Re:America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
by cognisent on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @05:46PM
(#45585426)
This is exactly how it is at my husband's high school: no penalties, no consequences, unlimited turning in of work until the end of the quarter. Didn't finish it all and ended up with a D or lower? Doesn't matter, because you can't be held back anyway.
Let's not even get into how kneecapped teachers are in classroom management. A student reported him for pointing at them and touching them when he was never fewer than 3 feet away pointing away from them. The students know they have the power now, and they're definitely not going to be told what to do.
Re:America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
by someothherguyy on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @05:55PM
(#45585524)
There are other ways to introduce motivating factors that aren't tied to grade level retention. Sometimes this is done in secondary and tertiary education in the US, like preventing participation in extracurricular activities.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scholastic_probation
You could also reward students for outstanding accomplishments.
Re:America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
by someothherguyy on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @05:22PM
(#45585111)
Right, the nodes of such a skills graph would require standardized evaluation.
To be clear, I am talking about replacing grade levels (K, 1, 2, ..., 12), not graded assessments. I updated my comment to clarify this.
FTA: "Elements of so-called equitable grading, which is supposed to be more resistant to bias than traditional grading, have taken off in American schools. Roughly 40 percent of middle-school teachers work in schools where there are no late penalties for coursework, no zeroes for missing coursework, and unlimited redos of tests."
> It would remove the stigma of "being held back", as there are no levels in a strict sense, just cumulative progress
These students do worse. Absent a challenge, you get the pedagogical equivalent of button mashing. Evaluation is a necessary component of progress. It seems that if the evaluation is stripped of consequence, it ceases to evaluate.