News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by in_cahoots on Sunday July 27, 2025 @10:53PM (#44706775)
I read the whole article and I still don't see how Big Ag misled anyone. I may be misunderstanding, but it seems that the author is trying to differentiate between growing corn for food vs growing the same corn for ethanol. I assume the entire reason the lobby exists is that farmers want to grow corn for food and ethanol. But the researcher lost interest before proving anything around there. Maybe ethanol is actually worse, but I didn't see any evidence in this article.

Instead, this article is a master class in the red herring fallacy. Every person on the 'wrong' side of the issue has their sordid past and connections exposed, whether it's their association with Wall Street or the fact that they're a sex offender. Nevermind the science, the author just assumes that because the reader (presumably) has a certain political persuasion denigrating the other side will serve as a convincing argument.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lelandbatey on Sunday July 27, 2025 @11:08PM (#44706844)
The corn varieties grown for industrial ethanol production are mutually exclusive with the corn varieties grown for human consumption; you cannot use one for the other. They might as well be corn vs soy beans.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by somat on Sunday July 27, 2025 @11:33PM (#44706976)
Fun fact: corn farmers almost always rotate with soybeans to replenish the nitrogen in the soil.

Also, most corn (and soybeans) is for animal food anyway. Very little of the corn grown in the US is for human consumption.

My understanding(not a corn farmer but have watched a show by one on youtube) is the farmer will harvest the corn then dry and store it, selling over the course of a year or two, the ethanol plant is sort of the fallback option when they need to get rid if it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSB-8dn3CkI

Personally, I am in the rapeseed bandwagon. Ethanol is not a very good fuel, better to be growing bio-diesel

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by kwk1 on Sunday July 27, 2025 @11:47PM (#44707055)
> little of the corn grown in the US is for human consumption.

Yup, just as a point of reference, something like 70% of Illinois corn goes straight into Illinois hogs.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by giantg2 on Sunday July 27, 2025 @11:20PM (#44706915)
I believe they grow field corn for animal feed as well as for ethanol. Technically some processed foods also use field corn. While there are a number of varieties of field corn, I don't believe any are exclusive to ethanol production and could be used in other capacities.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @10:51AM (#44711448)
> I believe they grow field corn for animal feed as well as for ethanol.

I grow corn. I grow it to be sold. Whatever the buyer decides to do with it — be that feed it to animals, turn it into tortilla chips, make sweeteners, create plastic for 3D printers, produce ethanol, or even burn it in their furnace — is up to them.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by in_cahoots on Sunday July 27, 2025 @11:14PM (#44706873)
I assumed something similar. But the author presents this as some sort of trump card, as if the agriculture industry was suggesting farmers grow corn for ethanol instead of for food. And then the researcher lost interest before he could be proven right. Maybe he actually was right, but there's no evidence here.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @10:53AM (#44711475)
> The corn varieties grown for industrial ethanol production are mutually exclusive with the corn varieties grown for human consumption

Not exactly. You wouldn't normally eat "industrial ethanol corn" off the cob, which is what you are probably trying to suggest, but it is often used in other corn-based food like tortilla chips, and, of course, its most infamous use: High-fructose corn syrup.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by sien on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:02AM (#44707357)
The EU does something impressively crazy burning 23 million tonnes of wood pellets in 2021.

https://unece.org/media/press/372591

It's labeled as 'renewable' electricity.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by voxelghost on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:26AM (#44707477)
It's labeled 'renewable energy' (not electricity), if wood pellets are sourced from sustainable renewable forest growth.

What is your argument?

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by rini17 on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:54AM (#44707616)
It requires stringent checking of the source. Which was shown does not happen or with only slap on the wrist.

https://spectator.sme.sk/culture-and-lifestyle/c/new-documen...

