News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brand Age by jgrahamc on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:11PM (#47265889)
"Because at Patek he'd encounter the most extreme brand age phenomenon: artificial scarcity. You can't just buy a Nautilus. You have to spend years proving your loyalty first by buying your way through multiple tiers of other models, and then spend years on a waiting list."

Strange game, the only winning move is not to play.

I've heard other brands do this (Ferrari?) and, of course, there are lines outside "luxury" brands like Louis Vuitton. Why bother?

PS I'll stick to my Casios: https://blog.jgc.org/2025/06/the-discreet-charm-of-infrastru...

Re:The Brand Age by coldtea on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:08PM (#47267324)
Because the people bothering are precisely those that want to differentiate themselves from those who'd rather stick to their Casios :)
Re:The Brand Age by jgrahamc on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:16PM (#47267408)
Ah, so these products are useful to me after all!
Re:The Brand Age by roughly on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:05PM (#47267948)
Genuinely. All fashion, all accessories, whatever you put on your body is a signal, even if you don’t intend it to be. Your outfit is a costume, and so is everyone else’s.
Re:The Brand Age by circlefavshape on Friday March 06, 2026 @05:16AM (#47273127)
and all the world is a stage
Re:The Brand Age by julianpye on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:47PM (#47266353)
Actually in many cases it is for social KPI storytelling. I know some wealthy people and at gatherings they love to tell 5-10min long stories of exclusive processes that they followed to gain something exclusive while dropping names and numbers. The processes are easy to understand for the entire social circle (i.e. not technical or business achievements which they can't easily disclose).
Re:The Brand Age by sdwr on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:08PM (#47267322)
It's a formalized, sanitized simulacrum of striving! Like sports is for competition
Re:The Brand Age by jvanderbot on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:11PM (#47266660)
So, hobbies. You're talking about hobbies.
Re:The Brand Age by coldtea on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:09PM (#47267332)
No, he talks about status signalling.

They might pass the time doing those things, but not as a mere passtime or hobby, like if they were sewing or playing CoD. Unlike those, doing them and telling about doing them serves a specific social purpose.

Re:The Brand Age by jvanderbot on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:31PM (#47267572)
I'm not arguing with you - you have a valid point.

But I don't view hobbies as that separate from status signals within the hobbying group. Oh you play games? What games? Did you beat it? etc etc.

Esoteric knowledge/practices here are status signls (Oh you reached shattered planet without xyz??).

That starts to sound a lot like "Oh you aquired a lambo XYZ without usual steps abc" and that's a really fun convo in the in-group, and a total miss with the out-group.

Re:The Brand Age by coldtea on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:37PM (#47268242)
>But I don't view hobbies as that separate from status signals within the hobbying group.

The difference though is that this is not meant to serve "within the hobbying group".

They serves the status signal purpose when showing them to "laymen" and other rich people in general, not necessarily to other expensive car buyers or luxury watch buyers.

In other words, the, typically quiet, flaunting, is done to people otherwise uninterested about the specific ting, that nonetheless recognize the exclusivity and the knowledge that it's a subtle signal of "elevated taste" and that they belong to the tasteful-rich club.

Re:The Brand Age by scubbo on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:35PM (#47267627)
I have several hobbies, and none of them revolve around artifical scarcity or gatekeeping.

(Well, the way that _some_ people play Magic: The Gathering does - but I wouldn't want to play with anyone who raised a stink about proxies)

Re:The Brand Age by jvanderbot on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:04PM (#47267946)
Look, I dont want to be argumentative, but my (perhaps cynical) view on people who say they don't do status signaling when they "avoid status signaling" is it's just like the fish who goes "what's water"? It's worth thinking about whether you're doing it by accident.
Re:The Brand Age by scubbo on Monday March 09, 2026 @09:07PM (#47317961)
You're shifting the goalposts. I agree that status signalling happens in hobbies. I disagree that everyone who indulges in a hobby does so purely - or even mostly, or at all! - in order to be able to tell stories about ways they managed to "cut the line".

