That’s why, presumably, Netflix came up with the algorithm for removing camera grain and adding synthetically generated noise on the client[0], and why YouTube shorts were recently in the news for using extreme denoising[1]. Noise is random and therefore difficult to compress while preserving its pleasing appearance, so they really like the idea of serving everything denoised as much as possible. (The catch, of course, is that removing noise from live camera footage generally implies compromising the very fine details captured by the camera as a side effect.)
1. camera manufacturers and film crews both do their best to produce a noise-free image 2. in post-production, they add fake noise to the image so it looks more "cinematic" 3. to compress better, streaming services try to remove the noise 4. to hide the insane compression and make it look even slightly natural, the decoder/player adds the noise back
Anyone else finding this a bit...insane?
This is not correct, camera manufacturers and filmakers engineer _aesthetically pleasing_ noise (randomized grains appear smoother to the human eye than clean uniform pixels). The rest is still as silly as it sounds.
Does this explain why i dislike 4K content on a 4K TV? Where some series and movies look too realistic, what in turn gives me a amateur film feeling (like somebody made a movie with a smartphone).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soap_opera_effect
Which is generally associated with excess denoisong rather than with excess grain.
This comment that I replied to is almost a textbook description of the soap opera effect.
The interpolation adds more FPS, which is traditionally a marker of film vs TV production.
But yes, there are definitely also many DPs that like their grain baked-in and camera companies that design cameras for that kind of use.
It is only an issue in content delivery.
This is patently wrong. The rest builds up on this false premise.
1.2.: Google "how to shoot a night scene" or something like that. You'll find most advice goes something along the lines of "don't crank the ISO up, add artificial lighting to brighten shadows instead". When given a choice, you'll also find cinematographers use cameras with particularly good low-light performance for dark scenes (that's why dark scenes in Planet Earth were shot on the Sony A7 - despite the "unprofessional" form factor, it had simply the best high-ISO performance at the time)
2: Google "film grain effect". You'll find a bunch of colorists explaining why film grain is different from ISO noise and why and how you should add it artificially to your films.
Next, no shit aesthetics are subjective, I never said this is the one objective truth. I said this is a thing that many people believe, as evidenced by the plethora of resources talking about the difference between noise and grain, why tasteful grain is better than a completely clean image and how to add it in post.
And finally, come on, it's obvious to everyone in this thread that I'm referring to digital, which is also not "just a subset" it's by far the biggest subset.
So idk what your point is. Most things are shot digitally. Most camera companies try to reduce sensor noise. Most camera departments try to stick to the optimal ISO for their sensor, both for dynamic range and for noise reasons, adjusting exposure with other means. In my experience, most people don't like the look of sensor/gain/iso/whatever noise. Many cinematographers and directors like the look of film grain and so they often ask for it to be added in post.
Besides the many/most/some qualifiers possibly not matching with how you percieve this (which is normal, we're all different, watch different content, work in different circles...), where exactly am I wrong?
TLDR - because although you made valid points on a specific area, you made no acknowledgement to my own favorite specific area, thusly I shall publicly declare your valid points shall not be taken seriously for others to read
> it's obvious to everyone in this thread that I'm referring to digital
It was blindingly obvious that you meant digital. That’s why I pointed this out. Without mentioning that it is only a concern with digital photography, your points become factually incorrect on more than one level; because the thread wasn’t talking specifically about digital photography, some of your points about noise don’t apply even if they were correct—which they aren’t, by your own admission that photography is subjective. Producing a noise-free image is not the highest priority for film crews (for camera manufacturers it is, but that’s because it means more flexibility in different conditions; it does not mean film crews will always prioritize whatever settings give them the lowest noise, there are plenty of higher priorities), and in some cases they choose to produce image with some noise despite the capability to avoid it.
Sorry, with your googling suggestions it just reads like a newbie’s take on subject matter.
h.264 only had FGS as an afterthought, introduced years after the spec was ratified. No wonder it wasn’t widely adopted.
