News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by zulux on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:16PM (#48215659)
>>If Christopher Nolan’s coming adaptation of the Odyssey happens to do well enough to get Hollywood back on its feet,

A typical laconic reply works here: "If"

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by felipellrocha on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:11PM (#48216108)
Because Nolan is known for his hits and misses
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by mrec on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:00PM (#48217314)
Not 100% sure whether you're being sarcastic but... yes? IMO more misses than hits, and the misses tend to miss by more than the hits hit.
[dead]
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by AlotOfReading on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:35PM (#48216732)
Would you be happier if they had cast the trans actor as the trans character (Tiresias), or would that also be a bridge too far?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by dyauspitr on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:09AM (#48218130)
Tiresias was magically turned into a woman. He may as well have been turned into a rabbit.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by michaelmrose on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:20AM (#48218198)
If a movie had a black actor in it would you say that the movie was about black ideology?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by vkou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:36PM (#48216740)
When a non-trans person stars in a film, nobody calls it a 'straight-cis' ideological hit piece.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by defrost on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:45PM (#48216810)
It's literally just manufactured faux-concern about a rumour and a very very minor character role:

  Achilles does not actually appear as a living character in Homer's epic poem The Odyssey (as he dies in the Trojan War before Odysseus' journey home). 

  However, in Christopher Nolan’s upcoming film adaptation, the character is rumored to make a brief appearance as a ghost in the Underworld. Viral rumors suggested Elliot Page was cast in this role.
Nolan movies will continue to fail or succeed, it's a stretch for the GP commentor to tie that to a person cast for a bit part.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by MaxHoppersGhost on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:24PM (#48217496)
Yeah he doesn’t appear as a living character in Homer’s poem but he does appear as a ghost in the poem when they visit the underworld (sorry for the spoilers). Not sure what difference it makes if Achilles shows up as alive or as a ghost but he is in the poem and it would be weird to have a non macho dude play Achilles.

Regardless I think it’s a bullshit rumor and people are running with it. The sad thing is how believable the rumor is.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by defrost on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:35PM (#48217567)
> it would be weird to have a non macho dude play Achilles.

Odd. Remind me, wasn't it Achilles who spent a couple of years cross dressing as a girl while hiding out to avoid a fight?

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Achilles_on_Skyros

  Buenos noches Senores y Senoras Bienvenidos

  La primera pregunta es: Que es mas macho, pineapple o knife?

  Well, let's see
  My guess is that a pineapple is more macho than a knife

  Si! Correcto! Pineapple es mas macho que knife
  La segunda pregunta es: Que es mas macho, lightbulb o schoolbus?

  Uh, lightbulb?
  No! Lo siento, Schoolbus es mas macho que lightbulb

  Gracias. And we'll be back in un momento
~ https://youtu.be/AY3OgLo8DUc?t=14
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by dyauspitr on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:23AM (#48218224)
I hate these gotchas but I can’t resist and it’s on a flagged comment so no one is really going to see this. Are you saying trans people are just cross-dressers?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by tsimionescu on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:52AM (#48218428)
No, it just suggests that to call Achilles "macho" is extremely weird. And the GP didn't even mention his extreme emotionality at the death of his lover, Patrocles, which is like half his plot in the Illiad.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by MaxHoppersGhost on Friday May 22, 2026 @11:48AM (#48237472)
They were not lovers, that is modern BS painted over myth.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by defrost on Friday May 22, 2026 @08:08PM (#48243114)
Modern BS based on Classical era BS ?

It's not some new DEI post-WWII crazy.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by defrost on Friday May 22, 2026 @03:27AM (#48233037)
No, just observing that some 2,000+ years of story telling portray Achilles as a short (by modern standards - average by ancient Greek standards) cross dressing bisexual.

That's not really a gotcha.

