also those kids who don't pass will hold those who do pass - as the next year teachers waste time teaching what the majority already knows
one complication is that standards for jobs you could live off of were at that point much lower... many more people could drop out and make a living, this is less often the case now
I just thought it aligned particularly well with the OP on that specific point.
While all this sold a story 'whole word' nonsense was going on in public schools (my mom was a public school teacher), our Catholic school (non union) used a phonics based curriculum. It was the teachers unions circulating misinformation to public school teachers about the efficacy of the 'whole word' method.
Mississippi Association of Educators (a teacher's union that is part of the National Education Association, aka the largest union in the US) supported the efforts to improve the literacy rates.
I'm fine with employees banding together. What CA and other states do (require teachers to pay dues to the union) is criminal.
Basically, the strength of the union correlates with educational outcomes: https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/research/how-strong-ar...
As of 2006 (a bit dated), only 36% of MS teachers were in the union.
> Teachers unions are political organizations that lean left. They are never going to want to get behind anything Mississippi does.
This teacher's union supported improved literacy rates in MS. Would be insane for any organization to not support that effort.
Also, the most effective left leaning organizations prioritize uplifting the South, including MS.
Person1> Don't trust Unions.
Person2> But you are using a union as an example.
Person1> No, my union is better than all the other unions. Mine makes a difference, thus I'm not a commie.
Person2> What?
You're painting with an awfully broad brush there.
0: https://www.maetoday.org/about-mae/our-history
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tate_Reeves
2: https://www.maetoday.org/about-mae/media-center/press-releas...
Because of this, the union has to do what teachers want, rather than vice versa.
I'm speaking from experience with the California Teacher's Association. CA mandates even non-member teachers to pay union dues.
EDIT: Here is an article from the CTA highlighting their efforts to fight phonics-based reading instruction: https://calmatters.org/education/k-12-education/2025/04/read...
Woohoo! teachers unions!!!
Then El Salvador went and literally did just that. Same with No Child Left Behind, other modern policies, more or less saying "you can't just discipline children."
And Mississippi and other red states are showing you literally can do just that.
Who said this?
I thought the argument was always you can’t do this and maintain the high living standards of a modern economy built on the rule of law. It’s essentially a challenge to a society: fuck up enough on security and you lose the fruits and freedoms of a modern state fielding a growing economy.
> more or less saying "you can't just discipline children."
Who said this?
I thought the argument was it inhibits learning in the long run and is not fair to poor kids or something. (We know that’s B.S. now.)
But totally unrelated to El Salvador.
Both are related in the sense that they said you can't just discipline people, more or less, with the same spirit of focusing on people's good side, to their detriment. Different application, same principles, same failure.
People obviously prefer safety to lawlessness, and El Salvador was uniquely awful. The issue is that once you jail everybody who might possibly be a criminal, you’re left with the entire extrajudicial infrastructure that now needs to find a new reason to exist. Not to mention in this particular circumstance that the government seems to have decided to pay off the cartels and use state violence pick winners and losers in order to quash the drug war. It works until it doesn’t.
Do you have evidence Bukele’s polling is corrupted?
Wikipedia lists several polling organisations [1]. And while there are building risks against fair and free elections [2], I haven't seen a credible monitor call that out as having already happened.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_on_the_Nayib_B...
[2] https://freedomhouse.org/country/el-salvador/freedom-world/2...
Do I have evidence that the polling coming out of an autocratic single party dictatorship is corrupted? I mean, no, of course not. Even if I did, it wouldn’t matter.
> I haven't seen a credible monitor call that out as having already happened.
https://www.wola.org/analysis/el-salvador-election-integrity...
One can argue that El Salvador is better off under Bukele than it was prior. I’d probably have to agree - things were really bad there and locking people up and throwing away the key absolutely works. Always has. It just isn’t sustainable and now that Bukele has successfully consolidated power, we just get to wait and see what happens.
Similarly, Yugoslavia generally loved Josip Tito. He was still a horrible dictator that butchered millions and when he died, the country collapsed.
Yes, that's what I'm asking for. We have this for e.g. Russia [1], North Korea [2] and Venezuela [3]. I'm asking for similar evidence out of El Salvador.
For example, did Wola reject the 2024 election ex post facto?
[1] https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2024/03/20/t...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_North_Korea
[3] https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/06/venezu...
There is diverse polling to support Bukele’s popularity [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_on_the_Nayib_B...
Freedoms sometimes break down at scale given the right conditions. That's not comfortable to contemplate. If even 20% of people were involved in the gang and using GrapheneOS, you bet that freedom would be revoked. There is no guarantee in natural law that freedom is self-sustaining or chaos-resistant.
Freedom is the privilege of a stable nation that can hopefully stay stable, but freedom does not guarantee stability.
Obviously extremely “generous” policies for jailing people involved with or adjacent to crime will reduce crime further, but he’s not singularly responsible for improvements and it’s not clear at all where the cost-benefit will net out
North Korea also has very low crime rates, I hear!
Throughout all of human history, the vast majority of awful people in power were consciously put there by people who wanted solutions to real problems
Our Founding Fathers’ insight was to say that it’s actually better the state struggle to solve some problems (including important ones!) than to create an extremely powerful apparatus that can be abused (whether that be with good or poor intentions, with or without popular support etc)
We’ve tried the whole dictator thing! Literally countless times in history! The reason we instead accept some amount of crime and “what the fuck why can’t we solve this?” is because dictators almost always end up being absolutely awful!
A starving man will rate highly someone giving him an ounce of food. That doesn’t mean their life is good. Just better than the hell it was.
El Salvador’s economy is middling [1]. It is growing faster than when it was ridden with crime. But it isn’t growing like a developed economy with the rule of law. (It can’t.)
