News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No AI Fridays by Jcampuzano2 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @10:40AM (#49499081)
At the very least, I do encourage people who are working on personal projects for explicitly learning and studying purposes to purposefully not use AI. Of course, if the purpose of the project is to learn AI, then that rule is allowed to be broken.

Anecdotal example but I know plenty of students (Including my own brother) who graduated recently who did it almost entirely with AI (unfortunately at the request of their own professors) who can't answer the most basic of questions that I would have expected of sometimes even first year CS students in the days before AI was a thing, which is why I encourage them to build projects without it.

Personally, I'm starting to think that in university and education systems, all projects should now be done in class and in computer labs/monitored study halls because we can't trust anyone to not use AI anymore.

Re:No AI Fridays by ynac on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:17PM (#49500026)
That reminds me of "coding" in my Roaring Spring No.20165. Which is to say, my notebook. It was great for when I didn't have access to a computer. I remember the feeling of how cool it looked along side cartoons of monsters and cars crashing into the paper's edge.
Re:No AI Fridays by dom96 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:42AM (#49499694)
I've been doing this on my latest personal project. What I've realised I missed the most is feeling in the zone or in a "flow" state as some call it. It really feels amazing. Coding agents take that away from you. I really think we need some coding agent implementation which takes less agency away from programmers and helps people be in the flow even more.

For my project I use Gemini/Google's AI mode to great effect. Quick answers to be reminded about syntax, and to get help when stuck. It actually enhances the flow state. Plus it's all free.

Re:No AI Fridays by KingOfMyRoom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:56AM (#49499822)
What do you use to be in the zone? music in the background? What type? Or silence or something else?
Re:No AI Fridays by noduerme on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:03PM (#49499894)
I don't think it has to do with sound. Some sounds can disrupt it, of course. I can work well in a noisy cafe as long as I'm not listening to any particular conversation. Although oftentimes, if I'm alone, I talk to myself out loud while I'm coding ("no, not that, it should go here... where's that header? stupid typo...")

We used to call it "seeing through the code". The moment when you're no longer looking at text on a page, you're seeing what it does as you scroll through it.

What you need most, to get to that place, is to simply spend a lot of time writing and reading code until it becomes second nature. Something like 10,000 hours.

Once you've done that, reading an LLM's code is trivial. But letting it write most of the code, without reviewing it line by line, causes rapid brain atrophy. Because to really be in the zone, you need to keep everything relevant in your head. Which means it has to be in there in the first place.

Re:No AI Fridays by KingOfMyRoom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:26PM (#49503450)
That makes sense. I wonder how much the sound itself matters versus it simply becoming part of the ritual that tells your brain "now we’re working"

I used to listen to classical music, rap or hip hop, but lately I’ve moved toward those long focus playlists on YouTube and things like Brain.fm. They seem to help me, so I was curious whether other people deliberately use something to get into that state or whether it just happens through the work itself.

Re:No AI Fridays by nunez on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:00PM (#49500442)
Good music, a good beverage and loads upon loads upon loads of free time.
Re:No AI Fridays by hrideshmg on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:21PM (#49500682)
the flow state isn't something that is triggered by music. It can help maybe, but it's not a pre-requisite.

It's something common to a lot of creative fields, that moment where u enter a sort of hyper-focused state where the line between you and the code blurs and you operate at peak efficiency.

It quite literally feels like overclocking your brain. I miss it a lot.

Re:No AI Fridays by KingOfMyRoom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:33PM (#49503499)
I tend to agree. I think music can help prolong the state. It helps to keep on grinding.

You said you miss that state a lot. What changed? Is it related to using AI more when coding or something else?

Re:No AI Fridays by nogbit on Sunday August 30, 2026 @04:39PM (#49502535)
You don’t need to use anything. You just need to enjoy what you are doing. This is often related to dopamine. Being in flow state for hours on end while programming is bliss and fun for me.

If you don’t enjoy programming keep trying, have the language or api docs open and do not use generative AI. Generative AI just gets you outcomes. An artist paints because they like painting, not because they like a pile of painted pictures.

Re:No AI Fridays by KingOfMyRoom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:29PM (#49503472)
I’m not a programmer, life choices took me in another direction, but I’m starting to understand the addictive part of building things and immediately seeing them come to life.

With AI coding it suddenly feels like there are so many possibilities. My biggest problem now is almost the opposite: trying not to chase every idea and keeping myself focused on building one thing. There’s definitely a dopamine hit in seeing visible progress regularly :)

Re:No AI Fridays by dom96 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:28PM (#49503862)
For me music is usually a must. I need to drown out any potential distracting noise.
Re:No AI Fridays by ceejayoz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:58AM (#49499837)
Eh, experiences will vary. For me, my zone is conducting things, not typing. Firing something off in twelve tabs and coming back later is precisely how my brain works.
Re:No AI Fridays by majormajor on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:22PM (#49500072)
> Firing something off in twelve tabs and coming back later

As someone who gets "in the zone" like the person you're replying to, I just don't get how this could possibly be the same thing. "Coming back later" doesn't make any sense when you're in that state. Stopping and waiting is a killer. You're just constantly doing things without necessarily consciously thinking about it.

