Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by benjiro on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:50PM
(#45550609)
> randomized grains appear smoother to the human eye than clean uniform pixels
Does this explain why i dislike 4K content on a 4K TV? Where some series and movies look too realistic, what in turn gives me a amateur film feeling (like somebody made a movie with a smartphone).
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by ZeroGravitas on Saturday October 11, 2025 @02:03PM
(#45551235)
This sounds like what is called the soap opera effect:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soap_opera_effect
Which is generally associated with excess denoisong rather than with excess grain.
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by dataflow on Saturday October 11, 2025 @02:46PM
(#45551578)
Are you sure? That seems to be about motion interpolation. Not even about smooth motion, but about it being interpolated. Here the concern seems to be about how the individual, still images look, not anything about the motion between them.
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by ZeroGravitas on Saturday October 11, 2025 @02:57PM
(#45551686)
> some series and movies look too realistic, what in turn gives me a amateur film feeling
This comment that I replied to is almost a textbook description of the soap opera effect.
The interpolation adds more FPS, which is traditionally a marker of film vs TV production.
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by ycombinatrix on Saturday October 11, 2025 @09:26PM
(#45554293)
Avatar 2 was particularly egregious with the poor interpolation
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by weaksauce on Saturday October 11, 2025 @02:51PM
(#45551620)
i think i've seen this effect on tv shot on cameras that were lower fps than the tv outputs. looks fake and bad and interpolated because it is.
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by franga2000 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @02:19PM
(#45551366)
Considering how much many camera brands boast their super low noise sensors, I'd still say a very common goal is to have as little noise as possible and then let the director/dop/colorist add grain to their liking. Even something like ARRI's in-camera switchable grain profiles requires a low-noise sensor to begin with.
But yes, there are definitely also many DPs that like their grain baked-in and camera companies that design cameras for that kind of use.
Re:AV2 video codec delivers 30% lower bitrate than AV1, fina...
by strogonoff on Sunday October 12, 2025 @04:57AM
(#45556609)
In any case, luma noise is not at all a massive issue, and it is a mistake to say that crews do their best to produce a noise-free image. They do their best to produce an image that they want to see, and some amount of luma noise is not a deal-breaker. There are routinely higher priorities that will take over using the lowest ISO possible. They can also be financial considerations, if you don’t have enough lights.
It is only an issue in content delivery.
This is not correct, camera manufacturers and filmakers engineer _aesthetically pleasing_ noise (randomized grains appear smoother to the human eye than clean uniform pixels). The rest is still as silly as it sounds.