Some of just like to do things, and to attain status by doing things well, rather than by bragging about our ability to cheat.

EDIT: to put it a different way - all tales of "skipping the line" are an integral part of that hobby; but not all hobbies involve, and not all hobbyists enjoy, tales of "skipping the line". And; every tale of "skipping the line" is status signalling, but not every status signal is such a tale.

Re:The Brand Age by georgemcbay on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:33PM (#47266914)
"Let's see Paul Allen's card"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlYH-hmxOqc

Re:The Brand Age by Terr_ on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:46PM (#47267740)
I wonder if it's intentional that they all say "Aquisitions", with no "c".

As for fonts etc: https://hobancards.com/blogs/thoughts-and-curiosities/americ...

Re:The Brand Age by georgemcbay on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:12PM (#47268028)
They all have the same phone number too.

This could be explained away by them working for the same place and assuming to contact them you call the same switchboard and ask for the person, but even back in the 90s it would have been strange for wall street "Vice Presidents" (even if it was somewhat of a ceremonial title) to not have their own unique business number.

Also, Paul Allen giving his card to someone else with the same contact number for the purposes of being in touch to plan to play squash doesn't make much sense unless you get meta and assume Paul Allen was aware this had no practical value and just wanted to ego-drop the card.

Re:The Brand Age by gwern on Saturday March 14, 2026 @11:39PM (#47384095)
Some of the typos and poor typography might be accidental simply because that is so common, but the rest of it is surely deliberate.

Remember that _American Psycho_ is repeatedly hinting to you throughout the movie that most, or even all, of what you see is just Bateman's own delusions and hallucinations, which are inferior imitations of reality due to his own impoverished mind and lack of substance. So there's a lot of little tricks all throughout it to subtly destabilize you: https://www.moviemaker.com/american-psycho-anniversary-oral-...

Re:The Brand Age by rfw300 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:28PM (#47267540)
Being wealthy solves virtually all problems of consumption, so the invisible hand provides new problems to serve the market need. Beautiful, really.
Re:The Brand Age by zigman1 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @10:08AM (#47412897)
There is a subreddit called r/r/SelfAwarewolves, where people unknowingly and accidentally basically answer their own questions or suspicions without realizing.

And this is how I feel about recent few pg's essays. There is this new market, political and social reality, that pg decribes well but for some reason just doesn't want to call what it is.

Re:The Brand Age by davidw on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:13PM (#47266690)
Economists have a term for these kinds of things where the demand rises as prices rise: Veblen goods

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good

Re:The Brand Age by marcosdumay on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:10PM (#47267338)
Buying unnecessary expensive stuff is one thing. But it's hard to understand why anybody would want to display that total loyalty to a brand signal.
Re:The Brand Age by fragmede on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:23PM (#47268132)
It taps into a very primordial "I'm better than you" urge some people need.
Re:The Brand Age by animal_spirits on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:26PM (#47268151)
"There is only sex. Everything is sex" - Robert California
Re:The Brand Age by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:02PM (#47268456)
Harley Davidson, anyone?
Re:The Brand Age by mtrovo on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:50PM (#47267093)
Clothes, wristwatches, cars, you name it. It's a very common play on luxury brands, Hermes Birkins is the most famous that comes to my mind and follow a very similar playbook.

Apart from the KYC aspect of the process it's their way of solving the problem of artificial scarcity on the second-hand market as the article explains. They want a second hand market to exist to indicate that this is a luxury item, but too many and the price tanking with excess supply.

Re:The Brand Age by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:07PM (#47267308)
It also solves the real problem of labor scarcity. If you have X master watchmakers available to make a halo product you can only get so much output from them. You can increase X, increase production efficiencies (reduce labor input), or limit supply. The first two reduce exclusivity and perceived quality so the third makes sense if you can live without growth or can grow via high pricing strategies.
Re:The Brand Age by kridsdale1 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:34PM (#47266206)
Anyone with $(80,00-250,000) (which is a lot of you) can buy a Nautilus today[1].