Do you mean you're switching continually between the twelve sessions? Or literally "coming back" in a different sort of operating mode?

The closest thing to it for me using AI tools is specifically not running multiple "agents" but making targeted changes over and over and over but with a 10x+ increase in typing-vs-change ratio. (This also rules out things like Opus let alone Fable as they're just too slow and do too much at once.)

Re:No AI Fridays by ceejayoz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:52PM (#49500365)
My zone is like that of an orchestra conductor.

I point at the violins. I gesture the drums upwards. Sometimes I make a big broad gesture that encompasses the entire orchestra.

My agents are tasked, in part, with explaining the context with mockups and examples I can poke at for each job.

Re:No AI Fridays by majormajor on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:05PM (#49500502)
You mentioned "coming back later" but being in the zone. That's the part I want to understand. So this metaphor isn't helping cause the conductor is constantly working, constantly seeing the output. Not coming back later.
Re:No AI Fridays by ceejayoz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:18PM (#49500647)
My zone is the big-picture zone. What are we building, what needs to be done, how do the interrelated bits all come together? I can tell an agent "go implement X" and start planning Y that comes after it.

I don't really get in the zone for raw code typing, that's always been a slog.

Re:No AI Fridays by dom96 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:33PM (#49503887)
I cannot imagine being able to plan the next thing when I don't know what issues the coding agent might run into with the previous/current task. It feels like a waste to be planning the next thing when my previous plan may turn out to be wrong. The only thing I can really think to do is to wait for the agent to be finished, which makes getting distracted by social media and other random stuff really easy. Total opposite of being in the zone.
Re:No AI Fridays by ceejayoz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @08:16PM (#49504219)
I can't imagine free soloing El Capitan, but there's a guy out there doing it. My artistic skills cap out at shitty stick figures.

I get more distracted if I attempt to focus on just one thing for a day.

Different brains.

Re:No AI Fridays by majormajor on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @10:42PM (#49545338)
> My zone is the big-picture zone. What are we building, what needs to be done, how do the interrelated bits all come together? I can tell an agent "go implement X" and start planning Y that comes after it.

Well hang on, why wouldn't you just have another agent planning Y for you? And then just come back and review what it comes up with?

Re:No AI Fridays by dieortin on Monday August 31, 2026 @08:12PM (#49516396)
Based on what you’re describing as “your zone”, I would assume you have never experienced the flow state others are talking about. Flow state comes with long stretches of deep, focused work, without context switches or interruptions. This is fundamentally incompatible with what you’re claiming to be “your zone”.
Re:No AI Fridays by wiether on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:20PM (#49501319)
I experience the exact opposite myself.

Before AI, the only way I could get in the flow was by isolating myself from everything to avoid direct distractions (phone, emails, IM...) or indirect (having something else on my mind). It was something I was able to achieve only a few times a year. It did felt incredible. As soon I was getting stuck on something tedious, I had to resort to a web search and it broke the flow.

With AI, I can achieve this state every weekend for personal projects, and every day I'm WFH or when I'm alone in my corner of the office. I start with a list of goals/tasks, put X agents at work (I prefer working on multiple projects in parallel, with only one task per project) and while they're doing their stuff, I'm thinking about the next steps, filling the backlog, catching issues needing rework... I don't get stuck: either the agent we'll offer a workaround, or I'll push it in the backlog. Most often, the solution comes to me while I'm not in front of my computer. I can focus on the big picture, the actual problems that I'm trying to solve. Yesterday I did exactly this: started at 8am, leaving my desk just to fill my water bottle or empty my bladder... and it's only because a friend came to my place at 8pm that I stopped. I thought I was at it for only two hours...

I hate how this comment can make me look as an AI preacher; but I'm not trying to convince anyone to stop doing anything they're doing because I found the ultimate solution. No. I'm just describing how I'm enjoying _doing stuff_ on the computer more than I ever did in the ~30 years I've been doing it.

Re:No AI Fridays by wkjagt on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:08AM (#49499327)
I got out of tech about 5 years ago, before AI really took off. I still do a lot of personal projects and now never use AI. I tried it a bit (only free plans) but noticed how much it caused me to no longer be able to think through a solution myself. I thought I was learning a lot from it but for some reason whatever I learned from it didn't stick. So now I'm no longer using it at all. I do realize that this is very specific to my situation of course.
Re:No AI Fridays by yoyohello13 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:25AM (#49499521)
There was a well known phenomenon people called ‘tutorial hell’ where when learning to program you could understand all the code from tutorials, but when it came time to actually create your own solutions for stuff you got stuck. I think AI is basically enabling eternal tutorial hell, you never actually need to break out of it anymore.
Re:No AI Fridays by nunez on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:01PM (#49500459)
Same thing happens when you're learning a (human) language.
Re:No AI Fridays by yoyohello13 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:22PM (#49501341)
Yeah it shows up in all learning really. Putting theory in to practice is a crucial component of learning.
Re:No AI Fridays by Mabusto on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:08PM (#49500537)
This has happened to me with Rust. I read the book, did the interactive tutorials and then started on a small project and couldn’t really code anything!

