluctuated by >60% over the course of my marriage without needing my ring resized. Having been both obese and medically underweight over the course of that time, I'm not particularly contemptful of people who are either.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by dhosek on Thursday September 17, 2026 @10:21AM (#49741205)
I’ve not quite had the same dramatic change of weight (only about 20% gain), but my fingers have retained their diameter through that. I was genuinely curious about what caused people to need resizing.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by anticorporate on Friday September 18, 2026 @05:26PM (#49760472)
The only thing I can figure is that my change wasn't extreme enough. I guess mine is centered on a roughly healthy weight, with fluctuations ~30% above and below that, which might be quite different than fluctuations only above. (Thankfully I'm now much closer to the midpoint now).
Re:Giving up on smart rings by phs318u on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @05:43PM (#49719270)
Ever heard of arthritis?
Re:Giving up on smart rings by someguynamedq on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @06:09AM (#49724276)
This is not typical
Re:Giving up on smart rings by catigula on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:23PM (#49714908)
A health and fitness tracker that cannot be worn during a common health and fitness activity seems highly problematic as a form factor, especially since competing form factors do not have this problem.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by muti on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:52AM (#49722237)
Not necessarily common, but I imagine most form factors would have issues with _some_ activities. I have a fitness watch that I don't like wearing when rock climbing. A ring also isn't suitable, but an armband worn further up would be.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by catigula on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @09:06AM (#49726416)
It’s a little intellectually disingenuous to compare something you don’t like wearing during a niche sub categorical activity to a category of tracker you CANNOT wear during a categorical activity.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by world2vec on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:37PM (#49715103)
People wear wedding rings but take them off for pull up bars and so on. But a fitness tracking device you need to take off to... Do some fitness exercises... Is not a smart idea in my book.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by rtkwe on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:50PM (#49715287)
I'd question the utility of the data from a ring for weightlifting, cardio sure but just lifting weights there's not a huge need to track your heart rate, you're not moving a lot for steps, etc.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by pastor_williams on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:29PM (#49716740)
Lifting weights definitely causes your heart rate to change.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by rtkwe on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:55PM (#49717112)
Of course it does but it's barely relevant to the goals of the exercise though so tracking it is minimally useful beyond the vague curiosity of cataloging and measuring every moment.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by ratmice on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @03:46PM (#49717882)
The data should be useful for automatically counting reps...
Re:Giving up on smart rings by rtkwe on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @09:18PM (#49721036)
I suppose, if counting to low double digits is difficult for you?
Re:Giving up on smart rings by ratmice on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @02:50AM (#49722926)
Not really the point.

If you make program with a bunch of different exercises, and are modifying your program a lot, it can be a pain to keep track of what your next exercise should be.

If you are automatically tracking reps, it can just announce whatever the next thing in your program is, and start rest timers automatically...

It's not really about tracking reps as much as tracking where you are in a program that it is useful for...

Re:Giving up on smart rings by louthy on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @03:58AM (#49723339)
I use the Pump Club app when lifting, it has the day's programme to follow: I simply enter the reps after each exercise.

It never occurred to me that I'd want to automatically track reps. I mean, it could be kinda useful, but I'm also taking 45 to 60 seconds cool-down between exercises anyway, so it's not like it gets in the way.

That also moves the app onto the next exercise in the programme. It's manual, but it's not intrusive and can't be wrong, like a fitness tracker, that definitely can be. So shrug, just personally, auto-tracking reps isn't something I need and wouldn't be a big selling point for a band/watch over a ring.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by ratmice on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:24AM (#49723520)
I wasn't wading into the watch/ring debate, never used a ring just a watch. Was just saying while heart rate data might not be the most useful. There might be uses for other sensors and reasons to replace the ring with a watch while lifting...
Re:Giving up on smart rings by louthy on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @08:11AM (#49725709)
Fair enough.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by rtkwe on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @10:59AM (#49728084)
If you're modifying your program a lot a ring isn't going to help you remember your rep count for that day either. Yes a watch can display that but we're talking about rings here that can't and could only count reps and there's no vibration or speaker on the ring to notify you so you'd need your phone there anyways and could just look at it at the start of the set and count.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by ratmice on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @08:10PM (#49734798)
I wasn't really talking about just rings, the comment I was replying to was talking about heart rate sensors. I'm saying it's still worthwhile replacing your ring with a watch.

Even if it is just for swiping or pressing buttons to switch between exercises in your program. But there are other uses for accelerometers.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by jerlam on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:39PM (#49716875)
It's usually not the primary benefit of the exercise. You are not going to maintain zone 2 (120-140 bpm) while lifting.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by fn-mote on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @09:07PM (#49720964)
The utility is not having to take your ring off. If nothing else, once it’s off, you are one step closer to losing it.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by louthy on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @05:50PM (#49719355)
If you constrain the device to ‘fitness tracker” and not lifestyle/sleep/health/illness/fitness telemetry, sure.

I wear an Oura Ring for the complete suite of telemetry, not just for tracking workouts.