Given that I'd say there's a lot of latitude for directors to portray the character .. as has been done in a few opera's over the past century or so.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by dyauspitr on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:21AM (#48218206)
I don’t think it’s a rumor. There’s literally a shot of her in the trailer.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by xdennis on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:07AM (#48218109)
You can't have a 1.55m woman play the greatest Greek hero of all time. It's an insult to Greek culture. If Sydney Sweeney played Martin Luther King it would be equally insulting.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by michaelmrose on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:29AM (#48218271)
If Greek machismo were blemished by mere fiction it would always have been eggshell thin. I have a feeling it shall hold up just fine as it has for millennia.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by dyauspitr on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:11AM (#48218143)
Somehow Sydney Sweeney playing MLK or Samuel L Jackson playing Adolf Hitler actually sounds interesting though.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by tsimionescu on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:07AM (#48220677)
A big part of Achilles' story in the Illiad is that he was hidden among a group of princesses, and that Odysseus had to use a trick to figure out which of the princesses he was. So, even though in other places he is described as quite manly, it also makes sense to portray him as having more feminine features if referencing this part of the canon.

I'd also note that Elliott Page is, of course, not a woman.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by xdennis on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:10PM (#48230347)
> I'd also note that Elliott Page is, of course, not a woman.

Scientists can tell that Lucy the hominid was a female even though only a few of her bones have survived since 3.2 million years ago when she died yet leftists think that Page is no longer a women just because she excised her breasts and changed her government papers.

If her bones get fossilized, 100 million years from now you'd still be able to figure out she's a woman.

> A big part of Achilles' story in the Iliad

Not only is it not a big part, but it's not even in the Iliad. You're clearly just regurgitating talking points.

That's a later invention. And it doesn't make him a transsexual. He marries a woman there.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:53PM (#48216874)
It looks pretty shonky.

I dont care about the casting.

But the costumes look like ass (One of the extras was saying he had fit into the same armor for a low budget sword and sandal film), they are using a viking longboat as a greek ship (have already seen half a dozen experts spitting chips over the difference in boat design). I just cant bring myself to care about the film.

"Oh its a fantasy film" its set in a historical time period, I wouldnt watch a WW2 Zombie movie if the nazi zombies were wearing viking armor driving an Abrams tank either.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by klausa on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:17PM (#48217435)
> "Oh its a fantasy film" its set in a historical time period, I wouldnt watch a WW2 Zombie movie if the nazi zombies were wearing viking armor driving an Abrams tank either.

WW2 Zombie movie with Nazis in Viking armors and random tanks sounds so much more _fun_ than a "historically acurate Nazi Zombie" movie!

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by zamadatix on Thursday May 21, 2026 @12:18AM (#48217819)
Different strokes for different folks. I think they are just used to the common trope of people immediately telling them because one aspect of a movie/film/play is unrealistic they shouldn't care if the entire thing is nonsense. Vice versa though, nobody should mind others enjoy or make such content, beyond these kinds of statements that it's not for them.

I also more often enjoy films which sit between "100% realistic/accurate" and "anything goes" than either extreme itself. 100% realistic/accurate and it tends to already be known unless it's relatively bland. 100% anything goes and it can still be good but there is a high risk it ends up feeling like every other "anything goes" movie of the same topic. In between you can often get the best of both worlds - something new, but still unique.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @12:55AM (#48218024)
>I also more often enjoy films which sit between "100% realistic/accurate" and "anything goes" than either extreme itself. 100% realistic/accurate and it tends to already be known unless it's relatively bland. 100% anything goes and it can still be good but there is a high risk it ends up feeling like every other "anything goes" movie of the same topic. In between you can often get the best of both worlds - something new, but still unique.

I think that Nolan sells himself (The online worship can hardly all be organic) as an authentic, technical director interested in accurate physical props.

When mostly what he does is potter about and destroy sound design.

I agree no one is going to be 100% accurate and accuracy isnt always desirable. But an attempt? When thats the guys reputation? Doesnt feel like too much to ask for.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by klausa on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:43AM (#48218359)
>I think that Nolan sells himself (The online worship can hardly all be organic) as an authentic, technical director interested in accurate physical props.

I'm not a huge Nolan-discourse-insider, but that seems like a pretty bizarre reputation to have for someone who's famous for directing three Batman movies, Inception, Interstellar and Tenet?