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by knappe on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:44AM (#44707567)
That it isn't sustainable. As Eating the Earth points out, by growing trees to then cut them down again we're not accounting for the cost of using that same forested land for anything else, like a forest which is a great carbon sink. Instead burning wood pellets is considered renewable until you consider the cost of using that land for something else in which case it isn't a renewal resource.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by happosai on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:31AM (#44707819)
The word renewable has a specific meaning (the source renews). Just because something is renewable, doesn't mean it's climate-friendly and/or sustainable.

Burning pellets as Bioenergy is renewable - it's just not sustainable[1] or climate-friendly.

[1] not sustainable in large scale use.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by eptcyka on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:53AM (#44707613)
Burning wood pellets is carbon neutral. Any forrest is a great carbon sink until it matures and it saturates, i.e. growth reaches replacement equilibrium and old trees/growth decay, releasing the CO2.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by sl-1 on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:11AM (#44709623)
This is not taking in to account the fossil fuel usage for growing wood, transporting it and processing it to pellets.

Biofuels rarely make sense, unless we can get the biomass as a side-flow from some other process. And that kind of flows are quite limited compared to our energy needs.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 7952 on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:47AM (#44709902)
It depends on the time and spatial scale. And how much replanting is happening.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:47AM (#44707582)
That makes no sense with the definition of ‘renewable’.

Trees grow again. They are renewed.

What is this junk?

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by fodkodrasz on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:46AM (#44707921)
The soil is degraded, washed away on clear-cut forests, and even old-growth protected forests are being relabeled unprotected to provide energy for the industry all over Eastern-Europe. The resulting flash floods, the water of which is harder to retain on the lowlands are worsening the droughts and the effects of climate change.

Ah, end eventually trees will not regrow, because they need soil for that. And water. Modern forestry is far from renewable. Only externalities having a longer time-frame to kick in are conveniently ignored by the decision makers and the masses willing to see only the upsides.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:47AM (#44709899)
In the US that is not how it has been done in a very, very long time. At this point all US timberland is multi-generation new growth; and is doing just fine.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by knappe on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:59AM (#44707634)
It makes perfect sense.

Forest are only carbon sinks if they stay as a forest. The second you cut one down it goes from being a sink to source. Searchinger's argument states that more forests will be grown to be cut down if burning wood pellets (that are shipped from North America to the EU) is considered renewable and that means you're now cutting down even more forests to clear land for growing more trees. The land used is not free; it could have instead stayed a forest and remained a carbon sink. When you compare wood pellets using for generating energy and compare it to other forms of energy generation it no longer holds up as a renewable resource after you take into account the land that could have been kept instead as a forest and carbon sink.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:02AM (#44707655)
Forests are not long term carbon sinks. They flatline rather quickly.

This is obvious to anyone who has spent much time in a forest, because if this wasn’t the case, forests would be sitting on thousands of feet of sequestered carbon. Instead of a few feet (typically) of non-mineral soil.

Forests also (typically) go through cycles of burning.

The highest rate of carbon sequestration is when a forest is in the 3-25 year old range, because that is when the bulk of the actual growth is occurring.

Renewable doesn’t mean ‘indefinite carbon sink’. Renewable means ‘renews’.

This entire discussion is incredibly ridiculous.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by knappe on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:26AM (#44707783)
Look dude, read the papers or read the book. I don't have much more to offer you. This isn't just about the forest itself but about the land used to grow the forest.

"In the Carbon Costs of Global Wood Harvests, published in Nature in 2023, WRI researchers using a biophysical model estimated that annual wood harvests over the next few decades will emit 3.5-4.2 billion tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) per year. That is more than 3 times the world’s current annual average aviation emissions. These wood-harvest emissions occur because the great majority of carbon stored in trees is released to the atmosphere after harvest when roots and slash decompose; as most wood is burned directly for heat or electricity or for energy at sawmills or paper mills; and when discarded paper products, furniture and other wood products decompose or burn. Another recent paper in Nature found that the word’s remaining forests have lost even more carbon, primarily due to harvesting wood, than was lost historically by converting forests to agriculture (other studies have found similar results1). Based on these analyses, a natural climate solution would involve harvesting less wood and letting more forests regrow. This would store more carbon as well as enhance forest biodiversity."[0]

[0]https://www.wri.org/technical-perspectives/wood-harvest-emis...

