I've barely used Google for over 2 years.
I barely driven myself in a year.
I haven't written code in 6 months.
Debate over, all sides have been expressed.
It makes me wonder why like 90% of the apps on my phone exist. I just want everything to be markdown files, skills, MCPs/API and then a nice TUI or voice to text.
I was once very good at advanced Google search queries but they seem to no longer respect such queries - either showing irrelevant results or none at all (that should exist).
I don’t love LLMs, but they seem to not make up stuff very often these days and usually cite links to what they summarized. Sometimes the tone of the summary is slightly wrong “algorithm X was designed for Y” (when I know it wasn’t) but it’s otherwise very close to the mark.
What does amaze me, is the LLM seems to “understand” my question with very little context — I would have to give a human many more details about goals/intent.
I know damn LLMs are not capable of thought and are just a glorified search engine, but they do it well. Perhaps all my education made me little more…
I used to mock Sci-Fi movies where characters lazily dictated questions to the computer and it gave high quality answers.
We’re living in that world now.
The vast majority of original content is now in one or another social network or on discord. News articles are an exception, though the news has its own problems. Some wikis still exist and are actively maintained, of course, but not a ton. If it's a topic that's academically studied you might find information in papers, but those have poor web visibility and are better located with specialty tools. LLMs seem to be quite good at locating papers, though.
Ah, but they are! Kagi is light years better than Google, and is a worthy replacement. You do have to pay for it, but I get my money's worth.
An increasing number of studies are indicating a reliance on "AI" leads to deleterious cognitive effects. I felt this acutely myself.
I've noticed a significant boost to my recall since shunning "AI" as much as possible.
Though I will say I get much better results from the LLMs I pay for than the free ones with Google or DuckDuckGo, which seem to be way way way more prone to just make crap up based on your search and cite web pages that, when followed, don't have the claim being made in the AI search results at all. By contrast every "source" link I've followed in the for-money AIs has 100% backed what the AI said it backed. Don't judge by the free AIs the search engines put out, those things are probably starved of resources and are nearly useless.
(Which I did not intend as a commentary on Google's plans here, but it is a data point of interest... that pressure to cut costs on the "free" services is quite directly at odds with providing quality AI services for the forseeable future.)
And I’ve tried Google’s once or twice and seen it used once or twice, and used ChatGPT exactly once, last week, and I was not at all impressed by any of them. Their output, for what I’ve personally seen, has been nonsense, obvious, or unverifiable.
Same here. The free version probably gets orders of magnitude less of a compute budget, though, so I am not really surprised.
What I find really surprising though is how many people still have only ever used the free version of any LLM, even those that are heavy users and could easily afford it. It seems like a pretty big and basic product marketing mistake to me to limit capabilities instead of usage time in the free version! How are people supposed to learn what they'd get if they were to pay?
You can't do something like this with search.
Sure, it's pretty low-friction to do this by opening a document on most platforms,[1] but using an LLM chatbot not only automates this but provides a synopsis of the findings, and if history's any guide, lowered frictions such as this tend to be the way people tend to move.
__________________________________________
Notes:
1. Though I'll note that opening a free-form text file on mobile OSes can be stubbornly difficult, let alone actually entering text into them. Even the simple act of copying and pasting text is remarkably higher-friction than on a desktop. In many ways the Web has gone vastly backward from text-based, CLI clients where I can 1) open my whole session in a terminal multiplexer (screen, tmux), 2) fire up a text-based web browser (w3m, lynx, etc.), and 3) just wholesale grab site metadata or result summaries and dump that to a textfile. Yes, you need a keyboard to do this efficiently, but keyboards and text-manipulation are just inherently so far superior to touch-based or speech-based interfaces it's not even funny. Touch and voice are convenient, for fast, very shallow uses. But not powerful.
I've been trying to use LLMs for things and it makes mistakes all the time. Just this week i had multiple instances of various LLMs basically saying "just run the software with --flag-that-fixes-your-problem" or "edit the config and add solve-your-issue=true" hallucinating non-existant options. Even if i manually link the relevant documentation pages it will still just make basic mistakes. and if im having to read the documentation myself anyway to fix the AI's mistakes, why is the AI even in the loop.
its infecting search too, because blogspam/slop articles are managing to make their way into search results by just making up untrue information, claiming software can do things it cant, or has options that don't exist.