This is familiar territory for me as I prefer to do a breadth first survey of something I’m trying to learn before digging in to an actual project with depth to make all the mistakes and blunders that make you actually good at something.

AI can still be a huge help here. I don’t really use AI to write the actual code. I will be tooting along, in the flow state, and then bang off a question or request like “how would you write this block of code” “how does this API work?”, and then just take what it says under advisement.

I find as soon as I start accepting what the AI says without critical thinking or just hitting the “apply block” button, it’s time to take a break. I use CoPilot and I barely touch 40% token spend per month and to me it’s the best way to work, I am always engaged, have a full mental model of what I’m working on, and have someone pushing back and criticizing what I’m writing. This gets you out of tutorial hell, but keeps you motivated because you’re not always staring at a blank code window wondering where to start.

Re:No AI Fridays by DrewADesign on Monday August 31, 2026 @08:36PM (#49516544)
The common denominator is cargo cultism. AI coding is really just trying to make cargo cult coding sustainable.
Re:No AI Fridays by tempest_ on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:22AM (#49499482)
Difference between taking your own notes and skimming someone else's.

I have found in the last year I "get more done" but I learn less. Whats even worse is if I burn though my token quota I am less likely(and less able) to "switch to manual". LLMs make an ocean of decisions and assumptions very quickly and if you don't slow it down very intentionally (and lose the promise of the AI providers are pitching) you will quickly not have a good idea of how systems work.

Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:29AM (#49499561)
It’s funny, I’m the exact opposite. I’ve tackled projects at scales I could never have done before, and learned more than I would have.

My actual coding ability is probably lower, but I’ve learned so much about music theory and production, CAD, and statistics. All because my hobby projects can go so much further than before.

Re:No AI Fridays by hello_moto on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:19PM (#49500038)
Will that knowledge stick? Given that you blasted through many things relatively quick?
Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:43PM (#49500262)
I’ve never been a cram for the test kind of person. I do best when using knowledge in an ongoing basis. Regardless of AI, things I studied intensely a decade ago but never use are by and large gone, whereas things I use frequently stay and deepen.

I don’t expect it to be any different with AI, but YMMV.

Re:No AI Fridays by dalmo3 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:39PM (#49500221)
As someone in a similar journey, I say: No, the knowledge won't stick.

OTOH, the output might stick?

Then the question becomes do you value knowledge for its own sake or for what it enables you to do? I don't have an answer.

Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:20AM (#49509452)
What an insightful response. I thought about that for a while, and its a great way to reframe some of this debate about the desirability of using AI.
Re:No AI Fridays by kaffekaka on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:50PM (#49500333)
Isn't there a risk that this learning is too superficial to actually stay around and impact your thinking in the long run?

How I experience it at least, there is no free lunch. Something that gives you knowledge and experience will almost by definition be painful and uncomfortable.

We use AI because it is faster, but that speed has a consequence.

Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:19AM (#49509442)
Someone else hit on it: a lot this discussion is about whether we as individuals see collection and maintenance of pure knowledge as the goal, or achievement of outcomes.

I’d say both are valid. I’m definitely an outcome person. I like making things. I’m taking a multi-year break from a decades-long CNC ceramics project, and I have no doubt my knowledge and skills will atrophy. That’s fine, I’m confident I can pick them up again if/when I return.

If I fail to work hard enough on understanding the physics of alternate tunings and rely “too much” on AI to produce a piece, I’m ok with that. If and when I hit a wall and AI isn’t giving the results I want, I’ll dive deeper.

Re:No AI Fridays by echelon on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:21AM (#49499474)
I really do not get all of y'all claiming this causes you to "not be able to think".

I worked on six nines active active payments infra that handled billions in daily transaction volume. I've built laser projection systems to play interactive games on skyscrapers. That ability is not atrophying.

I'm able to do 10-20x what I was able to do before AI, and I'm able to work at a breadth, depth, and level of polish that was previously impossible without mastering other diciplines (CSS, design, etc).

With AI, I've built several video games, my own SRS software, my own productivity software, and a business making $5M ARR and growing 70% month on month.

I've now done more hardware projects in the past eight months than I have in the last ten years. I might even start doing physics and bio (I did my undergrad in biochem) if I can find the time.

I'm also back to making movies. I was a major hobbyist filmmaker before the pandemic. I've shot dozens of films. They're extremely logistically complex and take so much time, and I was never capable of working in the high fantasy or sci fi genres I wanted to. Seedance is scratching so many of my itches it isn't even funny. It's like a gift from the gods.

I'm working more now than ever before, and I'm turning those hours of writing pointless glue code or testing new libraries and frameworks into actual productive work. Getting real work done.

2010-2020 felt like tech dystopia to me. Cellphone incrementalism, walled gardens, adtech, crypto, locked down devices. It was a pale shadow of the excitement of the early web. Personal websites, kids making Flash games, the indie web, p2p, people building stuff being 70% of the internet. For the first time in a long time, I feel extremely hopeful about the future and excited to work with tech again.

tl;dr - I can still write in cursive, but it turns out I just don't need to as I write my movie.

I do not get you folks who claim this is bad. This is magical.

Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:55AM (#49499819)
It sounds like you're experiencing a manic episode.
Re:No AI Fridays by echelon on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:02PM (#49499883)
Why do you (and lots of other people with your mindset) speak to other humans this way?

I post stuff I make on reddit and the teenagers (or grown men?) say things like, "your mother should have used a coat hanger if she knew you'd use AI". And it's almost a daily occurrence on social media.

I'm having a great time, and you don't have to join the club. Do whatever you want with your life. But stop talking to us like this.

I get that what I posted here is a critical refutation and not simply a neutral art or tech post about AI to a friendly audience. It invites critique and that's fine. But all the same, why do people go out of their way to frame it like this? To dunk on positive things and experiences people are having?

Re:No AI Fridays by spankibalt on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:21PM (#49500063)
> But all the same, why do people go out of their way to frame it like this?

Because you (and your legion of likeminded folks on pseudosocial media) indeed sound like some washed-up, self-delusional salesman with a loaded gun to his head, desperately trying to land that sales pitch. And that's before we come to address all the usual cheap clichés, false equivalences, or if you wrote that slop yourself in the first place, etc.

Re:No AI Fridays by yard2010 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:52PM (#49500362)
Lead, follow or get out of the way
Re:No AI Fridays by NateEag on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:51PM (#49500349)
I don't make comments like the appalling one you quote, and I'm sorry someone said that to you.

That said, I do hate genAI, and so have decent grounds for guessing why people would say things like that.

In my case, my employers have mandated LLM usage and all but banned actually programming, and I can see it rotting my ability to code and understand things.

That is extremely demoralizing, and I expect others going through it would be very likely to lash out in anger when they see people praising genAI as amazing and wonderful.

Distinct from that, those of us who have at one point supported ourselves in a purely artistic domain we love, such as music or illustration, are deeply saddened to see genAI destroying the opportunity to be paid to do those things we love. We hope that other humans will continue to invest their wealth into art made by humans, but clearly some are not, and that group may grow as the generators get better.

The pain of seeing the opportunities you had destroyed, both for yourself and for others, is made even more acute when you see someone shouting about how wonderful the tools causing the destruction are. Angry aggression is the expected result, we humans being what we are.

Finally, many of us in the anti-genAI camp are both able to see that the tools can be effective force-multipliers, but can also see the manifold negative externalities of genAI: on-demand propaganda, genAI psychosis, anonymous virtual rape (I don't know a better way to describe generating and distributing videos of actual humans doing sex acts they've never done), super-persuader scammers, potential massive job loss, concentration of social / political power into the GPU-holders' hands, accelerated climate change from the massive resource consumption, actual unaligned paperclip optimizers (see e.g. the HuggingFace hack, which is a textbook example of a monkeys-paw / paperclipper scenario), actually-effective mass surveillance, the increasing risk of bioterrorism at massive scale, and the looming possibility that an ASI evolved from these systems will actually bring us to "I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream" or extinction scenarios.

If you see all that, the urge to bully, insult, and denigrate people who are choosing all those consequences by using the things is very strong. Viewed from this angle, it's certainly hard not to conclude that those of us using genAI are being very, very selfish, choosing personal benefit over the collective good.

I feel guilty daily for not having the courage to refuse to use and accept the economic consequences (if I weren't a special-needs family's primary breadwinner, I would just refuse and accept the consequences).

Again, I'm sorry people are responding abusively to you, and I hope I will never react that way.

Have I helped you see why people might react cruelly to your comments?

Re:No AI Fridays by iammattmurphy on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @04:58PM (#49542459)
Honestly, I really appreciate this comment! I am quite a fan of LLMs for coding, learning, brainstorming, etc. But I’m also a musician, against AI slop media (who isn’t?) and of course most of the other negatives you cited.

It’s not like I’ve never heard the points you mentioned before, but I think you did a great job of assembling these ideas and presenting them in a sensible way… it’s legitimately made me far more empathetic to the AI haters and perhaps has even tempered my near-term optimism about AI.

I say near-term because I’m not so optimistic about AI in the medium- or long-term. And the short term may well be tiny.

Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @03:51PM (#49502125)
Because the shoes fits. Racing thoughts, high energy, highly distractible, detachment from reality and delusions of grandeur. Next comes the crash.
Re:No AI Fridays by wkjagt on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:37AM (#49499635)
I believe you. I'm just telling my own personal experience. What works for you doesn't seem to work for me. Maybe I'm doing something wrong? But also: I'm purely doing things for my own pleasure now, so whatever I enjoy more is what I'm free to do. Again though, that's just me.
Re:No AI Fridays by LogicFailsMe on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:45PM (#49500285)
I would absolutely believe people on the spectrum with hyperfocus-oriented ADHD (such as myself) might knock things out of the park with coding agents while everyone else is befuddled by their bizarre behavior. But then, I don't get the slow pace and fake drama of reality TV and professional wrestling, yet so many others do. Similarly, starting with British serial dramas like Survivors and Blake's Seven in the 80s, I really enjoy serialized dramas with an intricately constructed world. We are not all alike inside IMO, but that's 100% a good thing too.
Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @03:52PM (#49502137)
ADHD is an inability to focus. ChatGPT diagnosed you incorrectly.
Re:No AI Fridays by LogicFailsMe on Sunday August 30, 2026 @05:24PM (#49502982)
Not even wrong: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/hyperfocus-and-adhd

"When you have ADHD, the problem isn’t that you lack attention, it’s that you struggle to control your attention — to put your attention where you want it to go rather than having it go where it wants to go. Hyperfocus is a natural consequence of that lack of control."

Lived it. Made it work for me professionally in the end. Do not not need pointy hair edicts telling me how to do career development.

Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:34PM (#49503894)
Sounds like it's just telling you what you want to hear. ADHD is when you can't focus, or when you focus too much. Really meaningful label then.
Re:No AI Fridays by LogicFailsMe on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:51PM (#49504045)
The Cleveland clinic is telling me what I want to hear? Righto squire.
Re:No AI Fridays by ragequittah on Sunday August 30, 2026 @08:29PM (#49504295)
As odd as it sounds this is correct. Hyper focus is a huge problem with ADHD. You forget to eat and get worse sleep because you're so focused on 1 problem.

This often means that you pay attention to nothing else around you or what's actually important which is where the deficit is.

Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @08:41PM (#49504372)
Sounds like you're just defining ADHD to mean whatever you want it to mean. Thankfully we didn't have TikTok to diagnose hyperfocusers like Einstein with a brain disease, or we never would have got general relativity.
Re:No AI Fridays by ragequittah on Sunday August 30, 2026 @09:50PM (#49504743)
I highly suggest you read about the subject. This isn't the fringe science you're implying. It's a big reason I was diagnosed by my doctor. And it's often treated quite well by taking ADHD medications.

  “While the estimated 8 million adults in the USA affected by attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) might find it nearly impossible to sit still in a lecture hall or excruciatingly challenging to focus on writing a term paper, these same individuals might find themselves spending hours at a time composing a new song, tinkering with their car, writing computer code, or watching television (Kessler et al., 2006). The term “hyperfocus” (HF) has been used to characterize this state of heightened, focused attention that individuals with ADHD frequently report (Brown, 2005; Conner, 1994; Ozel-Kizil et al., 2016).”[1]
[1]https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30267329/ Other reading: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30267329/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12438511/
Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Sunday August 30, 2026 @10:01PM (#49504803)
Yes, the medicalization of normal human experiences is lamentable. But grant money doesn't appear without diseases for pharma to treat.
Re:No AI Fridays by ragequittah on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:09PM (#49511416)
Strange take. If it's normal to spend 12 hours not eating staring at a screen trying to solve 1 problem and completely oblivious to the outside world then I guess I don't know many normal people.
Re:No AI Fridays by breezybottom on Monday August 31, 2026 @02:42PM (#49513282)
We'd still be living in caves if there weren't people like that.
Re:No AI Fridays by ragequittah on Monday August 31, 2026 @06:20PM (#49515542)
At the same time if it significantly hinders you in everyday life it's nice to have a way to break free of it. I can't take most ADHD medications due to unrelated issues and it's such a shame after hearing / witnessing first hand how much it can genuinely change a person's life for the better.
Re:No AI Fridays by LogicFailsMe on Friday September 04, 2026 @12:51PM (#49567109)
I would absolutely consider medication but 2 of my 3 siblings were meth heads likely in part trying to address the same thing in a path that ought to be legal and cleaner, but that's a different conversation.

Anyway, not touching ADHD drugs given how easily I can convince myself 2+ drinks is a fantastic idea. So, TLDR 100% not going here:

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2002/feb/09/extract

Re:No AI Fridays by iammattmurphy on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @05:03PM (#49542534)
Having a label for a recognized and observable human condition does not condemn it. And it also doesn’t mean that we ought to medicate anyone with a label.

What it means is some people are able to potentially improve their lives by recognizing a pattern of behavior and educating themselves about strategies (including medication) that might help.

Re:No AI Fridays by yoyohello13 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:54AM (#49499808)
Links? What’s the business?
Re:No AI Fridays by echelon on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:19PM (#49500039)
Re:No AI Fridays by puelocesar on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:47PM (#49500313)
So basically you created a Slop Maker..

I mean, you do you I guess..

Re:No AI Fridays by echelon on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:17PM (#49500633)
Prior to AI, I've made over a dozen films. Six AM call times and eighteen hour days, location release forms, insurance, lifting big props off of two story shelving at the prop house in sweltering heat, last minute fixes to catering for hundreds of people, running AD and logistics.

During the pandemic I bought fifty grand of mocap gear to keep shooting virtually.