And the original paper that introduced the idea of land use https://www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1126/science.1151861

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by MOARDONGZPLZ on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:12AM (#44708091)
So I see what you’re saying. You’re talking about the whole system. Take land and then plant trees, the trees sequester carbon as they grow, some of them fall to the forest floor continuing to sequester carbon. But, I think the issue with your argument is, this process isn’t indefinite. The natural cycle is that these trees will decay, fall, rot (releasing carbon naturally) or natural forest fires will burn them anyways (releasing carbon naturally). Then more trees will take their places and sequester carbon, ad infinitum in the cycle that has taken place for the last 2 billion years since the Paleoproterozoic era.

But I see no difference between humans speeding this cycle by planting quick growth trees, cutting them down, releasing their stored carbon, planting more. It’s the same thing being sequestered and released continuously.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by wizzwizz4 on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:04AM (#44708441)
The planet isn't infinite: by running the cycle more quickly, you knock the "baseline" atmospheric carbon up a few more ppm. This has knock-on effects.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:52AM (#44708754)
Even if we converted all arable land in the United States to forest, best case we would take many years to sequester even a single years fossil carbon emissions. And we’d all starve to death in the process.

Any co2 released by harvesting a forest, is very shortly taken back up again by the forest regrowing. Within a lifetime for sure.

Trees are nice, I get it. But this is all in the noise.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by wizzwizz4 on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:34AM (#44708991)
Where do these numbers come from?
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:53AM (#44709944)
USFS studies, and US data on overall arable land. I broke it out in a prior thread exhaustively, but it’s been covered in other areas too. Here is one [https://www.nrs.fs.usda.gov/pubs/gtr/gtr_wo059.pdf]

The US emits a truly massive amount of fossil carbon. [https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis...], “Total emissions in 2022 are 6,343.2 Million Metric Tons of CO₂ equivalent”. Yes, that is 6 billion metric tons of co2 equivalent a year. 6 trillion kg. Or about 20,000 kg per person in the US, every year.

Currently (since ~ 1990), US forested land is estimated to offset ~ 13% of fossil co2 emissions. Forests cover 36% (!) of US land area, and have been slowly increasing since ~ 2000.

Farmland covers another 39% of US land [https://www.nass.usda.gov/Publications/Highlights/2024/Censu...].

Pretty much all the rest is either 1) waterways, 2) cities, 3) non-arable land like steep mountains and deserts with no ready source of water.

So even with a back of the envelope, easy math, if we changed all our farmland to grow forests, we’d roughly double the amount of carbon we could sequester - which would still be ~ 25% of the amount of fossil carbon we’re emitting, every year.

And then we would still need to DO something with all that wood, because burning it or letting it rot just releases all it’s co2 back into the atmosphere.

And we’d all starve to death in the meantime.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by dmbche on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:20AM (#44708897)
Go look at the article about the effects of the introduction of wolves back in yellowstone that was frontpage yesterday.

That f'ing with one species.

Now imagine the impact of f'ing with the forest itself.

Could the capacity to sequester carbon be affected by second or third order effects?

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:43AM (#44708687)
Modeling a forest like a spring is a better model than a petrochemical reservoir. (Though a water reservoir is not a terrible analogy if forest fires == a dam breaking! And overflows or evaporation == rotting.)

The (very common) thinking that forests are ‘sinks’ (aka it goes in one way and stays) or like a petrochemical reservoir (we can put it in, or take it out - but it stays there once in, or out) are a big part of the confusion.

On a geological timescale, carbon being stored in a forest is a temporary and rather rare circumstance. Some global percentage will always be in vegetation (see carbon cycle), but any given atom will move around a lot.

Harvesting forests and burning them, takes carbon that was in the atmosphere, then in wood, then puts it back in the atmosphere. Total carbon in the atmosphere was only temporarily out of it in this situation.