It's baffling that people have become so devoted to them as a source of information given how inaccurate they are. I've learned not to trust anything they say, ever, especially when it comes to technical subjects.
I don't comprehend how the average person gets any useful information out of Google.
Using google search, will return roughly infinite recipe sites. The sites were generated to spam AI generated recipes surrounded by advertisements. None of them are really any good because they were generated by a script and not looked at by a human until I come along and click. The standard is for all recipes to have at least 10-15 screenfulls of vertical spam wrapped by ads for recipe pages. The internet, at least using Search, is now useless for food recipes. I would have better, faster luck driving to the public library and looking in a physical cookbook; at least those recipes were probably tested at least once by humans unlike the advertising spam sites. Nobody has 45 minutes to watch 44 minutes of filler material surrounded by ads on Youtube either. If you want to cook food, the internet is near dead at this time, unfortunately.
AI search will plagiarize the "Original Nestle Toll House" recipe from the back of every bag of chocolate chips ever made. Its a good recipe and I've baked them many times over the decades.
I wish the internet were more useful, but the people in charge of it don't want it to be useful; here have some ragebait and doomscroll while watching the ads.
This is a wild take, as someone that cooks a lot, and largely from the internet (though I do own a lot of cookbooks)
The reality is that just googling for recipes was never good to begin with. People have been complaining about SEO spam and ads on recipe sites forever, but those recipes were always trash even before they got to the absurd state they're in now. Serious eats, bon appetit, food 52, smitten kitchen, chefsteps, all have great recipes. Some of these have paywalls, although you can get around them. Serious eats though is totally paywall free and has a pretty wide range of recipes. There are other sites for more niche cuisines.
You'll still have ads, and you'll still have a wall of text before the recipe. But the ads are slightly less obtrusive, and the wall of text on the quality sites is why those SEO techniques exist in the first place: a recipe that is just "list of ingredients + instructions" and doesn't include any context is ultimately a crapshoot. The thinking that goes into a recipe shows that you're not going to be wasting your time because it's been tested and optimized.
Currently, search engines are pretty bad at the second one because people try to use them as the first one
Is that useful enough to build a billion dollar advertising business around? My feeling now is not really.
Even for straight up searches, I find using an LLM to do a search and comb through the results is a better experience than Google is now for searching. If I'm specifically looking for esoteric web sites from 27 years ago on vintage computer hardware and software (thank god for Archive.org), Google is just ok for that.
In other words, I have no use for an LLM summarizer; I want an LLM librarian, working with me to say "beep-boop, here are some resources that seem relevant to your query, feel free to resume this session later if you'd like to further refine your search".
Surely we all understand that any commercial model is going to inevitably metastasize into this.
Yet.
> Can you find the girl who did a bunch of posts critisizing David Graeber's Debt? I thought it was really well done
> I saw a comment on hackernews a while ago about the optimal amount of credit card fraud being higher than zero because of game theory dynamics, can you find it.
In both cases it turned up the exact posts I was looking for in like 30 seconds which would have taken me much longer using traditional search. I've had similar success looking for technical documentation. It's downright magical how they're able to turn my vague idea of what I'm looking for into a pointer to the exact thing.
yeah man good thing LLMs are structurally incapable of being incentivized to sell you a product or render referral links, this is surely future-proof
Yeah, they probably aren't doing (most of) these now, but it doesn't take much mental energy to extrapolate once you factor nearly every other tech company's ethical trajectory and the current geopolitical environment. Substituting classic search entirely with LLMs is not a savvy move.
A search engine could certainly tamper with which of these sources they surface/rank higher (which I suspect happening more often of late), but they're still obliged by their nature to branch out and seek information from the broader world.
LLMs, on the other hand, are self-contained opaque monoliths that can be conditioned to deceive or obfuscate with devious cleverness, and all control over their behaviors is entirely concentrated in the hands of whatever corporation trains them.