Is this reputation just because of Oppenheimer?

I haven't seen Dunkirk (and I'm not a WWII buff so couldn't tell if they used right planes/boats/guns/uniforms/whatever even if I tried), but even a short blurb on Wikipedia talks about a "balance historical accuracy with aesthetics that would favour the film stock".

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by SvenL on Thursday May 21, 2026 @04:26AM (#48219495)
Well, interstellar has also some nerd stuff in it. If I remember correctly Kip Thorne did physics consulting on the movie and they even use a simulation running on a cluster to visualize the black hole physically correct.

They could have used some arbitrary CGI…but no, they wanted it accurate according to science.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.03808

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by klausa on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:23AM (#48220843)
Maybe we run in different circles, but I feel like “appreciates scientific accuracy” and “appreciates historical accuracy” are pretty disjoint sets?

Not entirely without overlap, but pretty distinct.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by SvenL on Thursday May 21, 2026 @05:35PM (#48229148)
I was referring to this:

>I think that Nolan sells himself (The online worship can hardly all be organic) as an authentic, technical director interested in accurate physical props.

I just wanted to give an example of such accurate physics props, that this is not only due to Oppenheimer.

This was not about the historic accuracy.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by aragilar on Thursday May 21, 2026 @06:40AM (#48220456)
And yet the rest of the movie runs on movie logic, enough so that every physicist I know rolls their eyes at it. It gives me the vibe of the "IFLS" crowd, not anyone who actually understands science.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Sunday May 24, 2026 @06:44PM (#48261749)
Yeah its a bugbear of mine "oh its so accurate" theres like 2 accurate scenes, and most of it (from economics/agriculture to space physics) is completely bonkers.

Sadly its a lot of "Filmbros first serious scifi movie" and thats something you cant disentangle, its love its not rational.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:09PM (#48229911)
>three Batman movies

The first batman movie was a paint by numbers reimplementation of The Shadow (1997). You can find comparisons online, nearly shot by shot and most of the same plot beats. The second and third went sort of back towards a very mechanical batman representation that reminded me of the planned low budget Iron Man movie where he wouldn't have had the ability to fly. Just stomping around punching badguys like a Power Rangers extra. The new Bat Mobile seems to inspire some of this reputation

>Inception

Inceptions pretty flat for a film about dreams.

>Interstellar

Neuro-Diverse level of detail until the bits with space magic at the end.

>Tenet

I couldnt sit through 10 minutes of it. Its like the antifilm. It didnt want me to observe it otherwise it wouldnt have emitted such a piercing screeching noise.

>Dunkirk

He has an old period watch, and he recorded the ticking. He overlays the ticking constantly. Also he tells the story out of sequence for some reason. But theres lots of practical effects if you include the stupid watch.

>Oppenheimer

Between tenet hating me on a physical level, and the perfectly servicable fat man and little boy film from the 70s I just havent seen it to comment.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by prawn on Thursday May 21, 2026 @06:34AM (#48220425)
Your sound design comment reminds me of seeing Inception in the cinema sitting next to a friend who works in sound (Frozen, John Wick films, etc). Early in the film, I offered him some of my popcorn, and he politely declined. I spent a good portion of the film partially distracted by the idea that maybe he didn't want to be crunching away on popcorn because he was keenly focused on thinking about the sound experience, and the cinema speakers and the like. I ate my popcorn even more quietly than usual.

After the film, I asked if he'd turned down the popcorn for professional reasons. He said, "No, I just didn't feel like popcorn."

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by vidarh on Thursday May 21, 2026 @03:22AM (#48219064)
The example was really to me because one of the better Nazi zombie movies is Norwegian (Dead Snow) and given the Nazi obsession with old Germanic and Norse myths, it wouldn't seem wrong at all to come across Nazi Vikings in a movie like that.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by RobotToaster on Thursday May 21, 2026 @12:54AM (#48218021)
The costumes are completely wrong.