If we wanted to permanently take it out of the atmosphere, we’d need to bury all those trees (deep enough where they won’t decompose and/or the decomposition products won’t make it into the atmosphere!). Turning it into furniture or building products is a more useful, but shorter term solution.

One idea-logically most pure solution would be to puree them and inject them into old depleted oil fields, eh?

Because otherwise those trees will just burn, die and decompose, etc. - it’s inevitable.

Ideally they would be replaced in a shortish timeframe by new trees or growth, roughly locking up the same amount of carbon. But that doesn’t always happen.

And people aren’t allowed to clear cut forests in the US (generally) anymore. Most (all?) US timberland is multi-generational new growth now at this point, and is harvested using as realistically healthy a process as possible. If we had battery powered industrial equipment, it would be even better.

I’ve read the papers, and I’ve done the math many times.

The amount of carbon being released by burning the trees, is roughly the same amount as was taken out by them growing. That’s the nature of it. When they regrow,they’ll take more out.

That is the nature of being renewable. Unlike fossil fuels, where chances are no more will replace it naturally.

Complaining about someone cutting down the trees, specifically from a ‘renewable’/‘total carbon’ perspective is silly in this context. The carbon released isn’t even fossil carbon, and will be back in the trees soon enough - less than a lifetime!

And I’ve done the math - even if we turned all of the arable land in North America into forests, based on the USDA data from National Forests, it would take 4-10ish years worth of growth to temporary store 1 years worth of fossil carbon being released just by the US right now.

Every year.

And to even try that, we’d all starve, because we turned all our crop land into forests too.

Worry about the massive quantities of fossil carbon still getting sucked out of the ground. That is what is feeding the impending disaster.

Unless people are salting the earth and stopping further growth (which generally is already forbidden in the US!), cutting down and burning a forest is a temporary nudge in the accounting that will self correct.

Generally most of it will get used in lumber though, which means it should net decrease atmospheric carbon until it rots or burns in a fire. If landfilled, it could go thousands of years.

In summary - the math doesn’t actually check out when you look at it over realistic timescales, and this is more an ideological thing than an actual real thing. I love trees. But they aren’t going to save us from this mess, no matter how hard core we go.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by vintermann on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:05AM (#44708053)
Sinks is about flows. The question is about reservoirs. Forests are a long term carbon reservoir. Yes, it's possible to regrow it and let it stay that way. But we don't do that if we regularly chop it down for wood pellets. If we regularly do that, then the carbon in it will spend more of its time in the atmosphere and cause trouble, even if it wasn't pumped from a fossil reservoir.

This is why you can't ignore land use changes in carbon budgets. It's a sound argument, it's not ridiculous at all.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by rrobukef on Monday July 28, 2025 @06:34AM (#44709356)
I disagree, wood pellets are more expensive than oil for energy, especially if only counting the production cost of oil w/o the tax. So even the first time an old forest is cut, when the land changes, it already displaces oil use. At greater expense even, so demand would be reduce the amount energy produced further.

Furthermore Europe can also choose to replant non-forest land or replant permanently afterwards.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by fodkodrasz on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:48AM (#44707933)
The soil they create, if they stay alive and are able to retain the soil layer, is gradually washed away (and locally replenished) and is fertilizing the lowlands.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by littlexsparkee on Monday July 28, 2025 @12:54PM (#44712730)
Even fast growing trees need 10-20 years to start storing significant amounts of carbon and old-growth forests can sequester it for hundreds of years.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:40AM (#44722036)
The challenge is that old growth forests, while retaining carbon, don’t pull much net carbon from the atmosphere. Their ‘spring’ is nearly fully compressed.

They are really beautiful and important, but they aren’t doing much when it comes to reducing atmospheric carbon anymore.