VP9, h.265 and h.266 don’t have FGS.
1. Video codecs like the denoise, compress, synthetic grain approach because their purpose is to get the perceptually-closest video to the original with a given number of bits. I think we should be happy to spend the bits on more perceptually useful information. Certainly I am happy with this.
2. Streaming services want to send as few bytes as they can get away with. So improvements like #1 tend to be spent on decreasing bytes while holding perceived quality constant rather than increasing perceived quality while holding bitrate constant.
I think one should focus on #2 and not be distracted by #1 which I think is largely orthogonal.
The hard disk space to store an episode of a show is $0.01. With peering agreements, the bandwidth of sending the show to a user is free.
I'm not sure why you think this, but it's one of the oddest things I've seen today.
The more streams you can send from a single server the lower your costs are.
That's not a correctly calibrated TV. The contrast is tuned WAY up. People do that to see what's going on in the dark, but you aren't meant to really be able to see those colors. That's why it's a big dark blob. It's supposed to be barely visible on a well calibrated display.
A lot of video codecs will erase details in dark scenes because those details aren't supposed to be visible. Now, I will say that streaming services are tuning that too aggressively. But I'll also say that a lot of people have miscalibrated displays. People simply like to be able to make out every detail in the dark. Those two things come in conflict with one another causing the effect you see above.
Someone needs to tell filmmakers. They shoot dark scenes because they can - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qehsk_-Bjq4 - and it ends up looking like shit after compression that assumes normal lighting levels.
i disagree completely. i watch a movie for the filmmakers story, i don’t watch movies to marvel at compression algorithms.
it would be ridiculous to watch movies shot with only bright scenes because streaming service accountants won’t stop abusing compression to save some pennies.
> …ends up looking like shit after compression that assumes normal lighting levels.
it’s entirely normal to have dark scenes in movies. streaming services are failing if they’re using compression algorithms untuned to do dark scenes when soooo many movies and series are absolutely full of night shots.
It should be noted, as well, that this generally isn't a "not enough bits" problem. There are literally codec settings to tune which decide when to start smearing the darkness. On a few codecs (such as VP1) those values are pretty badly set by default. I suspect streaming services aren't far off from those defaults. The codec settings are instead prioritizing putting bits into the lit parts of a scene rather than sparing a few for the darkness like you might like.
The issue is just that we don't code video with nearly enough bits. It's actually less than 8-bit since it only uses 16-235.
Before COVID Netflix were at least using 8Mbps for 1080P content. With x264 / beamr it is pretty good, and even better on HEVC. Then COVID hit, every streaming service not just Netflix have excuses to lower their quality due to increased demand with limited bandwidth. Everything went down hill since then. Customer got used to lower quality I dont believe they ever bring it back up. Now it is only something like 3-5Mbps according to previous test posted on HN.
And while it is easy for HEVC / AV1 / AV2 to have 50%+ bitrate real world savings compared to H.264 saving at 0.5 - 4Mbps range, once you go pass that the savings begin to shrink rapidly to the point good old x264 encoder may perform better at much higher bitrate.
The “best” quality of streaming you have is Sony Core https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Pictures_Core but it has a rather limited library.
Also the whole "you can hear more with lossless audio" is just straight up a lie.
Pricing, if I am reading the site correctly: $7k-ish for a server (+$ for local disks, one assumes), $2-5k per client. So you download the movie locally to your server and play it on clients scattered throughout your mansion/property.
Not out of the world for people who drop 10s of thousands on home theater.
I wonder if that's what the Elysium types use in their NZ bunkers.
No true self-respecting, self-described techie (Scotsman) would use it instead of building their own of course.
That I find super hard to believe!
It could be a single channel, but usually you have many in the multiplex. I don't know how it works in the US, but for DVB-T(2) that's how it is.