Are you a filmmaker? Because this tech helps me tell stories more directly than photons captured on extremely expensive glass, set dressing full of cheats and tricks, and spreadsheets of logistics.

I have several films coming out in theaters that use ArtCraft.

I'm working on anime reboots of several popular series from the 80's and 90's. Full licensing and original authors on board.

I'm talking to several major bands, huge directors, and tons of people in the space. I've talked to the leadership at many of the big studios and I'm working on deals.

I promise I care more about film than you do. I spend so much energy on it that it consumes me.

Hollywood already makes slop. Some of the projects that get greenlit are downright terrible. You don't need AI to make slop.

There are hundreds of AI filmmakers doing absolutely phenomenal work, and the pool is rapidly growing. You don't criticize early CG film for relying on imprecise Blinn-Phong shading, yet people who aren't even trying to carve sculptures out of the new kind of clay are eager to jump on AI rendering artifacts while discounting AI works as a whole.

An AI short film can take months and months of labor. An AI aided scene can take weeks. It's work. It's not "prompt and done".

What sucks is that I know a room full of people that went to expensive film school and wound up in support roles where they never got to helm their dream projects. Hollywood funding was never amenable to following your vision as your heart desired. We've been fortunate in software to not live with that curse. How many young Scorseses withered on the vine because they couldn't access the capital they needed to tell the stories their heart desired? AI is going to fix that.

Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:34AM (#49499605)
Hear hear. I do not understand the people who bemoan the loss of slide rules and books of trig tables in the era of graphing calculators.

I’m with you — I’m producing more and better art, with a deeper understanding of the art which comes from scale. My music is more innovative, my simulations are richer and more fun, I can wake up in the morning with a new idea and have a prototype in hours. It is magical.

Re:No AI Fridays by Jcampuzano2 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:57AM (#49499828)
Big difference is when you use a calculator or other tools, you still have to interpret and know what to enter.

With modern AI, you basically just ask for something and what used to be days worth of work magically appears, you didn't really think through a single thing when it comes to implementation, architecture etc unless you made a conscious effort to audit that.

We also generally still encourage students to learn how to do certain operations and what they mean without a calculator before letting them rely on it to make things quicker. If you never knew what a sin/cos was you'd never even know when to use those or why they even exist on a calculator.

AI is a step up where you literally don't have to know what those are, you could just take a picture and ask for the solution and it would do that all for you if you let it.

In reality modern AI is a massive test of willpower. You can completely let go of the reigns and it will happily do everything for you.

Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:15AM (#49509392)
I appreciate your reply and framing, but it strikes me as a spirited opposition to delegation. Or at least a strong assertion that AI use is similar to managing an organization.

The reins metaphor is also interesting and cuts both ways: riders don’t expect to do the walking themselves, and setting direction is not the same as doing (even understanding, or being able to do) the work.

Re:No AI Fridays by claytongulick on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:36PM (#49500201)
> Hear hear. I do not understand the people who bemoan the loss of slide rules and books of trig tables in the era of graphing calculators.

Why do you think so many people prefer to listen to live music over an album playing on a jukebox?

Live music doesn't have the polish and perfection of a studio recording, it's much less efficient to have to manually play instruments than to just hit "play" on a song. So why bother?

I think it's because we're looking at things wrong all over the place.

Similar to live music, I definitely prefer to read code written by a real human. I can get in their head, understand how they were reasoning to solve a problem, even if there were problems with their reasoning.

When I hear all the breathless takes about AI "productivity" improvements, my brain just circles aback to the old saw about activity over achievement.

What are your outputs? What is activity and what is achievement?

A business person brags that AI is able to generate a report for them that used to require lots of manual work linking spreadsheets. OK.

What was the value of the report? What was the goal? I like to follow this all the way down-

- Widget sales report

Why?

- To inform inventory and production decisions, as well as marketing

Why?

- So that the company can make money? So that the founders can be proud of their product? So that the product can improve lives in some way?

Why?

- So that the people working can have improved lives, and/or more status in society

Why?

- So that collectively by competing with each other in structured ways, humans as a whole thrive and benefit

Etc...

OK. Where does AI fit into this? What has it taken away from the human experience, and how had it affected all of these goals?

The goal isn't code. It isn't even the product that the code makes - it's the reward signaling that you get from cooperating and competing with other people.

When you short circuit your efforts at creation by using AI, it feels the same to me as saying you're putting on a live music show, but instead just hitting "play" on an album.

Re:No AI Fridays by brookst on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:00PM (#49503680)
To the extent code is artistic expression, sure, I get what you're saying.

But when you sit down at an awesome synth and start jamming, do you care whether the firmware was written by a real live human?

It's forest/trees.

Re:No AI Fridays by claytongulick on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @01:17PM (#49524933)
> But when you sit down at an awesome synth and start jamming, do you care whether the firmware was written by a real live human?

Yes. Very much so.

I want to play an instrument that was thoughtfully designed and created at every level by someone with deep knowledge and passion.

