News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by Aurornis on Monday August 10, 2026 @04:56PM (#49249608)
Not that I'm condoning it, but this law requires self-declaration, not verification. It might sound pedantic but the practical difference is huge.

Self-declaration means that the system asks the user to declare if they are a minor. Nothing is verified.

Age verification typically means a system which checks ID or has other enforcement measures to try to verify age.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by mosura on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:08PM (#49249756)
It is a technical ratchet. Once you accept part of the implementation it will never be undone, more will be added.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by bodge5000 on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:01PM (#49251060)
Very true, though this is something thats pretty difficult to get to by tiny increments, which is usually how these nefarious means are accomplished. One tiny thing is asked after another, each one too small to put up a fight against, and then suddenly they've crossed your line and you didn't even notice. Thats not particularly easy to do here, so the line will remain just as strong.

Maybe next they'll ask maintainers to go from a bracket to a specific age, and then next ask for verification, but the jump from specific age to verification is big enough that there'll be just as much resistance to it.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by terribleperson on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:44PM (#49250210)
I don't think this is a safe assumption.

As a counter, actual age verification is being rolled out in other places. I really don't think we're in a position of choosing between no age-based access mechanism, and age-based access mechanism. Between the anti-porn types and public demand for some kind of regulations on social media, regulation of some kind is inevitable.

Our actual choice may only be what type of restriction we can live with, and I much prefer this type to the kind that requires websites to demand my id and photos of my face. Especially since some implementations of this concept (the California one, I think) declare that websites aren't legally required to look deeper than the attested age, which is a very nice feature.

Mind you, I don't know why the legislators are bothering mandating OS support for these features. It would be much easier to mandate that websites support the feature, make it clear to them that supporting the feature appropriately will free them from liability for children accessing content, and then wait as users demand that their OS support the feature.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:57PM (#49250355)
Re: your last paragraph

I actually agree with you, if you mandate that the site has to look for an affirmative signal and if it doesn't get one, has to assume the user is the youngest possible age group. Users would demand the proper support for it.

Although it would have to have some teeth capable of biting the client software companies, because for instance, if browser(s) chose to on their own simply send "I'm over 21" to every site this becomes a pointless exercise and that applies whether the browser makers do it out of frustration that the OS support hasn't landed, or out of malice (imagine a browser that misreported age on purpose, specifically targeted at kids who want to bypass the parental controls).

Honestly though - because kids (especially the younger set) are hard pressed to buy their own hardware, a property that can only be set up out of the box, and can only be undone by using the account password of the parent who set it up, it is the perfect level of security here. And as for browsers, all you need is the gatekeepers (Apple, Google, MS) to agree not to ship in their "stores" browsers designed to evade it. Yes, you can totally compile your own browser, but most kids are using locked platforms like iOS and Android, and are by default denied permissions to run arbitrary software on platforms like Mac and Windows, so that's fine.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by terribleperson on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:08PM (#49250492)
Yeah, that's pretty much what I am imagining. You're right about needing some teeth - maybe the legislature could define a spec, and penalties for implementing the feature in a commercial product without actually following the spec.

I really think all we need is what you describe in your third paragraph. It doesn't need to be bulletproof, it just needs to be an easy way for parents to set the level of content their children can access without them having to hover over their children at all times. Something like that could easily be set up in the Genius store when someone gets a new iPhone, or set up at first boot on an Android phone. That's like 90% of the devices anyone is actually worried about. Windows support of the feature would take it to like 99.9%.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:16PM (#49250582)
Exactly. Fortunately, the kids we're most concerned with - young ones who just want to access their brainrot - has very little overlap with Linux users anyway. So, while I hate this hysterical propaganda portrayal as "aGe vErIfIcAtIoN," an "OSS operating system" exception doesn't really bother me, as long as it doesn't let the usual suspects make an end-run ("Darwin is OSS! See! iOS is exempt")
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by pessimizer on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:45PM (#49250927)
> if browser(s) chose to on their own simply send "I'm over 21" to every site this becomes a pointless exercise and that applies whether the browser makers do it out of frustration that the OS support hasn't landed, or out of malice (imagine a browser that misreported age on purpose, specifically targeted at kids who want to bypass the parental controls).

If it's a header, you can strip it out at the browser level, the user level, the kernel level, the hardware level, the router level, the router OS level, the router hardware level, or at the ISP level, depending on what a parent (or a state) desired.