At least they bothered to CGI out the stirrups, but it's incredibly obvious from how he's sitting on the horse in the trailer.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @12:55AM (#48218038)
I had forgotten about the stirrup controversy.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by fecal_henge on Thursday May 21, 2026 @03:44AM (#48219201)
Nothing like historical inaccuracy to stirrup some controversy.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by Ladioss on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:26AM (#48221537)
I would do unfathomable things for a movie with period-accurate Bronze Age armor sets.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Friday May 22, 2026 @02:44AM (#48232777)
Yeah same. I would book a full row to myself.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by xdennis on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:17AM (#48218185)
> I dont care about the casting.

You don't care about the casting because you're not allowed to care.

Criticizing the ridiculous armor is a safe opinion. But it's not okay to complain about black people playing Greeks and women playing men.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:46AM (#48218379)
No I legitimately don't care about those things. They could cast the smurfs if they had a cool period boat and nice period armor.

You are the one who has some weird race based conditioning where you are hyper-vigilant where it comes to race and need to act offended about it.

Seek medical assistance.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by modo_mario on Thursday May 21, 2026 @02:40AM (#48218745)
To be fair it is fairly onesided towards european history/folklore/tales and noticably always with black people inserted making it feel like there's some very... american focus on this from the opposing perspective as well. (And when it's anything east asian they typically insert a white main character) Which isn't helped by the industry basically farming this situation from both sides with actors and articles claiming queen charlotte, cleopatra and such were back. (to the point of leading to legal complaints in egypt, etc)
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by verisimi on Thursday May 21, 2026 @03:52AM (#48219262)
You care about the historical detail of the boats and armour, but don't care about the person (sex or colour)? And people who disagree with you need medical help?

Do you realise all the contradictions in your position? And then to suggest that the other person needs medical help for stating the obvious, indicates your malign intent. This is gas lighting, ie abusive behaviour. Your own conditioning is making you unable to see the obvious.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:01AM (#48221944)
If you genuinely believe every actor should be Greek or Anatolian, that would be a fair and consistent position.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:51PM (#48230638)
>Do you realise all the contradictions in your position? And then to suggest that the other person needs medical help for stating the obvious, indicates your malign intent. This is gas lighting, ie abusive behaviour. Your own conditioning is making you unable to see the obvious.

Its not gas lighting and you diminish the term by suggesting it is.

If you demand arbitrary whiteness for a film thats about people who were considered black until the 60s or so, when you arent also demanding greekness of the whites, you are just here to grind your culture war axe.

I was accused of being conditioned, all I did was point out that its the culture war practitioners who have been conditioned like pavlovs dog to bark every time they see a person of colour on film. And yeah, that requires medical attention.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by verisimi on Friday May 22, 2026 @02:36AM (#48232713)
> If you demand arbitrary whiteness for a film thats about people who were considered black until the 60s or so, when you arent also demanding greekness of the whites, you are just here to grind your culture war axe.

You think greeks were considered black in the 1960s?

Perhaps you have just received a very poor education. Perhaps the colours of people really have shifted a lot in your understanding.

> Its not gas lighting and you diminish the term by suggesting it is.

If the colours of different people have NOT shifted in your understanding, saying someone needs medical help for stating the obvious, common understanding is pretty close to the text book definition of gas lighting. It's just that you think it is for a good cause.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by Fezzik on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:52AM (#48218427)
I’m just offended Helen isn’t depicted as having goose parts. After-all, Zeus was a goose when he seduced Leda, and Helen hatched from an egg. Some part of her must be goosey.

Edit: I meant swan. My recollection of mythology is rusty.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by verisimi on Thursday May 21, 2026 @03:30AM (#48219111)
A black or white swan?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @04:52AM (#48219679)
One thing that always rubs me the wrong way in this type of situations, is how patronizing it is towards black people.

It got the "let little timmy play too" vibe all over it. It hints that there are no interesting historical events with black people having a major role in it that you would want to create a movie about.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:44AM (#48221054)
Is it also patronizing towards Americans to have Brad Pitt play Achilles?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:57AM (#48221907)
I don't get your argument. You can look at historical monuments or modern Greeks and Brad Pitt doesn't look to different from them.