This status-through-martyrdom ritual to get it from retail at MSRP is utterly bizarre.

[1] https://www.chrono24.com/patekphilippe/nautilus--mod106.htm

Re:The Brand Age by candiddevmike on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:46PM (#47267047)
More and more I realize I am completely obvlious to all of the class signaling happening here. I couldn't imagine spending that much on anything, let alone a watch. And I certainly wouldn't think someone wearing that did, either.

I feel bad for the folks who pick up on stuff like this, that must be a heavy weight to bear constantly comparing yourself to other people.

Re:The Brand Age by AnotherGoodName on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:11PM (#47267344)
Ironically a desire for such social signalling requires being poor enough that you believe the item is worth a vast and near unobtainable amount of money making it seem like a very impressive signal to you. That’s what makes these items desirable. As in these signals can be a sign of just how poor you are as opposed to how wealthy.

A classic case is when you observe teenager targeted status signalling trends. This can be as low value as an expensive shirt, ie shirts branded ‘supreme’ costing $300 which isn’t worth signalling to anyone who pays rent or a mortgage. But to a teenager? Wow man $300! such status!!! On the flip side if we see someone above teenager age wearing such teenager targeted status symbols we reasonably subconsciously assume they live with their parents and have very little income.

This continues up the wealth chain forever. Status symbols are invariably a way to see just how little people actually have because the person wearing the status symbol clearly believes the value of what they are flaunting is impressive.

Status symbols aren’t a signal of how much money you have so much as signal of what you believe to be an incredible amount of wealth to flaunt.

Re:The Brand Age by apsurd on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:13PM (#47268548)
Well framed. I will add though that it's not entirely indicative of how much one thinks is a lot; it can also be, as was explained to me, that for ultra wealthy people, the price, at any magnitude becomes a rounding error.

half a million for a car sounds absurd to me, but it's 0.5% of $100M. Compare that to $50k car on a ~$200k median net-worth US household.

Re:The Brand Age by Earw0rm on Friday March 06, 2026 @01:53AM (#47271793)
Yep. I'm in a European city, most of the people driving Mercedes and BMW cars are, if not outright poor, low-status, low-education, low long-term wealth.

The old money drives beat-up cars (often Swedish made, US imports for enthusiasts, or old-style 4x4s for outdoor pursuits) and are more likely to take taxis. Young, highly-educated BoBo types walk, take transit or cycle.

Just-above-poor neighbourhoods have a much higher proportion of flash cars than rich ones.

Re:The Brand Age by watwut on Friday March 06, 2026 @03:12AM (#47272334)
I mean, you just wrote that rich people buy vanity cars and poor people buy cars that are for daily use. US imports for enthusiasts and old-style 4x4s for outdoor pursuits are both definition of vanity car.
Re:The Brand Age by coldtea on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:12PM (#47267360)
>I feel bad for the folks who pick up on stuff like this, that must be a heavy weight to bear constantly comparing yourself to other people.

You can have that heavy weight while living on the suburbs or even the ghetto too. The objects are prices mostly change with the wealth level, not the game.

Re:The Brand Age by fragmede on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:27PM (#47268162)
I dunno, I'd probably spend that much on a house.
Re:The Brand Age by munificent on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:23PM (#47268631)
> I am completely oblivious to all of the class signaling happening here.

If you're comfortably middle class and in a demographic recognized to "deserve" to be middle class, then you can afford to be oblivious to a whole lot of class signaling. You aren't striving to reach a higher station, and you aren't likely to get demoted out of your current one, so you can mostly ignore it.

People that are lower-class and trying to move up, or in demographic categories that are often shunned access to higher social classes don't have that luxury and are incentivized to be savvy to this kind of stuff.

This is one of the kinds of things that people talk about when they talk about "privilege". It's not that you should feel bad because you don't have to worry about this stuff. It's just an acknowledgement that some people have the privilege of not having to worry about this stuff because they were born into a level of class security that others lack.