I want hand crafted waveforms that someone spent endless hours with a headphone making just right, and they were damn proud of it.

I want to see videos of the person who did it and how. What inspired the sound, how it evolved.

I want the human experience.

Re:No AI Fridays by eudamoniac on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:43AM (#49499707)
What is this 5M business?
Re:No AI Fridays by echelon on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:17PM (#49500019)
https://getartcraft.com

https://youtu.be/kzvQMdg66Go (Now with full animation control, not just blocking and posing.)

This isn't UGC. I know a lot of studios from my filmmaking and 30% of my customers are spending thousands of dollars a month. It's got really good word of mouth and 89% M3 retention.

There are two films coming out in theaters this year that use ArtCraft.

It's also completely open source (the desktop app and the server).

There's another variant of ArtCraft that works with other subscriptions (Runway, Higgs, OpenArt, Comfy, etc.) that I'm testing with some artists: https://artcraftx.ai

Artists are fine tuning their own workflows on top of my own source software and then sharing their variants of ArtCraft.

I'm building OpenSourceRouter.com (soon) that will be an open source OpenRouter/FAL/RunPod/Featherless fine tunes. It already powers ArtCraft and is 90% complete to launch. Maybe in the future compute will be fully portable and you can just login to services with compute.

I'm also building a collaborative space for AI artists to share workflows, refs, fine tunes, network, and collaboratively build. This side of the business is already here and growing and I haven't built the infra for it yet. It's currently in Discord and an assortment of other places.

I'm going to make ArtCraft work with local models too. Comfy is not comfortable, and an all-rust/native, heavily opinionated product with lots of love from filmmakers and artists can do a better job than node graphs IMO.

I really care about these tools and I'm doing all of this from a place of passion. I'm not a mercenary trying to get rich quick. I'm here for the mission of empowering artists (and I count myself - this is a tool for me.)

It's growing really fast and I'm talking to bigger and bigger folks. It's kind of wild.

Re:No AI Fridays by yard2010 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:43PM (#49500256)
Dam everything about it sounds like a fairy tale. Way to go. That's so inspiring
Re:No AI Fridays by PKop on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:08PM (#49500538)
The comment on the YouTube video is accurate:

"Soul-less slop for people who don't understand art nor craft".

Cutting corners no doubt has appeal to some people in the industry making things, but this says nothing about the appeal to audiences that are supposedly going to want to pay to watch entire movies containing this nonsense. The end result shown in this video and on your website https://getartcraft.com/ just doesn't look good, at all.

> There are two films coming out in theaters this year that use ArtCraft.

Which ones? Like the internet itself, if movies start filling up with more and more slop, it's just going to be another instance of enshitification.

Re:No AI Fridays by nunez on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:07PM (#49500531)
Let me assist.

Yes, *you* are able to leverage your previous expertise *that you spent years accumulating with your own mind* to productivitymaxx to the extreme and work on all the things. AI is awesome for people who know what they're doing. This is well-documented.

What is _also_ true is that people think less to a lot less when they defer work to AI. For those who are getting into this industry or learning new things (i.e. the people that you will eventually NOT hire for your growing business that you MIGHT have hired in the past), that is an absolutely terrible thing to have happen. This is _also_ well documented. Your success does not refute that.

Re:No AI Fridays by polnoner on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:52PM (#49503627)
You were probably exposed to a wide range of art, music, culture and ideas growing up.

I think there is a whole generation of people who were so culturally starved during their formative years they can only see a blank canvas as a useless white square.

"Who is going to buy a painting of a white square?"

Re:No AI Fridays by CodeMage on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:38AM (#49505648)
Others have already talked to you about the significance of your anecdata and your faintly dismissive tone, but there's something else in your comment that tickled me and that no one's addressed yet:

> 2010-2020 felt like tech dystopia to me. Cellphone incrementalism, walled gardens, adtech, crypto, locked down devices. It was a pale shadow of the excitement of the early web. Personal websites, kids making Flash games, the indie web, p2p, people building stuff being 70% of the internet. For the first time in a long time, I feel extremely hopeful about the future and excited to work with tech again.

Who do you think was responsible for that dystopia? It wasn't those people you mentioned, who built the 70% of the old internet. The enshittification started when the people whose passion in life is to make money caught the scent of money-making potential the internet had.

But then, how did those people actually accomplish the enshittification we're dealing with now? The answer is: with the enthusiastic help of the True Believers. Crypto is the best example. Just recall how many devs were convinced that the blockchain was going to revolutionize everything. And I mean devs. Not snake-oil peddlers in suits, not LinkedIn influencers, none of the usual posse of posers, but people who actually wrote code and were reasonably good at that.

And that's not the only example, just the best one. I've been there myself. Back when OOP, UML, capital-A Agile, CMMi, and MDA (Model Driven Architecture) were the Hot New Thing, I was one of the True Believers, following the trends and proselytizing my colleagues.

Every bit of the dystopia you lament was pushed by the combination of ambitious MBAs and True Believer devs.