I also lift, I’ll take the ring off for heavy lifts, and keep it on for every other exercise (unless I feel there’s a risk that the ring could get caught on the equipment, in which case I’ll take it off for those reps too). Granted this is in my home gym, so there’s no inconvenience to me doing this.

I’ll rest between exercises and that’s when I make the call to keep the ring on or not [for the subsequent exercise].

I still get most of the insights and the Oura ring app lets me to tell it that I was doing strength training, which allows it to guesstimate calorie usage based on duration.

Of course that’s not perfect, but it’s good enough for people who are interested in health metrics without being obsessed with them (which is just probably a better idea unless you’re a pro athlete).

The workout tracking is kinda the least interesting aspect for me. It’s more about the long term trends of activity, sleep, heart rate, stress, etc.

Also, it’s worth saying, I went with a ring rather than a watch or a band because I like to wear a real watch.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by Aurornis on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:41PM (#49715162)
Agree. I thought this article was going to be about smart rings, but it was a rant about rings. His first exposure to rings was a smart ring, but that's it.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by monster_truck on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @01:15PM (#49715633)
A tungsten wedding ring is a pretty silly/unsafe thing to have. I'll readily admit it's cool but I like my fingers too much to worry about degloving one of them. That said using it as an example of or point of comparison for most anything is pretty unrealistic.

Similarly I am not willing to wrap a LiPo battery around one of my fingers. Absolutely not. I suspect this is in part why we have not seen more smartwatch bands doing the same.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by dpark on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @01:30PM (#49715840)
Why would a tungsten band increase the chances of degloving your finger?

A tungsten band is a lot harder than a gold band. But a gold band is already way harder than your flesh. Jimmy Fallon was wearing a traditional platinum band when he nearly lost his finger.

If you want to reduce your risk, you should either not wear a ring or wear a silicone band.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by kenniskrag on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:20PM (#49716615)
In a hospital, they may need to remove the ring quickly for example, if your finger was injured and begins to swell.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by happyopossum on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:40PM (#49716886)
In a hospital setting nobody will be degloving your finger - this is a common situation, and they have pliers that will crack/shatter the tungsten for removal.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by phyzome on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @03:17PM (#49717442)
I'm guessing that strongly depends on how big the hospital is. I know someone who lives out in the boonies and it's amazing what isn't on hand.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by Ancapistani on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:12AM (#49721997)
I live in a town of <15k people, and it’s the county seat. Our hospital can handle tungsten carbide rings without issue. I checked before getting one for this very reason (though I now wear an Oura as my wedding ring).
Re:Giving up on smart rings by bluGill on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:53PM (#49717073)
Steel toed work boots are almost never allowed to have a steel toe anymore. It is always plastic which is just as strong but it shatters when it breaks so they don't have to uncrush that once they get whatever fell on your toes off.

There are some rare exceptions for specific jobs, see OSHA (or your country equivalent) for the exact rules that apply to you.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by Clent on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:19PM (#49718321)
This isn't remotely true. Steel is absolutely still allowed. The steel toe is designed to collapse without crushing the toe. When that happens, the boot needs to be replaced.

There are composites which are fiber based but those aren't labelled as steel toes, they aren't designed to shatter and it's not plastic.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by bluGill on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @05:01PM (#49718865)
Osha allows steel where plastic (fiber is a plastic) has issues. However they have complex rules and none of the industries I work with will allow steel.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by tredre3 on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @06:30PM (#49719748)
I've been wearing them all my life all over North America. Very few industries require metal-free footwear. Composite toes (since we're getting carried away with various terms, that's the actual term and fabrication method, which is fiber mesh and epoxy) still have downsides. Those don't apply if you're a white collar guy and just need them because of regulations.

But if you're an actual worker that relies on them to save your toes, CT has much worse puncture resistance than ST. So it's trivial to puncture with a framing nail gun or cut through it if you rest a board on your toe, for example.

They also shatter when something heavy falls on them. If the thing bounces and you're quick enough to pull your foot, then great. If not, the second bounce will be shattering your toes and your boot will be filled with fleshy composite soup that is impossible to save. A steel toe in that situation will just bend and odds are good that your foot will be salvageable.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by dpark on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @06:42PM (#49719868)
Tungsten also shatters. It doesn’t crush. That’s actually how a tungsten ring that’s stuck is removed. You break it with a vice.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by monster_truck on Thursday September 17, 2026 @12:13PM (#49742919)
Go check out the OSHA injury reports my dude. All it takes is something like a seemingly harmless hop over a short chain fence gone wrong. Where any other band would deform or break, that fucker's taking everything else with it.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by dpark on Thursday September 17, 2026 @03:32PM (#49745467)
My dude the question is not what danger a ring poses but why tungsten poses a higher risk. The flesh on your finger is much softer than a normal wedding band. Again, Jimmy Fallon is an excellent example of this. He fell in his kitchen and his very traditional platinum band took the flesh off his finger when it caught on the counter.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by dreamcompiler on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:30PM (#49718488)
Amen. As an EMT/Firefighter you'll never catch me wearing a ring made of any kind of metal. I have seen and dealt with some pretty horrific things. Degloving is the only traumatic injury that makes me queasy to think about.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by marssaxman on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:47PM (#49718701)
I loved my first tungsten wedding ring so much I got another one when I remarried. It has a really satisfying feeling of solidity. Your safety concern does not trouble me at all: yes, it's a very hard metal, but it's brittle. You can't cut a stuck tungsten ring loose the way you can a gold ring, but you can easily break it, using a hammer or a pair of vice-grips.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Y2gzBI-2amA

My ring has a "comfort fit" profile, and it slips off so smoothly I can't imagine why this would ever be necessary.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by hbn on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @01:16PM (#49715654)
> Adulting: buying rings that are the right size.