As soon as one gets annoying, expensive, advertiser heavy etc. you just rip it out and replace it with the other one. AFAICT there is zero lock-in or moat. I often am able to switch models in one click or command. This is why all the LLM providers are desperate for a product layer/comprehensive tool set.
Sure maybe they all end up that way, but there’s plenty of reasons corporate customers will want private LLM usage that is not skewed towards advertising. I am happy to pay for that.
Also, open source models are a bulwark against another search style ad Monopoly.
Since this is how Google makes all their money, why are they killing it off? Do they think people will eventually pay for LLM search? Do they plan to stuff the results with ads, not even sharing the ad revenue with the content sources?
But I still want to also be able to do my normal, old school searching.
The advertisements fed the content, which fed the AI, which in turn feeds your AI workflows. AI is still not trusted unless it's output is grounded with sources.
I already saw a article recently about how to set up a business domain which can reliably show up in a search result and dump overly positive reviews into anyone's context.
My experience with AI searches is that they'll still be wrong a lot of times, but it will condense/flatten the content generating trash sites and give me alternatives from these deeper results. What I'm looking for is usally in there.
The question though: Why is that?
Is your Google search usage down because LLMs are "so much better"? Or because Google actively chose to destroy the quality of their search results to juice advertising revenue, and appears to continue to do so to juice AI adoption?
> and have them provide me links for source data.
And therein lies the answer: You don't care about the LLM, you're just using the LLM as a means to get the good links.
This is a common flow for me and works with other skills such “as find recent PR’s in our code base that are related to this research topic”
Also yes, I don't care about the LLM and I am just using it to get what I want because that is what LLMs are for.
ps: I'm not pro centralized corp. owning data and ai. But so far they are the cheap highway to answers
1. LLM Model providers are starting to charge real costs to users, revealing that AI usage is much more expensive than the subsidized rates we've been seeing for years.
2. Google is now using an LLM to answer every single google search that happens, for which Google bears the entire cost.
That is, it's training costs which are fixed, high, and amortised across all revenue potential.
In raising prices, pure-play AI chatbot vendors are facing the challenge that their only revenue option at present is pay-for-use. This is typical of numerous other information goods (software, comms networks, information services), but simply reflects the business reality that cost-basis and revenue-basis are largely disconnected, and that average cost pricing tends to be necessary despite not matching marginal cost provision. (That is, the charged per-unit price of use is going to be far higher than the actual marginal cost of provision for that use.
Google's situation differs from pure-play AI in several ways:
- The firm already has one of if not the largest corpus of Web data, as well as much offline / print material data (Google Books), of any entity in the world.
- Presuming Google are already using this for training AI for other purposes or general resource, the fixed costs are sunk costs already incurred, subsidised by the firm's existing AdTech monopoly, and which might as well be put to use.
- Similarly, Google's service costs (marginal costs) for traditional GWS are probably, within an order of magnitude comparable to those for an AI/LLM response.
- Google presently captures 90% or more of worldwide general web search (GWS) traffic, meaning it has an extant market for offering AI as a default search alternative.
- Complaints about declining Google search quality are nearly as old as Hacker News. Here's a seventeen year old submission on that topic, "Google's regression toward mediocrity (search quality & aggressive matching)" <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=641145> (2009). There are many, many, many results in both stories and comments for related searches. If traditional Web search is going to die anyway, and LLMs replace it, Google might as well get up on the curve.
- Google can directly attach its existing AdTech revenue model to LLM search. And probably has options for extending advertising into the LLM SERPs themselves.
- Doing all of this directly attacks pure-play AI firms' attempts to capture Web search from Google, as well as challenges other GWS challengers (DDG, Kagi, Marginalia, etc.), all of whom have vastly lesser revenue options and technical resources than Google.
I'm not saying this as a fan of Google (I think the firm should be broken up or destroyed, and it's not the only one). But I think it's a fair assessment of the firm's strategic position.
While there are times where I want pure search (Kagi, Old Google) I mostly use LLMs to search now and have them provide me links for source data.
When I do use LLMs as a search engine I always want it integrated into my AI workflows with access to tools and scripts etc. I never want to have a conversation with a website that is geared towards advertising me products.