News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by reactordev on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:27PM (#45466105)
It’s more aggressive than that. It’s an intentional dismantling of higher education overall.
[dead]
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by smallmancontrov on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:55PM (#45466430)
Academia didn't choose trickle-down policy. Quite the opposite -- that was you guys, after you purged all the leftist economists in the McCarthy era. In fact, the think-tank driven economics departments of recent years are so notoriously to the right of most academic faculty that this is a point of frequent conflict.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by the_sleaze_ on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:53PM (#45467084)
This wasn't a response to any of his arguments.

I am interested in what people have to say about them though.

1. DEI and identity politics prioritization 2. cost

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by corimaith on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:27PM (#45467420)
This is just partisan conspirational nonsense. Modern Economics took the useful things from Marx and left the rest in the dustbin of history like it should. Nor do Economists advocate for "trickle-down" theory, the answer has more to do with where one is on the laffer curve.

Economists clash frequently with other fields like social sciences because such fields continue to use unfalsifiable and highly flawed epistemic tools like dialectics to advocate for debunked theories like World Systems Theory.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by array_key_first on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:30PM (#45469695)
Economic theory in western nations is so hilariously skewed towards free market capitalist think that obvious models are just straight up missed, or sometimes obviously wrong conclusions are drawn. Most economics start with the understanding that the answer or cause is something about free market forces, and then work backwards.

For example, when talking about the economics of healthcare (or anything else, but lets start with healthcare), the conversation is approached from the get-go under the assumption that:

1. Healthcare is already a free market.

2. It is possible for healthcare to be a free market.

1. is just not true. Healthcare, in the US and and all developed nations, is not a free market. But, economists will just assume it is, because they assume everything is a free market, and then apply free market dynamics. Basically, they skip step 1, and go to step 1000.

And, for number 2, it's very debatable. IMO no, healthcare cannot be a free market, just by virtue of what healthcare is as a service. But that's debatable, I won't get into it.

Point is, we immediately start our economic understanding based off assumptions on top of assumptions that come from free market thinking, thinking around IP, thinking about consumer knowledge, thinking about access, etc.

We make absolutely wild and unsubstantiated claims for free, and nobody checks them.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by corimaith on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:59PM (#45469873)
>But, economists will just assume it is, because they assume everything is a free market, and then apply free market dynamics. Basically, they skip step 1, and go to step 1000.

Which economist are you referring to here? It's hard to even see what specific policy conclusions you're critiquing here, beyond a vague strawman against "free market assumptions".

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by quantumgarbage on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:09AM (#45471246)
That isn't a vague strawman, that's a great point. Economists work from assumptions, which can be flawed in two ways: they can be blatantly wrong (see the work Kahneman and Tversky did on the rational individual hypothesis) and they can be unfalsifiable (you can't always gather data about the assumption itself). There is a good essay on this from Tirole (yet a very mainstream economist) here: https://www.tse-fr.eu/sites/default/files/TSE/documents/doc/...
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by corimaith on Saturday October 04, 2025 @05:04AM (#45471877)
You're pointing to a critique of an assumption, what I'm saying can you name a specific economic policy or position given by an economist that is used in real public policy and then we can measure the merits of those policies and their assumptions as opposed to the counterfactuals. I'd bet 9/10 times the chosen policy likely would have been the most logical option.

After all, it's not like the epistemologies of the other humanities stands on far more shakier grounds...

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @07:58AM (#45472673)
> the most logical option

Well for whom? Another aspect of this problem is an economic solution can have winners and losers. An economic policy that invokes slavery as solution to labor issues may actually be 'logical' but clearly puts the interests of one group over another. Economics is just the science resource allocation after all. People have some serious biases when it comes to deciding policy on who gets what and how.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by corimaith on Saturday October 04, 2025 @09:32AM (#45473200)
I've asking multiple posters to give a specific policy example to critique and so far all of you have been unable to do so, instead dancing around and critiquing vague notions of a possibility of bias without giving concrete examples. Very postmodern, but this is why actual policymakers don't listen to critique like this.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @11:49AM (#45474185)
Ok, cutting taxes to the very rich while raising them on middle and lower classes and cutting services. This was part of the big beautiful bill. This is 'logical' from the point of view of the billionaire class, but in terms of the economy that everyone else lives in, things will be worse for them.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by corimaith on Saturday October 04, 2025 @04:54PM (#45476612)
>Ok, cutting taxes to the very rich while raising them on middle and lower classes and cutting services. This was part of the big beautiful bill. This is 'logical' from the point of view of the billionaire class

Deciding who benefits or not from legislation is not a Economist's domain, their work is descriptive, not normative. You're critiquing politicians here for prioritizing GDP, but that is divorced from your critique of economics. The economist will only tell you what they think will happen with regard to the economy if you pass a bill or not given the goals you've outlined to them.

https://taxfoundation.org/blog/big-beautiful-bill-impact-def...