And the reason I bring this up is because you're one of those True Believers now. It's easy to fall into that trap. All you need is to have enough good experiences with the Hot New Thing to suppress your critical thinking and believe that this will Make Everything Great Again.

The same kind of people who profited off the tech dystopia you saw are now ushering a new, worse tech dystopia that you're turning a blind eye to. Your belief that this new tech will somehow balance and even counteract what those people did to the internet you loved is not based in facts. It's faith.

Re:No AI Fridays by iamsaitam on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:25AM (#49509507)
Maybe instead of delving into physics and bio, delve into ethics and empathy.
Re:No AI Fridays by ropbear on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:00PM (#49499859)
In my experience, students were actually pretty good about understanding this for themselves, at least in a security course I ran a survey in[0]. Unfortunately I didn’t get a statistically significant sample size (10/~60).

Another caveat is this was a graduate course, so I would expect more maturity and integrity on average than an undergrad course. But anecdotally I thought it was an interesting result.

[0] https://exploiting.systems/posts/2026-05-17-learning-focused...

Re:No AI Fridays by ajasmin on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:11PM (#49499969)
Sure. No AI for toy projects:. But the professional mission-critical ones, you should just let the LLM write them
Re:No AI Fridays by praveer13 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:48AM (#49499758)
For my personal “project” I’ve been using chatgpt to teach me from math (linear algebra) to quantum computing - asked it to create a big list of prompts optimal for single threads, for me to learn with Socratic method. I plan to write my notes as a blog for each thread in my own words. I think this is a good use of AI for personal goals, it’s the best learning experience for me so far. I’ve never been able to focus on lecture videos
Re:No AI Fridays by LogicFailsMe on Sunday August 30, 2026 @12:41PM (#49500238)
After many decades of coding, probably 1M+ LOC*, for real, I am purposely doing most of my work through coding agents to understand their capabilities. No stupid demand that I take a day off from AI is remotely helpful here.

But broadly my preliminary findings after a year or so:

1. AI gets you to that MVP 80% dopamine rush and then takes all that dopamine away if you lean into doing the last 20% with it. But if you try to do the last 20% yourself, you will experience the joy of agentic coding style and you will lose the ability to even produce dopamine. I use these things to build PoCs, not products.

2. The haters mostly have no idea how amazing getting to that 80% really is as a technological achievement and they are mostly stuck at Stochastic Parrot. And 3 days of the ungimped Fable demonstrated to me most of that remaining 20% is achievable, but not with gimping and/or production optimizations by the frontier labs.

3. If you want to see the promise and the limits of coding agents, you have to try to build something with them. But if you hate AI, you've already made up your mind and no amount of evidence will sway you, so don't bother.

4. These things are hideously power inefficient. And Moore's Law is out of steam. While we could stand up renewable and nuclear to power this, there are factions that hate one or the other more than they hate AI so good luck with that.

5. The San Francisco AGI cult is 100% unhelpful and the C-suite linkedin lunatics who take them seriously are even worse.

I'm reading a book written in the 90s but set in the 1980s where one of the assertions was that America is incompatible with technocracy. Prophetic methinks.

*No this does not mean I have some sort of 10x engineer privilege compared to GenZ and how will they ever learn to code? No, this just means I got the crap kicked out of me in grade school and consistently dismissed as weird growing up with the parents of those GenZ kids who have landed in a disturbing culture of learned helplessness and social media addiction built by an unholy cabal of GenX and GenY. They built it, they can fix it. Won't someone finally think of the chiiiilldren? Especially the weird ones that could replace me and outdo me?

Re:No AI Fridays by lijok on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:06PM (#49500514)
If you’re not learning with AI in play, you sure as sunshine wont be learning anything without AI

It’s when we put arbitrarily impossible deadlines that AI users learn nothing

Re:No AI Fridays by caconym_ on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:49PM (#49500994)
I don't think this is true at all. If you don't have AI then either you build what you need to build and learn how to do it along the way, or you build nothing and learn nothing. There is no option to build something but learn nothing, but that's the default outcome with AI. To learn how to build something AI built for you, you need to build it again on your own, which I dare say very few AI users are doing for nontrivial projects.
Re:No AI Fridays by roosterIllusi0n on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:40PM (#49501515)
Universities are the type of place you would automatically expect to teach the fundamentals. They do it in every other subject. You should have "coding like a caveman" back to back with "coding like a spaceman". You can make the hand coded class have two 1.5hr in-person labs each week. With an AI class along side of it. Don't wait on either skill, both need to start freshman year.

First year AI is teach assistive coding using llms with open source models. Setup a workbench llm for each student to have with an openweight model on it. Teach different ways of getting good results and go over setting up the whole environment yourself.

The next year do a 4hr lab in a lab room with office chairs, variable height desks, and model it off an open office. No special dress code, but name tags and people will talk to each other with the openness of dialog at a good workplace. This even gives the TA usable experience. You could introduce different structures with leads or co-equals or any useful team structure.

People need to be taught in-person working skills because companies don't want to hire people without experience. This also helps someone be able to interview for a work from home job.