Let me try to elaborate on my argument. Imagine you are in a park and there are three children playing, child A, B and C. Imagine child A has 10 toys, B has 7 and C 1.

Now if you forcefully took toys from A and B and gave them to C, then that's patronizing behavior as it means "you can't have your own toys, you need to steal them from someone else, you are not good enough".

A more respectful way of solving the dilemma for all involved parties is by just getting more toys for child C.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Friday May 22, 2026 @01:33PM (#48238920)
What historical monuments are you referring to?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @09:26AM (#48257130)
I'm surprised anyone would ask. For example this https://www.worldhistory.org/image/6002/marble-bust-of-a-you...
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @08:54AM (#48293539)
Are you aware this is from the Roman era, more than a 1000 years after Achilles supposedly lived?

Also, this does not particularly look like Brad Pitt. If you are referring to the greyish color of the marble, be aware statues were painted in antiquity.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by enoint on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:12AM (#48222093)
One thing that might change your mind is the 20th century mythic cowboy. Where I’m from, maybe 1/4 cowboys were black. So we accepted that as whites-only theatre. Do we have to keep accepting whites-only theatre?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:27AM (#48222260)
I think this makes my argument even more true. Imagine you have a budget and want to create a western/cowboy movie. You care about representation and want to have more black cowboys in the movies.

Option A: Take a story with a white cowboy, cast a black guy for him and shoot the movie.

Option B: Find a story of a black cowboy (and as you said there were many of them) and shoot a movie about it.

IMHO option A is patronizing while option B is empowering. Because option A assumes there were no black cowboys, there are no good stories too tell about black people.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by enoint on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:56AM (#48222638)
Because dime novels were indeterminate about race, it’s not a binary set of options. Those novels relied on dialect rather than physical description.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @10:09AM (#48222860)
I think we agree there are a lot of books which you can make movies about where it is more than reasonable to have a black cowboy protagonist.

And this is the right way to do things, and not by pity race swapping some famous character/historical figure.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by anang on Thursday May 21, 2026 @05:38AM (#48220041)
We've already accepted a lot of non-Greek casting, and always have. Movies like Troy are filled with people of German, English, Scandinavian whatever heritage, same here with The Odyssey.

I think they get a pass because we see Greek history as a shared western history, even though it's about as accurate as a black person in those roles.

So I think for a lot of people, when they see complaints about black actors playing historically "white" roles, what they're really seeing is a claim that black people don't have any right to our shared western heritage despite the fact that it's almost always a black person that has grown up in and only ever really been a part of western culture.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by stavros on Thursday May 21, 2026 @06:51AM (#48220545)
I don't know about what Americans think, but, as a Greek, the whole "whiteness" thing is an American social construct. There aren't whites and blacks in Greece, mostly because we don't have enough black people here to have a divide.

As far as I'm concerned, all your casting is wrong, it's not like Brad Pitt in Troy looks anything like a Greek person. Casting black people goes even farther, but it's just a matter of degree.

It does make sense, these are American movies, they're going to cast Americans, and the whole race issue is about who gets to star in them. There aren't enough Greek people in Hollywood to make a fuss about representation, so they don't get representation. It is what it is, but let's not pretend it's about accuracy or faithfulness to the original material, it's just about less racially biased casting.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by anang on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:33AM (#48220927)
Yes, people that get upset about racially “incorrect” casting hand wave away casting someone of Irish decent as Greek because it falls into some sort of western bucket.

So when someone complains about a black person being cast as Greek, in a movie filled with people of English, Irish, Scandinavian and who knows else decent, what they’re actually saying is that black people will never have a right to the shared western culture.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:50AM (#48222530)
If you go to the streets of Athens and show them two pictures one of Diane Kruger and one Lupita Nyong'o, and ask them who they think represents Helena of Troy more I'm certain you are going to get Diane as the definitive answer.

I'm also certain that many will feel the casting of Lupita Nyong'o as cultural appropriation while the same will be less true for Diane Kruger.