The teeth are only necessary for the websites, which are never going to conform to the law anyway, whether through a header or through device attestation, without draconian Chinese-level enforcement that has never been seen in the West before. This new contract will have to be enforced at both endpoints. You will need the ID (whatever you want to call it) to get onto the network, whether you're an individual or the site being visited.

The idea that device attestation is going to bother the Moldovan tube site your kid gets pirated porn through is a surprisingly ignorant fantasy, especially when it comes from technical people. The Pirate Bay is still up. Megaupload is up and runs better than ever. People have 20 year old torrent site accounts. OS-level age attestation must be a first step, because it won't work.

And as to it not being enforced either by the hardware or by identity verification of the user, that's an impossibility. A kid can also overwrite an operating system, or even just overwrite the important part; so that means that either only attested operating systems can be installed, or no user is trusted at any time without state verification.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:06PM (#49251105)
This sounds like a hot take, but I'm way less concerned with sketchy porn sites (mostly for the kind of reasons you say which boil down to ... they're sketchy).

I'm more concerned with deliberate manipulation of young people by social media. TikTok and its clones especially have demonstrated an incredibly strong ability to not just addict and brainrot kids (which is bad enough -- and it's really, really bad), but also to shape their opinion. All that discussion about the CPC having complete control if they wanted to exert it wasn't BS. Whoever controls them absolutely can use an algorithmic feed to astroturf "viral" videos pushing any narrative they want. Think of Elon Musk in his role as owner of X if you like the CPC.

Anyway. Most tweens and young teens don't know how to use Bittorrent. They use iOS and Android all day, and Chromebooks. These function as closed platforms, and macOS is as well unless you go out of your way. And Windows unless you make your kid an Administrator. Linux and other noncommercial OSS operating systems can have an exception if it makes it less burdensome on the maintainers. This doesn't change the fact that a law like this still solves a ton of problems that parents otherwise can't solve, and that big tech could only solve independently today by very privacy-invasive means.

> because it won't work.

It sounds like you think "work" means "prevent 100% of minors from seeing even a single frame of Bad Stuff anywhere online on any device"

To me "work" means "prevent most children (who aren't extremely technical) from mainstream social media sites openly experimenting on them daily to build a paperclip maximizer, where the paperclips are 'watch minutes' (as a proxy for ad revenue) and the planet being dismantled is our society."

It would "work" by this definition.

> device attestation

this specific term means something specific and is not what this law is about - not sure if you meant to tangle that idea up with this.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by JoshTriplett on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:52PM (#49250304)
> I really don't think we're in a position of choosing between no age-based access mechanism, and age-based access mechanism.

It is impossible to win a battle you stop fighting.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by terribleperson on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:10PM (#49250514)
But it's possible to lose a battle you were never going to win in the first place, and end up in a worse place.

I think that if these types of laws (illinois, california) don't hit a critical mass, we're going to see ID verification become the dominant method of age verification. Most websites will use it, and it'll become global because it's easier to just demand an ID and a photo for every user through some third party provider than to offer looser restrictions for the handful of states that have different demands.

This is especially true since it's now been demonstrated that states (like Texas) can go after out-of-state sites serving people in Texas. Sure, you could scrupulously try to identify which state someone is in and use the appropriate level of verification, but then you might be liable if it turns out it was someone from Texas or Georgia or Britain using a VPN.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by JoshTriplett on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:39PM (#49250866)
> I think that if these types of laws (illinois, california) don't hit a critical mass, we're going to see ID verification become the dominant method of age verification.

You are assuming that age verification must necessarily happen. It needs to be destroyed at every possible juncture.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by tzs on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:10PM (#49251145)
What is your objection to the California law?

A summary for those not familiar with it:

• Operating systems on devices whose primary user is a child must provide a way for the parent to provide age bracket information about the child.

• They must also provide an API that apps and app stores can use to find out that age range if they need to have limits on what children can do with them.

• They amended it to not apply to most open source operating systems.

Note that there is no actual age verification. It just uses what the parents put in. It is really just requiring each OS to have a standardized parental control system.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by JoshTriplett on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:58PM (#49251509)
Among many other things, privacy. If you know an age range that's more information about the user than you should have, and you can use it for marketing. And if you can ask for an age range, then in practice you know a birthday; just keep asking until the range changes and record when you saw it change.

It's also the wrong way around: apps shouldn't ask for an age range, apps should provide one and the OS should do the checking.

I also object to it because it's a foot in the door for demanding that websites and apps care about that age range.

And most importantly, devices already provide parental controls in practice, and this law doesn't make those any better, it just unnecessarily cements one aspect of them into law. You can, already, on many devices, say "don't allow installing apps without permission", or "don't allow installing apps except those with this rating".