As ugly as it is, chopping them down (as long as we can stop the wood from rotting/burning/etc) and then having new trees grow in their place does more actual atmospheric carbon reduction.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by rini17 on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:55AM (#44707623)
The soil gets depleted when biomass is consistently taken away. It might be possible to avoid it but that's cost center.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lazide on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:58AM (#44707631)
Carbon comes from the atmosphere in this scenario.

Crops can be rotated.

Trees can be non-clear cut when harvested.

None of this changes the definition of renewable.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by rini17 on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:59AM (#44709140)
In practice we want forest soil not eroded away after clear cut logging, but also not depleted nutrients like phosphorus, nor prone to wildfires[note], nor trees damaged by acid rain etc. Definition of "sustainable" in the law alone is not sufficient to cover all this and never will be, some discretion and responsibility is required.

[note] depends on the biome, part of said discretion

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 7952 on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:48AM (#44709907)
So do fish when they are harvested from the ocean. But that doesn't mean it is sustainable.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by HDThoreaun on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:36PM (#44713823)
Opportunity cost has nothing to do with whether something is renewable
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by paganel on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:00AM (#44707643)
Because is bs, pure and simple. Typical Brussels re-inventing the definition of words in order to push their political objectives.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by petre on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:30AM (#44707813)
I would agree if you'd be talking about branding gas as sustainable, which Germany actually tried before the war in Ukraine and the sabotage of the Northstream pipeline. But in this context, it's pure hogwash. Burning wood pellets is actually sustainable and renewable and has been a net win for Eastern European counrties that joined the EU, mainly because little to no sawdust is discarded into rivers and streams any longer. I remember the 2000s and before, when we hiked through the mountains: wherever there was a wood processing plant, there were also overflowing heaps of sawdust. None of that is a reality any longer, all of it is pelletized, sold and burned.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by soco on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:47AM (#44709065)
The issue with Eastern European woods is that they're being razed - for pellets, furniture, you name it. And rarely replaced. So yes in some places you'll have new growth, but most places there's soil washing and flash floods and destroyed habitats and all that. Is that renewable? Hardly.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by petre on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:20AM (#44707758)
What do you think the furniture industry does with the wood byproducts such as sawdust and bark?
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by blitzar on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:07AM (#44708459)
IKEA. We should burn discarded ikea (wooden) furniture too.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by fodkodrasz on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:49AM (#44707941)
adds glue to it and creates more "wooden" furniture from it
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by hibikir on Monday July 28, 2025 @06:12AM (#44709207)
There's a whole lot of buildings that were designed with a coal furnace in the basement which heats water, and all aparments getting a bunch of water radiators. A switch from that to, say, a typical American forced air system is a huge expense, and it might not be all that easy to design a system that is well balanced anyway given the small space for said ducts.

So when a building association finds themselves having to replace the old furnace, given that getting a new coal furnace is now illegal, the pellets are seen as the reasonable, if not wonderful alternative.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by knappe on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:42AM (#44707551)
This is an excerpt from Eating the Earth. The entire point of the book is that when we consider land use, we're not accounting for other uses for that same land (or how other land would be used) because the land, prior to Searchinger's work in the field all calculations did not consider this factor. Even after Searchinger published their work showing the flaws on land use, it was often ignored.

If you find the excerpt underwhelming, go read the book. I will warn you that in some ways it feels more like a memoir of Searchinger's life than a book on land use considerations, but, despite that, it still does a great job of showing how land use is still not being accounted for in all situations.

I finished Eating the Earth last week and found it rather interesting to read.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by verisimi on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:18AM (#44707746)
> If you find the excerpt underwhelming, go read the book

... and be overwhelming underwhelmed?

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by burnt-resistor on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:02AM (#44707657)
Corn and most ag subsidies are using taxpayer money for corporate welfare for mostly mega farming consortia with a smattering of medium and smaller farmers, who also can't exist in the rigged market without welfare. 5% of all US land, not just arable land, ALL land is used for mostly cow corn. It's absolute insanity.