He did buy it at the right size. Then he lost weight.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by juancn on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:26PM (#49716685)
There aren't many places where a wearable doesn't get in the way, even an Apple watch it's unusable if you do kettlebell training (I severely scratched one doing a kb snatch).

I also stopped wearing my wedding ring because of lifting, it mangled beyond all recognition and had to cut it off with pliers and send it for repair.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by Terr_ on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:31PM (#49716768)
> Most people don't even lift. Those that do, dont mind taking off jewelry.

I dimly recall some folks promoting silicone wedding bands, although at that point I think it's more about social-signalling "I'm in a relationship" rather than a durable memento or signalling wealth.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by bluGill on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:50PM (#49717030)
That is what I wear - when I bother wearing one at all. Or sometimes the cheaper rubber rings, depending on what is in stock at the store. They are cheap enough that I don't worry about losing them. When (not if!) they break I just get a new one. My gold ring stays hidden at home where I don't have to worry about it.

I've never got used to the feel of a ring on my fingers though and now I do without. I know I'm married and girls never "hit on me", so I really don't need it for anything.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by scrumper on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:31PM (#49718498)
I wear silicone ring in the gym, in my workshop, and working on or sailing boats and a platinum band when I'm not doing manual stuff. I could wear no ring at all, but I don't particularly like the optics of an obviously married man with tan lines on ring finger not wearing his ring: I think it makes you look like there's something wrong with you - recently divorced at best, a sleazy creep at worst. Should I care? No, but I'm not that well adjusted. Silicone is basically as safe as no ring at all for almost any manual or physical activity. Metal rings offer an entire exciting catalog of spectacularly horrible accidents for the low price of one tiny slip.

So, yes, it's literally a social signal that I'm in a relationship :)

Re:Giving up on smart rings by DeluluDon on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @10:40PM (#49721521)
Men do divorce their wives, just saying.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by aidenn0 on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @06:41PM (#49719863)
I wear a silicone wedding band. The "durable memento" went missing when I took it off at the gym. My wife bought me a new gold band for our 15th anniversary and it lives in my jewelry box, since I don't want to lose it.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by maccard on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @02:58PM (#49717159)
I have a soft gold ring, and I lift. I take my ring off to lift or it would get absolutely destroyed.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by pyrale on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:43PM (#49718653)
> Same problems that regular rings have, yet people still wear them.

In some jobs/hobbies, it is highly recommended to wear soft metal rings, and add a structural weakness to the ring in order to limit finger injuries, in case you forget to remove it.

Doesn't mean everyone must do it, but as with this post, it's a good point of view to get before making a choice: not everyone rides horses, but the same injuries can happen in everyday life.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by thih9 on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @05:06PM (#49718915)
> Most people don't even lift.

It’s about any physical activity involving hands and friction. Rock climbing, basketball, tennis, etc. Perhaps this depends on intensity. Still, much more than just lifting.

People who don’t usually wear rings might not realize this.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by Morromist on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @05:46PM (#49719299)
I think what we might be moving towards is the idea that rings are kinda dumb.

Rings make our fingers less mobile, harder to clean, get in the way of our delicate hand-tasks, scratch things our hands are manipulating, yada yada.

Earings make much more sense. Or bracelets. What about Torques?

Re:Giving up on smart rings by nkrisc on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @06:36PM (#49719806)
My wife and I both just stopped wearing our wedding bands, and it turns out you’re still married even if you’re not wearing the ring. Also we just have simple gold bands so we never spent much on them in the first place.
Re:Giving up on smart rings by chabska on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @09:24PM (#49721075)
These are problems with it being a smart ring RELATIVE to a smart watch.

- wrist size changes far less dramatically, and even if it do change, a strap swap for a smartwatch is far cheaper and easier than a whole-device change for a smart ring - wristwatch doesn't interfere with any hand activity - wristwatch far less likely to trap debris from your activities.

Re:Giving up on smart rings by GJim on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:09AM (#49723409)
> My tungsten wedding ring

You do realise that in the (admittedly unlikely) event that needs to be cut off in the Emergency Department, they wont have a chance?

Re:Giving up on smart rings by quickthrowman on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:38PM (#49729561)
Place the tungsten ring against concrete, hit the top of the ring gently with a hammer and increasing the force with each hammer blow until the ring cracks.

Search YouTube for “break tungsten ring” for examples.