Re:The Brand Age by thot_experiment on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:01PM (#47266531)
Holy shit that's an ugly watch too, looks like something outta chinatown lmao.
Re:The Brand Age by LevGoldstein on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:52PM (#47267118)
My least favorite of that eras Gerald Genta designs. The original Royal Oak is comparatively far more attractive. Both are outdone by the 222 (different designer though), but it's all subjective.
Re:The Brand Age by PaulHoule on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:29PM (#47266862)
Ads for Patek Philippe on the back of The Economist get more and more annoying over time. (e.g. the president writes "How Happy I am to be a Nepo Baby")
Re:The Brand Age by garethsprice on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:45PM (#47267726)
It being an "acquired taste" is part of the appeal. A lot of high-end stuff is ass-ugly on purpose. If everyone liked it because it simply looked nice, you couldn't tell who's "in the club" of other rich people. Brands will attach elaborate stories and histories to objects to make people feel cultured that they have invested time in acquiring the knowledge, but really it comes down to in-group object recognition.
Re:The Brand Age by ninalanyon on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:45PM (#47292208)
These things are shibboleths. It doesn't really matter what they look like or whether they are actually any good for their ostensible purpose so long as they signal that you are a member of the correct group.
Re:The Brand Age by stronglikedan on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:18PM (#47265997)
> Why bother?

ego, of course

Re:The Brand Age by measurablefunc on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:29PM (#47266159)
Vanity. Ego is something else.
Re:The Brand Age by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:29PM (#47266153)
> ego, of course

This is so silly. Do you really not have any hobbies where you spend inordinate time or money on things you could objectively accomplish quicker and cheaper, but having less fun, in other ways? Like, I ski. It’s a silly way to get up and down a hill in the 21st century.

I’m not a watch guy. But mechanical watches are beautiful. There are idiots who buy them. But that doesn’t mean everyone who does is an idiot.

Re:The Brand Age by boelboel on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:44PM (#47267036)
Collecting watches isn't a hobby, it's pure consumerism. Sure many hobbies have (recently?) gotten way more people spending top dollars for no reason but with watch collecting there's nothing else. You're not tweaking the dials, you don't know how to make the watch, you just watch it and wear it while a technologically superior version is 500 times cheaper. There's also no natural shortage of them, they can make a trillion of these watches.

At least with cars or audio equipment there's some marginal benefits once you get to crazy numbers, not the case with watches.

Re:The Brand Age by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:02PM (#47268455)
What is wrong with watch consumerism? It isn't like it's ruining the planet and hurting anyone. Like you said, there is no shortage and nobody will die without them.
Re:The Brand Age by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 05, 2026 @10:18PM (#47270427)
> You're not tweaking the dials, you don't know how to make the watch, you just watch it and wear it while a technologically superior version is 500 times cheaper

This describes precisely zero watch enthusiasts I know. Each of them can open up the watch and understand what's happening. In one case, he'll disassemble the major components to clean them. (Analogous to how riders can take care of their horses and gear, or I can tune and wax my skis.)

Your dismissal could be just as accurately be applied to the various programming languages many of us learn for fun. We don't know how to write its compiler. We can barely do anything useful in it. We just play with it while a technologically-superior version would take a fraction of the effort.

> There's also no natural shortage of them, they can make a trillion of these watches

Quartz? Obviously. Aegler/Rolex? Probably. Handmade movements? No.

> At least with cars or audio equipment there's some marginal benefits once you get to crazy numbers, not the case with watches

As an enthusiast of neither cars nor watches, I call total bullshit on this comparison. Anyone arguing they're getting utility out of their Ferrarri, Pagani, Omega or Audemars is full of themselves.

Re:The Brand Age by kridsdale1 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:38PM (#47266257)
We can say all the same things about cars, but nobody thinks it’s odd that there’s a status culture about cars worth more than $75,000.
Re:The Brand Age by bombcar on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:53PM (#47266432)
Because that’s only 2-5x the price of a new cheap car.