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61387

Well you look at analysis here, do you then disagree with the predictions of the bill and the methodology used, and if so, what is your better analysis here with supposedly more refined epistemic assumptions?

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by erxam on Saturday October 04, 2025 @06:10PM (#45477169)
Milei's government slashed the national health care budget by 48 percent in real terms and fired over 2,000 Health Ministry workers — 1,400 in just a few days in January. These drastic moves were part of Milei's broader plan to shrink the state and remake Argentina's debt-ridden economy.

Among the most dramatic cutbacks was the dismantling of the National Cancer Institute, which halted early detection programs for breast and cervical cancer. Funding was also frozen for immunization campaigns, severely disrupting vaccine access during Argentina's first measles outbreak in decades. The National Directorate for HIV, Hepatitis, and Tuberculosis lost 40 percent of its staff and 76 percent of its budget, delaying diagnosis and treatment across the country. Emergency contraception and abortion pill distribution have also stopped.

Prescription drug prices and private health insurance premiums have surged by 250 percent and 118 percent, respectively, according to official data.

https://www.bignewsnetwork.com/news/278391265/mileis-austeri...

Obviously, this is an article from the political side of things (I tried to cut out value judgements), but these are decisions made by actual economists like José Luis Espert, Agustín Etchebarne, Federico Sturzenegger, Alberto Benegas Lynch and probably a million others I'm not aware of.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by reactordev on Saturday October 04, 2025 @11:46AM (#45474158)
There is no economics that involves enslaving other humans. Not slavery. Not ever. However, in debt in perpetuity is a thing. So you have to work to pay, so you can live, so you can work, so you can pay…

Debt crisis is a real problem. We have borrowed more than we can ever repay, all nations, for the last 30 years. Both sides. Just drove right off the cliff.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:10PM (#45475823)
> Economists work from assumptions

All models start with givens…

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by idiotsecant on Saturday October 04, 2025 @10:28PM (#45478420)
Which is fine, as long as your assumptions are good models of reality. When your assumptions are essentially articles of faith your models tend to be about as good as the guys who interpret patterns in chicken bones.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by aorist on Sunday October 05, 2025 @01:17AM (#45478998)
You need assumptions exactly for the things which cannot be tested against reality. Otherwise why assume rather than measure?
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 05, 2025 @01:50AM (#45479117)
> Otherwise why assume rather than measure?

You need a model to design an experiment.

This is how all science is done. You hypothesize. Then experiment.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by quantumgarbage on Sunday October 05, 2025 @05:35AM (#45480229)
Sure, that does not mean all models are equal.

Economics both describe and prescribe, so those models should be evaluated on their predictive power and on whether they have actually done any good.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 05, 2025 @11:33AM (#45482298)
> that does not mean all models are equal

Sure. Nobody claimed that. I’m just pointing out that being upset that a model makes assumptions is nonsense.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by quantumgarbage on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @07:23AM (#45514871)
We are questioning the assumptions themselves, not the act of making them.

(I don't feel like anyone is upset?)

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:53PM (#45475684)
> the conversation is approached from the get-go under the assumption that: 1. Healthcare is already a free market. 2. It is possible for healthcare to be a free market

Nobody does this.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by array_key_first on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @11:29PM (#45511760)
Literally almost everyone does this.

If you start talking about competition or consumer choice, surprise! You have made an extremely bold assumption: that healthcare is currently operating as a free market.

That assumption is actually, like, 1000 assumptions. Do people prove even one of those? No. They just move on and hope nobody notices.

And, well, we don't. We're so used to these economy falacies that they're practically invisible.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by the_sleaze_ on Monday October 06, 2025 @11:01AM (#45492161)
If yall want to know why "Im a Doctor" economists are dying out - look at this back and forth. There is not one single solution or thread here. It's a series of old married couples bickering.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by bonsai_spool on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:51PM (#45466376)
> pissed off half of customers in their quest for moral purity

I'm not sure what 'half' means here. It's neither true that men make up half of applicants (which are really what we should be focusing on), nor that so-called 'conservatives' make up half of this population.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by gjsman-1000 on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:53PM (#45466400)
> nor that so-called 'conservatives' make up half of this population

There it is; the quest for moral purity continues.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by bonsai_spool on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:55PM (#45466434)
> There it is; the quest for moral purity continues.

I am neither a university nor 'academia'.