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by terribleperson on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:01PM (#49276340)
The only age range you get for adults is 18+, I think. For children, I don't think we should let companies retain that data.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by queenkjuul on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:53PM (#49288733)
> it's a foot in the door for demanding that websites and apps care about that age range.

This has been the case for literally decades. Social media sites aren't (technically) supposed to allow users under 13, and porn sites have obviously had this concern since forever.

This law does in fact make parental controls better by forcing the social media companies to change how they present content to minors.

I don't totally disagree that the impetus should be on the social media companies instead of the OS but i also genuinely don't see a problem with a voluntary adult/minor flag with a consistent API either

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by JoshTriplett on Thursday August 13, 2026 @02:03PM (#49289738)
Social sites aren't supposed to knowingly allow users under 13, but they're not required to proactively exclude them either, nor should they be.

And addictive feeds are a problem for everyone, of any age.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by queenkjuul on Thursday August 13, 2026 @09:46PM (#49293892)
Why shouldn't they have to exclude them? Cigarettes and alcohol are addictive for everyone but we require vendors to proactively exclude minors and only minors.

I mean look, up to me, sure, ban Facebook entirely or whatever, but i genuinely don't get why they shouldn't be required to exclude kids if they're gonna exist?

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by ivl on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:21PM (#49251223)
A headless server operating system does not need those steps. It does not need the bloat of prepping an API to communicate with websites.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by ivl on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:20PM (#49251214)
> This is especially true since it's now been demonstrated that states (like Texas) can go after out-of-state sites serving people in Texas.

Hey, give credit where credit's due.

The first to try that was NJ going after 3d printed gun developers.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by terribleperson on Monday August 10, 2026 @10:13PM (#49252550)
Yeah, I'm not super happy about all the 3d printing control legislation going around, which I frankly think is a lot more overreaching than these age declaration laws.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by AnimalMuppet on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:09PM (#49249774)
Stronger: Once you accept their right to ask, then you open the door to their right to a truthful answer, and thus to a verified answer.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by avianlyric on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:50PM (#49250289)
Hasn’t the right to ask existed since the invention of consent laws?

The state being able demand a persons age, and gate their behaviour based on that, has existed for hundreds of years so far. During that entire time the requirement to be truthful has also existed otherwise the laws would be meaningless.

All that’s changing now, is figuring out how that extends into the digital realm. I personally find the argument that the digital realm is somehow special compared to the physical realm, and thus certain laws simply shouldn’t apply when “done on a computer”, difficult to reconcile.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:03PM (#49250419)
Hard agree. I don't think we allowed video store operators in 1995 to just let kids wander into the back room and rent porn, but we're so used to there just being "no rules" online, it is coming as a massive shock now when it's being suggested that maybe there should be some basic guardrails to discourage that.

Let me be clear, I don't want face scans, or more of those creepy companies that operate this age verification crap for Discord, etc. Because I know it's not going to be implemented in the privacy-preserving way it could be, if there's ANY involvement with identity documents. Not least because we don't even have any proper cryptographically useful identity cards, so everything like that operates on a "trust us bro" basis where they pinky promise not to accidentally store everyone's raw face scans / ID cards / numbers / etc and inevitably leak them.

But out-of-box age declaration is not extreme and is not slippery-slope, any more than out-of-box user account creation 25 years ago has led to out-of-box ID card checks.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by singpolyma3 on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:11PM (#49249790)
Literally a slippery slope argument
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by eterm on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:13PM (#49249819)
Sometimes when you see your opponents getting out a ramp and a barrel of lube, you can call it a slippery slope.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:10PM (#49250518)
Or alternatively - you could recognize that normal people are getting more and more pissed off by the fact that social media companies are force-feeding garbage into their kids eyeballs 16 hours a day.

We could give them a reasonable solution that demonstrably preserves privacy and doesn't inconvenience anyone else (Suppose you want to see all the uncensored everything, you open your new PC or phone and say your DOB is 1/1/1900. Done. Status quo.)

Or we could be alarmist about that, torpedo that plan, and then in 2 more years when people are even MORE pissed, a horrifying new plan comes out, where the government scans your photo ID (with the help of some crappy private contractor of course) and both of them promise to probably not store the info and log your access. And that one manages to scrape by because people are at that point even more pissed and are determined to solve the problem somehow.

The actual 'bad guys' just wouldn't be able to get the public support for that second, shitty plan, if we basically solve the problem now with this very modest plan that's on the table now. Parents can handle this simple one-time out-of-box prompt and it makes sense. Device owner, the parent, that's the one who should make the call.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by eterm on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:26PM (#49251261)
I actually agree with you, but you have an optimism about the ability for open source maintainers to have achievable political aims, in a way that I haven't seen happen for decades.

What your happier future looks like requires both a technical solution, but more importantly political wins to sell that solution as the better one.

The current operating systems weighted by users, are entirely under the control of three major players, who are incentivised to further centralise things.

( I'm counting the three operating systems as Google Play Services, IOS and Windows. Yes, AOSP exists, but it's useless without Google Play Services. ).

I also don't think a device level switch would stop anything for a second, given the number of stories of parents who seem to hand their children their credit card, then complain about them racking up thousands of dollars on Roblox or whatever.

When the light-touch measures fail, the framework will be leveraged to start requiring more centralised and less private solutions.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:41PM (#49251384)
> given the number of stories of parents who seem to hand their children their credit card, then complain about them racking up thousands of dollars on Roblox or whatever

Sure, but you hear about those because of how shocking they are to all sensible people. Actually I bet a lot more kids rack up those charges using cards they stole from mom's purse. Same kids will start trying to sneak mom's old iPhone out of the desk drawer to install "Adult TikTok" on. But again, this is not more concerning than the way my generation rooted around on the top shelf of Dad's closet to find the old Penthouse magazines.

I just don't accept the absolutist idea that if anything can be gotten around by any means, that means it can't still be sensible policy. Which seems to be the attitude taken by two separate groups -

1. Your and my common enemy -- the ones who are eager to enact "Show ID to access this site (trust us!)" verification schemes

2. And the freedom-loving hackers I've been arguing with today, who also detest those schemes but also don't want to see any scheme of any kind.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by eterm on Monday August 10, 2026 @09:01PM (#49251995)
> I just don't accept the absolutist idea that if anything can be gotten around by any means, that means it can't still be sensible policy

Now on that I agree strongly, there is a crowd on here that believe that technical weaknesses defeat political strengths, and focus all their effort into proving a technical workaround only for the political juggernauts to continue crushing their freedoms.

These are arguments which often flow, "This law is impossible to enforce in totality, therefore the law will fail", which fails to understand what law really is, and how much people abide to even bad laws.

I think we disagree on what's actually needed to defeat the increasing centralisation of the internet, I think it really needs a movement to wake people up, it needs skilled political operators, and it needs passionate orators, to spread the message that we're increasingly operating in a controlled space which every year has greater hurdles to communicate outside of the bounds which those who control it allow, rather than the open internet we used to enjoy and need to fight to defend.

And, most importantly, that that fight needs to be political and not technical. Being seduced by the appeal of technical solutions is unhelpful distraction. Cryptocurrency will not keep you free. Duress pins will not keep you free. It is political will that will do that.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @03:50PM (#49263509)
Hear, hear. I could even argue that the dearth of "skilled political operators" and "passionate orators" - at least excluding the ones that seem to be under exclusive contract to the Devil himself - is maybe the worst part of our current era. And it's widespread, and on multiple continents. We haven't seen the likes of Teddy Roosevelt, William Jennings Bryan, or FDR, or even JFK or LBJ, in a whole generation. Even a comparison to Richard Nixon, by any measure, makes every presidential candidate and congressional leader in the past 20 years look like buffoons and fools. Terms like "Debate" have become redefined as "Insulting and ranting past your opponents to get cheers out of your fans." No wonder we can't pass any policy that makes any sense with these jackasses in charge.

And in case anyone wonders, on my list of skilled politicians above, I'm only old enough to have witnessed Nixon, so this is not a "back in my day" rant. It's a "it hasn't been ok since way before my day."

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by Akronymus on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:50PM (#49250272)
It's a fallacy when there is no cause and effect for each step. This, however states the steps.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xp84 on Monday August 10, 2026 @06:03PM (#49250430)
What? The GP comment is one single line which states that it just "will" happen.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by boredatoms on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:13PM (#49249820)
Slippery slope actually works though.

Makes no sense to treat it like some unwelcome argument

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by thephyber on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:41PM (#49250178)
Slippery Slope is the assertion that A therefore B therefore C therefore D.