A watch at $80,000 is what, 10,000x what a new cheap one is?

But good for them! It’s really hard to be angry at them for buying said watch without it being some form of jealousy.

Re:The Brand Age by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:46PM (#47266347)
> nobody thinks it’s odd that there’s a status culture about cars worth more than $75,000

Sure. To each their own. I drive a Subaru. I don’t think it’s weird that others like a nice car. (I also think there are douchebags who drive both.)

Re:The Brand Age by garethsprice on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:33PM (#47267606)
Humans are status-seeking creatures, and status is expressed through signaling. If you're rich and so are the people around you, money alone ceases to be a differentiator. Ultra-luxury brands appeal to this by adding hoops that money alone can't clear: time, loyalty, relationships. The signal shifts from "I can afford this" to "I was invited to spend my money here."

Lines outside Louis Vuitton are more down-market, aspirational luxury - an ultra-wealthy person wouldn't be caught dead queuing on a sidewalk. Patek and Ferrari operate at the level above, where the signal isn't wealth but access. (HBS calls Ferrari's version "deprivation marketing.")

Is it a game worth bothering with? Enough people think so to sustain billion-dollar brands.

(Of course, PG writing an essay about being too smart for fancy watches - while knowing a lot about them - is its own signaling game, just aimed at a different audience)

Re:The Brand Age by Retric on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:20PM (#47268612)
Status is a tool for the working wealthy, but ultra-luxury brands are only appealing to a subset of wealthy people.

There’s a great number of people with 100+M and even far beyond that who enjoy nobody knowing just what kind of wealth they have. This doesn’t mean looking poor, but there’s plenty of value in anonymity.

Re:The Brand Age by velocity3230 on Sunday March 08, 2026 @06:46PM (#47302430)
I don't know why anyone would want to be rich and famous.

Rich and anonymous is where it's at.

Re:The Brand Age by titanomachy on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:44PM (#47268291)
He’s probably also too rich for fancy watches to actually be a useful signal of wealth amongst his peers.
Re:The Brand Age by intuitionist on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:14PM (#47268561)
The price isn’t keeping anyone at that level of wealth from buying a Nautilus or a Lange 1 or a panda Daytona. But they can still flex with ultralimited pieces like Zuck’s Greubel Forsey.
Re:The Brand Age by soperj on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:33PM (#47268730)
I didn't realize that "fools and their money will soon be parted" was a flex.
Re:The Brand Age by intuitionist on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:36PM (#47268755)
“There are three of these things made in a year, and I’ve got the juice to get one of them” is. Zuck doesn’t care about a million dollar price tag, any more than I would care about a couple bucks.
Re:The Brand Age by soperj on Friday March 06, 2026 @12:26PM (#47278104)
If he was buying a solid gold furby would you have the same take? That's great that he doesn't care, still looks like an idiot to me.
Re:The Brand Age by eucyclos on Friday March 06, 2026 @12:56AM (#47271403)
I had a coworker who became nouveau riche a while back- he made fuck you money day trading during the roaringkitty debacle - and one interesting thing he said about the experience was that he learned certain luxury goods, such as high end watches, don't depreciate. Like gold jewelry one can usually resell them for cost plus inflation. As such, his logic was that a fancy watch is essentially free while a cheap watch costs whatever it costs.

Not sure if that's the truth or clever marketing by purveyors of luxury goods, but it changes the wealth signaling dynamics of fancy watches if it is.

Re:The Brand Age by OJFord on Friday March 06, 2026 @04:25AM (#47272817)
I don't think that's really any more true of watches and gold jewellery than it is cars - which is to say it's true of some models, or over time and especially what comes to be considered a classic.

Maybe he meant second-hand though? If someone else has already taken the 'used' depreciation on a watch, the 'art' added value on the gold price, then yes I think it's probably fair to say they hold their residual value better than a lot of things that continue to depreciate.