I am, however, still unclear about what your point is.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by hluska on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:49PM (#45467049)
It’s funny that instead of making points or adding data, you just repeat the same slogan and act like a victim. Many of us have tried to listen for a long time but we have never found any intellectual meat on the slogans. It’s boring.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by kelipso on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:36PM (#45467504)
What’s there to discuss any more?

There is data that some ridiculous percentage of academics are on the left, and drastically so for liberal arts departments.

“Everyone knows” that they filter against conservatives (maybe there isn’t hard data, but it’s pretty obvious to a lot of people, so I would say this is something that need to be disproven, not proven).

Liberals deny this, so what’s the point of discussing it. Let the dismantling continue until corrections happen I guess.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by tzs on Friday October 03, 2025 @06:45PM (#45468702)
There was a paper published in 2022 on the political leanings of scientists [1]. Here's the abstract:

> Scientists in the United States are more politically liberal than the general population. This fact has fed charges of political bias. To learn more about scientists’ political behavior, we analyze publicly available Federal Election Commission data. We find that scientists who donate to federal candidates and parties are far more likely to support Democrats than Republicans, with less than 10 percent of donations going to Republicans in recent years. The same pattern holds true for employees of the academic sector generally, and for scientists employed in the energy sector. This was not always the case: Before 2000, political contributions were more evenly divided between Democrats and Republicans. We argue that these observed changes are more readily explained by changes in Republican Party attitudes toward science than by changes in American scientists. We reason that greater public involvement by centrist and conservative scientists could help increase trust in science among Republicans.

An example they give of the changes in the Republican Party are the Republican position on climate change. For a good illustration at just how much Republicans have changed just take a look at the 2008 Republican Party Platform [2].

They wanted to address climate change by reducing emissions and greenhouse gases, increasing energy efficiency, promoting EVs and natural gas powered vehicles, and create multi-million dollar prizes for technological developments to eliminate the need for gas powered cars or abate atmospheric carbon.

They also talk about the need for renewables to become mainstream and supported long-term energy tax credits to promote that.

Compare to today. Now they are opposed to nearly all of that. The current administration's position is the climate change is a hoax or scam.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01382-3

[2] https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/2008-republican-pa...

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by yongjik on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:53PM (#45467651)
Members of an ideological group that sees educational institutions as their enemies less likely to find jobs in educational institutions, news at eleven.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by reactordev on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:48PM (#45467611)
Ugh, there is only ignorance and enlightenment. Keep enjoying ignorance.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by kelipso on Saturday October 04, 2025 @12:25PM (#45474492)
This is religious thinking.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by lovich on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:59PM (#45475257)
> maybe there isn’t hard data, but it’s pretty obvious to a lot of people, so I would say this is something that need to be disproven, not proven

This is not religious thinking? You’re arguing based on faith and claiming the rest of us have to prove there is no tea pot floating in orbit on the other side of the sun

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by kelipso on Monday October 06, 2025 @10:05AM (#45491600)
No, that’s setting the parameters for an argument.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by bikezen on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:49PM (#45467621)
Have you considered that it's not filtering for conservatives, but conservatives are self-selecting out or can't cut it at all? Isn't liberal arts degree a literal punchline to so many on the right, yet you cant figure out why that might skew left?

> maybe there isn’t hard data, but it’s pretty obvious to a lot of people, so I would say this is something that need to be disproven, not proven

Huh, wonder why this world view doesnt jive with academia.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by legostormtroopr on Friday October 03, 2025 @05:42PM (#45468139)
> Have you considered that … conservatives are self-selecting out or can't cut it at all?

When the ingroup is underrepresented the question is “how can we get more ingroup in”.

But when the outgroup is underrepresented it’s met with “maybe outgroup just isn’t as good”.

Eg. women in tech, men in nursing; conservatives vs liberals in academia.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by acdha on Saturday October 04, 2025 @12:52PM (#45474680)
It’s worth thinking about why you’re wrong, because it explains why those comparisons aren’t valid. Modern conservatism is defined by rejecting ideas like objective truth or pluralism which are the core of academia. There’s no way to have conservatives more represented in science when conservatives refuse to allow people who practice science to be part of their movement: you used to be able to find Republicans who wanted to do something about climate change, for example, but anyone who wants to apply scientific principles there now has been purged from the party. Vaccines aren’t quite there yet but it’s trending in that direction and the percentage of doctors who are Republican have been declining since the pandemic.

Contrast that with women in tech or men in nursing and it becomes obvious why the comparison isn’t valid: women want to be good technologists, not to reject the validity of technology or say we should all go back to the Amish lifestyle (that desire is common to senior developers of both genders). Male nurses want to be good nurses, not claiming that their gender means they can commit medical malpractice.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by kelipso on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:54PM (#45467667)
Well if “I can only act until there is hard data” is a principle in academia then maybe academia deserves what it’s getting. We live in a Bayesian world after all.