Circa 2019, after the FCC "repack" / "incentive auction" (to free-up TV channels for cellular LTE use) it became very common for each RF channel to carry 4+ channels. But to be fair, many broadcasters did purchase new, improved MPEG-2 encoders at that time, which do perform better with a lower bit-rate, so quality didn't degrade by a lot.
These days the FCC is unlikely to care, but I suspect viewership would suffer if any of the major broadcast networks downgraded their "main channel" signal to SD.
This explains the typical arrangement, as well as listing some of the extreme cases:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_subchannel#United_Stat...
Right now, Netflix can say stuff like "we think the 4K video we're serving is just as good." If they offer a real-4K tier, it's hard to make that argument.
Adaptive streaming isn't really adaptive anymore. If you have any kind of modern broadband, the most adaptive it will be is starting off in one of the lower bitrates for the first 6 seconds before jumping to the top, where it will stay for the duration of the stream. A lot of clients don't even bother with that anymore; they look at the manifest, find the highest stream, and just start there.
That can happen at even the highest bitrates if "HDR" is not enabled in the video codec.
Related video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9j89L8eQQk
At the higher prices, I'd have to agree with you. If you pay for the best you should get the best.
The biggest jump in quality was when everything was still analog over the air, but getting ready for the digital transition.
Then digital over the air bumped it up a notch.
You could really see this happen on a big CRT monitor with the "All-in-Wonder" television receiver PCI graphics adapter card.
You plugged in your outdoor antenna or indoor rabbit ears to the back of the PC, then tuned in the channels using software.
These were made by ATI before being acquired by AMD, the TV tuner was in a faraday cage right on the same PCB as the early GPU.
The raw analog signal was upscaled to your adapter's resolution setting before going to the CRT so you had pseudo better resolution than a good TV like a Trinitron. You really could see more details and the CRT was smooth as butter.
As the TV broadcaster's entire equipment chain was replaced, like camera lenses, digital sensors and signal processing they eventually had everything in place and working. You could notice these incremental upgrades until a complete digital chain was established as designed. It was really jaw-dropping. This was well in advance of the deadline for digital deployment, so the signal over-the-air was still coming in analog the same old way.
Eventually the broadcast signal switched to digital and the analog lights went out, plus the All-in-Wonder was not ideal with a cheap converter like analog TV's could get by with.
But it was still better than most digital TVs for a few years, then it took years more before you could see the ball in live sports as well as on a CRT anyway.
Now that's about all you've got for full digital resolution, live broadcasts from your local stations, especially live sports from a strong interference-free station over an antenna. You can switch between the antenna and cable and tell the difference when they're both not overly compressed.
The only thing was, digital engineers "forgot" that TV was based on radio (who knew?) so for the vast majority of "listeners" on the fringe reception areas who could get clear audio but usually not a clear picture if any, too bad for you. You're gonna need a bigger antenna, good enough to have gotten you a clear picture during the analog days. Otherwise your "clean" digital audio may silently appear on the screen as video, "hidden" within the sparse blocks of scattered random digital noise. When anything does appear at all.
Kate - Netflix - 11.15 Mbps
Andor - Disney - 15.03 Mbps
Jack Ryan - Amazon - 15.02 Mbps
The Last of Us - Max - 19.96 Mbps
For All Mankind - Apple - 25.12 Mbps
https://hd-report.com/streaming-bitrates-of-popular-movies-s...
You will be made to feel the springs on the cheapest plan/mattress, and it's on purpose so you'll pay them more for something that costs them almost nothing.
I have a top-of-the-line 4K TV and gigabit internet, yet the compression artifacts make everything look like putty.
Honestly, the best picture quality I’ve ever seen was over 20 years ago using simple digital rabbit ears.
You especially notice the compression on gradients and in dark movie scenes.
And yes — my TV is fully calibrated, and I’m paying for the highest-bandwidth streaming tier.
Not my tv, but a visual example: https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd....