Every single story and moral guidance I've ever been told from childhood, whether from movies, books, church, or culture in general is that people like those in power right now are the bad guys.
I no longer have any idea what people on the other side actually think. I don't think they know anymore either. I think they just want to exert power and control and revenge over their personal grievances and boogeymen, and seem to be under a constant bombardment of ideology to convince people to untether themselves from any moral restraint or connection with the out-group.
I am one of the scary minorities they use as a boogeyman, and their rhetoric about the group of people I belong to is so unattached from my daily life, the values that I hold, and my own attitudes that it would be comical if it didn't come out in sideways glances, scowls, and stares of people on the street. Nobody ever even bothers to ask, to even have a moment of conversation to see that there is a real person. I try to walk through life friendly, open, and interested in people. We walk around with conceptions of other people built for us, not ones that we have made ourselves.
The only thing that seems to help is to try to be offline as much as possible, to be in community with people and in real space.
As someone who doesn't think the people in power right now are the bad guys, it's because we get downvoted/banned/doxxed (on most platforms) when we do say what we think.
For the past decade or so, we've been doing iterations of the prisoner's dilemma, where defection involves using the state against one's political adversaries (or large corporations that are basically an extension of the state.) Cooperation on the other hand means using one's free speech to try and convince the other side, instead of just getting someone more powerful to shut them up and/or fired from their job.
The general consensus in my circles is that for the past decade "our side" have been advocating cooperation, while the other side repeatedly defects. Given this history, if you know the other side is likely going to defect, it's a losing strategy to try to cooperate, even if you desire cooperation.
I often fantasize about being able to just converse openly and be able to mutually share experiences. I was raised very conservative and speak the language and know the values. I don't hold those beliefs anymore because of experiences I've had that made them contradictory to hold. But I still appreciate why someone who hasn't had my experiences might hold them.
For my "side", among all the people that I talk to who, who would be considered pretty far to one side, everyone wants primarily to be left alone, not harassed, and wants to coexist, and be respected. Is it the same from yours?
Both. I worked at a company that leaned right, and there was a guy I worked with that took every opportunity to interject with his left/liberal opinion. I think people found it annoying sometimes, but we had some good discussions every once in a while. His career didn't suffer and we still keep in touch. Other companies have either been apolitical or left-leaning, and I've never observed the opposite. Personally, I keep my mouth shut because providing for my family is more important than (best case scenario) changing someone's mind, and I'm guessing that's everyone else's strategy as well.
> everyone wants primarily to be left alone, not harassed, and wants to coexist, and be respected. Is it the same from yours?
Nominally, yes. But even with that I think that's where there's a lot of disagreement. What does coexistence mean exactly? Does it mean forcing people to accept others into their spaces? What if a company wants to exclusively hire men? What if they want to exclusively hire Christians? To me, infringing on the right of free association is at odds with being left alone. Am I being left alone if a significant amount of my income is being confiscated against my will and spent in a way that I disagree with? What does being respected mean? Is it forcing people to use certain pronouns, even if you don't think it aligns with their biological sex, and it feels like lying?
Most of my friends are some flavor of Christian. They use my pronouns around me. I don't take their Lords name in vain around them. Sometimes, coexistance and respect are really as simple as that.
Unfortunately, history has shown that allowing that kind of selectivity ends up with extremely unfair job prospects for people from different ethnic backgrounds. You might be fine if you're a Christian man, but there's a lot of other people in the world so you should learn to get along with them (not intending to imply that you personally have an issue).
> Is it forcing people to use certain pronouns, even if you don't think it aligns with their biological sex, and it feels like lying?
It's not so much forcing as just being polite. If you meet someone and call them "David" and they reply "oh, I prefer Dave", then it'd be kind of odd for you to insist on using "David" because that's the name that was written on their birth certificate. It's about consideration for other people's self image etc.
This admin is solving that dilemma by attempting to deport them all..
we arent talking about “how many immigrants should we allow”, we’re talking about “trans people shouldnt exist”, “christianity is the true religion”, “deport all legal immigrants”, “gay people shouldnt have human rights”
And before you downvote me, explain how the concept of charity maps to non-cooperation unless you yourself has something to gain
What /would/ someone have to offer you, your family or your community? What do you value? What does your community value? How do you know folks have nothing to offer?
FWIW I believe dehumanization is a horrendous thing, especially when aimed at relatively powerless minorities.
And what opinions are these?
Gee I wonder why! Maybe because you guys say the most vile and hateful shit out loud, are intolerant of people existing and constantly try to impose your way of living to others instead of letting people live as they like/want/can.
You’re completely brainwashed.
If this is really truly the case, explain the J6 insurrection. Trump lied for 2 months about the election results. Summoned his supporters, who literally show up with weapons flying Trump / Confederate / Nazi flags side by side, sacked the capitol, attempted to murder the Vice President and Speaker of the House. They engaged in what was described as "medieval combat" for hours. People died, cops and injured for life.