And then there's the federal US sugar cartel keeping prices artificially (no pun intended) high.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by AngryData on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:42AM (#44707892)
Crop subsidies are certainly poorly applied and poorly distributed, but we also need to not throw the baby out with the bath water. Crop subsidization is the only alternative to the granary system, which while decent still resulted in repeated famines for thousands of years basically everywhere, while no country that has decent crop subsidization ever has famine. Crop subsidization in general makes granaries 90% obsolete because you always aim to over produce crops and so even in bad years you still produce enough food despite the unexpectedly low yields. It also makes food prices WAY more stable so that a bad July doesn't cause wheat prices to double because there isn't enough to satisfy demand. It is really the only way to ensure you always produce extra food in a capitalist economy because otherwise margins are only like 2% while crop yields can swing 30% even without extraordinary weather events or storm damage.

I do want to note though that corn is possibly one of the least useful crops to subsidize, it is one of the most robust and predictable food crops we grow, which is why so much of it is grown despite a large fraction of it's energy going into worthless stalk. More delicate crops that have larger and less predictable yield swings, like wheat, or something with delicate fruits that can't be stored long, likely deserve the majority of subsidization money that currently goes towards corn.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by mschuster91 on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:27AM (#44708175)
The problem is, you almost always end up with a massive amount of overproduction. That either ends up diverted into fuel production, which raises ethical concerns on one side and prolongs the use of fossil fuels because it's "effectively free" and so stops people from switching over to electric mobility on the other side.

And on top of that, many Western countries routinely dump their overproduction on Africa, where as a result of all that free aid, local food production industry has all but vanished. Up until the '00s, Simbabwe was known as "Africa's corn chamber" - that is long gone now.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by burnt-resistor on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:10AM (#44708470)
Grain overproduction is also a significant driver of climate change. Fossil fuels, meat, and GMO monocultures aren't ecologically sustainable in current form, they continue because of capture of factions of governments by corrupt lobbying interests who threaten elected officials into driving more cash and favorable regulations their way.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by bbarnett on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:27AM (#44708948)
People need to stop pointing the finger at food production, with such massive blinders on. Food "overproduction", are you actually serious? Are people so removed from farming, and food production, that they think it's a simple thing?

Plant X food, get X food?

Absolutely not! Even with irrigation, there are years with drought, yes even in the West. There are years that are too cloudy, or too sunny (yes, too sunny is a thing). There are years with locusts, and no insecticide doesn't completely solve that. And regardless of global warming or not, some seasons have always been worse for hurricanes, tornadoes, and some events at harvest time can wipe out crops entirely!

Outside of all of the above, few nations feed themselves on their own output. External food production can wither and vanish in an instant, whether through war, or inclement weather too.

You must overproduce to ensure a continuity of food supply. It's the same reason that fallow farmland must be a thing, too. There must be extra, there must be a safety net.

Only people who have never starved, never been truly hungry would espouse such things.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by MindSpunk on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:57AM (#44709118)
We saw what happens when you use just-in-time manufacturing and keep minimal stock of material when covid collapsed supply chains a few years ago. Imagine if that was our food supply instead. The over production is the price we pay for food security.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @08:58AM (#44710413)
> and some events at harvest time can wipe out crops entirely!

And that swings both ways. Last year, with the stars aligning just right, the corn yields around here were ~100 bushels per acre higher than even our most optimistic pre-harvest estimates. That is an incredible amount of unexpected extra product. Corn especially has a huge, unpredictable yield band.

Which, of course, is exactly why we started producing corn-based ethanol. To buffer the periods of uncontrollable excess — where the previous alternative was to see it rot away.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by mschuster91 on Monday July 28, 2025 @09:48AM (#44710854)
I agree, but we have to take care that getting rid of excess production (i.e. post reserve building/maintenance) is not going to fuck up supply chains in other countries, like it did in Africa.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @11:45AM (#44711989)
> Crop subsidies are certainly poorly applied and poorly distributed

Crop subsidies, since the 2014 reforms at least, are "fair" to all crops. That does mean that the most grown crops (which in the US is corn, by a large margin) receive the most subsidies, but is that truly poor application and distribution?