Also the whole idea that they are self selecting out is absurd. There are many flavors of conservative, not just the ones you see on Ali G show or whatever.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by ceejayoz on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:50PM (#45466374)
> That's not a great way to survive.

Wait until you see how well setting it all on fire works.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by gjsman-1000 on Friday October 03, 2025 @02:51PM (#45466383)
At this point, we might be just fine. The academics won't be, but they were the ones telling everyone to wait on having kids in the first place. Demographic trickle down, biting the hand that feeds academia, is a big part of this story.

At my college, birth control was as free as water. Teaching people to postpone marriage, children, for the sake of career, combined with record-high school debt... might be partly why academia finds themselves in this demographic decline. They told the next generation not to have kids, made it financially impossible to have kids, and lo and behold, there's less kids entering college now.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by smallmancontrov on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:13PM (#45466657)
Academia didn't make it financially impossible to have kids. Just what control do you think academia has over the market? Over the government?

"Raise house prices now or I'll send you to the principal's office!"

The gays didn't send house prices to the moon. Mexicans didn't send the jobs to China. No, it's the people with assets who pursued asset-pumping policy to great effect. You're right to be angry, but you're a fool to believe them when they point at universities as the source of the problem.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by rightbyte on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:23PM (#45466762)
You seem to argue that academia of all places made having children being a chore. Not like, dunno, job security, housing and child care costs?

Whatever beef you got is what 'media' fed you selected smug academics to piss you off.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by bonsai_spool on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:24PM (#45466776)
> At this point, we might be just fine. The academics won't be, but they were the ones telling everyone to wait on having kids in the first place. Demographic trickle down, biting the hand that feeds academia, is a big part of this story.

> At my college, birth control was as free as water. Teaching people to postpone marriage, children, for the sake of career, combined with record-high school debt... might be partly why academia finds themselves in this demographic decline. They told the next generation not to have kids, made it financially impossible to have kids, and lo and behold, there's less kids entering college now.

Hard to tell if this is just parody.

I will say that if feel that providing something equates to mandating it... I don't know how we're going to be able to have logical exchanges

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by someothherguyy on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:32PM (#45467461)
I feel bad for the toxic world building you are committing yourself to. You should try not monolithizing groups of people.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by Arainach on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:00PM (#45466501)
How does the phrase go? Facts don't care about your feelings?

When one side of the political spectrum not only abandons scientific rigor, rationality, and questioning beliefs but attacks those ideals instead of religious devotion to dogma over evidence, then acts outraged that educated people tend not to share their beliefs, it's on them.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by jmugan on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:05PM (#45466558)
Which side are you talking about?
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by yongjik on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:47PM (#45467602)
America's greatest conservative government pressured a private business to fire a comedian for a remark on the death of someone who was basically a celebrity troll.

...and they turn around and complain about liberals' "moral purity."

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by reactordev on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:59PM (#45469870)
To them, he was a master of manipulation, exactly what they’re looking for. Someone who can spout racism and bigotry and drive listenership based on what crazy thing he’ll say next. Where does this sound familiar? It’s playbook man. That’s their business. I don’t condone any of what happened but he’s not someone we should be building statues of.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by FrustratedMonky on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:23PM (#45467379)
Yeah, where do people think Technology Growth comes from. GOP is all Growth, Growth, Growth, will save us, but hey lets poison the well from which it flows.

All AI growth today, is actually from Academia from 20 years ago.

Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by nradov on Friday October 03, 2025 @05:33PM (#45468052)
Growth comes from many sources. The supply-side economics wing of the GOP would claim that lower taxes and smaller, less intrusive government will allow for a higher private sector growth rate. There may be some truth to that, although the effects are probably limited compared to the development of disruptive new technologies.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by idiotsecant on Saturday October 04, 2025 @10:25PM (#45478415)
They would claim that, and they would be wrong. As has been repeatedly and exhaustively demonstrated.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by teddy-smith on Sunday October 05, 2025 @10:18AM (#45481678)
Amen, trickle down economics is the worst meme ever created.
Re:The collapse of the econ PhD job market by rolandog on Monday October 06, 2025 @07:27AM (#45490192)
Just yesterday I was talking with some friends about the disaster that neoliberalism has been.

I see billionaires as "water-balloon" (wealth) hoarders, and I see taxes on the rich as thorns on bushes. If the politicians ever wanted to make "trickle down" work, then we need thornier bushes and to make it impossible for rich people to not go through thorny bushes.

But the whole deregulation craze has made it so that the billionaires don't even need people to help them protect their "water-balloons"...