El Salvadoreans made the best choice they could. When confronted with security versus long-term prosperity, most choose security. And who knows, they might slough off dictatorship as a transitional period like Korea and Taiwan did after all.
TL; DR It’s a straw man to claim what Bukele did was some revolution in social thought that confounded thinkers outside El Salvador. It wasn’t. Martial law has always existed. And Duterte had literally just wrapped up doing the same thing.
> they said you can't just discipline people
Who said this?
I can just as easily invent conservative straw men who didn’t like their idiot kids failing grades and getting their states to not implement ESSA. It’s narratively cohesive. But it isn’t credible, same as this allegation.
[1] https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/elsalvador/overview
Meanwhile El Salvador is ranked 130th out of 180 in the Corruption Perceptions Index with a score of 30/100, and has mostly been sliding lower in the past decade.
I'd love to hear what you think "living under the rule of law" means, and how you feel that relates to approval rating?
I wouldn't hold your breath.
Obviously you could make a metric for this and if you're holding back say 50% of students there's probably a problem but a small portion isn't obviously a bad thing. Snark is fun but it isn't analysis.
Sending kids who haven't learned to read on to higher grades and having no standards for success is not a more "inclusive" policy than having benchmarks that must be passed.
We’ve built a system where the performance of teachers and schools is measured by graduation rates, as if every student who doesn’t graduate on time is a failure of instruction. That’s nonsense. Some kids need more time. Some face life circumstances that derail their progress like undiagnosed learning disabilities, unstable home environments, trauma, poverty. There are hundreds, if not thousands of reasons a child might struggle in a given year, and pretending that all of them can be solved by pushing them forward anyway is not accomplishing anything but putting them in academic and later career situations that they are not prepared properly for.
What No Child Left Behind did was make an AWFUL perverse incentive where schools are indirectly ordered to pass every kid at every opportunity lest their already meager budgets get slashed even further. Children are not widgets moving along on an assembly line and we have spent decades now proving this fact.
It strikes me that US K-12 systems don't have a clear architecture to support, er, non-uniform progress. A student either moves to the next grade in all classes, or "repeats" a year. Or perhaps has remedial classes over the summer? Maybe in high-school the concept of "honors" classes becomes available.
Perhaps that represents a conflict between the social goals (keeping cohorts together) versus per-subject educational ones.
This works for middle and high-school students, where courses are somewhat independent. It doesn't for a third grader who can't read. They need the time to master what they haven't. Rushing that process compromises every year of education in front of them.
Resources doesn't mean iPads and software subscriptions, it means teachers. Good teachers.
There's been a catastrophic collapse in numbers in the profession, and many of the leavers are at the more talented end. They're the ones who have the skills and quals to get better jobs elsewhere.
There's no point "raising expectations" unless you provide the resources to change what's possible.
Individually, students have the least agency in the entire system. They're at the mercy of parents, school boards, and administrators who may be actively hostile to the very idea of a broad liberal education, of corporate opportunists who are trying to sell unproven study aids of all kinds, and of the disapproval of their peer culture.
The one thing that can cut through this - sometimes - is inspiration and motivation from educators.
The "Mississippi Miracle" boils down to directing resources toward struggling kids. They hired reading coaches specifically for struggling students, provided teachers with literacy-based professional development resources, and created Individualized Reading Plans for struggling kids and their parents. Yes, they also held back kids who didn't pass a literacy exam (and moved them to teachers who specialized in helping struggling children), but failing more students was not the primary policy improvement here, and on its own it would do nothing.
"Low-expectations theory" (and the accompanying suggestion that progressives are somehow to blame) is an absurd diagnosis for a problem that was not solved by raising expectations, but rather by targeting available resources toward problem areas—a solution which is painfully obvious in hindsight. That doesn't have an ideological valence, though, and this article seems intent on sticking it to progressives somehow.
It would remove the stigma of "being held back", as there are no levels in a strict sense, just cumulative progress.
FTA: "Elements of so-called equitable grading, which is supposed to be more resistant to bias than traditional grading, have taken off in American schools. Roughly 40 percent of middle-school teachers work in schools where there are no late penalties for coursework, no zeroes for missing coursework, and unlimited redos of tests."
> It would remove the stigma of "being held back", as there are no levels in a strict sense, just cumulative progress
These students do worse. Absent a challenge, you get the pedagogical equivalent of button mashing. Evaluation is a necessary component of progress. It seems that if the evaluation is stripped of consequence, it ceases to evaluate.
Let's not even get into how kneecapped teachers are in classroom management. A student reported him for pointing at them and touching them when he was never fewer than 3 feet away pointing away from them. The students know they have the power now, and they're definitely not going to be told what to do.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scholastic_probation
You could also reward students for outstanding accomplishments.
To be clear, I am talking about replacing grade levels (K, 1, 2, ..., 12), not graded assessments. I updated my comment to clarify this.
A system like this would address that issue, and could prevent education resources from being applied redundantly.
You might need more carrots and sticks since the penalty for being held back is lessened.
We already run colleges this way, granular down to an academic quarter.
There are methods that you could use to increase mentorship and attention by distributing expertise to less-credentialed individuals. This is done in many other credentialed institutions, like hospitals, colleges, or universities.
Beyond that, you could utilize technology in blended learning. This lessens a load on a teacher.
From what I understand, much of this cannot happen easily because there is a gigantic top-down system distributing rules to institutions. On top of that you have labor agreements that blend into those rules and so on.
It seems accomplishing major reform, outside of curricula alone, would be a massive undertaking.
It has examples of states which are seeing some improvements. Those states seem to be addressing one of the main problems this article highlights: they hold students to expectations and prevent them from advancing grades if they don’t meet the bar.