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by HDThoreaun on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:39PM (#44713847)
Yes, they just explained way. The goal isnt fairness, its preventing famine.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:44PM (#44713917)
The goal isn't fairness, but it is fair[1]. There is nothing in the crop subsidies that would compel you to grow, say, corn over a vegetable.

Corn does receive the lion's share of the subsidies, but that's because we grow way more corn, because that's what the consumer chooses to buy (either directly or indirectly [e.g. meat]).

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by HDThoreaun on Monday July 28, 2025 @02:52PM (#44714021)
Right, and part of why we grow way more corn is the subsidies(vast majority of corn is going to animals, they eat whatever is cheapest). The subsidies lead to too much corn growth which means they are poorly applied, even if they are fair.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:27PM (#44714514)
> part of why we grow way more corn is the subsidies

That would imply that subsidies give reason to produce corn over a vegetable, which isn't the case. The subsidies are "fair" — even when that isn't the goal.

You are right that corn is cheap, but that's a result of technology and the nature of what it is. It requires almost no human effort to produce. Stuff like vegetables, on the other hand, remain incredibly labor intensive even on the most technically advanced farms. It is a much harder problem to solve.

As compared to virtually every other food, grain is significantly simpler to handle in almost every way from seeding right to storage and distribution. And corn benefits from being insanely high yielding compared to other grains.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by hibikir on Monday July 28, 2025 @06:27AM (#44709310)
Unfortunately farmers everywhere get subsidies: A lot of European farming would collapse and be replaced by farming done in the southern hemisphere if there weren't subsidies.

As for too much corn, it's a purely economical plan: There's rotation with soybeans in most of the midwest because corn-corn-sobeans is more profitable and treats the land better. Your typical farmer would change to anything else that makes more money per acre, especially if it needs fewer treatments.

As for the total acreage, corn is the second highest in land coverage. There's a worse one: Lawn grass. It just sits there, requires a bunch of maintenance, and produces no economic output. It's often also mandatory: My county's minimal ratios mean 75% of my property has to be well maintained lawn

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by 9rx on Monday July 28, 2025 @01:04PM (#44712830)
> Your typical farmer would change to anything else that makes more money per acre

As a grain farmer, I would want cooler tech first (which, granted, would follow if the money was there). I chose grain farming because it has the best toys.

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by scaramanga on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:47AM (#44708312)
Yeah, the details are scattered through the article, so you've got to pay close attention. It says that the LCA that the industry produced ignored the carbon intensivity of draining wetland, creating more farmland, and fertilizing it. When that's accounted for (last 2 paragraphs, the bit of hagiography on Searchinger), biofuels isn't a climate policy anymore. Using an LCA that ignores the carbon emissions you're creating, misleads people, whether done on purpose or not.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1151861

"These analyses have failed to count the carbon emissions that occur as farmers worldwide respond to higher prices and convert forest and grassland to new cropland to replace the grain (or cropland) diverted to biofuels. By using a worldwide agricultural model to estimate emissions from land-use change, we found that corn-based ethanol, instead of producing a 20% savings, nearly doubles greenhouse emissions over 30 years"

Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by hibikir on Monday July 28, 2025 @06:03AM (#44709150)
It's also not the same corn varieties for different uses. Most of what we'd feed humans would be sweet corn, and that's not ideal for ethanol, or animal feed. If you look at total acreage planted, sweet corn is just 1% of the total crop.
Re:Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of ... by lithos on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:33AM (#44709792)
There are some loose numbers tosed around like agricultural ethanol being 2x the carbon emissions of big oil.

While not circled around to properly destroying a wetland for farming, is also destroying a far more permanent carbon sink than a farm.

-----

IMO the article is tripping over itself to tell a story and cares about that story far more than factual information.

It could even help for some types of people, even if it's likely painful for the people reading from here.