I'm not saying the Greeks should decide who to cast in a US film, but the argument that if the actress isn't Greek then any other choice has the same level of accuracy is wrong.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by anang on Thursday May 21, 2026 @11:13AM (#48224159)
The Odyssey is not a documentary that sets out to be as visually authentic as possible, it's a drama. If we exclude black people from any roles in western canon, then doesn't that mean we're also excluding them from being part of western culture?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:39PM (#48226383)
I don't get the argument, there are a million other places you can (and have) black people being part of "western culture", just to list a few sports, music, politics, military, literature and the list goes on. In some of them they are the predominant group.

By your logic every movie should have a lot more east Asians, Indians, Native American etc. which I don't see anybody pushing for.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by jimnotgym on Thursday May 21, 2026 @02:46AM (#48218788)
Would you choose the weapons, armour and tactics as described in the Iliad? Even though it is thought they are inaccurate for the time period that they think the Iliad is set? Not so easy I would say.

And the extra you describe, where does he appear on screen? Front and centre, or in the fourth rank behind the people in better costumes?

And the longboat, does it appear on screen in its original form, or with additions to make it look more period accurate?

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bee_rider on Thursday May 21, 2026 @03:13AM (#48218996)
> Would you choose the weapons, armour and tactics as described in the Iliad? Even though it is thought they are inaccurate for the time period that they think the Iliad is set? Not so easy I would say.

Either “best attempt at historical accuracy” (although that would have been difficult given the sparse record), or “true to Homer’s anachronistic story” would have been reasonable ways to go. Sounds like they picked neither, though…

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Friday May 22, 2026 @02:32AM (#48232690)
>Would you choose the weapons, armour and tactics as described in the Iliad?

Thats fine but my ultimate preference would be fully period.

Theres an old painting of jesus getting stabbed by Longinus kicking around, and Longinus and the other romans are wearing modern (at the time of painting) Italian plate harness with sallet helms.

The reason we dont depict romans like this painting, or wearing modern army fatigues and carrying rifles, is that we know better.

>And the extra you describe, where does he appear on screen? Front and centre, or in the fourth rank behind the people in better costumes?

The gist here is that most of the costumes are rentals with a few exceptions. The extra himself is barely on screen, but he is one of apparently a large number of people in the same outfit. YMMV.

The costumes they have created for the film are no better in accuracy, the batmanesque helmet for Agamemnon has been thoroughly ridiculed online and I wont bother going over it again here.

>And the longboat, does it appear on screen in its original form, or with additions to make it look more period accurate?

They took the dragon head prow down at least. Not much more than that has been done.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by kakacik on Thursday May 21, 2026 @04:38AM (#48219569)
This is fairly typical level of detail for Hollywood, most of stuff they do around Europe is insulting as hell if one cares about the topic, historical stuff being the most visible source of offense.

Dumbed down far more than required for short movie transition of any topic. But I guess they know their US audience, their level of knowledge and care for authenticity better than me.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by cess11 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @06:40AM (#48220461)
"I wouldnt watch a WW2 Zombie movie if the nazi zombies were wearing viking armor driving an Abrams tank either."

OK, so you didn't watch Kung Fury?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kung_Fury

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by ourmandave on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:40AM (#48221010)
Would you watch a 1965 WW2 "historical" movie if the Nazis were driving M47 Patton tanks?

https://www.warhistoryonline.com/world-war-ii/the-battle-of-...

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:48PM (#48230618)
I get pretty cranky at WW2 films that dress up modern tanks as WW2 ones. Particularly the tiger in Kellys Heroes that is definitely not a Tiger.

Also A Bridge too Far had this issue too.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by joshuahedlund on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:43AM (#48221044)
For someone who purports not to care about the film, you seem very familiar with the discourse about it. (I have seen zero experts, or anyone really, discussing boat design.)
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by zulux on Thursday May 21, 2026 @10:38AM (#48223437)
Stop noticing, eh?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by protocolture on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:47PM (#48230611)
I said I dont care about the casting. Not the other discourse.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by Induane on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:46PM (#48217216)
That's a whole ass Spartan letter.