It is frequently a fallacy because D isn't predetermined by A when humans are involved. If you believe in free will, each of B, C, D are independent decisions. Sometimes we stop at A. Sometimes we pass Prohibition as a Constitutional Amendment, and later roll it back.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by manphone on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:12PM (#49249813)
Only if it was not something they constantly already do.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by hex4def6 on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:31PM (#49250037)
In a philosophy classroom, it’s a fallacy. In a courtroom, it’s called precedent.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by rolph on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:22PM (#49249941)
it is the thin edge of a slippery wedge..
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by huvarda on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:25PM (#49249963)
slippery slope is if you say 'if a therefore d' not 'a leads to b leads to c leads to d'
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by unethical_ban on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:16PM (#49249869)
"Slippery slope" is a term like "conspiracy theory". Tarnished by overuse, often misapplied, but they absolutely exist.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by rowanG077 on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:24PM (#49249956)
I would rather call it the boiling frog. But hey, whatever floats your boat.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by tstrimple on Monday August 10, 2026 @10:06PM (#49252504)
This is a nonsense argument considering over half the states have already put actual ID verification requirements in front of "adult content". Blue states are trying to ratchet to what red states just pass? Why? They could just follow suit and require you to upload your ID to a 3rd party service and scan your face. Your conspiracy theories don't seem to hold up to reality.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by weaksauce on Monday August 10, 2026 @04:58PM (#49249637)
that is the start of a lot of bills like this... they really only ever increase in scope and invasiveness.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by bryanlarsen on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:10PM (#49249783)
On the contrary in my experience once a legislature passes a bill to "fix" a particular problem they consider it fixed and don't update it for at least 20 years.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by paimapi on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:14PM (#49249839)
it depends on whether or not there's someone who sees it as a crusade (rare), sees it as a way to get political clout (very common) and/or is getting a lot of lobbying money (extremely common [1]). see, for eg, the anti-trans bills that are being passed

this is the same rhetorical and political strategy, that there are 'dangerous' people who will exploit your children so please vote for me, the person who cares the most about children and will go after the 'dangerous' people

[1] https://themarkup.org/privacy/2021/04/15/big-tech-is-pushing...

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by frumplestlatz on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:50PM (#49250273)
What is the connection to “anti-trans bills”?
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by paimapi on Monday August 10, 2026 @09:39PM (#49252310)
they're both grounded in fearmongering that's led to cultural panics and utilize the rhetoric of 'protecting children' as the sell

https://www.law.georgetown.edu/gender-journal/wp-content/upl...

"Overwhelmingly, state legislators behind recent anti-trans legislation have argued that they were introducing these bills with the intent to protect children – whether that be “protecting children” from “profoundly unethical and morally wrong” medical practices"

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/06/eff-gov-pritzker-veto-...

"Much of H.B. 5511 is modeled after controversial legislation passed in California (A.B. 1043) and New York’s Stop Addictive Feeds Exploitation (SAFE) for Kids Act"

there's also the rampant astroturfing

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/30/christian-hate...

"The surge in funding to the ADF, which has been termed an “anti-LGBTQ hate group” by the Southern Poverty Law Center, saw it record revenue of $104.5m in 2021, according to filings with the Internal Revenue Service."

ADF's main funders being the Servant Foundation or a single billionaire family's pet foundation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Servant_Foundation) and the National Christian Foundation which receives large donations from multiple extremely wealthy individuals like David Green, co-founder of Hobby Lobby (https://readsludge.com/2019/03/19/americas-biggest-christian...)

this is very much like the funding of these 'privacy' acts by Meta, Alphabet, etc - lots of money directly into the hands of local legislators across multiple state legislatures with the ultimate goal of providing institutional power over individuals, one just has a slightly more Machiavellian economic logic foregrounding it but the strategy, tactics, and overall erosion of civil liberties make for very similar outcomes

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by buran77 on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:41PM (#49250169)
Unless there is a big lobby behind getting more "fixes".
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by an0malous on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:58PM (#49251512)
Who's the lobby?
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by weaksauce on Monday August 10, 2026 @07:17PM (#49251189)
i mean with the rise of flock ad campaigns of "think of the children" and them installing platereaders all over the place this kind of thing is something that people want to capitalize on and make a buck. i can definitely see the lobbying pushing for more and more invasive versions of this.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by skinfaxi on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:01PM (#49249683)
Think of it like a foot in the door.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by SV_BubbleTime on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:26PM (#49249982)
Everyone else is arguing slippery slope.

I don’t even get that far, the proper response to my operating system asking me if I’m a minor or not is: fuck you. It isn’t a harmless question. We aren’t friends, I don’t want an algorithm of news and content, it’s an OS.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by shevy-java on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:05PM (#49249728)
I don't see the argument here. You can easily adjust the law to force verification.