To this day, the people in power who you say are not the bad guys refuse to admit responsibility for what happened and pardoned all the people who committed those crimes on his behalf.
How do you square what happened then with your assertion that "the past decade "our side" have been advocating cooperation"?
I see this almost every day in any thread that's even 5% "political". There are no consequences to this deranged behaviour, one might even say it's encouraged (because rightoid trolls love negative attention and a new account is two clicks away).
The main purpose of "green accounts" was so that a blog author could quickly respond to comments here, without having an account beforehand. This is like 1% of green accounts I see now.
That's not what's happening.
When most people serving in positions of government do so in good faith, most forms of government work, including the American one. When most people serve in bad faith, most forms of government do not work, including the American one.
The American system has checks in place to keep what is happening from happening, but those checks aren't working because those who would exercise them aren't doing so, as withholding those checks benefits them personally, at least in the short term. The underlying theory of the American system is that if you distribute power enough, one or a few bad actors can't seize total power.
But, there are just too many people in elected office right now who did not take their oath to uphold the Constitution in good faith. Namely, in Congress which has simultaneously demonstrated that it is unwilling to effectively wield the impeachment check, and is unable to do effective legislative work, leading to a latent desire for a stronger executive. In this circumstance, no form of government will hold up without a correction towards replacing all the bad-faith actors.
I think this is why some people are concerned.
Right wing authoritarianism is by far the biggest terrorist threat in the united states - right wingers literally threaten war on social media on the regular and love their guns, elected officials are literally conspiracy theorists who talk about jewish space lasers and weather control systems, women have lost the right to abortions, we are testing the waters on gay marriage and mixed race marriage, we started a global trade war, the courts, congress, and the executive branch are controlled by one party and no one is doing any balance of powers.
This all happens and I still hear people talk to me like "the liberals just shouldn't say X on twitter because its rude!!!" as if that's going to stop the white nationalists currently on the rampage in the government.
Tim Urban makes an interesting argument to the contrary in https://waitbutwhy.com/whatsourproblem
Though he argues that both “sides” are dangerously anti-liberal, but in different way.
Did I thought he was a fascist and did I want to kill him? No, he seemed like a decent man who’s just afraid of things he’s not familiar with and who believe in stuff pushed by crazy radicals because he has no experience with people and situations unknown to him.
Did I want to punch him? No, I wanted to discuss with him, but I haven’t got time, as I needed to pick up my kid from the same art school he was bringing his kid in.
So tell me, why is he concerned about people who he saw on metro and who were not threatening him? Should he be afraid of me, because I probably could be described as woke as I think that you should let others be, if they don’t hurt you or others? I don’t care about online media, this is real life example.
As such, using the term "anti-woke" to describe oneself is essentially self-identifying as White Supremacist.
This is an intentional decision by the far right, and if you're not in on it, then yes, you've been tricked. Therefore it is completely reasonable for someone to think you are a fascist, if you use terminology that self-identifies yourself as fascist.
And you can't claim I'm changing the rules on you or anything like that. Woke is a word coined by anti-racists. You're using our word to self-identify as a bad person. It literally is that simple.
However, that slippery slope about randomly getting punched for vague ????? is total nonsense and irrational on your part.
There have been periods of pause, and even reverse, but two terms of the Trump administration trailing on the heels of the tea party movement in the 2010s have really done a lot of damage at all levels of US government.
By now, so many politicians, lawyers, and judges, are compromised it's going to take some pretty extreme changes to the way people are voting to make an impact.
I don't see that happening in the near future, even if I do see it happening in the long term.
big government is exactly what is happening now
I never said it wasn't.Such is the paradox of the modern Republican party. For the last so many decades they have claimed to want a smaller government. Then went handed the keys to the kingdom they immediately increase its size and get right to abusing its power.
I wish the law that restricted the number of public stations/licenses a single entity could own was still in place. It was created to prevent what's happening now, silencing of varied and different ideas, views, and opinions.
https://thedesk.net/2025/09/nexstar-sinclair-jimmy-kimmel-fc...
> Sinclair's stations have been known for featuring news content and programming that promote conservative political positions. They have been involved in various controversies surrounding politically motivated programming decisions,[172][173] such as news coverage and specials during the lead-ups to elections that were in support of the Republican Party.[174][175][172]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinclair_Broadcast_Group#Polit...
My read is they weren't coerced, but did as Trump desired because they like Trump. Either way, it should go to court.
"This is a nice merger deal, shame anything should happen to it…" does not look like a recipe for a free will / willing action to be made.
For the record, the merger is with Nexstar, not Sinclair, but the point is the same:
* https://www.nexstar.tv/nexstar-media-group-inc-enters-into-d...
But the GOP holds all three. Even the court system has fallen apart, with the Supreme Court using shadow dockets with no explanation, not establishing any precedent, just overriding lower courts to rule by fiat as they please. The GOP congress is utterly maga whipped, with only very rare signs of protest; deathly afraid of provoking Trump's ire.
Even still there's constant legal losses for the administration. But the shock and awe, the endless acting bad, in bad faith, doing bad things, and disrespecting the constitution, the liberties, the democracy: it's very grinding and very hard to see such pure malice against our history and rights and decency performed so ruthlessly so regularly.
A man was assassinated holding a mic practicing free speech. Celebrating the assassination can be interpreted as a form of celebrating attacks on free speech, because the murdered mic holder was saying average political views.
Therefore people argue that we have to shame (not imprison or kill) celebrations on attacks on free speech to protect free speech.
Kimmel's words:
"...the MAGA gang [was] desperately trying to characterize this kid who murdered Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them..."
The assassin may have indeed once been a MAGA supporter - his family certainly appear to be so. But political beliefs can change quickly as his history demostrates:
The assassin found true love in a transsexual roommate/lover.So overcome was he by his love for his transsexual roomie and so offended by MAGA supporter Charlie Kirk's objections to LGBTQ+, that he engraved LGBTQ+ graffiti on 30-06 ammo and shot Charlie Kirk in the neck with one of the bullets. He left the remaining bullets with the rifle IIRC.
Was the assassin a MAGA supporter at the moment he pulled the trigger? Beats me!
It’s not a surprise with the bubble people are living in though.
So what you're saying is "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences?"
Odd. I suspect the same people arguing that now would have been outraged at the very thought before Charlie Kirk's death. Because they celebrate the death of people also practicing free speech all the time while insisting that freedom of speech exists to defend the speech you disagree with, not the speech you agree with.
It's just weird how fast their principles turn on a dime when it's one of theirs.
Free speech has been under threat at the academic and cultural level for a while now, especially in the 2010's. All of that was a good thing in my opinion, because a generation of college students were able to see firsthand what happens when we try and silence dissent.
This situation is admittedly more dangerous, as the federal government is attempting to suppress speech via governmental subsidies (as far as I can tell, I don't have all the facts).
But this is also an opportunity. It's a moment for those on the political left to see clearly why protecting speech is, in fact, a very good thing. So hopefully the sane people on both sides of the aisle can reflect on where we're at, how we got here, and how we get out of this situation. To me it's clear - we reject both explicit and implicit attempts to suppress speech we don't like, full stop. We don't kill people, we don't get people fired, we don't threaten to withhold funding. We need to collectively agree to do this across the board, for everyone in this country.
When I was in college we had 3 days of a small group of Vietnam war protests. Right away the administration kicked everyone off campus who wasn't an employee or student. The next day they told the remaining 3 protestors to either leave or be expelled. One left, the other 2 went back to class. Everybody put their heads back in their books. I was sooooo grateful we had an enlightened administration.
That's the way to handle protesting students! The university is not a political podium, it is a place to learn.
People suffer critical gaps in their education b/c university classes are interrupted by campus politics. Professors would skip important topics b/c of the time lost. Decades later I've heard engineers & mathematicians complain about gaps in their learning as a consequence. I mean, imagine the woe of not being properly introduced to say, the Laplacian or Hamiltonian view of mechanics!
FWIW I understand about that "...shitty...shitty...Not trying to be argumentative,really..." thing. Perhaps you have too much "shit" between your ears?
Ear wax remover works well on that: but be careful not to take it all out, man, you might have some brain left.
Of course universities were political for a hundred years, and students were often very active.
So Congress people spend more time fund raising (taking bribes) than helping their district.
Nothing real has gotten done in many districts for multiple decades. Real wages, when compared to inflation, and has been falling for decades. When I was very young, laws where passed that actually helped people. As a very young kid, I remember waking up as a kid with coal flakes on my window sill due to its use in the mills. That ended in the 70s.
Now, to get more money the laws that cleaned up the environment are being cancelled, why, rich are "tipping" congress people.
The US is done, time for civilization advancement to be carried on by another Country. Hopefully the EU can get its act together.
I always thought the US to be a stronghold of democracy and free speech. I know, it's a naive view and we know how huge companies and corrupt politicians can subvert the system. But still, I thought it had a decent law system that, although imperfect like any other system, kept things from going back to the dark ages.
I don't believe that anymore after what I've seen this year. A few individuals can completely takeover the government, keep committing bigger and bigger crimes and nothing happens. All they get is outrage on social media, which they are happy to shrug off.
I know democracy and free speech are fragile things and we have to be constantly watching but I didn't imagine it would be this ephemeral in the US.