News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @04:52AM (#48219679)
One thing that always rubs me the wrong way in this type of situations, is how patronizing it is towards black people.

It got the "let little timmy play too" vibe all over it. It hints that there are no interesting historical events with black people having a major role in it that you would want to create a movie about.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @07:44AM (#48221054)
Is it also patronizing towards Americans to have Brad Pitt play Achilles?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:57AM (#48221907)
I don't get your argument. You can look at historical monuments or modern Greeks and Brad Pitt doesn't look to different from them.

Let me try to elaborate on my argument. Imagine you are in a park and there are three children playing, child A, B and C. Imagine child A has 10 toys, B has 7 and C 1.

Now if you forcefully took toys from A and B and gave them to C, then that's patronizing behavior as it means "you can't have your own toys, you need to steal them from someone else, you are not good enough".

A more respectful way of solving the dilemma for all involved parties is by just getting more toys for child C.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Friday May 22, 2026 @01:33PM (#48238920)
What historical monuments are you referring to?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @09:26AM (#48257130)
I'm surprised anyone would ask. For example this https://www.worldhistory.org/image/6002/marble-bust-of-a-you...
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by bazoom42 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @08:54AM (#48293539)
Are you aware this is from the Roman era, more than a 1000 years after Achilles supposedly lived?

Also, this does not particularly look like Brad Pitt. If you are referring to the greyish color of the marble, be aware statues were painted in antiquity.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by enoint on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:12AM (#48222093)
One thing that might change your mind is the 20th century mythic cowboy. Where I’m from, maybe 1/4 cowboys were black. So we accepted that as whites-only theatre. Do we have to keep accepting whites-only theatre?
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:27AM (#48222260)
I think this makes my argument even more true. Imagine you have a budget and want to create a western/cowboy movie. You care about representation and want to have more black cowboys in the movies.

Option A: Take a story with a white cowboy, cast a black guy for him and shoot the movie.

Option B: Find a story of a black cowboy (and as you said there were many of them) and shoot a movie about it.

IMHO option A is patronizing while option B is empowering. Because option A assumes there were no black cowboys, there are no good stories too tell about black people.

Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by enoint on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:56AM (#48222638)
Because dime novels were indeterminate about race, it’s not a binary set of options. Those novels relied on dialect rather than physical description.
Re:Archaeologists Find Egyptian Mummy Buried with the 'Iliad' by throwfaraway135 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @10:09AM (#48222860)
I think we agree there are a lot of books which you can make movies about where it is more than reasonable to have a black cowboy protagonist.

And this is the right way to do things, and not by pity race swapping some famous character/historical figure.