You seem to assume that "this is now final, nothing will change after that". Why would you assume this to be the case?

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by xboxnolifes on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:08PM (#49249752)
The slope is only slippery if the change in question makes it easier for future changes to be bad. Otherwise you're only arguing for no changes to ever be made. Does this law make forced verification easier than if this law didn't exist?
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by tripleee on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:27PM (#49249992)
Once you go up the first step of a ladder, the second step is now easier. It's a shifting of the Overton window. You can't enact full surveillance in one move - no-one would accept that. You can boil the frog over a few decades, though.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by 3form on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:11PM (#49249804)
Potentially. The existence of the law exemplifies the idea the law is there to protect someone; all you need then to upgrade it is to argue that the current method is insufficient protection. Spirit of the law has been established - letter of the law will follow.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by zamadatix on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:11PM (#49249791)
Seems so - it builds in the verification infrastructure requirement, making it dead simple to change whether it is opt in or opt out at any time.

It's actually pretty hard not to have a change be part of a slippery slope. It requires including blocks for further behavior as any subset implementation is hard to sell as not being a slippery slope path otherwise.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by MrJohz on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:17PM (#49249875)
But they could also just implement verification now, which many governments are trying to do. The idea that you shouldn't let a government do one thing because they might do another thing is flawed if they could already do the other thing.

The danger of a slippery slope comes when one change enables the next change - for example, a law mandating certain kinds of data collection enables a future decision to discriminate or control based on the collected data. But in this case, no data is being collected, there's no step happening here that enables a more dangerous later step.

If anything, I'd argue this makes it harder to implement more invasive measures later, because rather than arguing that some form of age control is necessary, Illinois will specifically need to argue that age verification is necessary over the existing anonymous system. That's harder than saying "there is no protection for children right now, age verification is the only way forward".

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by TeMPOraL on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:26PM (#49249972)
'AnimalMuppet has the right take upthread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49249774): "Once you accept their right to ask, then you open the door to their right to a truthful answer, and thus to a verified answer.

> But they could also just implement verification now, which many governments are trying to do.

That itself is a proof: the voluntary age declaration was and is common on all the services that governments are now trying to force to do age verification, and it wasn't enough.

EDIT: in more general terms, and going beyond age verification thing and over many recent developments in information security, the Internet as a culture is missing an on-line equivalent to a key real-life social feature: the ability to answer with a shocked "gross!", followed by slapping the asker in the face.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by tstrimple on Monday August 10, 2026 @10:10PM (#49252532)
Nope. It's a stupid take. Especially considering over half of the US states have jumped right to looking for that verified answer but no one on HN gives a shit when red states do things. They only ever bitch and moan when a blue state is doing something far less invasive and then they have to turn it into a conspiracy theory that the blue states are secretly trying to do what the red states are just blatantly doing in the open with zero push back.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by MrJohz on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @04:43AM (#49255048)
But we already accept their right to ask. Certain websites have had age restrictions on them for years. There's nothing new to the idea that certain media is not permitted to certain age ranges. (This is leaving aside the idea that people generally agree that age restrictions and age verification are perfectly fine in public spaces in the physical world, and that the internet is very much an anomaly in this regard.)

Moreover, nothing really seems to have changed in the enforcement of that (as far as I understand, specifically focusing on laws like Illinois') — it's still ultimately the responsibility of parents to ensure their own child doesn't access restricted websites. This legislation would essentially provide a mechanism that makes it easier for parents to do that.

So no, I don't think that that is the right take.

I also find your edit somewhat amusing, as the key reason that age verification is such a topic is because of a different missing real-life social feature, which is the ability to look at someone and identify whether they're an adult or a child, alongside the ability to look at someone's ID without recording all their personal details forever. As they used to say, on the internet, no-one knows if you're a dog, which is both a strength and a weakness. Identifying mechanisms like this (ensuring parents have more control over their own computers, but not requiring full verification anywhere) seems like a reasonable approach to fixing some of the weaknesses of internet anonymity, while still preserving the basic strength that identifying yourself is always opt-in.

Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by chaps on Monday August 10, 2026 @05:39PM (#49250150)
As someone who's pushed on a technical law change.... "easily" DEEPLY, DEEPLY misstates the challenges of getting the law changed. Fun fact: people who oppose something tend to get in the way.
Re:Illinois just passed a law that puts Linux on the hook fo... by theNotFractured on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @05:25AM (#49255370)