Re:The Brand Age by cam_l on Friday March 06, 2026 @06:11AM (#47273521)
I dunno about that. I bought a Casio at a garage sale in the late eighties for 20 cents, and sold it to a mate 10 years later, give or take, for a couple of bucks. It was still running, still keeping time.

Expensive watches are way closer to bitcoins than useful assets. They inherently rely on the gullibility of other rich prick wanna be's. Still a good bet probably.. sadly..

Re:The Brand Age by garethsprice on Friday March 06, 2026 @11:02AM (#47276685)
Patek and Rolex have generally always held value well. The internet has brought price transparency and created a secondary market that has made this true for most well-known brands these days, with the caveat that there is not a high degree of liquidity (yes you can sell a Rolex same-day at a pawn shop but you'll take a big hit, otherwise you are waiting a while for a buyer and navigating various risks like scammers).

So you likely won't get rich day-trading (or even collecting) watches, but besides the initial capital investment it is not as irrational as it seems at first.

Of course, that only adds to the signaling power for the classes where merely having money isn't enough, and being a "savvy investor" is a status marker (ie. the upper-middle and nouveau riche).

The Patek Nautilus PG mentions is particularly interesting as a status symbol as it has not only held value but, for various reasons, been an outlier that has appreciated drastically in value. It'd be gauche even on Sand Hill Rd to wear a hat that says "My investments beat the S&P 500" — but for the last few years, flashing a Nautilus (~413% investment return from 2016-2026 vs ~322% in the S&P) is the equivalent of that, a self-reinforcing cycle boosting its value as a Veblen good where the high price is the point.

Re:The Brand Age by observationist on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:25PM (#47268143)
>>> ...PG writing an essay about being too smart for fancy watches

Stealthy, like a submarine.

Re:The Brand Age by nitwit005 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:28PM (#47268674)
While the ultra rich do buy from luxury brands, they're often spending the most on unique items, such as ordering a custom yacht.

Having the most expensive item in some category, or close to it, often gets you news coverage, which is something a normal purchase can't really offer.

Re:The Brand Age by keybored on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:22PM (#47268123)
I know I’m being sold something when someone declares the science of human nature.
Re:The Brand Age by userulluipeste on Thursday March 05, 2026 @08:47PM (#47269783)
"The signal shifts from «I can afford this» to «I was invited to spend my money here.»" "the signal isn't wealth but access"

The most shocking aspect here is the mindset of these people that come to value this access, and the fact that they have to have their own self-perceived worth at some lower (i.e. improvable) level in comparison. It has to be, otherwise the value of that access can't make much sense, otherwise that association to a brand (as chosen not chooser) can't be perceived as something of value. The only (sane) question worth asking, knowing that about the people falling into this game is - do I want to count myself as one of them?

Re:The Brand Age by danielparsons on Friday March 06, 2026 @01:26AM (#47271610)
I think it just sounds like a fun game to be honest. By a goofy little overengineered piece of jewellery. Buy a bunch of them and join the club. Compare to your friends. Reminds me of pokemon cards on the school playground...
Re:The Brand Age by otterley on Thursday March 05, 2026 @09:28PM (#47270079)
> If you're rich and so are the people around you, money alone ceases to be a differentiator.

You could differentiate based on your personality. It costs nothing at all, and is far more interesting than a trinket.

Strive to be Warren Buffet, not Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos.

Re:The Brand Age by bigstrat2003 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @10:06PM (#47270341)
> Of course, PG writing an essay about being too smart for fancy watches - while knowing a lot about them - is its own signaling game, just aimed at a different audience

So you're saying that everyone seeks status, and even the people who say they don't are seeking status by not seeking status? That argument seems like you are overreaching. What, then, would you consider evidence that falsifies your theory?

Re:The Brand Age by danielparsons on Friday March 06, 2026 @01:31AM (#47271633)
status-seeking isn't inherently bad or good, depends who's appreciation you are seeking
Re:The Brand Age by garethsprice on Friday March 06, 2026 @09:32AM (#47275346)
Yes - though this isn't my theory so much as settled science. There are no substantial counter-theories to the concept that status desire is a fundamental and universal human motive.

As for falsification: you'd need evidence like subjects showing no well-being drop (self-esteem, cortisol) from lab-induced status demotions, or entire cultures genuinely indifferent to respect. Neither holds up in the data: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25774679/

John Adams put it well in Discourses on Davila (1790): "The desire of the esteem of others is as real a want of nature as hunger — and the neglect and contempt of the world as severe a pain as the gout or stone."

Re:The Brand Age by rswail on Friday March 06, 2026 @08:11AM (#47274522)
> (Of course, PG writing an essay about being too smart for fancy watches - while knowing a lot about them - is its own signaling game, just aimed at a different audience)

He was aiming at people like the people commenting on this thread and who read the essay.

Also to the startup/entrepreneur founder-types that are actually interested in building a business that makes a qualitative improvement in the market that it works in.

But mechanical watches are very appealing to nerd/geek types as well, purely in terms of the design and engineering of the movements and the precision of the manufacture.

Complications are absolutely pointless, but making a movement that can deliver them is very appealing.

Re:The Brand Age by giancarlostoro on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:46PM (#47267741)
I just want low maintenance cars. Everything else is a waste.
Re:The Brand Age by zinkem on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:07PM (#47267970)
> Strange game, the only winning move is not to play.

What a tired aphorism. Just like PG's 50 year old insights.

Re:The Brand Age by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:19PM (#47268090)
> Casios

I've got three Oceanus watches (Casio's boutique brand). I never wear them, anymore, because of Apple Watch.

I brought a couple of them in Japan. There, the G-Shock brand is very popular. They sell G-Shock watches for ridiculously (to Americans, who are used to cheap G-Shocks) high prices.

Re:The Brand Age by observationist on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:24PM (#47268136)
It's exclusivity and sales schticks. Artificial scarcity, social status, conspicuous consumption. Same things that drive influencers to rent limos, pose on other people's private jets, pretend to buy bottles in clubs, flash fake cash, wear bling.

From a birds-eye view it's less a hedonistic treadmill and more a feeding frenzy.

It's a game you can play, but for the life of me, I cannot comprehend why you'd want to, there are so many other better things in life.

>>> Why bother?

Exactly - go give someone you love a hug, that's worth infinitely more than flexing an expensive watch.

Re:The Brand Age by robocat on Friday March 06, 2026 @01:45PM (#47279249)
> Exactly - go give someone you love a hug, that's worth infinitely more than flexing an expensive watch.

Hugs are massive signals of status (who, where, initiator, awkwardness, yada yada).

My fascination with the politics of hugs might be called autistic by some.

I wonder whether my own status avoidance is on account of being bad at playing at ladders.

Re:The Brand Age by CGMthrowaway on Thursday March 05, 2026 @07:04PM (#47268970)
>I've heard other brands do this (Ferrari?)

It's called relationship-based allocation or more simply purchase history requirement, and its practiced by both Patek and Rolex but add to the list famously Hermes, Bugatti, high jewelry from VCA/Bulgari etc, getting access to prestigious artists at galleries, etc.

The devil's advocate/ other side of the coin is that it's not just a moneygrab, it protects the brand image by controlling who is seen wearing / using your products. When the value of these goods is so influenced by who else has them, that kind of control is intrinsically important for the seller.

Re:The Brand Age by Zak on Thursday March 05, 2026 @08:16PM (#47269542)
Jay Leno, perhaps the world's most famous car collector refuses to buy a Ferrari due to practices like that.
Re:The Brand Age by fud101 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @09:06PM (#47269931)
>Strange game, the only winning move is not to play.

pg dr. This is the answer. A pg article is clickbait at best, harmful at worst. Keep in mind this is the same man who chose to write his antiwokeness hit peace right at the cusp of the election.